施用影響精神藥物者之以全人為導向的復元與社會復歸架構：社區服務機構之文本分析

A Whole Person-Oriented Recovery and Social Recovery Framework for Individuals Who Use Psychoactive Drugs: A Content Analysis of Community Recovery Service Providers

10.30074/FJMH.202206_35(2).0004

白鎮福(Chen-Fu Pai)；李宗憲(Tsung-Hsien Li)；吳思穎(Szu-Ying Wu)；黃韻儒(Yun-Ju Huang)；李思賢(Tony Szu-Hsien Lee)

成癮 ； 毒品 ； 復元 ； 社會復歸 ； 藥癮服務機構 ； 復元／社會復歸架構 ； 全人復元 ； addiction ； drugs ； recovery ； social recovery ； recovery service providers ； recovery and rehabilitation framework ； whole-person recovery

中華心理衛生學刊

35卷2期（2022 / 06 / 01）

181 - 213

繁體中文

研究目的：本文目的是以美國物質成癮與心理健康服務部（SAMHSA, 2011）針對施用毒品者「復元」（recovery）所提出的定義、四大復元面向與十個指導原則為基礎，建構出以全人為導向的復元／社會復歸架構（whole person-oriented recovery and social recovery framework），來整合復元／社會復歸概念的實質內涵，並以其檢視台灣社會復歸服務機構對於施用影響精神藥物者復元／社會復歸的理念、目標與工作現況，做為未來政府與民間機構在建置施用影響精神藥物者的多元化復元與社區復歸服務網絡之參考。研究方法：針對2020年度18家接受衛生福利部「藥癮者社區復健方案布建及服務品質提升計畫」補助之民間機構的申請計劃書、結案報告書與實地訪談內容進行文本分析。研究結果：SAMHSA對於復元的工作定義與各項指導原則可以在18家機構中找到相對應的服務與工作內容，但對於復元的定義、機構本身在個案復元過程中的角色定位與提供服務策略，缺乏前後邏輯連結與品質確認，使得服務內涵與社會復歸的目的連結不明確、導致難有合適的效果評估。研究結論：本研究也針對建構施用影響精神藥物者復元政策與社會復歸服務機構提出相關建議。

Purpose: In 2011, the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) proposed a definition, dimensions, and guiding principles of recovery. We applied their concepts to construct the whole person-oriented recovery and social recovery framework, and used this framework to examine the contents of recovery service providers in Taiwan. Methods: We used thematic analysis to analyze annual reports from 18 service providers participating in a recovery project funded by the Taiwan Ministry of Health and Welfare in 2020. Results: Overall, the services and resources provided by the18 providers fell under SAMHSA's working definition of recovery. However, there exists a lack of clear insight into the definition of recovery, roles of providers, and service strategies among the majority of the 18 providers. A blurred understanding may create dissonance between targeted services and goals for social recovery, and add to the difficulty in assessing the outcomes of a service program. Conclusions: Implications and future recommendations for recovery service providers and government regulations are discussed.

1. Lee, T. S. H.(2006).Sexual violence victimization and condom use in relation to exchange of sexual services by female methamphetamine prisoners.Taiwan Journal of Public Health,25(3),214-222.
   連結：
2. Aristotle,McMahin, J. H.(Trans.)(1991).The metaphysics.Prometheus.
3. Ashford, R. D.,Brown, A.,Brown, T.,Callis, J.,Cleveland, H. H.,Eisenhart, E.,Groover, H.,Hayes, N.,Johnston, T.,Kimball, T.,Manteuffel, B.,McDaniel, J.,Montgomery, L.,Phillips, S.,Polacek, M.,Statman, M.,Whitney, J.(2019).Defining and operationalizing the phenomena of recovery: a working definition from the recovery science research collaborative.Addiction Research & Theory,27(3),179-188.
4. Ashford, R. D.,Brown, A.,Ryding, R.,Curtis, B.(2020).Building recovery ready communities: The recovery ready ecosystem model and community framework.Addiction Research and Theory,28(1),1-11.
5. Ashforth, B. E.,Mael, F.(1989).Social identity theory and the organization.The Academy of Management Review,14(1),20-39.
6. Babor, T. F.,Stenius, K.,Romelsjo, A.(2008).Alcohol and drug treatment systems in public health perspective: mediators and moderators of population effects.International Journal of Methods in Psychiatric Research,17(S1),S50-S59.
7. Becker, H. S.(1953).Becoming a marihuana user.American Journal of Sociology,59(3),235-242.
8. Best, D.,Andersson, C.,Irving, J.,Edwards, M.(2017).Recovery identity and wellbeing: Is it better to be ‘Recovered’ or ‘in Recovery’?.Journal of Groups in Addiction & Recovery,12(1),27-36.
9. Best, D.,Bird, K.,Hunton, L.(2015).Recovery as a social phenomenon: What is the role of the community in supporting and enabling recovery?.Positive criminology
10. Best, D.,de Alwis, S.(2017).Community recovery as a public health intervention: The contagion of hope.Alcoholism Treatment Quarterly,35(3),187-199.
11. Best, D.,Irving, J.,Collinson, B.,Andersson, C.,Edwards, M.(2017).Recovery networks and community connections: Identifying connection needs and community linkage opportunities in early recovery populations.Alcoholism Treatment Quarterly,35(1),2-15.
12. Brown, A.,Ashford, R.(2019).Recovery-informed theory: Situating the subjective in the science of Substance Use Disorder recovery.Journal of Recovery Science,1,1-15.
13. Brunette, M.,Mueser, K.,Drake, R.(2004).A review of research on residential programs for people with severe mental illness and co-occurring substance use disorders.Drug and Alcohol Review,23(4),471-481.
14. Center for Substance Abuse Treatment(2005).Center for Substance Abuse Treatment. (2005). National Summit on Recovery Conference Report the National Summit on Recovery, Washington, D. C..
15. Clarke, V.,Braun, V.(2017).Thematic analysis.The Journal of Positive Psychology,12(3),297-298.
16. Corrigan, P.,Schomerus, G.,Shuman, V.,Kraus, D.,Perlick, D.,Harnish, A.,Magdalena K.,Kane-Willis, Kathleen K.,Sang, Q.,Smelson, D.(2017).Developing a research agenda for understanding the stigma of addictions part I: Lessons from the mental health stigma literature.The American Journal on Addictions,26(1),59-66.
17. Cruwys, T.,Stewart, B.,Buckley, L.,Gumley, J.,Scholz, B.(2020).The recovery model in chronic mental health: A community-based investigation of social identity processes.Psychiatry Research,291,113241-113241.
18. De Ruysscher, C.,Vandevelde, S.,Vanderplasschen, W.,De Maeyer, J.,Vanheule, S.(2017).The concept of recovery as experienced by persons with dual diagnosis: A systematic review of qualitative research from a first-person perspective.Journal of Dual Diagnosis,13(4),264-279.
19. Debaere, V.,Verhaeghe, P.,Vanheule, S.(2017).Identity change in a drug-free Therapeutic Community: a Lacanian interpretation of former residents’ perspectives on treatment process and outcome.The International Journal of Therapeutic Communities,38(3),147-155.
20. Erlandson, D. A.,Harris, E. L.,Skipper, B. L.,Allen, S. D.(1993).Doing naturalistic inquiry: A guide to methods.Sage Publications.
21. Gable, R. S.(1993).Toward a comparative overview of dependence potential and acute toxicity of psychoactive substances used nonmedically.The American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse,19(3),263-281.
22. Gergen, K. J.(2009).Relational being: Beyond self and community.Oxford University Press.
23. Gossop, M.(2013).Living with drugs.Taylor & Francis Ltd.
24. Humphreys, K.(2003).Circles of recovery: Self-help organizations for addictions.Cambridge University Press.
25. Jacobson, N.,Farah, D.(2012).Recovery through the lens of cultural diversity.Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal,35(4),333-335.
26. Jacobson, N.,Greenley, D.(2001).What Is Recovery? A Conceptual Model and Explication.Psychiatric services,52(4),482-485.
27. Kidd, S. A.,George, L.,O’Connell, M.,Sylvestre, J.,Kirkpatrick, H.,Browne, G.,Odueyungbo, O.,Davidson, L.(2011).Recovery-oriented service provision and clinical outcomes in assertive community treatment.Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal,34(3),194-201.
28. Kuan, K. K. Y.,Zhong, Y.,Chau, P. Y. K.(2014).Informational and normative social influence in group-buying: Evidence from self-reported and EEG data.Journal of Management Information Systems,30(4),151-178.
29. Leamy, M.,Bird, V.,Boutillier, C. L.,Williams, J.,Slade, M.(2011).Conceptual framework for personal recovery in mental health: systematic review and narrative synthesis.British Journal of Psychiatry,199(6),445-452.
30. Leshner, A. I.(1997).Addiction is a brain disease, and it matters.Science,278(5335),45-47.
31. Marshall, C.,Rossman, G. B.(2016).Designing qualitative research.Sage Publications.
32. Martin, C.,Otter, C.(1996).Locus of control and addictive behaviour.Addictive behaviour: Molecules to mankind: Perspectives on the nature of addiction
33. Maslow, A. H.(1971).The farther reaches of human nature.Viking Press.
34. Maslow, A. H.,Frager, Robert D.(Ed.),Fadiman, James(Ed.),McReynolds, Cynthia(Ed.),Cox, R.(Ed.)(1987).Motivation and personality.Longman.
35. McDaniel, J. M.,Brown, A. M.,Thompson Heller, A.,Johnston, T. W.,Bergman, B.,Bohler, R.,Brown, T.,Eisenhart, E.,Finch, A.,Harper, K.,Hart, C.,Kimball, T.,Rabolt, T.,Speciale, C.,Whitney, J.,Ashford, R. D.(2020).Interdisciplinary expansions: Applying recovery-informed theory to interdisciplinary areas of recovery science research.Alcoholism Treatment Quarterly,38(4),457-469.
36. Mohammad Nia, S.,Mashhadi, A.(2018).The effect of meaning of life on the relationship between attitude toward substance abuse and depression.The Neuroscience Journal of Shefaye Khatam,6(3),43-51.
37. National Institute on Drug Abuse. (2008). Comorbidity: Addiction and other mental illnesses. https://www.drugabuse.gov/sites/default/files/rrcomorbidity.pdf
38. Nicholson, T.,Higgins, W.,Turner, P.,James, S.(1994).The relation between meaning in life and the occurrence of drug abuse: A retrospective study.Psychology of Addictive Behaviors,8(1),24-28.
39. Nutt, D. P.,King, L. A. P.,Saulsbury, W. M. A.,Blakemore, C. P.(2007).Development of a rational scale to assess the harm of drugs of potential misuse.The Lancet (British edition),369(9566),1047-1053.
40. Prendergast, M. L.,Podus, D.(2000).Drug treatment effectiveness: An examination of conceptual and policy issues.Substance Use & Misuse,35(12-14),1629-1657.
41. President’s New Freedom Commission on Mental Health (US). (2003). Achieving the promise: Transforming mental health care in America. https://sprc.org/sites/default/files/migrate/library/freedomcomm.pdf
42. Rapp, R. C.,Kelliher, C. W.,Fisher, J. H.,Hall, F. J.(1994).Strengths-based case management. A role in addressing denial in substance abuse treatment.Journal of Case Management,3(4),139-144.
43. Rawls, A. W.(Ed.)(2002).Ethnomethodology’s program: Working out Durkheim’s aphorism.Rowman & Littlefield.
44. Saleebey, D.(1996).The strengths perspective in social work practice: Extensions and cautions.Social Work,41(3),296-305.
45. Sheedy, C., & Whitter, M. (2009). Guiding principles and elements of recovery-oriented systems of care: What do we know from the research? HHS Publication No. (SMA) 09-4439. Center for Substance Abuse Treatment(US), Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (US). https://www.naadac.org/assets/2416/sheedyckwhitterm2009_guiding_principles_and_elements.pdf
46. Shelton, L. G.(2018).The Bronfenbrenner primer: A guide to develecology.Routledge.
47. Simoneau, H.,Kamgang, E.,Tremblay, J.,Bertrand, K.,Brochu, S.,Fleury, M.-J.(2018).Efficacy of extensive intervention models for substance use disorders: A systematic review.Drug and Alcohol Review,37,S246-S262.
48. Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration. (2016). What individuals in recovery need to know about wellness. https://store.samhsa.gov/sites/default/files/d7/priv/sma16-4950.pdf
49. Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration. (US). (2011). SAMHSA’s working definition of recovery. https://www.naadac.org/assets/2416/samhsa_working-definition_of_recovery.pdf
50. Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (US). (2010). Recovery-oriented systems of care resource guide. https://www.samhsa.gov/sites/default/files/rosc_resource_guide_book.pdf
51. Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (US). (2018). Recovery housing: best practices and suggested guidelines. https://www.samhsa.gov/sites/default/files/housing-best-practices-100819.pdf
52. Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (US). (2020). PATH annual report for FY 2019. https://pathpdx.samhsa.gov/Content/preGen/national/24/PATH_Annual_Report_For_FY_2019.pdf
53. UNODC(2020).World drug report 2020.United Nations.
54. White, W. L.,Sanders, M.(2008).Recovery management and people of color: Redesigning addiction treatment for historically disempowered communities.Alcoholism Treatment Quarterly,26(3),365-395.
55. Zinberg, N. E.(1986).Drug, set, and setting: The basis for controlled intoxicant use.Yale University Press.
56. 李宗憲,白鎮福,束連文,吳思穎,黃韻儒,林毓恩,顧以謙,李思賢(2021)。建置毒品施用者之復原與社會復歸：介紹美國物質成癮與心理健康服務部的定義與反思台灣現況。藥物濫用防治，6(2)，1-14。
57. 李思賢,徐倩,蔡孟璋(2019)。分流處遇模式的提出與推行：以高雄毒品犯緩起訴分流處遇為例。藥物濫用防治，4(2)，57-74。
58. 李思賢,楊士隆,楊浩然,吳慧菁,廖文婷,林依蒖,林依蒖,鄭凱寶,Festinger, D.,Dugosh, K.,Seymour, B. L.(2014)。毒品再犯風險與醫療需求分流處置評量工具之研究。犯罪防治研究專刊，2，2-13。
59. 楊俊樂(2020)。施用毒品除罪化之研究—從治療模式觀點出發。藥物濫用防治，5(2)，89-116。
60. 劉民和,莫少珍(2016).福音戒毒的深度與實際.基督教晨曦會.

1. 白鎮福(2022)。邁向全人復元－以建構全人之架構與內涵來反思與突破藥癮者全人復元之困境。刑事政策與犯罪防治研究專刊，33，127-180。
2. (2023)。誰會待得久？戒癮者於宗教型戒癮安置機構留置期間的影響因素。中華心理衛生學刊，36(4)，361-385。