離婚與婚姻不穩定代間傳遞研究之回顧與分析

An Overview of Research on the Intergenerational Transmission of Divorce and Marital Instability

10.30074/FJMH.201312_26(4).0001

陳韻如(Yun-Ju Chen)

離婚 ； 婚姻不穩定 ； 代間傳遞 ； Divorce ； Marital Instability ； Intergenerational Transitions

中華心理衛生學刊

26卷4期（2013 / 12 / 01）

527 - 547

繁體中文

研究目的：回顧Social Science Citation Index期刊中，關於離婚與婚姻不穩定代間傳遞之研究，以瞭解此議題發展趨勢，並依據分析結果提出國內發展相關研究之建議。研究方法：以內容分析方式，針對過去研究之年代趨勢、期刊出處、研究主題與方法進行量化計算；除量化描述外，另針對理論運用、研究發現與限制等面向進行彙整與評析，以呈現此議題過去發展累積。研究結果：過去二十多年來西方有關離婚與婚姻不穩定的代間傳遞研究持續受到重視，其中以探討離婚代間傳遞現象的研究數量列首，研究出處則以Journal of Marriage and Family期刊為大宗。多數研究採取量化研究方式，運用長期資料庫或縱貫研究設計方式進行探討。研究中最常用來驗證的理論包含：社會化模式、生命歷程觀點、以及基因遺傳論等。整合過去研究發現，離婚與婚姻不穩定的代間傳遞現象，並非直接因著父母離婚事件而來，而是透過不同中介因素間接地進行傳遞效果。研究結論：期以西方研究做為借鏡，在臺灣發展相關研究時能有所啟發。

This paper provides an overview of research published in journals listed in the Social Science Citation Index on the intergenerational transmission of divorce and marital instability. The goal was to review historical development of the topic and make suggestions for future research. Content analysis was applied to analyze the era, topic, source and method. The main research theories, findings, contributions, and limitations were identified. Results of the analysis showed that this topic has been examined for at least two decades. Most articles explored the intergenerational transmission of divorce rather than transmission of marital instability and both (intergenerational transmission of divorce and marital instability). The ”Journal of Marriage and Family” published the most papers on these three topics. Most researchers applied a quantitative approach. Some used longitudinal databases and some collected their own longitudinal data. The main theories applied were the socialization model, the life course perspective, and the genetic model. The intergenerational transmission of divorce and marital instability has been established; however, transmission is indirect through multiple mediators rather than direct. Taiwanese researchers should use this foundation to conduct our own studies on this topic.

1. 孫旻儀(2010)。父母管教方式對教師管教方式影響之代間傳遞模式探討。輔導與諮商學報，32(1)，43-66。
   連結：
2. 內政部(2012)。〈內政國際指標：主要國家離婚率〉。2012年，6月30日，取自http://sowf.moi.gov.tw/stat/national/list.htm。
3. Amato, P. R.(1993).Children's adjustment to divorce: Theories, hypotheses, and empirical support.Journal of Marriage and Family,55(1),23-28.
4. Amato, P. R.(2001).Children of divorce in the 1990s: An update of the Amato and Keith (1991) Meta-analysis.Journal of Family Psychology,15(3),355-370.
5. Amato, P. R.(1996).Explaining the intergenerational transmission of divorce.Journal of Marriage and Family,58(3),628-640.
6. Amato, P. R.(1987).Family process in intact, one-parent, and step-parent families: The child's point of view.Journal of Marriage and Family,49(2),327-337.
7. Amato, P. R.,Booth, A.(2001).The legacy of parents' marital discord: Consequences for children's marital quality.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,81(4),627-638.
8. Amato, P. R.,Booth, A.(1991).Consequences of parental divorce and marital unhappiness for adult well-being.Social Force,69(3),895-915.
9. Amato, P. R.,Cheadle, J.(2005).The long reach of divorce: Divorce and child well-being across three generations.Journal of Marriage and Family,67(1),191-206.
10. Amato. P. R.,DeBoer, D. D.(2001).The transitions of marital instability across generations: Relationship skills or commitment to marriage?.Journal of Marriage and Family,63(4),1038-1051.
11. Booth, A.(Ed.)(1991).Contemporary families: Looking forward, looking back.Minneapolis:National Council on Family Relations.
12. Carter, B.(Ed.),Mc-Goldrick, M.(Ed.)(1988).The changing family life cycle: A framework for family therapy.New York, NY:Gardner Press.
13. Cramer, D.(1993).Personality and marital dissolution.Personality and Individual Differences,14(4),605-607.
14. Diekmann, A.(1995).Sex-specific effects in the intergenerational transmission of divorce risks.Zeitschrift fur Soziologie,24(3),215-228.
15. Diekmann, A.,Schidheiny, K.(2008).,未出版
16. D''onofrio, B. M.,Turkheimer, E.,Emery, R. E.,Harden, K. P.,Slutske W. S.,Heath, A. C.,Madden, P. A. F.,Martin, N. G.(2007).A genetically informed study of the intergenerational transmission of marital instability.Journal of Marriage and Family,69(3),793-809.
17. Dronkers, J.,Härkönen, J.(2008).The intergenerational transmission of divorce in crossnational perspective: Results from the Fertility and Family Surveys.Population Studies: A Journal of Demography,62(3),273-288.
18. du Bois-Reymond, M.(Ed.),de Jong Gierveld, J.(Ed.)(1993).Volwassen wroden: Generaties toen en nu: Transities in de levensloop.Houten:Bohn Stafleu Van Loghum.
19. Duncan, G. J.,Saul, D. H.(1985).A reconsideration of the economic consequences of marital disruption.Demography,22,485-498.
20. Feng, D.,Giarrusso, R.,Bengtson, V. L.,Frye, N.(1999).Intergenerational transmission of marital quality and marital instability.Journal of Marriage and Family,61(2),451-463.
21. Glenn, N. D.,Kramer, K. B.(1987).The marriages and divorces of the children of divorce.Journal of Marriage and Family,49(4),811-825.
22. Greenberg, E. F.,Nay, W. R.(1982).The intergenerational transmission of marital instability reconsidered.Journal of Marriage and Family,44(2),335-348.
23. Guerin, P. J.(Ed.)(1976).Family therapy, theory and practice.New York, NY:Gardner Press.
24. Jacquet, S.E.,Surra, C. A.(2001).Parental divorce and premarital couples: Commitment and other relationship characteristics.Journal of Marriage and Family,63,627-631.
25. Jockin, V.,McGue, M.,Lykken, D. T.(1996).Personality and divorce: A genetic analysis.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,71(2),288-299.
26. Kerr, M. E.,Bowen, M.(1988).Family evaluation.New York, NY:W. W. Norton.
27. Li, J. C. A.,Wu, L. L.(2008).No trend in the intergenerational transmission of divorce.Demography,45(4),875-884.
28. Lyngstad, T. H.,Engelhardt, H.(2009).The influence of offspring's sex and age at parents' divorce on the intergenerational transmission of divorce, Norwegian first marriages 1980-2003.Population Studies: A Journal of Demography,63(2),173-185.
29. McLanahan, S.,Bumpass, L.(1988).Intergenerational consequences of family disruption.American Journal of Sociology,94(1),130-152.
30. Mueller, C. W.,Pope, H.(1977).Marital instability: A study of its transmission between generations.Journal of Marriage and Family,39(1),83-93.
31. Perren, S.,Von, W. A.,Bürgin, D.,Simoni, H.,Von, K.(2005).Intergenerational transmission of marital quality across the transition to parenthood.Family Process,44(4),441-459.
32. Sanders, M. R.,Halford, W. K.,Behrens, B. C.(1999).Parental divorce and premarital couple communication.Journal of Family Psychology,13(1),60-74.
33. Schulz, S.(2009).Intergenerational transmission of divorce and growing up in stepfamilies. Does the transmission of divorce affect stepchildren as well?.Zeitschrift Fur Familienforschung,21(1),5-29.
34. Story, L. B.,Karney, B. R.,Lawrence, E.,Bradbury, T. N.(2004).Interpersonal mediators in the intergenerational transmission of marital dysfunction.Journal of Family Psychology,18(3),519-529.
35. Tallman, I.,Gray, L. N.,Kullberg, W.,Henderson, D.(1999).The intergenerational transmission of marital conflict: Testing a process model.Social Psychology Quarterly,62(3),219-239.
36. Teachman, J. D.(2002).Childhood living arrangements and the intergenerational transmission of divorce.Journal of Marriage and Family,64(3),717-729.
37. Traag, T.,Dronkers, J.,Vallet, L. A.(2000).The intergenerational transmission of divorce risks in France.conference of research committee 28- Social Stratification of the International Sociological Association,Libourne, France:
38. Wolfinger, N. H.(2000).Beyond the intergenerational transmission of divorce - Do people replicate the patterns of marital instability they grew up with?.Journal of family issues,21(8),1061-1086.
39. Wolfinger, N. H.(1999).Trends in the intergenerational transmission of divorce.Demography,36(3),415-420.
40. Wolfinger, N. H.(2011).More evidence for trends in the intergenerational transmission of divorce: A completed cohort approach using data from the General Social Survey.Demography,48(2),581-592.
41. 王文科、王智弘(2007)。教育研究法。台北:五南。
42. 沈慶鴻(1996)。博士論文(博士論文)。國立彰化師範大學輔導學系。
43. 廖秀茸(2005)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。世新大學社會心理學系。
44. 羅皓誠、洪雅鳳(2011)。重整之路：再婚家庭常見的議題與介入考量。臺灣心理諮商季刊，3(1)，29-48。

1. 黃宜翎(2015)。以家庭系統理論探討夫妻親密互動關係。諮商與輔導，349，19-21。
2. 劉宗幸,陳婉真,許立亞,江守峻(2020)。青少年憂鬱的代間傳遞：個人、家庭與學校保護性因子之相關研究。家庭教育與諮商學刊，22，59-84。