日常活動理論分析護理人員職場暴力被害恐懼感之成因

Fear of Workplace Violence among Nursing Staff in Taiwan: A Routine Activities Perspective

10.30074/FJMH.201706_30(2).0003

賴擁連(YUNG-LIEN LAI)；苗延宇(MIAO, YAN-YU)

醫療暴力 ； 職場暴行 ； 護理人員 ； 日常活動 ； 被害恐懼感 ； medical violence ； workplace violence ； nursing staff ； routine activities ； fear of victimization

中華心理衛生學刊

30卷2期（2017 / 06 / 01）

195 - 219

繁體中文

研究目的：本研究希望從環境犯罪學視角，嘗試探討「日常活動理論」對於護理人員職場暴力被害恐懼感之影響，進而提出適切的預防措施或對策。研究方法：本研究乃運用日常活動理論為研究框架，採取問卷調查法設計問卷，並利用方便抽樣法，於2015年1至2月成功地自紙本問卷與網路問卷獲得251受訪者。研究結果：在調查期間的過去一 年，高達87.6%的受訪者自陳在工作場所曾有暴力攻擊或侵害的被害經驗，在此同時，受訪者也表達出高度的職場暴力恐懼感。透過OLS迴歸模式分析後發現，女性、有被害經驗者、在急診加護單位服務者、曾接受過暴力因應訓練者、暴露在危險情境愈高者以及對於潛在性犯罪人可接近性愈高者，顯著地表達出較高的職場暴力恐懼感，但工作場域監控力愈強者和工作場域有裝設緊急通報按鈕者，顯著地表達出較低的暴力被害恐懼感。研究結論：秉持被害預防應從日常活動與工作環境之改造著手，建議提升辨識高風險病患之能力、區隔高風險病患之醫療作為、強化工作環境的監控力道以及加強醫護人員自我防護能力，期能降低護理人員職場暴力恐懼感。

Purpose: While medical violence has attracted much attention on the part of scholars and practitioners alike, little empirical research is available on fear of workplace violence within medical settings in Taiwan. This study draws on the routine activities approach to explore the levels and influence of fear of workplace violence among nursing staff in Taiwan’s medical institutions. Methods: Using convenience sampling, we collected data via mail and online surveys between January and February in 2015. As a result, a total of 251 respondents have been reached to conduct a self-administered questionnaire. Results: More than 87% of respondents reported that they had experienced some kind of workplace violence from patients or visitors in the previous 12 months prior to this survey. These respondents expressed a high level of fear of violence in workplace at 5.02 on a 6-point scale. OLS multiple regression models showed that while the variables of female, victimization, emergency room (ER) and intensive care unit (ICU), being well-trained experiences, exposure to risky patients, and accessibility to potential offenders dramatically increased the level of fear of workplace violence, workplace surveillance and the presence of an emergency alarm system significantly reduced the probability of fear of workplace violence. Conclusion: Policy implications derived from the routine activities approach are as follows: improve nurses’ ability to identify high-risk patients, separate the high-risk patients from other patients, strengthen surveillance and monitoring of the workplace, and strengthen the self-protection abilities of medical staff.

1. 邊立中、鄭雅文、陳怡欣、陳秋蓉(2014)。職場暴力盛行率與受僱者健康狀況之相關。台灣衛誌，33，36-50。
   連結：
2. 中時電子報(2013)：蘆竹鄉代王貴芬掌摑護士 反告長庚恐嚇。2013年11月28日。http://www.chinatimes.com/newspapers/20131128000379-260102
3. American Nurses Association(2001).Nurses cite stress, overwork as top health, safety concern.American Nurse,33(5),1.
4. Antunes, M. J. L.(2006).Routine activities and television viewing: An exploration of the influences of fear of crime in Lisbon, Portugal.International Journal of Comparative and Applied Criminal Justice,30(1),1-23.
5. Arnetz, J. E.,Arnetz, B. B.(2001).Violence towards health care staff and possible effects on the quality of patient care.Social Science & Medicine,52,417-427.
6. Carroll, V.,Morin, K. H.(1997).Workplace violence affects one third of nurses.American Nurse,30(5),15-15.
7. CDC,NIOSH(1996).Current intelligence bulletin 57: Violence in the workplace,57
8. Chen, W.-C.,Sun, Y.-H.,Lan, T.-H.,Chiu, H.-J.(2009).Incidence and risk factors of workplace violence on nursing staffs caring for chronic psychiatric patients in Taiwan.International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health,6(11),2812-2821.
9. Cohen, L. E.,Felson, M.(1979).Social change and crime rate trends: a routine activity approach.American Sociological Review,44,588-608.
10. Cooper, C. L.,Swanson, N.(2002).Violence in the health sector-State of the art (WHO Report)s..Geneva:Organizacion Internacional de Trabajo.
11. Di Martino, V.(2002).Workplace violence in the health sector - country case studies Brazil, Bulgaria, Lebanon, Portugal, South Africa, Thailand and an additional Australian study:Synthesis report.Geneva:ILO/ICN/WHO/PSI Joint Programme on Workplace Violence in the Health Sector.
12. Duncan, S. M.,Hyndman, K.,Estabrooks, C. A.,Hesketh, K.,Humphrey, C. K.,Wong, J. S.,Giovannetti, P.(2001).Nurses experience of violence in Alberta and British Columbia Hospitals.Canadian Journal of Nursing Reseach,32(4),57-78.
13. Elliott, P. P.(1997).Violence in health care: What nurse managers need to know.Nursing Management,28(12),38-41.
14. Fernandes, C. M.,Raboud, J. M.,Christenson, J. M.,Bouthillette, F.,Bullock, L.,Ouellet, L.,Moore, C. C. F.(2002).The effect of an education program on violence in the emergency department.Annals of Emergency Medicine,39(1),47-55.
15. Ferraro, K. F.(1995).Fear of crime: Interpreting victimization risk.New York:State University of New York Press.
16. Finkelhor, D.,Asdigian, N. J.(1996).Risk factors for youth victimization: Beyond a lifestyle/routine activities approach.Violence and Victims,24,35-65.
17. Gates, D. M.,Ross, C. S.,McQueen, L.(2006).Violence against emergency department workers.Journal of Emergency Medicine,31(3),331-337.
18. Gerberich, S. G.,Church, T. R.,McGovern, P. M.,Hansen, H. E.,Nachreiner, N. M.,Geisser, M. S.,Watt, G. D.(2004).An epidemiological study of the magnitude and consequences of work related violence: The Minnesota Nurses' Study.Occupational and Environmental Medicine,61(6),495-503.
19. Gerberich, S. G.,Church, T. R.,McGovern, P. M.,Hansen, H.,Nachreiner, N. M.,Geisser, M. S.,Jurek, A.(2005).Risk factors for work-related assaults on nurses.Epidemiology,16(5),704-709.
20. Hahn, S.,Müller, M.,Hantikainen, V.,Kok, G.,Dassen, T.,Halfens, R. J. G.(2013).Risk factors associated with patient and visitor violence in general hospitals: Results of a multiple regression analysis.International Journal of Nursing Studies,50,374-385.
21. Henderson, A.(2003).Nurses and workplace violece: Nurses' experience of verbal and physical abuse at workplace.Canadian Journal of Nursing Leadership,16(4),82-98.
22. Judge, G. G.,Hill, R. C.,Griffiths, W. E.,Lütkepohl, H.,Lee, T.-C.(1988).Introduction to the Theory and Practice of Econometrics.New York:John Wiley.
23. Lai, Y.-L.,Ren, L.,Greenleaf, R.(2017).Residence-based fear of crime: A routine activities approach.International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology,61(9),1011-1037.
24. Landau, S. F.,Bendalak, Y.(2008).Personnel exposure to violence in hospital emergency wards: A routine activity approach.Aggressive Behavior,34(1),88-103.
25. Lane, J.,Rader, N. E.,Henson, B.,Fisher, B. S.,May, D. C.(2014).Fear of crime in the United States: Causes, consequences, and contradictions.Durham, North Carolina:Carolina Academic Press.
26. Lanza, M. L.,Zeiss, R.,Rierdan, J.(2005).Violence assessment, medication, and prevention: Factors related to staff violence and implications.Washington, D.C.:American Nurses Association Conference.
27. Lee, S.-h. S.,Gerberich, S. G.,Waller, L. A.,Anderson, A.,McGovern, P.(1999).Workrelated assault injuries among nurses.Epidemiology,10(6),685-691.
28. Magin, P. J.,May, J.,McElduff, P.,Goode, S. M.,Adams, J.,Cotter, G. L.(2011).Occupational violence in general practice: A whole-of-practice problem. Results of a cross-sectional study.Australian Health Review,35(1),75-80.
29. Magnavita, N.,Heponiemi, T.(2012).Violence towards health care workers in a public health care facility in Italy: A repeated cross-sectional study.BMC Health Services Research,12,108-116.
30. Mahoney, B.(1991).The extent, nature, and response to victimization of emergency nurses in Pennsylvania.Journal of Emergency Nursing,17(5),282-291.
31. Mayhew, C.,Chappell, D.(2003).The occupational violence experiences of 400 Australian health workers: An exploratory study.Journal of Occupational Health and Safety,19(6),3-43.
32. McPhaul, K. M.,London, M.,Murrett, K.,Flannery, K.,Rosen, J.,Lipscomb, J.(2008).Environmental evaluation for workplace violence in healthcare and social services.Journal of Safety Research,39,237-250.
33. Miethe, T. D.,Meier, R. F.(1994).Crime and its social context: Toward an integrated theory of offenders, victims, and situations.Albany:State University of New York Press.
34. Pai, H. C.,Lee, S.(2011).Risk factors for workplace violence in clinical registered nurses in Taiwan.Journal of Clinical Nursing,20,1405-1412.
35. Pompeii, L.,Dement, J.,Schoenfisch, A.,Lavery, A.,Souder, M.,Smith, C.,Lipscomb, H.(2013).Perpetrator, worker and workplace characteristics associated with patient and visitor perpetrated violence (Type II) on hospital workers: A review of the literature and existing occupational injury data.Journal of Safety Research,44,57-64.
36. Rogers, K. A.,Chappell, D.(2003).Preventing and Responding to Violence at Work.Geneva:International Labour Office.
37. Rountree, P.(1998).A reexamination of the crime-fear linkage.Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency,35,341-372.
38. Rountree, P.,Land, K. C.(1996).Burglary victimization, perceptions of crime risk, and routine activities: A multilevel analysis across Seattle neighborhoods and census tracts.Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency,33,147-180.
39. 李選、白香菊、顏文娟(2010)。台灣護理人員職場暴力經驗及其相關因素研究。護理雜誌，57(2)，61-69。
40. 沈芳吉(2013)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。慈濟大學護理學系碩士班。
41. 周佳霓(2016)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立中正大學犯罪防治研究所。
42. 林小鈴、尹祚芊、黃惠美(2012)。某醫學中心護理工作職場暴力評估之研究。榮總護理，29(2)，176-196。
43. 洪千涵、許春金、陳玉書(2014)。犯罪被害恐懼感之調查研究：人口／社會解組因素與警政作為之影響。中央警察大學犯罪防治學報，20，69-99。
44. 陳玉書、邱炫綿(2006)。犯罪被害恐懼感影響因素之分析。中央警察大學犯罪防治學報，7，4-42。
45. 陳伯年(2013)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立中正大學勞工關係學系。
46. 陳柑伴、楊秀芬、陳慧蘭、楊美賞(2010)。醫院護理人員遭受職場暴力後情緒反應及調適處理。護理暨健康照護研究，6(3)，163-171。
47. 陳維恭(2007)。談急診暴力事件。台灣醫界，50，328-329。
48. 麥嘉萍、陳芳儀、胡瑞桃、朱翠萍(2005)。急診護理人員面對暴力之壓力反應、壓力調適及相關因素之探討。長庚護理，16(4)，359-368。
49. 黃癸瑩(2012)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立中正大學犯罪防治研究所。
50. 楊春梅(2011)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。臺北醫學大學護理學研究所。
51. 楊錦桂(2014)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。中臺科技大學護理系。
52. 衛生福利部(2015)。臺灣病人安全通報系統：2015年年報。臺北:衛生福利部。
53. 衛生福利部(2014)。臺灣病人安全通報系統：2014年年報。臺北:衛生福利部。
54. 衛生福利部(2016)。臺灣病人安全通報系統：2016年年報。臺北:衛生福利部。
55. 鄭淑利、蔡欣玲、陳展航、廖榮利、張敏(1999)。暴力處置課程對精神科護理人員處置暴力知識、態度、行為之成效研究。護理研究，7(5)，408-422。
56. 賴尚儀、魏玉雲、吳美慧、林琇珠、石富元(2014)。醫療暴力之態樣與防範。澄清醫護管理雜誌，10(4)，4-11。
57. 羅鼎程(2015)。臺灣保護性社會工作員犯罪被害恐懼感之探索性研究。社區發展季刊，151，282-306。

1. 翁芝爾(2017)。探討職場暴力對護理人員身心健康的影響-以某區域教學醫院為例。國立臺灣大學健康政策與管理研究所學位論文。2017。1-63。