多目標下電子產品之最佳拆解回收程序

Optimal Disassembly and Recycling Process for End-of-Life Electronic Products under Multiple Criteria

李珣琮(Shun-Chung Lee)；施勵行(Li-Hsing Shih)；簡重光(Chung-Kuang Jien)

妥協規劃法 ； 拆解回收 ； 產品壽命終了 ； 啓發式求解法 ； 多目標最佳化 ； Compromise Programming ； Disassembly and Recycling ； End-of-Life ； Heuristics ； Multi-Criteria Optimization

管理與系統

17卷3期（2010 / 07 / 01）

527 - 558

繁體中文

近年來，由於歐盟WEEE(Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment)回收指令以及生產者責任的義務，企業愈來愈重視產品的回收程序及相關的回收成本與對環境影響的評估方法，期望能夠在產品回收的過程中同時兼顧賺取經濟利潤與減少環境衝擊，並在這二者相衝突的目標之間找出最佳的組合。本文提出啟發式求解法求解此多目標最佳化問題，目的在求出達到最大經濟效益與最小環境衝擊之產品壽命終了(end-of-life, EOL)時的回收程序，此求解法的主要精神是利用電子產品回收時的特性，快速搜尋回收程序的可行解，進而找出主要的柏拉圖解，並運用妥協規劃法求解最佳解。本文以筆記型電腦爲案例，說明EOL回收程序最佳化的求解過程，如何配置出EOL產品之人工拆解－粉碎回收－廢棄物處置等回收方式的最佳組合，並求解筆記型電腦中每一個模組應拆解到何時，方可對經濟效益及環境衝擊有最佳的妥協效果。此外，文末同時探討未來當筆記型電腦採用最新的產品設計技術時，對最佳化回收程序可能產生的影響。

Recently, due to EU's Directive of Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment (WEEE) recycling end-of-life products has caught a lot of attention of enterprises worldwide. How to take care of both economic and environment aspects in recycling products becomes an emerging issue. This study proposes a heuristic method to find optimal disassembly and recycling process for end-of-life electrical and electronic products with consideration of minimizing cost and environmental impact. The proposed method uses characteristics of recycling electronic products to evaluate most possible recycling and disassembly processes and then obtain Pareto solutions. Compromise programming method is also used to find optimal process for the bi-criteria problem. Notebook computer is taken as an illustrative example to demonstrate the proposed solution process. Optimal combination of manual disassembly, shredding for material recycling and waste disposal is obtained. Both Pareto solutions and optimal solution by compromise programming are presented. Finally, the influences of several new technologies on the optimal process are also discussed.

1. Tang, Y.,Turowski, M.(2007).Adaptive Fuzzy System for Disassembly Process Planning with Uncertainty.Journal of the Chinese Institute of Industrial Engineers,24(1),20-29.
   連結：
2. Andrés, C.,Lozano, S.,Adenso-Díaz, B.(2007).Disassembly Sequence Planning in a Disassembly Cell Context.Robotics and Computer-Integrated Manufacturing,23(6),690-695.
3. Boothroyd, G.,Dewhurst, P.(1987).Product Design for Assembly.RI:Wakefield, Boothroyd and Dewhurst, Inc..
4. Boothroyd, G.,Dewhurst, P.(1983).Technique Report, Department of Mechanical EngineeringTechnique Report, Department of Mechanical Engineering,Lowell, MA:University of Massachusetts Press.
5. Bufarid, A.,Sakara, D.,Gheorghe, R.,Kiritsis, D.,Xirouchakis, P.(2003).Multiple Criteria Decision Aid for Selecting the Best Product End of Life Scenario.International Journal of Computer Integrated Manufacturing,16(7-8),526-534.
6. Chan, J. W. K.,Tong, T. K. L.(2007).Multi-Criteria Material Selections and End-of-Life Product Strategy: Grey Relational Analysis Approach.Materials & Design,28(5),1539-1546.
7. Dong, J.,Arndt, G.(2003).A Review of Current Research on Disassembly Sequence Generation and Computer Aided Design for Disassembly.Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers,217(3),299-312.
8. Dong, J.,Gibson, P.,Arndt, G.(2007).Disassembly Sequence Generation in Recycling Based on Parts Accessibility and End-of-Life Strategy.Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part B: Journal of Engineering Manufacture,221(6),1079-1085.
9. Effting, S.(2006).Wizard Manual-Introduction into programming of Wizards in SimaPro 7.PRe Consultants B. V..
10. Feldmann, K.,Trautner, S.,Lohrmann, H.,Melzer, K.(2001).Computer-Based Product Structure Analysis for Technical Goods Regarding Optimal End-of-Life Strategies.Engineering Manufacture,215(5),684-693.
11. Feldmann, K.,Trautner, S.,Meedt, O.(1999).Innovative Disassembly Strategies based on Flexible Partial Destructive Tools.Annual Review in Control,23,159-164.
12. Galantucci, L. M.,Percoco, G.,Spina, R.(2004).Assembly and Disassembly Planning by Using Fuzzy Logic & Genetic Algorithms.International Journal of Advanced Robotic System,1(2),67-74.
13. Gao, M.,Zhou, M. C.,Tang, Y.(2004).Intelligent Decision Making in Disassembly Process Based on Fuzzy Reasoning Petri Nets.IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics-Part B: Cybernetics,34(5),2029-2034.
14. González, B.,Adenso-Diaz, B.(2006).A Scatter Search Approach to the Optimum Disassembly Sequence Problem.Computers & Operations Research,33(6),1776-1793.
15. Gungor, A.,Gupta, S. M.(2001).Disassembly Sequence Plan Generation Using a Branch-and-Bound Algorithm.International Journal of Production Research,39(3),481-509.
16. Gungor, A.,Gupta, S. M.(1997).An Evaluation Methodology for Disassembly Processes.Computers and Industrial Engineering,33(1-2),329-332.
17. Kongar, E.,Gupta, S. M.(2006).Disassembly to Order System under Uncertainty.International Journal of Management Science,34(6),550-561.
18. Kongar, E.,Gupta, S. M.(2002).A Genetic Algorithm for Disassembly Process Planning.Proceedings of SPIE,4569,54-62.
19. Kuo, T. C.,Zhang, H. C.,Huang, S. H.(2000).Disassembly Analysis for Electromechanical Products: A Graph-Based Heuristic Approach.International Journal of Production Research,38(5),993-1007.
20. Lambert, A. J. D.(2007).Optimizing Disassembly Processes Subjected to Sequence-Dependent Cost.Computers & Operations Research,34(2),536-551.
21. Lambert, A. J. D.,Gupta, S. M.(2002).Demand-Driven Disassembly Optimization for Electronic Consumer Goods.Journal of Electronics Manufacturing,11(2),121-135.
22. Lee, D.-H.,Xiroucharkis, P.(2004).A Two-Stage Heuristic for Disassembly Scheduling with Assembly Product Structure.Journal of the Operational Research Society,55(3),287-297.
23. Lee, S. G.,Lye, S. W.,Khoo, M. K.(2001).A Multi-Objective Methodology for Evaluating Product End-of-Life Options and Disassembly.International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology,18(2),148-156.
24. Liu, Z. F.,Liu, X. P.,Wang, S. W.,Liu, G. F.(2002).Recycling Strategy and a Recyclability Assessment Model based on an Artificial Neural Network.Journal of Materials Processing Technology,129(1-3),500-506.
25. Mergains, I.,Moustakas, K.,Papadopoulos, A.,Loizidou, M.(2007).Multi-Criteria Decision Aid Approach for the Selection of the Best Compromise Management Scheme for ELVs: The Case of Cypros.Journal of Hazardous Materials,147(3),706-717.
26. Navin-Chandra, D.(1994).The Recovery Problem in Product Design.Journal of Engineering Design,5(1),65-86.
27. Neuendorf, K. P.,Lee, D. H.,Kiritsis, D.,Xirouchakis, P.(2001).Disassembly Scheduling with Parts Commonality Using Petri Nets with Timestamps.Fundamenta Informaticae,47(3-4),295-306.
28. Ravi, V.,Shankar, R.,Tiwan, M. K.(2008).Selection of a Reverse Logistics Project for End-of-Life Computers: ANP and Goal Programming Approach.International Journal of Production Research,46(17),4849-4870.
29. Rosell, J.,Muñoz, N.,Gambin, A.(2003).Robot Tasks Sequence Planning Using Petri Nets.Proceedings of Fifth IEEE International Symposium on Assembly and Task Planning
30. Shih, L. H.,Chang, Y. S.,Lin, Y. T.(2006).Intelligent Evaluation Approach for Electronic Product Recycling via Case-based Reasoning.Advanced Engineering Informatics,20(2),137-145.
31. Shih, L. H.,Lee, S. C.(2007).Optimizing Disassembly and Recycling Process for EOL LCD-Type Products: A Heuristic Method.IEEE Transaction on Electronics Packaging Manufacturing,30(3),213-220.
32. Staikos, T.,Rahimifard, S.(2007).An End-of-Life Decision Support Tool for Product Recovery Considerations in the Footwear Industry.International Journal of Computer Integrated Manufacturing,20(6),602-615.
33. Waterbury, R.(1985).Designing Parts for Automated Assembly.Assembly Engineering,24(2),211-217.
34. Wen, L. C.(2000).A Study of Waste Recycling-and-Treatment Fee Collection for Scrap Personal Computers.Taiwan:Environmental Protection Administration.
35. Yu, P. L.,Leitmann, G.(1974).Compromise Solutions, Domination Structures and Salukvadze's Solution.Journal of Optimization Theory and Applications,13(3),362-378.
36. Zussman, E.,Kriwet, A.,Seliger, G.(1994).Disassembly-Oriented Assessment Methodology to Support Design for Recycling.Annals of the CIRP,43(1),9-14.
37. 李珣琮(2006)。成功大學資源工程系。
38. 許志義(2003)。多目標決策。台北:五南圖書出版公司。
39. 簡重光(2008).成功大學資源工程系.