服務補救人員的外表吸引力重要嗎？－蠻橫顧客不當行為類型與服務補救策略之影響

Does Service Recovery Providers' Physical Attractiveness Matter?-The Impact of Jaycustomers' Dysfunctional Behavior Types and Service Recovery Strategies

蔡佳靜(Chia-Ching Tsai)；劉建志(Chien-Chih Liu)

顧客不當行為 ； 服務補救 ； 外表吸引力 ； 顧客相容性 ； 顧客滿意 ； Dysfunctional Customer Behavior ； Service Recovery ； Physical Attractiveness ； Customer Compatibility ； Customer Satisfaction

管理與系統

22卷4期（2015 / 10 / 01）

381 - 406

繁體中文

本研究實驗一探討蠻橫顧客不當行為類型與服務補救策略對顧客相容性與顧客滿意度之影響。實驗二則探討在服務失誤下，服務補救策略與服務補救人員外表吸引力對服務補救滿意度之影響。兩實驗皆為2×2=4的因子設計。實驗一研究結果發現顧客對蠻橫顧客的無心不當行為的容忍度與顧客滿意度皆高於蓄意的不當行為，且實質補救的顧客滿意度高於心理補救。對於蠻橫顧客無心的不當行為，心理補救的容忍度與心理舒適度顯著大於實質補救，但對於蠻橫顧客蓄意的不當行為，服務補救策略無顯著的影響。對於蠻橫顧客無心的不當行為，實質補救的顧客滿意度顯著大於心理補救，但對於蠻橫顧客蓄意的不當行為，服務補救策略則無顯著影響。實驗二則發現實質補救的顧客滿意度優於心理補救，且高度外表吸引力的顧客滿意度優於適度外表吸引力。但無論由高度或適度外表吸引力人員進行服務補救，實質補救的顧客滿意度均顯著大於心理補救。

This research investigates the impact of dysfunctional customer behavior types and service recovery strategies on customer compatibility and customer satisfaction in study 1 and the impact of service recovery strategies and physical attractiveness of service recovery providers on customer compatibility and customer satisfaction toward service recovery under service failure in study 2. Both of the studies are 2×2=4 factorial design. The results of study 1 indicate that accidental dysfunctional customer behavior causes significantly higher tolerance and customer satisfaction than intentional one, and tangible service recovery strategy results in significantly higher satisfaction than psychological one. The tolerance and psychological comfortness comes from psychological service recovery strategy are significantly higher than tangible one under the condition of accidental dysfunctional customer behavior, while there is no significant difference between service recovery strategies under the condition of intentional one. The tangible service recovery strategy causes significantly higher satisfaction than psychological one when accidental dysfunctional customer behavior happens, while there is no significant difference between service recovery strategies when intentional one happens. The results of study 2 indicate that the tangible service recovery strategy is better than the psychological one, and the highly attractive provider outperforms the moderately one for customer satisfaction. Besides, no matter using highly or moderately physical attractive provider, the tangible service recovery strategy causes significantly higher satisfaction than psychological one.

1. 邱光輝、吳碧珠(2009)。外表吸引力對跨性別親暱服務關係強度影響之研究。商管科技季刊，10(1)，91-115。
   連結：
2. Baker, M. J.,Churchill, A. G., Jr.(1987).The Impact of Physically Attractive Models on Advertising Evaluations.Journal of Marketing Research,14,538-555.
3. Bitner, M. J.(1992).Servicescapes: The Impact of Physical Surroundings on Customers and Employees.Journal of Marketing,56(2),57-71.
4. Bitner, M. J.,Booms, B. H.,Mohr, L. A.(1994).Critical Service Encounters: The Employee's Viewpoint.Journal of Marketing,58(4),95-106.
5. Bitner, M. J.,Booms, B. H.,Tetreault, M. S.(1990).The Service Encounter: Diagnosing Favorable and Unfavorable Incident.Journal of Marketing,54(1),71-84.
6. Bower, A. B.,Landreth, S.(2001).Is Beauty Best? Highly versus Normally Attractive Models in Advertising.Journal of Advertising,30(1),1-12.
7. Burns, L. H.(1987).Infertility and the Sexual Health of the Family.Journal of Sex Education and Therapy,13,30-34.
8. Caballero, M. J.,Pride, W. M.(1984).Selected Effects of Sales Person Sex and Attractiveness in Direct Mail Advertisement.Journal of Marketing,48(1),94-100.
9. Carlzon, J.(1987).Moments of Truth.New York:Ballinger.
10. Clark, G. L.,Kaminski, P. F.,Rink, D. R.(1992).Customer Complaints: Advice on How Companies Should Respond Based on an Empirical Study.Journal of Services Marketing,6(1),41-50.
11. Etzel, M. J.,Silverman, B. I.(1988).A Managerial Perspective on Directions for Retail Customer Dissatisfaction Research.Journal of Retailing,57(3),124-136.
12. Fullerton, R. A.,Punj, G.(1997).What is Consumer Misbehavior?.Advances in Consumer Research,24(1),336-339.
13. Gronroos, C.(1988).Service Quality: the Six Criteria of Good Perceived Service Quality.Review of Business,9(3),10-13.
14. Grove, S. J.,Fisk, R. P.(1997).The Impact of Other Customers on Service Experiences: a Critical Incident Examination of 'Getting Along'.Journal of Retailing,73(1),63-85.
15. Grove, S. J.,Fisk, R. P.,Bitner, M. J.(1992).Dramatizing the Service Experience: a Managerial Approach.Advances in Services Marketing and Management,1(1),91-121.
16. Harris, L. C.,Reynolds, K. L.(2003).The Consequences of Dysfunctional Customer Behavior.Journal of Service Research,6(2),144-161.
17. Hart, C. W. L.,Heskett, J. L.,Sasser, W. E.(1990).The Profitable Art of Service Recovery.Harvard Business Review,68(4),148-156.
18. Hoffman, K. D.,Kelley, S. W.,Rotalsky, H. M.(1995).Tracking Service Failures and Employee Recovery Efforts.Journal of Service Marketing,9(2),49-61.
19. Huang, W.,Lin, T.(2011).Developing Effective Service Compensation Strategies: Is a Price Reduction More Effective than a Free Gift?.Journal of Service Management,22(2),201-216.
20. Keh, H. T.,Ren, R.,Hill, S. R.,Li, X.(2013).The Beautiful, the Cheerful, and the Helpful: The Effects of Service Employee Attributes on Customer Satisfaction.Psychology & Marketing,30(3),211-226.
21. Kenney, M. J.(1995).Antecedents to Customer Expectations for Service Recovery.Journal of Academy of Marketing Science,22(1),52-61.
22. Langeard, E.,Bateson, J. E. G.,Lovelock, C. H.,Eiglier, P.(1981).Services Marketing: New Insights from Consumers and Managers.Cambridge:Marketing Science Institute.
23. Langlois, J. H.,Kalakanis, L.,Rubenstein, A. J.,Larson, A.,Hallam, M.,Smoot, M(2000).Maxims or Myths of Beauty? A Meta-analytic and Theoretical Review.Psychological-Bulletin,126(3),390-423.
24. Lehtinen, U.,Lehtinen, J. R.(1991).Two Approaches to Service Quality Diminions.Service Industries Journal,11(3),287-303.
25. Lovelock, C. H.(2001).Service Marketing in Managing Service Encounters.USA:Prentice-Hall.
26. Lovelock, C. H.(1994).Product Plus: How Product and Service Equals Competitive Advantage.New York:McGraw-Hill.
27. Lovelock, C.,Wright, L.(2002).Principles of Service Marketing and Management.New Jersey:Prentice Hall.
28. Martin, C. L.(1995).The Customer Compatibility Scale: Measuring Service Customers' Perceptions of Fellow Customers.Journal of Consumer Studies and Home Economics,19(3),299-311.
29. Martin, C. L.(1996).Consumer-to-consumer Relationships: Satisfaction with Other Consumers' Public Behavior.The Journal of Consumer Affairs,30(1),146-169.
30. Martin, C. L.,Pranter, C. A.(1989).Compatibility Management: Customer to Customer Relationships in Service Environments.Journal of Service Marketing,3(3),6-15.
31. Martin, M. C.,Kennedy, P. F.(1993).Advertising and Social Comparison: Consequences for Female Pre-Adolescents and Adolescents.Psychology and Marketing,10(6),513-530.
32. Miller, J. L.,Craighead, C. W.,Karwan, K. R.(2000).Service Recovery: A Framework and Empirical Investigation.Journal of Operations Management,18(4),387-400.
33. Morrow, P. C.(1990).Physical Attractiveness and Selection Decision Making.Journal of Management,16(1),45-60.
34. Patzer, G. L.(1983).Source Credibility as a Function of Communicator Physical Attractiveness.Journal of Business Research,11(2),229-241.
35. Petroshins, S. M.,Crocker, K. E.(1989).An Empirical Analysis of Spokesperson Characteristics on Advertisement and Product Evaluations.Journal of Academy of Marketing Science,17(3),217-225.
36. Reichheld, F. F.,Sasser, W. E.(1990).Zero Defections: Quality Comes to Service.Harvard Business Review,68(5),150-111.
37. Reingen, P. H.,Gresham, L. G.,Kernan, J. B.(1980).Behavioral Consequences of the Physical Attractiveness Stereotype in Personal Selling.the 1980 AMA Educators' Conference Proceedings,Chicago:
38. Richins, M. L.(1991).Social Comparison and the Idealized Images of Advertising.Journal of Consumer Research,18(7),71-83.
39. Ronkainen, I. A.,Reingen, P. H.(1979).Cognitive Effects of the Physical Attractiveness Stereotype in Personal Selling.the 1979 AMA Educators' Conference Proceedings,Chicago:
40. Siu, Y. N.,Zhang, J. T.,Yau, C. J.(2013).The Roles of Justice and Customer Satisfaction in Customer Retention: A Lesson from Service Recovery.Journal of Business Ethics,114(4),675-686.
41. Solnick, S. J.,Schweitzer, M. E.(1999).The Infuence of Physical Attractiveness and Gender on Ultimatum Game Decisions.Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,79(3),199-215.
42. Solomon, M. R.,Surprenant, C.,Czepiel, J. A.,Gutman, E. G.(1985).A Role Theory Perspective on Dyadic Interactions: The Service Encounter.Journal of Marketing,49(1),99-111.
43. Striegel-Moore, R. H.,Silberstein, L. R.,Rodin, J.(1986).Toward an Understanding of Risk Factors for Bulimia.American Psychologist,41(3),246-263.
44. Strutton, D.,Vitell, S. J.,Pelton, L. E.(1994).How Consumers may Justify Inappropriate Behavior in Market Setting: An Application on the Techniques of Neutralization.Journal of Business Ethics,30(3),253-260.
45. Tax, S. S.,Brown, S. W.,Chandrashekaran, M.(1998).Customer Evaluations of Service Complaint Experiences: Implications for Relationship Marketing.Journal of Marketing,62(4),60-76.
46. Wang, S. E.,Chang, S.(2013).Creating Positive Word-of-Mouth Promotion Through Service Recovery Strategies.Services Marketing Quarterly,34(2),103-114.
47. Wu, P. P.,Hwang, I.(2012).The Influence of Gender Dyads and Physical Appearance on the Strength of the Customer-Provider Relationship in the Taiwanese Hairdressing Industry.Services Marketing Quarterly,33(2),138-154.
48. 楊佳容(2009)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立中興大學行銷學研究所。
49. 蔡佳靜(2006)。廣告模特兒外表吸引力的迷思？－不同男性產品之探討。廣告學研究，25，107-129。

1. 蔡明潔、劉娜婷、劉以慶、陳淑貞(2018)。主管不當督導對部屬之主管導向偏差行為的影響：談回應策略的調節效果與LMX的中介作用。管理與系統，25(2)，115-143。
2. 蘇維杉、顏君彰、黃政紘(2017)。從認知公平觀點探討服務補救對再購意願的影響：以臺北市民運動中心為例。品質學報，24(6)，452-470。