题名

台灣產險業績效與市場競爭力之動態追蹤資料分析

并列篇名

Dynamic Panel Data Analysis of Performance and Market Competitiveness of Taiwanese Non-Life Insurance Industry

DOI

10.6160/SYSMR.202206_30(3).0004

作者

陳冠志(Guan-Chin Chen)

关键词

產物保險業 ； Lerner指數 ； 績效 ； 市場競爭力 ； Non-life Insurance Industry ； Lerner Index ； Performance ； Market Competitiveness

期刊名称

中山管理評論

卷期/出版年月

30卷3期（2022 / 06 / 01）

页次

555 - 592

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

本研究透過Lerner指數衡量其台灣產險市場競爭力，以動態追蹤資料分析公司績效與市場競爭力之關聯性，並探討不同公司型態之產物保險公司在績效與市場競爭力之關聯上是否存在差異。實證結果發現台灣產險業為寡占性競爭市場，產險公司之核保獲利績效、投資績效與業務績效在第三階段實施前後皆對市場競爭力均有顯著正向影響且具正向遞延效果。第三階段費率自由化實施前，金控體系與非金控體系產險公司當期之市場競爭力對營運績效皆有顯著負向影響，且金控體系產險公司之負向影響更為強烈。而在第三階段費率自由化實施後，整體產險業當期之市場競爭力對營運績效轉變為顯著正向影響，且外商產險公司與非金控體系公司更有顯著正向之遞延效果。
英文摘要

This research measures the competitiveness of Taiwanese non-life insurance market through the Lerner index to explore the relationship of performance and market competitiveness by dynamic panel data analysis and the difference of the relationship between different corporate types. The empirical results show that Taiwanese non-life insurance market is an oligopolistic competitive market. The underwriting profitability performance, investment performance and business performance of non-life insurers all have a significant positive effect on the market competitiveness and have a positive deferral effect before and after the third phase rate liberalization. Before the third phase rate liberalization, the market competitiveness of financial holding insurers and non-financial holding insurers had a significant negative impact on operating performance, and the negative impact of financial holding insurers was even stronger. The market competitiveness of the current property and casualty insurance industry had a significant positive effect on operating performance with a positive deferral effect after the third phase rate liberalization.
主题分类 社會科學 > 管理學
参考文献
  1. 陳冠志, G. C.,張瑞益, J. I.,李七花, Q.(2020)。中國財產保險業多元化經營與財務績效之非線性關聯分析。中山管理評論，28(3)，507-545。
    連結：
  2. 陳家祥, J. S.,何健德, C. T.,鄒鴻泰, H. T.,羅兆凱, T. K.(2009)。大量客製化能力與敏捷性之研究：前置因素與對企業競爭優勢之影響。電子商務學報，11(3)，489-518。
    連結：
  3. 黃台心, T. H.,鍾銘泰, M. T.,陳世章, S. J.(2018)。臺灣證券業市場競爭度與創新之研究。證券市場發展季刊，30(2)，151-194。
    連結：
  4. 劉景中, J. C.(2011)。銀行集中度及效率對市場競爭度的影響：台灣實證研究。經濟論文叢刊，39，115-173。
    連結：
  5. 劉景中, J. C.(2009)。銀行集中度、銀行市場競爭度與銀行風險─台灣實證研究。經濟論文，37，101-135。
    連結：
  6. 鄭士卿, S. C.,汪琪玲, C. L.,蕭維萱, W. H.(2017)。保險業集中度及效率對市場競爭程度之影響：以日本產險業為例。臺大管理論叢，27(2S)，289-318。
    連結：
  7. Aghion, P.,Bloom, N.,Blundell, R.,Griffith, R.,Howitt, P.(2005).Competition and innovation: An inverted-U relationship.The Quarterly Journal of Economics,120(2),701-728.
  8. Albaity, M.,Mallek, R. S.,Noman, A. H. M.(2019).Competition and Bank Stability in the MENA Region: The Moderating Effect of Islamic versus Conventional Banks.Emerging Markets Review,38,310-325.
  9. Ambrose, J. M.,Seward, J. A.(1988).Best’s Ratings, Financial Ratios and Prior Probabilities in Insolvency Prediction.Journal of Risk and Insurance,55(2),229-244.
  10. Angelini, P.,Cetorelli, N.(2003).The Effects of Regulatory Reform on Competition in the Banking Industry.Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking,35(5),663-684.
  11. Anginer, D.,Demirguc-Kunt, A.,Zhu, M.(2014).How Does Competition Affect Bank Systemic Risk?.Journal of Financial Intermediation,23,1-26.
  12. Arellano, M.,Bover, O.(1995).Another Look at the Instrumental Variables Estimation of Error-Components Models.Journal of Econometrics,68,29-51.
  13. Azmi, W.,Ali, M.,Arshad, S.,Rizvi, S. A. R.(2019).Intricacies of Competition, Stability, and Diversification: Evidence from Dual Banking Economies.Economic Modelling
  14. Barney, J. B.,Zajac, E. J.(1994).Competitive Organizational Behavior: Toward an Organizationally‐Based Theory of Competitive Advantage.Strategic Management Journal,15(1),5-9.
  15. Basturk, F. H.(2012).Characteristics and Competition Structure of Turkish Insurance Industry.Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences,62,1084-1088.
  16. Beck, T.,De Jonghe, O.,Schepens, G.(2013).Bank Competition and Stability: Cross-Country Heterogeneity.Journal of Financial Intermediation,22(2),218-244.
  17. Biener, C.,Eling, M.,Wirfs, J. H.(2016).The Determinants of Efficiency and Productivity in the Swiss Insurance Industry.European Journal of Operational Research,248(2),703-714.
  18. Brockett, P. L.,Cooper, W. W.,Golden, L. L.,Utai, P.(1994).A Neural Network Method for Obtaining an Early Warning of Insurer Insolvency.Journal of Risk and Insurance,61(3),402-425.
  19. Browne, M. J.,Robert, E.(1995).Economic and Market Predictors Insolvencies in the Property-Liability Insurance Industry.Journal of Risk and Insurance,62(2),309-328.
  20. Camino-Mogro, S.,Armijos-Bravo, G.,Cornejo-Marcos G.(2019).Competition in the Insurance Industry in Ecuador: An Econometric Analysis in Life and Non-Life Markets.The Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance,71,291-302.
  21. Căpraru, B.,Ihnatov, I.,Pintille, N. L.(2020).Competition and Diversification in the European Banking Sector.Research in International Business and Finance
  22. Căpraru, B.,Moise, N.(2015).Insurance Market's Competition in Romania after 2007.Procedia Economics and Finance,20,112-118.
  23. Carbó, S.,Humphrey, D.,Maudos, J.,Molyneux, P.(2009).Cross-Country Comparisons of Competition and Pricing Power in European Banking.Journal of International Money and Finance,28(1),115-134.
  24. Casu, B.,Girardone, C.(2006).Bank Competition, Concentration and Efficiency in the Single European Market.The Manchester School,74(4),441-468.
  25. Chandler, G.,Hanks, S. H.(1994).Market Attractiveness, Resource-Based Capabilities; Venture Strategies and Venture Performance.Journal of Business Venturing,9,331-349.
  26. Chen, C. H.,Lin, M.,Chen, G. C.(2011).Does Financial and Business Performance Affect Market Share? - A Case of Non-Life Insurance Industry in Taiwan.Journal of Statistics and Management Systems,14(2),453-465.
  27. Chen, G. C.,Xu, H.(2016).A Study of the Financial/Business Performance and Market Share of Non-Life Insurance Industry in Taiwan.The Standard International Journals,4(8),98-105.
  28. Chen, Y, B.,Wei, X. H.,Zhang, L. L.,Shi, Y.(2013).Sectora Diversification and the Banks’ Return and Risk: Evidence from Chinese Listed Commercial Banks.Procedia Computer Science,18,1737-1746.
  29. Choi, B. P.,Weiss, M. A.(2005).An Empirical Investigation of Market Structure, Efficiency, and Performance in Property-Liability Insurance.Journal of Risk and Insurance,72,635-673.
  30. Clark, E.,Mare, D. S.,Radic, N.(2018).Cooperative banks: What do We Know about Competition and Risk Preferences?.Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions & Money,52,90-101.
  31. Clerides, S.,Delis, M. D.,Kokas, S.(2015).A New Data Set on Competition in National Banking Markets.Financial Market Institutions & Instruments,24(2),267-311.
  32. Diewert, W. E.(1974).Applications of Duality Theorem.Stanford Institute for Mathematical Studies in the Social Science,55,43-68.
  33. Dumitrescu, E. I.,Hurlin, C.(2012).Testing for Granger Non-Causality in Heterogeneous Panels.Economic Modelling,29(4),1450-1460.
  34. Elango, B.,Ma, Y. L.,Pope, N.(2008).An Investigation into The Diversification Performance in The U.S. Property-liability Insurance Industry.Journal of Risk and Insurance,75(3),567-591.
  35. Fernández de Guevara, J.,Maudos, J.,Pérez, F.(2005).Market Power in European Banking Sectors.Journal of Financial Services Research,27(2),109-137.
  36. Fernández de Guevara, J,Maudos, J.(2007).Explanatory Factors of Market Power in the Banking System.The Manchester School,75(3),275-296.
  37. Gilbert, R.(2006).Looking for Mr. Schumpeter: Where are We in the CompetitionInnovation Debate?.Innovation Policy and the Economy,6,159-215.
  38. Grant, R. M.(1991).The Resource-Based Theory of Competitive Advantage: Implications for Strategy Formulations.California Management Review,33(3),3-23.
  39. Grosfeld, I.,Tressel, T.(2002).Competition and Ownership Structure: Substitutes or Complements? Evidence from the Warsaw Stock Exchange.Economic of Transition,10(3),525-551.
  40. Hertenstein, J. H.,Platt, M. B.(2000).Performance Measures and Management Control in New Product Development.Accounting Horizons,14(3),303-323.
  41. Holtz-Eakin, D.,Newey, W.,Rosen, H. S.(1988).Estimating Vector Autoregressions with Panel Data.Econometrica,56(6),1371-1395.
  42. Im, K. S.,Pesaran, M. H.,Shin, Y.(2003).Testing for Unit Roots in Heterogeneous Panels.Journal of Econometrics,115,53-74.
  43. Kang, H. K.,Lee, S.,Yang, H.(2011).The Effects of Product Diversification on Firm Performance and Complementarities between Products: A Study of US Casinos.International Journal of Hospitality Management,30(2),409-421.
  44. Lampel, J.,Giachetti, C.(2013).International Diversification of Manufacturing Operations: Performance Implications and Moderating Forces.Journal of Operations Management,31(4),213-227.
  45. Lerner, A. P., 1934, "The Concept of Monopoly and the Measurement of Monopoly Power," Review of Economic Studies, Vol. 1, No. 3, 157-175.
  46. Levin, A.,Lin, C. F.,Chu, C. S. J.(2002).Unit Root Tests in Panel Data: Asymptotic and Finite-Sample Properties.Journal of Econometrics,108,1-24.
  47. Long, C.,Vickers-Koch, M(1995).Using Core Capabilities to Create Competitive Advantage.Organizational Dynamics,24(1),7-22.
  48. Lopez, L.,Weber, S.(2017).Testing for Granger Causality in Panel Data.The State Journal: Promoting Communications on Statistics and Stata,17(4),972-984.
  49. Ma, Y.,Elango, B.(2008).When do International Operations Lead to Improved Performance? An Analysis of Property-Liability Insurer.Risk Management and Insurance Reviews,11(1),141-155.
  50. Maudos J.,Fernández de Guevara, J.(2004).Factors Explaining the Interest Margin in the Banking Sectors of the European Union.Journal of Banking and Finance,28,2259-2281.
  51. Nguyen, M.,Perera, S.,Skully, M.(2012).Bank Market Power and Revenue Diversification: Evidence from Selected ASEAN Countries.Journal of Asian Economics,23,688-700.
  52. Nguyen, M.,Perera, S.,Skully, M.(2016).Bank Market Power, Ownership, Regional Presence and Revenue Diversification: Evidence from Africa.Emerging Markets Review,27,36-62.
  53. Pedroni, P.(1999).Critical Values for Cointegration Tests in Heterogeneous Panels with Multiple Regressors.Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics,61,653-670.
  54. Phan, H. T.,Anwar, S.,Alexander, W. R. J.,Phan, H. T. M.(2019).Competition, Efficiency and Stability: An Empirical Study of East Asian Commercial Banks.North American Journal of Economics and Finance,50
  55. Porter, M. E.(1990).The Competitive Advantage of Nations.Harvard Business Review,68(2),73-93.
  56. Sargan, J. D.(1958).The Estimation of Economic Relationships Using Instrumental Variables.Econometrica,26,393-415.
  57. Song, S.,Park, S.,Lee, S.(2017).Impacts of Geographic Diversification on Restaurant Firms’ risk: Domestic vs. International Diversification.International Journal of Hospitality Management,61,107-118.
  58. Steers, R.(1975).Problems in the Measurement of Organizational Effectiveness.Administrative Science Quarterly,20,546-558.
  59. Tan, Y.(2016).The Impacts of Risk and Competition on Bank Profitability in China.Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions and Money,40,85-110.
  60. Tan, Y.,Floros, C.(2014).Risk, Profitability, and Competition: Evidence from the Chinese Banking Industry.Journal of Developing Areas,48(3),303-319.
  61. Trinugroho, I.,Risfandy, T.,Ariefianto, M. D.(2018).Competition, Diversification, and Bank Margins: Evidence from Indonesian Islamic Rural Banks.Borsa Istanbul Review,18(4),349-358.
  62. Zander, U.,Kogut, B.(1995).Knowledge and the Speed of the Transfer and Imitation of Organizational Capabilities: An Empirical Test.Organization Science,6(1),76-92.
  63. 王財驛, T. Y.,卓翠月, T. Y.,黃明祥, M. H.(2011)。財產保險業經營績效之研究。財金論文叢刊，14，1-15。
  64. 成曉光, X. G(2009)。企業核心競爭力影響要素分析。南京財經大學學報，4，73-76。
  65. 李明輝, M. H.,黃葉苨, Y. N.,劉莉亞, L. Y.(2018)。市場競爭、銀行市場勢力與流動性創造效率-來自中國銀行業的證據。財經研究，44(2)，103-114。
  66. 李知臨, J. L.,李德惠, D. H.(2014)。我國商業銀行貸款價格競爭與風險的關係研究－基於我國主要非國有商業銀行的平衡面板數據分析。南方金融，6，4-9。
  67. 汪可, K.(2018)。金融科技、價格競爭與銀行風險承擔。哈爾濱商業大學學報（社會科學版），158，40-48。
  68. 周天芸, T. Y.,姜禹杉, Y. S.(2017)。競爭度、集中度和金融體系的穩定性－基於新興市場經濟國家的數據。金融發展研究，1，63-69。
  69. 林明俊, M.,陳青浩, C. H.,陳冠志, G. C.(2010)。產險業財業務績效與市占率之分析。保險經營與制度，9(1)，51-68。
  70. 高瑋, W.(2012)。中國銀行業競爭與穩定關係研究。湖北經濟學院學報，10(2)，32-38。
  71. 張簡永章, I. J.,曾漢文, H. W.,陳惠萍, H. P.(2017)。多角化策略與財產保險人績效：股權結構重要嗎？。藝見學刊，13，41-56。
  72. 曹永棟, Y. D.,陸躍祥, Y. X.(2012)。城市商業銀行競爭力指標體系及其對策設計。改革，1，66-74。
  73. 梁榮輝, J. H.,廖振盛, C. S.(2008)。台灣地區產險業經營績效因素之研究─財務面的實證分析。保險專刊，24(1)，81-102。
  74. 許良賢, L. X.(2014)。產險公司競逐市場地位之主要經營策略探討。核保學報，21，75-100。
  75. 陳冠志, G. C.(2018)。台灣地區產險業經營績效之研究。保險學報，13，39-70。
  76. 陳建勝, J. S.,陳聰賢, T. H.,陳美菁, M. C.,劉儀美, Y. M.(2008)。我國壽險產業結構對經營策略與獲利能力影響之研究。朝陽商管評論，7(1)，73-88。
  77. 陳洪轉, H. Z.(2007)。基於價值鏈的商業銀行核心競爭力影響要素研究。金融教學與研究，1，16-18。
  78. 陳嘉文, J. W.(2009)。衡量產險業真實核保利潤訂定經營績效指標之研究。核保學報，17，61-82。
  79. 黃台心, T. H.,江典霖, D. L.(2014)。我國銀行業市場競爭度與金融創新之關聯。中央銀行季刊，36(2)，15-52。
  80. 黃旭男, S. N.,吳國華, K. H.(2001)。台灣地區壽險業經營續效之衡量。管理與系統，8(4)，401-420。
  81. 黃江川, J. C.,孫嫚萍, M. P.,張雅婷, Y. T.(2015)。本國與外商保險公司獲利能力影響因素之探討。財金論文叢刊，23，66-77。
  82. 廖振盛, C. S.(2010)。費率自由化前後產險業經營績效變化分析─隨機邊界法之應用。臺灣銀行季刊，61(2)，46-59。
  83. 趙碧瑩, B. Y.(2019)。中國商業銀行競爭力評價與影響因素研究。金融監管研究，89(5)，70-82。
  84. 蔣才芳, C.,陳收, C.(2014)。中國人壽保險公司經營績效的 DEA 有效性分析。財經理論與實踐，190(4)，27-32。
  85. 蔣永丹, Y. D.,袁鯤, K.(2017)。銀行市場競爭水準對收入多元化影響研究－基於中國銀行業的非平衡面板模型。財務與金融，165，16-23。
  86. 簡仲明, C. M.(2009)。產險業費率自由化費用率管理之潛在風險與因應對策。保險大道，16，26-30。
被引用次数
  1. (2024)。化石燃料產業與再生能源產業的財務比較分析。臺灣能源期刊，11(2)，125-143。
print cancel