整合專利家族與專利引用於新產品設計之研究

New Product Design Process by Integrating Patent Family and Patent Citation

賴奎魁(Kuei-Kuei Lai)；歐陽光(Kuang OuYang)；郭宗賢(Tsung-Hsien Kuo)

專利家族 ； 專利引用 ； IPDP ； Patent Family ； Patent Citation ； IPDP

管理與系統

18卷1期（2011 / 01 / 01）

199 - 229

繁體中文

專利家族(patent family)蘊含企業專利佈局(portfolio)的豐富資訊，專利引用(patent citation)則可以獲得專利先前技藝(prior art)，提供新產品設計之創意來源，然而過去研究未見有效整合。本研究基於「先聚焦再放大」的研究構想，提出一套整合專利家族及專利引用的新模式，可以有系統的萃取專利情報(intelligence)，提升新產品設計的效能，並植入「創意產品發展程序」(Innovative Product Development Process, IPDP)之中，包括：(1)兼具管理與技術角度進行專利檢索(patent search)。(2)選擇產業基礎專利，建構專利家族。(3)篩選專利家族，獲得關鍵性專利。(4)以專利引用追溯研發設計所需技術資訊。(5)結合TRIZ理論建構專利技術功效(technology-performance)地圖，發掘產品利基(niche)。並且以實證方式具體說明本研究方法的可行性。

A patent family comprises the information of a patent portfolio in an enterprise. While it is possible to get the information of a patent's prior art by means of patent citation analysis; however, no method has been proposed to integrated a patent family and a patent citation effectively. Based on the idea of ”focusing first, and then finding the details” which arose from this study, this report proposes a new model that combines patent family analysis with patent citation analysis into the Innovative Product Development Process (IPDP), and our research shows that the new model can indeed promote increased effectiveness of product design to extract useful patent intelligence systematically, including: (1) management based and technology based patent searching, (2) building the patent family based on an industry basic patent, (3) filtering the patent family to obtain key patents, (4) the use of patent citations to trace the necessary technology information in product design, and (5) combining TRIZ theory to build patent technology performance maps, and discover product niches. This new procedure is illustrated by applying it to a real life study.

1. Lai, K. K.,Wu, S. J.,Chang, S. B.(2005).Establishing an Industry Classification System-from the Viewpoint of Patent Co-citation.Journal of Management,22(2),261-277.
   連結：
2. 翁順裕、賴奎魁、陳孟棋(2008)。將專利組合鑲嵌至技術規劃中。管理與系統，15(2)，323-354。
   連結：
3. Akao, Y.,Mazur, G. H.(2003).The Leading Edge in QFD: Past, Present and Future.International Journal of Quality & Reliability Management,20(1),20-35.
4. Altshuller, G. S.(1988).Creativity as an Exact Science: the Theory of Inventive Problem Solving.New York:Gordon and Breach.
5. Bajaj, A.,Kekre, S.,Srinivasan, K.(2004).Managing NPD: Cost and Schedule Performance in Design and Manufacturing.Management Science,50(4),527-536.
6. Berkowitz, L.(1993).Getting the Most from Your Patents.Research Technology Management,36(2),26-31.
7. Breitzman, A. F.,Mogee, M. E.(2002).The Many Applications of Patent Analysis.Journal of Information Science,28(3),187-205.
8. Cattell, R. B.(1966).The Scree Test for the Number of Factors.Multivariate Behavioral Research,1(1),245-276.
9. Chakrabarti, A. K.(1991).Industry Characteristics Influencing the Technical Output: A Case of Small and Medium Size Firms in the US.R&D Management,21(2),139-152.
10. Chen, A.,Chen, R.(2007).Design Patent Map: an Innovative Measure for Corporative Design Strategies.Engineering Management Journal,19(3),14-29.
11. Cooper, R. G.(2001).Winning at New Products: Accelerating the Process from Idea to Launch.New York:Perseus.
12. Ernst, H.(2003).Patent Information for Strategic Technology Management.World Patent Information,25(3),233-242.
13. Ernst, H.,Fabry, B.,Soll, J. H.(2004).Enhancing Market-oriented R&D Planning by Integrated Market and Patent Portfolios.Journal of Business Chemistry,1(1),2-13.
14. Griliches, Z.(1990).Patent Statistics as Economic Indicators: A Survey.Journal of Economic Literature,28(4),1661-1707.
15. Grupp, H.,Schmoch, U.(1999).Patent Statistics in The Age of Globalization: New Legal Procedures, New Analytical Methods, New Economic Interpretation.Research Policy,28(4),377-396.
16. Hall, B. H.,Jaffe, A.,Trajtenberg, M.(2005).Market Value and Patent Citation.The Rand Journal of Economics,36(1),16-38.
17. Harhoff, D.,Scherer, F. M.,Vopel, K.(2002).Citations, Family Size, Opposition and the Value of Patent Rights.Research Policy,32(8),1343-1363.
18. Haupt, R.,Kloyer, M.,Lange, M.(2007).Patent Indicators for the Technology Life Cycle Development.Research Policy,36(3),387-398.
19. Hubka, V.,Eder, W. E.(1988).Theory of Technical Systems.Berlin:Springer Verlag.
20. Jaffe, A. B.,Trajtenberg, M.,Fogarty, M. S.(2000).Knowledge Spillovers and Patent Citations: Evidence from a Survey of Inventors.The American Economic Review,90(2),215-218.
21. Kim, Y. S., Cochran, D. S.(2000).Reviewing TRIZ from the Perspective of Axiomatic Design.Journal of Engineering Design,11(1),79-94.
22. Lager, T.(2005).The Industrial Usability of Quality Function Deployment: A Literature Review and Synthesis on a Meta-level.R&D Management,35(4),409-426.
23. McGrath, M. E.(1996).Setting the PACE in Product Development: A Guide to Product and Cycle-time Excellence.Boston:Butterworth-Heinemann.
24. Moehrle, M. G.(2005).How Combinations of TRIZ Tools Are Used in Companies - Results of a Cluster Analysis.R&D Management,35(3),285-296.
25. Moehrle, M. G.,Walter, L.,Geritz, A.,Sandra, M. I.(2005).Patent-based Inventor Profiles as a Basis for Human Resource Decisions in Research and Development.R&D Management,35(5),513-524.
26. Mogee, M. E.,Kolar, R. G.(1994).International Patent Analysis as a Tool for Corporate Technology Analysis and Planning.Technology Analysis & Strategic Management,6(4),485-503.
27. Narin, F.(1995).Patents as Indicators for the Evaluation of Industrial Research Output.Scientometrics,34(3),489-496.
28. Narin, F.,Noma, E.,Perry, R.(1987).Patents as Indicators of Corporate Technological Strength.Research Policy,16(2-4),143-155.
29. Osteras, T.,Murthy, D. N. P.,Rausand, M.(2006).Product Performance and Specification in New Product Development.Journal of Engineering Design,17(2),177-192.
30. Pahl, G.,Beitz, W.(1996).Engineering Design-A Systematic Approach.London:Springer Verlag.
31. Podolny, J. M.,Stuart, T. E.(1995).A Role-based Ecology of Technological Change.American Journal of Sociology,100(5),1224-1260.
32. Reitzig, M.(2003).What Determine Patent Value? Insights from the Semiconductor Industry.Research Policy,32(1),13-26.
33. Stuart, T. E.,Podolny, J. M.(1996).Local Search and the Evolution of Technological Capabilities.Strategic Management Journal,17(7),21-38.
34. Ullman, D. G.(1997).The Mechanical Design Process.New York:McGraw-Hill.
35. Ulrich, K. T.,Eppinger, S. D.(1995).Product Design and Development.New York:McGraw-Hill.
36. Wartburg, I. V.,Teichert, T.,Rost, K.(2005).Inventive Progress Measured by Multi-stage Patent Citation Analysis.Research Policy,34(10),1591-1607.
37. Watts, R. J.,Porter, A. L.,Courseault, C.(1999).Functional Analysis Deriving Systems Knowledge from Bibliographic Information Resources.Information Knowledge System Management,1(1),45-61.
38. Yamashina, H.,Ito, T.,Kawada, H.(2002).Innovative Product Development Process by Integrating QFD and TRIZ.International Journal of Production Research,40(5),1031-1050.
39. Yoon, B. U.,Yoon, C. B.,Park, Y. T.(2002).On the Development and Application of Self-organizing Feature Map-based Patent Map.R&D Management,32(4),291-300.
40. Zeng, Y.,Guö, P.(1999).A Science-based Approach to Product Design Theory. Part II: Formulation of Design Requirements and Products.Robotics and Computer Integrated Manufacturing,15(4),341-352.

1. (2022)。金融專利與期貨商經營模式的研究。期貨與選擇權學刊，15(2)，39-70。