我「受創」故我「消費」：比較家庭與同儕關係對於大學生流行消費之影響

I Suffered Therefore I Buy: Family and Peer Effects on Fashion Consumption among College Students

10.30074/FJMH.201409_27(3).0003

吳明燁(Ming-Yeh Wu)；許絲茜(Scc-Chien Hsu)

流行消費 ； 家庭關係 ； 同儕關係 ； 性別效應 ； 寂寞感 ； fashion consumption ； family relationship ； peer relationship ； gender effect ； sense of loneliness

中華心理衛生學刊

27卷3期（2014 / 09 / 01）

379 - 408

繁體中文

研究目的：流行消費的主要目的已不是為了滿足基本需求，而在於追求情感性的與社會性的目標。本研究從社會互動的觀點探討青少年階段的同儕與家庭關係如何影響大學生的流行消費行為，並進一步檢視性別效應與寂寞感的中介作用。研究方法：我們使用「台灣青少年成長歷程研究」針對中學(第一至六波)以及大二(第八波)階段的長期追蹤問卷調查資料，篩選就讀一般或技職體系的大學生做為分析樣本，共計1,070位，並運用多元迴歸分析法進行統計檢定。研究結果：本研究有兩個主要發現：（一）友誼受創事件和家庭受創事件有提高流行消費支出的作用，但家庭受創事件的影響僅限於女性，對於男性的影響不顯著；（二）寂寞感對於受創事件和流行消費行為之間的連結具有中介作用，但寂寞感的中介作用是有性別效應的，只有女性受中介因素的影響。研究結論：本研究顯示負面的社會關係對於大學生流行消費行為的影響效果與影響路徑因性別因素而不同。往後的消費研究可就性別因素進行更有系統的探討。

Purpose: For the younger generation, fashion consumption is focused on social and emotional aspects rather than on basic needs. The current study investigates how family and peer interactions during adolescence affect fashion consumption among college students. It further examines whether the associations vary according to gender and whether they are mediated by a sense of loneliness. From the perspective of social interaction, we hypothesize that (1) peer or family traumatic events are associated with greater fashion consumption and the association is mediated by a sense of loneliness, (2) the associations among traumatic events, the sense of loneliness, and fashion consumption is stronger for female college students than for males. Methods: The empirical data used to examine the hypotheses were taken from Taiwan Youth Project (TYP), a longitudinal survey research project conducted by the Institute of Sociology, Academic Sinica. The TYP survey, launched in 2000, applies a multistage stratified-cluster random sampling framework to obtain school-based representative samples. The sampled students were seventh graders when the first-wave survey was administered. Annual follow-up surveys continued until 2009. The data analyzed in this study include reports collected at both high school (waves 1 to 6, from March 2000 to March 2005) and college stage (wave 8, June 2007). The sample size was 1,070. Two-stage multiple regression analysis was employed to investigate gender effects on the association between social relationships and fashion consumption. Two separate multiple regression analyses were then used to further examine whether the association between social relationships and fashion consumption is mediated by a sense of loneliness. Results: There were two major findings. First, both friendship and family traumatic events promote expenditure on fashion consumption as hypothesized, but the effect of family traumatic events was significant only for female and not male students. Secondly, the effect of friendship and family traumatic events on expenditure on fashion consumption is mediated by loneliness. The mediating effect of lonliness, however, was only significant among female but not male students. Specifically, female college students who had ever suffered negative friendships were more likely to have a stronger sense of loneliness and then to make greater expenditures on fashion consumption. Conclusions: The social and emotional influence model proposed by this study seems fitting for females rather than for males. It indicates research on fashion consumption need to pay attention on gender effects.

1. 方紫薇(2010)。網路沉迷、因應、孤寂感與網路社會支持之關係：男女大學生之比較。教育心理學報，41(4)，773-797。
   連結：
2. 王韻、詹夢菱(2011)。流行涉入程度對大學生身體意象的影響。身體文化學報，12，41-65。
   連結：
3. 池文海、張書豪(2006)。商店關係投資與滿意度：寂寞感之多層次干擾效果。臺大管理論叢，16(2)，1-28。
   連結：
4. 林定立(2002)。消費文化中「資訊崇拜」的意義。資訊社會研究，3，63-84。
   連結：
5. 徐淑敏、林麗華(2007)。國小高年級學童的金錢態度與消費行為。教育實踐與研究，20(2)，1-28。
   連結：
6. 程景琳(2010)。社交計量及同儕知覺受歡迎度與青少年關係攻擊及孤寂感之相關研究。教育心理學報，42(1)，143-162。
   連結：
7. 行政院主計處(2009)：《九十八年青少年狀況調查統計結果》。台北：行政院主計處。
8. Abrutyn, S.,Mueller, A. S.(2014).Are suicidal behaviors contagious in adolescence? Using longitudinal data to examine suicide suggestion.American Sociological Review,79(2),211-227.
9. Bakewell, C.,Mitchell, V. W.,Rothwell, M.(2006).UK generation Y male fashion consciousness.Journal of Fashion Marketing and Management: An International Journal,10(2),169-180.
10. Baudrillard, J.(1988).America.New York:Verso.
11. Blumer, H.(1969).Fashion: From class differentiation to collective selection.Sociological Quarterly,10,275-291.
12. Bourdieu, P.(1984).Distinction: A social critique of the judgment of taste.Cambridge, MA:Harvard University Press.
13. Brage, D.,Meredith, W.,Woodward, J.(1993).Correlates of loneliness among midwestern adolescents.Adolescence,28(111),685-693.
14. Buunk, A. P.,Gibbons, F. X.(2007).Social comparison: The end of a theory and the emergence of a field.Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,102(1),3-21.
15. Cassidy, J.,Asher, S. R.(1992).Loneliness and peer relations in young children.Child Development,63(2),350-365.
16. Charles, K. K.,Hurst, E.,Roussanov, N.(2009).Conspicuous consumption and race.Quarterly Journal of Economics,124(2),425-467.
17. Chen-Yu, J. H.,Seock, Y. K.(2002).Adolescents' Clothing purchse motivations, information sources, and store selection criteria: A comparison of male/female and impulse/nonimpulse shoppers.Family and Consumer Sciences Research Journal,31(1),50-77.
18. Cotte, J.,Wood, S. L.(2004).Families and innovative consumer behavior: A triadic study of siblings and parents.Journal of Consumer Research,31(1),78-86.
19. DeLeire, T.,Kalil, A.(2010).Does consumption buy happiness? Evidence from the United States.International Review of Economics,57(2),163-176.
20. DeVault, M. L.(1991).Feeding the Family: the Social Organization of Caring as Gendered Work.Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
21. Erikson, E. H.(1980).Identity and the Life Cycle.New York:Norton.
22. Falk, P.(ed.),Campbell, C.(ed.)(1997).The Shopping Experience.London:Sage.
23. Forman, A. M.,Sriram, V.(1991).The depersonalization of retailing: Its impact on the "lonely" consumer.Journal of Retailing,67(2),226-243.
24. Goldberg, M. E.,Gorn, G. J.,Peracchio, L. A.,Bamossy, G.(2003).Understanding materialism among youth.Journal of Consumer Psychology,13(3),278-288.
25. Griffith, D. A.(2003).Intimacy, rites of passage and social support: Symbolic meaning from lifetime shopping experience.The International Review of Retail, Distribution and Consumer Research,13(3),263-278.
26. Guillen-Royo, M.(2008).Consumption and subjective wellbeing: Exploring basic needs, social comparison, social integration and Hedonism in Peru.Social Indicators Research,89(3),535-555.
27. Hojat, M.(1982).Loneliness as a function of parent-child and peer relations.Journal of Psychology,112(1),129-133.
28. Hojat, M.,Borenstein, B. D.,Shapurian, R.(1990).Perception of childhood dissatisfaction with parents and selected personality traits in adulthood.Journal of General Psychology,117(3),241-253.
29. Jackson, S.(Ed.),Rodriguez-Tome, H.(Ed.)(1993).Adolescence and its Social Worlds.Hillsdale, NJ:Erlbaum.
30. Kim, Y. K.,Kang, J.,Kim, M.(2005).The relationships among family and social interaction, loneliness, mall shopping motivation, and mall spending of older consumers.Psychology & Marketing,22(12),995-1015.
31. Lascu, D. N.,Zinkhan, G.(1999).Consumer conformity: Review and applications for marketing theory and practices.Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice,7(3),1-12.
32. Marcoen, A.,Brumagne, M.(1985).Loneliness among children and young adolescents.Developmental Psychology,21(6),1025-1031.
33. Miller, D.(1998).A Theory of Shopping.Cambridge:Polity Press.
34. Moore, D.,Schultz, N. R.(1983).Loneliness at adolescence: Correlates, attributions, and coping.Journal of Youth and Adolescence,12(2),95-100.
35. Mowen, J. C.(2004).Exploring the trait of competitiveness and its consumer behavior consequences.Journal of Consumer Psychology,14(1-2),52-63.
36. Noble, S. M.,Griffith, D. A.,Adjei, M. T.(2006).Drivers of local merchant loyalty: Understanding the influence of gender and shopping motives.Journal of Retailing,82(3),177-188.
37. O'Cass, A.(2004).Fashion clothing consumption: Antecedents and consequences of fashion clothing involvement.European Journal of Marketing,38(7),869-882.
38. Otnes, C.,McGrath, M. A.(2001).Perceptions and realities of male shopping behavior.Journal of Retailing,77(1),111-137.
39. Peplau, L. A.(ed.),Perlman, D.(ed.)(1982).Loneliness: A Sourcebook of Current Theory, Research and Therapy.New York:Wiley.
40. Reed II, A.,Wooten, D. B.,Bolton, L. E.(2002).The temporary construction of consumer attitudes.Journal of Consumer Psychology,12(4),375-388.
41. Richins, M. L.(1994).Valuing things: The public and private meanings of possessions.Journal of Consumer Research,21(3),504-521.
42. Rose, G. M.,Dalakas, V.,Kropp, F.(2003).Consumer socialization and parental style across cultures: Findings from Australia, Greece, and India.Journal of Consumer Psychology,13(4),366-376.
43. Rotenberg, K. J.,Bartley, J. L.(1997).Children's stigmatization of chronic loneliness in peers.Journal of Social Behavior and Personality,12(2),577-584.
44. Russell, D.,Peplau, L. A.,Cutrona, C. E.(1980).The revised UCLA loneliness scale: concurrent and discriminant validity evidence.Journal of personality and Social Psychology,39(3),472-480.
45. Sener, A.(2011).Influences of adolescents on family purchasing behavior: Perceptions of adolescents and parents.Social Behavior and Personality: An International Journal,39(6),747-754.
46. Simmel, G.(1957).Fashion.American Journal of Sociology,62(6),541-558.
47. Tauber, E. M.(1972).Marketing notes and communication: Why do people shop?.Journal of Marketing,36,46-59.
48. Underhill, P.(1999).Why We Buy: the Science of Shopping.New York:Simon & Schuste.
49. Weiss, R. S.(1973).Loneliness: The Experience of Emotional and Social Isolation.Cambridge, MA:MIT Press.
50. Winship, C.,Mare, R. D.(1992).Models for sample selection bias.Annual Reviews of Sociology,18,327-350.
51. Wong, Y. T.,Osman, S.,Said, A.,Paim, L.(2014).Moderating effect of gender in repatronage behavioral intention: The role of personal characteristics.Asian Social Science,10(1),106-116.
52. Woodward, L.,Fergusson, D. M.,Belsky, J.(2000).Timing of parental separation and attachment to parents in adolescence: Results of a prospective study from birth to age 16.Journal of Marriage and Family,62(1),162-174.
53. Youniss, J.,Smollar, J.(1985).Adolescent relations with mothers, father and friends.Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
54. 王以仁(1989)。大學生寂寞感之相關研究。嘉義師院學報，3，1-53。
55. 朱瑞玲(1997)。青少年性格量表之編製。測驗年刊，44(2)，21-46。
56. 吳靜吉(1994)。害羞、寂寞、愛。台北:遠流出版社。
57. 李玉瑛(2006)。Shopping、血拼、瞎拼：逛街購物研究的初探。臺灣社會學刊，37，207-236。
58. 林儒君(2004)。大學生人格特質與消費態度之研究—以臺南地區為例。臺南女院學報，23(1)，37-52。
59. 胡蘭沁(2007)。大學生之背景、生活型態及兼職工作對其消費決策型態及消費類型影響力之探討。人文研究學報，4(2)，99-124。
60. 張瑾芳、申屠光(2006)。現代青年人的服裝消費價值觀與個人因素之探討—以台北大專與研究生為例。華岡紡織期刊，13(2)，230-238。
61. 陳高生、顏仲汝(2010)。論吞世代流行文化與消費價值：以潮流服飾為例。華岡紡織期刊，17(1)，33-44。
62. 黃宜貞、王桂芸、陳金彌(2010)。孤寂的概念分析。護理雜誌，57(5)，96-101。