單次與多次電話諮商戒菸成效之比較：以戒菸專線服務中心為例

The Effects of Single-Session and Multiple-Session Telephone Counseling for Smoking Cessation

10.30074/FJMH.200609_19(3).0001

張德聰(Te-Chung Chang)；潘瑞香(Ruei-Shiang Pan)；張景然(Ching-Jan Chang)

吸菸 ； 戒斷 ； 復發 ； 電話諮商 ； abstinence ； relapse ； smoking ； telephone counseling

中華心理衛生學刊

19卷3期（2006 / 09 / 01）

213 - 229

繁體中文

研究目的：評估「戒菸專線服務中心」的個案多次電話戒菸諮商成效及追蹤個案戒菸維持成效，並藉由比較單次諮詢組與多次諮商組的戒菸成效，用以檢驗完整電話戒菸諮商的個案其戒菸成效及戒菸維持成效的效果是否較優。研究方法：研究分為實驗組及對照組兩部分：實驗組（即多次諮商組）在諮商完成後，與對照組（即單次諮詢組）在初談完成後的一個月、三個月及六個月等三個時段分別由電訪員做電話訪問調查，追蹤個案的戒菸持續情況。研究結果：經由t檢定比較兩組在追蹤菸量、戒菸信心指數及戒菸天數上均有顯著差異。而在戒菸戒斷成功率及戒菸維持成效的成功率兩方面，多次諮商組均優於單次諮詢組。研究結論：採用多次電話戒菸諮商方式其成效顯著優於單次諮詢，完整的電話戒菸諮商服務證實可行。

The present study examined the follow-up effects of two types of telephone counseling service based on the data of ”Taiwan Smokers' Helpline”. The lower intensity counseling consisted of only one session. The higher intensity counseling included the same initial session plus an average of seven additional sessions. We tested the hypothesis that multiple sessions of counseling would produce a higher abstinence rate among participants than would a single session. The results of the multiple-session group were significantly better than the single-session group regarding cessation rates, self-efficacy, days of cessation, and continuous one-, three- six-months abstinence rates. Multiple sessions did produce significantly higher abstinence rates compared with a single-session.

1. 張景然(2003)。加州戒菸專線的介紹。諮商與輔導，209，52-55。
   連結：
2. 鄭丁元、溫啟邦、蔡夢娟、蔡善璞(2002)。國人吸菸行為現況：2001年國民健康調查之分析。台灣衛誌，22，453-464。
   連結：
3. Baer, J. S.,Holt, C.S.,Lichtentein, E.(1986).Self-efficacy and smoking reexamined: Construct validity and clinical utility.Journal of Consulting and Clinical psychology,54(6),846-852.
4. Bandura, A.(1977).Self-efficacy: Toward a unifying theory of behavior change.Psychological Review,84(2),191-215.
5. Coeoho, R. J.(1984).Self-efficacy and cessation of smoking.Psychological Reports,54,309-310.
6. Garcia, M. E.,Schmitz, J. M.(1990).A Fine-grained analysis of the role of self-fefficacy in self-initiated attempts to quit smoking.Journal of Consulting and Clinical psychology,58(3),317-322.
7. Lando, H. A.,Hellertstedt, W. L.,Pirie, P. L.,McGovern, P. G.(1992).Brief supportive telephone outreach as a recruitment and intervention strategy for smoking cessation.American Journal of public Health,82,41-46.
8. Marlatt, G. A.,Curry, S.,Gordon, J. R.(1988).A longitudinal analysis of unaided smoking cessation.Journal of Consulting Psychology,54,447-453.
9. Mary, G. S.,Mark, P.(2000).A comparison of successful smoking cessation intervention for adults and adolescents.Journal of Counseling and Development,78(4),448-453.
10. Mermelstein, R.,Lichtenstein, E.,McIntyre, K.(1983).Partner support and relapse in smoking cessation programs.Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology,51,465-466.
11. Naomi, B.,Edward, L. P.(1996).Smoking cessation in young adults: Age at initiation of cigarette smoking and other suspected influence.American Journal of public Health,86(2),214-220.
12. Oei, T. P.,Hallam, J.(1991).Behavioral strategies by long-term successful self-quitters.International Journal of Addictions,26,993-1002.
13. Orleans, C. T.,Schoenbach, V. J.,Wanger, E. H.,Quade, D.,Salmon, M. A.,Pearson, D. C.,Fielder, J.,Porter, C. Q.,Kaplan, B. H.(1991).Self-help quit smoking intervention: Effects of self-help materials, social support intervention, and telephone counseling.Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology,59,439-448.
14. Ossip-Klein, D. J.,Giovine, G. A.,Megahed, N.,Black, P. M.,Emont, S. L.,Shulman, E.,Moore, L.(1991).Effects of a smokers hotline: Results of a 10-country self-help trial.Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology,59,325-332.
15. Shiffman, S.(1982).Relapse following smoking cessation: a situational analysis.Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology,50,71-86.
16. Zhu, S. H.,Stretch, V.,Balabnis, M.,Rosbrook, B.,Sadler, G.,Pierce, J. P.(1996).Telephone counseling for smoking cessation: Effects of single-session and multiple-session interventions.Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology,64,202-211.
17. Zhu, S. H.,Tedeschi, G.,Anderson, C. M.,Rosbrook, B.,Byrd, M.,Jonson, C. E.,Gutierrez-Terrell, E.(2000).Telephone counseling as adjuvant treatment for nicotine replacement therapy in a “Real-World” setting.Preventive Medicine,31,357-363.
18. 李蘭(1999)。民國八十八年台灣地區成年及青少年之吸菸率及吸菸行為調查：菸害防制法實施一年後之初評。行政院衛生署八十八年度委託研究計畫成果報告
19. 衛生署國民健康局(2002)。台灣地區臨床戒菸指南
20. 謝淑卿、尹祚芊(1996)。成人菸害認知與行為衝突之探討。護理研究，4(3)，219-230。

1. 陳孟君,李玉嬋,王則雅(2020)。護理人員喪親電話關懷實作經驗之研究～以中部某安寧團隊為例。臺灣諮商心理學報，8(1)，89-112。
2. 南玉芬(2010)。電話輔導於自殺防治的成效與限制。臺灣社會工作學刊，8，157-207。
3. 潘璦琬、陳韻玲、陳詞章、吳博儒、吳昭儀、王曉琳(2014)。戒菸方案之隨機控制試驗之系統性文獻回顧。臺灣公共衛生雜誌，33(5)，470-482。
4. 闕妤榛、黃久美、郭鐘隆、姜郁美、邱怡玲(2009)。社區藥局戒菸諮詢站之成效評估初探。臺灣公共衛生雜誌，28(2)，93-102。
5. 張景然、王珮蘭(2007)。電話諮商的協助歷程：戒菸個案的觀點。輔導與諮商學報，29(1)，47-66。