結合多重訊息來源篩檢3歲以下自閉症類群疾患幼兒

Combining Information from Multiple Sources to Screen Children with Autism Spectrum Disorders under the Age of 3 Years

10.30074/FJMH.201512_28(4).0007

吳進欽(Chin-Chin Wu)；侯育銘(Yuh-Ming Hou)；朱慶琳(Ching-Lin Chu)；李羽涵(Yu-Han Lee)

臺灣版兩歲期自閉症篩檢工具 ； 自閉症類群疾患 ； 克氏行為量表 ； 篩檢 ； Screening Tool for Autism in Two-Year-Olds Taiwan Version ； autism spectrum disorders ； Clancy Behavior Scale ； screening

中華心理衛生學刊

28卷4期（2015 / 12 / 01）

605 - 630

繁體中文

研究目的：臨床實務常使用篩檢工具協助自閉症類群幼兒之診斷。本研究探究結合多重訊息來源篩檢年幼自閉症類群之效度。研究方法：本文研究期間為2012年4月至2015年4月。參與者為24至36個月大的自閉症類群或發展遲緩幼兒各45名，及其家長，兩組幼兒在生理年齡、整體心理年齡及性別比例，沒有顯著差異。使用「臺灣版兩歲期自閉症篩檢工具」與「克氏行為量表」進行評估。兩組幼兒接受臺灣版兩歲期自閉症篩檢工具評估，家長填寫克氏行為量表。克氏行為量表以全部14題(克氏行為量表-14)及關鍵9題(克氏行為量表-9)進行分析。研究結果：單一篩檢工具，臺灣版兩歲期自閉症篩檢工具以2作為切截分數，敏感度.89、特異度.84；CBS-14以12為切截分數，敏感度為.78、特異度為.71；克氏行為量表-9以7為切截分數，敏感度及特異度皆為.76。結合兩項篩檢工具時，臺灣版兩歲期自閉症篩檢工具與克氏行為量表-14一致時，敏感度.97、特異度.96；臺灣版兩歲期自閉症篩檢工具與克氏行為量表-9一致時，敏感度.97、特異度1。研究結論：本研究再次驗證臺灣版兩歲期自閉症篩檢工具是具備良好效度的層次二ASDs幼兒篩檢工具，而克氏行為量表僅為可接受程度。合併臺灣版兩歲期自閉症篩檢工具與克氏行為量表使用時，能提升診斷正確性，如二者結果不一致，宜以訪談澄清。

Purpose: It is conventional to use screening tools to diagnose children with autism spectrum disorders (ASDs) in a clinical setting. However, no study has used different ASDs screening tools simultaneously to screen young children with ASDs. In the current study, we examine the validity of diagnoses based on combining multiple information sources for screening young children with ASDs. Methods: A total of 90 young children aged 24 -36 months and their caregivers were recruited between April 2012 and April 2015. They comprised two groups, including 45 with ASDs, and 45 with developmental delays. The groups were matched on chronological age, mental age, and sex ratio. The Screening Tool for Autism in Two-Year-Olds Taiwan Version (T-STAT) and the Clancy Behavior Scale (CBS) were used simultaneously to screen ASDs. The T-STAT is an interactive tool in which the examiner directly observes the social-communicative behaviors of the children in strange contexts. The CBS is a parent report questionnaire for caregivers to fill out based on the daily behaviors of their children. For the CBS, we used two criteria: sum scores of the total 14 items (CBS-14), and the critical nine items (CBS-9). Results: Using 2 as the cutoff for the T-STAT, the results yielded a sensitivity of .89, and a specificity of .84. The T-STAT had good accuracy of classification. Using 12 as the cutoff score for the CBS-14, the results indicated a sensitivity of .78, and specificity of. 71. Using the 7 as the cutoff score for the CBS-9, the results indicated a sensitivity and specificity of .76. The CBS had an acceptable classification accuracy, but the accuracy of the T-STAT was higher. Combining the T-STAT and the CBS-14 yielded a sensitivity of .97 and specificity of .96. Combining the T-STAT and the CBS-9 yielded a sensitivity of .97 and specificity of 1. The results indicated that combing multiple information sources resulted in excellent classification accuracy. Conclusions: The current study replicated prior results indicating that the T-STAT is a promising level-two screening tool for differentiating young children with ASDs from young children with developmental delays. However, the CBS is only an acceptable leveltwo screening tool. Combining the information from the two screening tools in a clinical setting yielded excellent sensitivity and specificity. However, when the results of the T-STAT and CBS are different, an interview may be needed to further clarify the diagnosis.

1. 吳進欽、朱慶琳、侯育銘、林姿伶、姜忠信(2014)。T-STAT評估18~24個月自閉症類嬰幼兒效度探究。中華心理衛生學刊，27(4)，621-644。
   連結：
2. 吳進欽、朱慶琳、侯育銘、姚淑芬(2014)。克氏行為量表篩檢4歲以下自閉症類疾患兒童效度探究。中華心理衛生學刊，27(1)，131-161。
   連結：
3. 吳進欽、姜忠信、侯育銘(2013)。兩歲前自閉症類疾患嬰幼兒篩檢工具：文獻回顧。中華心理衛生學刊，26(4)，549-548。
   連結：
4. 姜忠信、吳進欽、劉俊宏、侯育銘(2012)。2-3歲自閉症幼兒篩檢量表的發展：T-STAT的初究。中華心理衛生學刊，25(1)，135-154。
   連結：
5. 姜忠信、宋維村(2005)。自閉症嬰幼兒的早期診斷：文獻回顧。臨床心理學刊，2(1)，1-10。
   連結：
6. American Psychiatric Association(2000).Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders.Washington DC:American Psychiatric Association.
7. American Psychiatric Association(2013).Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders.Washington DC:American Psychiatric Association.
8. Bryson, S. E.,Rogers, S. J.,Fombonne, E.(2003).Autism spectrum disorders: Early detection, intervention, education, and Psychopharmacological management.The Canadian Journal of Psychiatry,48(8),506-516.
9. Charman, T.,Taylor, E.,Drew, A.,Cockerill, H.,Brown, J. A.,Baird, G.(2005).Outcome at 7 years of children diagnosed with autism at age 2: Predictive validity of assessments conducted at 2 and 3 years of age and pattern of symptom change over time.Child Psychology and Psychiatry,46(5),500-513.
10. Chawarska, K.,Klin, A.,Paul, R.,Macari, S.,Volkmar, F.(2009).A prospective study of toddlers with ASD: Short-term diagnostic and cognitive outcomes.Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry,50(10),1235-1245.
11. Chiang, C. H.,Wu, C. C.,Hou, Y. M.,Chu, C. L.,Liu, J. H.,Soong, W. T.(2013).Development of T-STAT for early autism screening.Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders,43(5),1028-1037.
12. Corsello, C. M.,Akshoomoff, N.,Stahmer, A. C.(2013).Diagnosis of autism spectrum disorders in 2-year-olds: A study of community practice.The Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry,54(2),178-185.
13. Daniels, A. M.,Mandell, D. S.(2014).Explaining differences in age at autism spectrum disorder diagnosis: A critical review.Autism,18(5),583-597.
14. Filipek, P. A.,Accardo, P. J.,Ashwal, S.,Baranek, G. T.,Cook, E. H., Jr.,Dawson, G.,Volkmar, F. R.(2000).Practice parameter: Screening and diagnosis of autism: Report of the quality standards subcommittee of the American Academy of Neurology and the Child Neurology Society.Neurology,55(4),468-479.
15. Glascoe, F. P.(2005).Screening for developmental and behavioral problems.Mental Retardation and Developmental Disabilities,11(3),173-179.
16. Gotham, K.,Risi, S.,Pickles, A.,Lord, C.(2007).The Autism Diagnostic Observation Schedule: Revised algorithms for improved diagnostic validity.Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders,37(4),613-627.
17. Inada, N.,Koyama, T.,Inokuchi, E.,Kuroda, M.,Kamio, Y.(2011).Reliability and validity of the Japanese version of the modified checklist for autism in toddlers (M-CHAT).Research in Autism Spectrum Disorders,5(1),330-336.
18. Khowaja, M. K.,Hazzard, A. P.,Robins, D. L.(2015).Sociodemographic barriers to early detection of autism: Screening and evaluation using the M-CHAT, M-CHAT-R, and follow-up.Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders,45(6),1797-1808.
19. Kim, S.,Lord, C.(2012).Combining information from multiple sources for the diagnosis of autism spectrum disorders for toddlers and young preschoolers from 12 to 47 months of age.Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry,53(2),143-151.
20. Kim, S.,Lord, C.(2012).New Autism Diagnostic Interview-Revised (ADI-R) algorithms for toddlers and young preschoolers from 12 to 47 months of age.Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders,42(1),82-93.
21. Kleinman, J. M.,Robin, D. L.,Ventola, P. E.,Pandey, J.,Boorstein, H. C.,Esser, E. L.,Fein, D.(2008).The modified checklist for autism in toddlers: A follow-up study investigating the early detection of autism spectrum disorders.Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders,38(5),827-839.
22. Le Couteur, A.,Haden, G.,Hammal, D.,McConachie, H.(2008).Diagnosing autism spectrum disorders in pre-school children using two standardised assessment instruments: The ADI-R and the ADOS.Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders,38(2),362-372.
23. Lord, C.,Risi, S.,DiLavore, P. S.,Shulman, C.,Thurm, A.,Pickles, A.(2006).Autism from 2 to 9 years of age.Archives of General Psychiatry,63(6),694-701.
24. Lord, C.,Rutter, M.,DiLavore, P. C.,Risi, S.(1999).Autism Diagnostic Observation (ADOS).Los Angeles, CA:Western Psychological Services.
25. Luyster, R.,Gotham, K.,Guthire, W.,Coffing, M.,Petrak, R.,Pierce, K.,Lord, C.(2009).The Autism Observation Schedule-Toddler module: A new module of a standardized diagnostic measure for autism spectrum disorders.Journal of Autism and Developmen-tal Disorders,39(9),1305-1320.
26. Mullen, E.(1995).Mullen Scales of Early Learning.Circle Pines, MN:American Guidance Service.
27. Noterdaeme, M.,Hutzelmeyer-Nickels, A.(2010).Early symptoms and recognition of pervasive developmental disorders in Germany.Autism,14(6),575-588.
28. Nygren, G.,Cederlund, M.,Sandberg, E.,Gillstedt, F.,Arvidsson, T.,Gillberg, I. C.,Gillberg, C.(2012).The prevalence of autism spectrum disorders in toddlers: A population study of 2-year-old Swedish children.Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders,42(7),1491-1497.
29. Ozonoff, S.,Goodlin-Jones, B. L.,Solomon, M.(2005).Evidence-based assessment of autism spectrum disorders in children and adolescents.Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology,34(3),523-540.
30. Pallant, J.(2010).SPSS Survival Manual: A step by step guide to data analysis using SPSS.NY:The McGraw-Hill companies.
31. Risi, S.,Lord, C.,Gotham, K.,Corsello, C.,Chrysler, C.,Szatmari, P.,Pickles, A.(2006).Combining information from multiple sources in the diagnosis of autism spectrum disorders.Journal of the American Academy of child and Adolescent Psychiatry,45(9),1094-1103.
32. Robins, D. L.,Casagrande, K.,Barton, M. L.,Chen, C. M. A.,Dumont-Mathieu, T.,Fein, D.(2014).Validation of the modified checklist for autism in toddlers, revised with follow-up (M-CHAT-R/F).Pediatrics,133(1),37-45.
33. Robins, D. L.,Fein, D.,Barton, M. L.,Green, J. A.(2001).The modified checklist for autism in toddlers: An initial study investigating the early detection of autism and pervasive developmental disorders.Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders,31(2),131-144.
34. Rogers, S. J.(2009).What are infant siblings teaching us about autism in infancy?.Autism Research,2(3),125-137.
35. Rogers, S. J.,Hepburn, S. L.,Stackhouse, T.,Wehner, E.(2003).Imitation performance in toddlers with autism and those with other developmental disorders.Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry,44(5),763-781.
36. Rutter, M.,Le Couteur, A.,Lord, C.(2003).Autism Diagnostic Interview-Revised (ADI-R).Los Angeles, CA:Western Psychological Services.
37. Stone, W. L.,Coonrod, E. E.,Ousley, O. Y.(2000).Screening tool for autism in two-year-olds (STAT): Development and preliminary data.Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders,30(6),607-612.
38. Stone, W. L.,Lee, E. B.,Adhford, L.,Brissie, J.,Hepburn, S. L.,Coonrod, E. E.,Weiss, B. H.(1999).Can autism be diagnosed accurately in children under 3 years?.Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry,40(2),219-226.
39. Swets, J. A.(1988).Measuring the accuracy of diagnostic systems.Science,240(4857),1285-1293.
40. Tsai, W. C.,Soong, W. T.,Shyu, Y. I.(2012).Toddler autism screening questionnaire: Development and potential clinical validity.Autism,16(4),340-349.
41. Turner, L. M.,Stone, W. L.(2007).Variability in outcome for children with an ASD diagnosis at age 2.Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry,48(8),793-802.
42. Wetherby, A. M.(Ed.),Prizant, B. M.(Ed.)(2000).Autism spectrum disorders: A transactional developmental perspective.Baltimore:Brookes.
43. Wiggins, L. D.,Baio, J.,Rice, C.(2006).Examination of the time between first evaluation and first autism spectrum diagnosis in a population-based sample.Developmental and Behavioral Pediatrics,27(2 Suppl),s79-s87.
44. Wong, V.,Hui, L. H.,Lee, W. C.,Leung, L. S.,Ho, P. K.,Lau, W. L.,Chung, B.(2004).A modified screening tool for autism (Checklist for autism in toddlers [CHAT-23] for Chinese children.Pediatrics,114(2),166-176.
45. Zwaigenbaum, L.,Bryson, S.,Lord, C.,Rogers, S.,Carter, A.,Carver, L.,Yirmiya, N.(2009).Clinical assessment and management of toddlers with suspected autism spectrum disorders: Insights from studies of high-risk Infants.Pediatrics,123(5),1383-1391.
46. 黃毅志(1998)。臺灣地區新職業分類的建構與評估。調查研究，5，5-36。
47. 謝清芬、宋維村、徐澄清(1983)。自閉症：克氏行為量表的效度與研究。中華民國神經精神醫學會會刊，9，17-26。

1. 陳庭筠,吳進欽,甘如晶(2018)。克氏行為量表篩檢自閉症類群障礙嬰幼兒的效度探究。臨床心理學刊，12(1/2)，35-51。
2. 陳奕臻,洪楹佳,吳進欽(2019)。修訂版學步期自閉症檢核表在不同場域篩檢自閉症類群障礙症幼兒的正確率。特殊教育研究學刊，44(3)，33-61。
3. 陳昭芬,吳進欽(2019)。台灣學齡前自閉症類群障礙兒童篩檢工具：文獻回顧。若瑟醫護雜誌，13(1)，23-37。
4. 陳昭芬,吳進欽(2021)。克氏行為量表篩檢自閉症類群障礙症幼兒：追蹤研究。若瑟醫護雜誌，15(1)，6-19。
5. 陳昭芬,吳進欽(2023)。自閉症類群障礙症幼兒社會功能的發展：縱貫研究。若瑟醫護雜誌，17(1)，6-20。
6. 侯育銘、吳進欽、朱慶琳(2016)。2歲前自閉症類群障礙症早期篩檢：18個月後追蹤。中華心理衛生學刊，29(4)，327-356。