以口語評估方式進行群體決策綜合評判函數之建構與應用

The Construction and Application of Aggregation Function for Group Decision-making Based on Verbal Evaluation

陳光華(Kaung-Hwa Chen)

群體決策 ； 口語模式 ； 綜合評判函數 ； Group decision-making ； verbal model ； aggregation function

管理與系統

12卷2期（2005 / 04 / 01）

33 - 51

繁體中文

口語使用的便利性與普遍性已日益增加，且其效果與數值並無差異因而適用專家在作決策時評估之用，因此口語模式(verbal model)已被廣泛地使用在決策系統上。本研究根據決策者行為構面（對評估口語的極值與平均位置的考量）的特性，針對口語評估語的綜合評判函數提出適用的條件與性質，並據以建構多人決策之口語綜合評估函數對口語直接作綜合運算。本研究著重在決策者行為構面，並提出一系統化的程序來表示其對評估口語權重的影響，這是統計方法無法分析的。

Verbal terms have become increasingly convenient and prevalent nowadays as they can be easily used by experts (decision makers) for decision preferences and reveal the same affectivity in terms of number for decision making. Therefore, the verbal models have been applied frequently to decision systems. This paper has proposed available conditions and properties of aggregation function for verbal models from the perspective of social behavior (i.e. averaged location and polar evaluators of decision makers in group decision making). A multi-person verbal model is then established and aggregation function is also aggregated directly by verbal terms according to the above conditions and properties. The proposed model focuses on behavior of decision makers and proposes a systematic process to express the impact of these behaviors on the weight of verbal terms, which cannot be analyzed by any statistical methods.

1. Bellman, R.E.,Zadeh, L.A.(1970).Decision-making in a Fuzzy Environment.Management Science,17,141-164.
2. Bross, I.D.J.(1958).How to Use Ridit Analysis.Biometrics,14,18-38.
3. Brun, W,Teigen, K.H.(1988).Verbal Probabilities: Ambiguous, Context-dependent, or Both?.Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,41,390-404.
4. Buckles, B.P.,Petry, F.E.(1984).Extension of the Fuzzy Database with Fuzzy Arithmetic.In Sanchez,421-426.
5. Buckles, B.P.,Petry, F.E.(1982).A Fuzzy Representation of Data for Relational Database.Fuzzy Sets and Systems,7,213-226.
6. Buckles, B.P.,Petry, F.E.(1982).Fuzzy Databases and Their Applications.Gupta and Sanchez,361-371.
7. Buckles, B.P.,Petry, F.E.(1983).Information-theoretical Characterization of Fuzzy Relational Database.IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics,74-77.
8. Budescu, D.V.,Wallsten, T.S.(1990).Dyadic Decisions with Numerical and Verbal Probabilities.Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,46,240-263.
9. Chen, K.H.,Lin, H.H.(1998).Interactive Group Decision-making: Modeling and Application.Socio-Economic Planning Science,32,113-122.
10. Cholewa, W.(1985).Aggregation of Fuzzy Opinions-an Axiomatic Approach.Fuzzy Sets and Systems,17,249-258.
11. Dubois, D.,Koning, J.L.(1991).Social Choice Axioms for Fuzzy Set Aggregation.Fuzzy Sets and Systems,43,257-274.
12. Fung, L.W.,Fu, K.S.(1975).Fuzzy Sets and Their Applications to Cognitive and Decision Processes.New York:Academic Press.
13. Hawkins, R.(2003).The Phantom of the Marketplace: Searching for New E-commerce Models.Communication & Strategies,46,297-329.
14. Herrera(1996).Direct Approach Processes in Group Decision Making Using Linguistic OWA Operators.Fuzzy Sets and Systems,79,175-190.
15. Hersh, H.M.,Caramazza, A.(1976).A Fuzzy Set Approach to Modifiers and Vagueness in Natural Language.Journal of Experimental Psychology,105,3.
16. Huizingh, E.K.,Vrolijk, H.C.J.(1997).A Comparison of Verbal and Numerical Judgments in the Analytic Hierarchy Process.Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,70,237-247.
17. Jaynes, E.T.(1957).Information Theory and Statistical Mechanics I.Physics Review,106,620-630.
18. Kacprzyk, J.(1990).Multiperson Decision Making Model Using Fuzzy Sets and Possibility Theory.Dordrecht:Kluwer Academic Publishers.
19. Kickert, W.J.(1979).Advances in Fuzzy Set Theory and Application.Amsterdam:North Holland.
20. Kleindorfer, P. R.(1993).Decision Science-An Integrative Perspective.Cambridge University Press.
21. Kuipers, B.,Moskowitz, A.J.,Kassirer, J.P.(1988).Critical Decisions under Uncertainty: Representation and Struction.Cognitive Science,12,177-210.
22. Levy, W.B.,Delic, H.(1994).Maximum Entropy Aggregation of Individual Opinions.IEEE Transactions on System, Man, and Cybernetics,24,606-613.
23. Ma, J.,Fan, Z.P.,Huang, L.H.(1999).A Subjective and Objective Integrated Approach to Determine Attribute Weights.European Journal of Operational Research,112,397-404.
24. Mahadevan, B.(2000).Business Models for Internet-based E-commerce: An Anatomy.California Management Review,42,55-69.
25. Merz, J.F.,Druzdzel, M. J.,Mazur, D.J.(1991).Verbal Expressions of Probability in Informed Content Litigation.Medical Decision Making,11,273-281.
26. Myung, I.J.,Ramamoorti, S.,Bailey, A.D.(1996).Maximum Entropy Aggregation of Expert Predictions.Management Science,42,1420-1436.
27. Ohtsubo, Y.,Masuchi, A.(2004).Effects of status difference and group size in group decision making.Group Process & Intergroup Relations,7(2),161-172.
28. Tversky, A.(1972).Elimination by Aspects.Psychological Review,79,281-299.
29. Wallsten, T.S.,Budescu, D.V.,Zwick, R.(1993).Comparing the Calibration and Coherence of Numerical and Verbal Probability Judgments.Management Science,39,176-190.
30. Wei, Q.,Yan, H,Ma, J.,Fan, Z.(2000).A Compromise Weight for Multi-criteria Group Decision Making with Individual Preference.Journal of the Operational Research Society,51,625-634.
31. Wenstop, F.(1976).Deductive Verbal Model for Organization.International Journal of Man-Machine Studies,8,293-311.
32. Yager, R.R.(1994).Aggregation Operators and Fuzzy Systems Modeling.Fuzzy Sets and Systems,67,129-145.
33. Yager, R.R.(1988).On Ordered Weight Averaging Aggregation Operators in Multi-criteria Decision Making.IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man and Cybernetics,18,183-190.
34. Zadeh, L.A.(1972).A Fuzzy-set-theoretical Interpretation of Linguistic Hedges.Journal of Cybernetics,5,4-34.
35. 余慶芳(1997)。中山大學資管所。
36. 陳光華(2001)。群體決策模式之口語綜合評判函數建構程序。管理與系統，8，225-238。
37. 蕭文峰(2001)。口語評估尺度之統計值直覺估計。

1. 黃振傑、王穎駿(2014)。航空器簽派作業風險因素分析。航空安全及管理季刊，1(1)，61-82。
2. 劉毓珊、王穎駿(2013)。機坪勤務人員人為風險因素評估與策略。危機管理學刊，10(2)，87-100。