雙重上市指數期貨市場之價差套利以及定價、指數套利與避險比較之研究

Spread Arbitrage and Comparison of Pricing, Index Arbitrage, and Futures Hedging between Dual Listed Index Futures Markets

王健聰(Jan-Chung Wang)

雙重上市指數期貨 ； 跨市場價差交易 ； 市場完美性 ； 指數套利 ； 期貨避險 ； Dual Listed Index Futures ； Inter-market Spread Trading ； Market Perfections ； Index Arbitrage ； Futures Hedging

管理與系統

23卷1期（2016 / 01 / 01）

31 - 64

繁體中文

本文主要針對新加坡交易所與日本Osaka證券交易所雙重上市之Nikkei 225指數期貨，以及新加坡與台灣期貨交易所雙重上市之MSCI台指期貨，進行下列議題之探討。首先，針對雙重上市指數期貨，估計完美市場假設下持有成本模式之錯價，依此以比較雙重上市指數期貨之間的定價績效與市場完美性。另外，在考量交易成本下，本文也比較雙重上市指數期貨之間的指數套利利潤。其次，市場完美性與避險效益亦具有正向關係，本文將運用時變的最小變異數避險比率以比較雙重上市指數期貨市場之間的避險效益。最後，本文則是檢視雙重上市指數期貨之跨市場價差交易利潤，並比較跨市場價差交易與指數套利之套利利潤。實證結果指出在雙重上市指數期貨市場中，持有成本模式對於新加坡交易所上市的Nikkei 225指數期貨以及MSCI台指期貨都有顯著較佳的定價績效，並且此兩個期貨市場亦有較小指數套利利潤。此外，新加坡交易所上市的Nikkei 225指數期貨以及MSCI台指期貨也都有較佳避險效益。最後，不同幣別乘數之跨市場價差交易似乎較同幣別乘數之跨市場價差交易有顯著較大的定價誤差。再者，跨市場價差交易之絕對價格誤差率具持續性。

This study addresses several issues related to dual listing of stock index futures using the Nikkei 225 index futures traded on the Singapore Exchange and the Osaka Securities Exchange, and the MSCI Taiwan index futures traded on the Singapore Exchange and the Taiwan Futures Exchange. This study first estimates mispricings of the cost of carry model under the assumptions of perfect markets for dual listed index futures. Based on mispricings, this study compares pricing performance and market perfections between dual listed index futures markets. In considering transaction costs, this study also compares index arbitrage profits between dual listed index futures markets. Second, owing to the positive relationship between market perfections and hedge effectiveness, this study also compares hedge effectiveness between dual listed index futures using the time-varying minimum variance hedge ratio. Finally, this study examines spread arbitrage profits between dual listed index futures markets, and also compares arbitrage profits between index arbitrage and inter-market arbitrage trading. Empirical results indicate that the pricing performance of the cost of carry model under the assumption of perfect markets is better for the Nikkei 225 index futures traded on the Singapore Exchange than for the Nikkei 225 index futures traded on the Osaka Securities Exchange. Additionally, compared to the MSCI Taiwan index futures traded on the Taiwan Futures Exchange, the cost of carry model provides better performance for the MSCI Taiwan index futures traded on the Singapore Exchange. Furthermore, the Nikkei 225 index futures and the MSCI Taiwan index futures markets on the Singapore Exchange have better hedging effectiveness. The empirical results of inter-market arbitrage trading show that there are significantly larger pricing errors of inter-market arbitrage trading for the multipliers with different currencies than the multipliers with the same currency. Furthermore, the absolute errors of inter-market arbitrage trading are persistent.

1. Baba, Y., Engle, R. F., Kraft, D. F., and Kroner, K. F., “Multivariate Simultaneous Generalized ARCH,” Working Paper, Department of Economics, University of California, San Diego, 1990.
2. Bailey, W.(1989).The Market for Japanese Stock Index Futures: Some Preliminary Evidence.Journal of Futures Markets,9(4),283-295.
3. Bessembinder, H.,Seguin, P. J.(1992).Futures-Trading Activity and Stock Price Volatility.Journal of Finance,47(5),2015-2034.
4. Black, D. G.(1986).Success and Failure of Futures Contracts: Theory and Empirical Evidence.Salomon Brothers Center for the Study of Financial Institutions, Graduate School of Business Administration, New York University.
5. Board, J.,Sutcliffe, C.(1996).The Dual Listing of Stock Index Futures: Arbitrage, Spread, and Currency Risk.Journal of Futures Markets,16(1),29-54.
6. Bollerslev, T.(1986).Generalized Autoregressive Conditional Heteroskedasticity.Journal of Econometrics,31(3),307-327.
7. Booth, G. G.,Brockman, P.,Tse, Y(1998).The Relationship between US and Canadian Wheat Future.Applied Financial Economics,8(1),73-80.
8. Brailsford, T. J.,Cusack, A. J.(1997).A Comparison of Futures Pricing Models in a New Market: The Case of Individual Share Futures.Journal of Futures Markets,17(5),515-541.
9. Brenner, M.,Subrahmanyam, M. G.,Uno, J.(1990).Arbitrage Opportunities in the Japanese Stock and Futures Markets.Financial Analysts Journal,46(2),14-24.
10. Brooks, C.,Garrett, I.,Hinich, M. J.(1999).An Alternative Approach to Investigating Lead-Lag Relationships between Stock and Stock Index Futures Markets.Applied Financial Economics,9(6),605-613.
11. Brown-Hruska, S.,Kuserk, G.(1995).Volatility, Volume and the Notion of Balance in the S&P 500 Cash and Futures Markets.Journal of Futures Markets,15(6),677-689.
12. Cakici, N.,Chatterjee, S.(1991).Pricing Stock Index Futures with Stochastic Interest Rates.Journal of Futures Markets,11(4),441-452.
13. Chung, Y. P.(1991).A Transactions Data Test of Stock Index Futures Market Efficiency and Index Arbitrage Profitability.Journal of Finance,46(5),267-284.
14. Chung, Y. P.,Kang, J. K.,Rhee, S. G.(2003).Index-futures arbitrage in Japan.International Finance Review,4,173-197.
15. Cornell, B.,French, K. R.(1983).Taxes and the Pricing of Stock Index Futures.Journal of Finance,38(3),675-694.
16. Cornell, B.,French, K. R.(1983).The Pricing of Stock Index Futures.Journal of Futures Markets,3(1),1-14.
17. Covrig, V.,Ding, D. K.,Low, B. S.(2004).The Contribution of a Satellite Market to Price Discovery: Evidence from the Singapore Exchange.Journal of Futures Markets,24(10),981-1004.
18. D'amato, M.,Pistoresi, B.(2001).Interest Rate Spreads between Italy and Germany: 1995-1997.Applied Financial Economics,11(6),603-612.
19. Engle, R. F.,Kroner, K. F.(1995).Multivariate Simultaneous Generalized ARCH.Econometric Theory,11(1),122-150.
20. Figlewski, S.(1985).Hedging with Stock Index Futures: Theory and Application in a New Market.Journal of Futures Markets,5(2),183-199.
21. Floros, C.,Vougas, D. V.(2004).Hedge Ratios in Greek Stock Index Futures Market.Applied Financial Economics,14(15),1125-1136.
22. Fung, J. K. W.,Draper, P.(1999).Mispricing of Index Futures Contracts and Short Sales Constraints.Journal of Futures Markets,19(6),695-715.
23. Gay, G. D.,Jung, D. Y.(1999).A Further Look at Transaction Costs, Short Sale Restrictions, and Futures Market Efficiency: The Case of Korean Stock Index Futures.Journal of Futures Markets,19(2),153-174.
24. Ghosh, A.,Keong, C. I.(1994).Hedging Effectiveness of U.S. Dollar Index Futures: An Error Correction Model.Journal of Futures Markets,4(1),69-78.
25. Guermat, C.,Harris, R. D. F.(2002).Robust Conditional Variance Estimation and Value-at-Risk.Journal of Risk,4(1),25-41.
26. Hegde, S. P.,Nunn, K. P.(1985).Interest Rate Volatility, Trading Volume, and the Hedging Performance of T-Bond and GNMA Futures-A Note.Journal of Futures Markets,5(2),273-286.
27. Johnson, L.(1960).The Theory of Hedging and Speculation in Commodity Futures.Review of Economic Studies,27(3),139-151.
28. Kempf, A.(1998).Short Selling, Unwinding and Mispricing.Journal of Futures Markets,18(8),903-923.
29. Kroner, K. F.,Sultan, J.(1993).Time-Varying Distributions and Dynamic Hedging with Foreign Currency Futures.Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,28(4),535-551.
30. Kuberek, R. C.,Pefley, N. G.(1983).Hedging Corporate Debt with U.S. Treasury Bond Futures.Journal of Futures Markets,3(4),345-353.
31. Lindahl, M.(1992).Minimum Variance Hedge Ratios for Stock Index Futures: Duration and Expiration Effects.Journal of Futures Markets,12(1),33-53.
32. MacKinlay, A. C.,Ramaswamy, K.(1988).Index-Futures Arbitrage and the Behavior of Stock Index Futures Prices.Review of Financial Studies,1(2),137-158.
33. Monroe, M. A.,Cohn, R. A.(1986).The Relative Efficiency of the Gold and Treasury Bill Futures Markets.Journal of Futures Markets,6(3),477-493.
34. Park, T. H.,Switzer, L. N.(1995).Time-Varying Distributions and the Optimal Hedge Ratios for Stock Index Futures.Applied Financial Economics,5(3),131-137.
35. Park, T. H.,Switzer, L. N.(1996).Mean Reversion of Interest-Rate Term Premiums and Profits from Trading Strategies with Treasury Futures Spreads.Journal of Futures Markets,16(3),331-352.
36. Peters, E.(1986).Hedged Equity Portfolios: Components of Risk and Return.Advances in Futures and Options Research,1B,75-91.
37. Pope, P. F.,Yadav, P. K.(1994).The Impact of Short Sales Constraints on Stock Index Futures Prices: Evidence from FT-SE 100 Futures.Journal of Derivatives,1(4),15-26.
38. Wahab, M.,Cohn, R.,Lashgari, M.(1994).The Gold-Silver Spread: Integration, Cointegration, Predictability, and Ex-Ante Arbitrage.Journal of Futures Markets,14(6),709-756.
39. Wang, C.,Low, S. S.(2003).Hedging with Foreign Currency Denominated Stock Index Futures: Evidence from the MSCI Taiwan Index Futures Market.Journal of Multinational Financial Management,13(1),1-17.
40. Wang, J.(2010).Short Selling and Index Arbitrage Profitability: Evidence from the SGX MSCI and TAIFEX Taiwan Index Futures Markets.Emerging Markets Finance and Trade,46(5),51-69.
41. Wang, J.,Hsu, H.(2006).Degree of Market Imperfection and the Pricing of Stock Index Futures.Applied Financial Economics,16(3),245-258.
42. Yadav, P. K.,Pope, P. F.(1994).Stock Index Futures Mispricing: Profit Opportunities or Risk Premia?.Journal of Banking & Finance,18(5),921-953.
43. 王健聰(2006)。市場不完美性與指數套利關係之研究。管理與系統，13(4)，441-469。
44. 洪茂蔚、林丙輝、黃玉娟、周建新(2007)。台灣期貨交易所委託研究計畫台灣期貨交易所委託研究計畫,台灣期貨交易所。
45. 黃柏凱、張元晨、臧大年(2004)。影響股價指數期貨定價誤差因素之研究－以台股期貨為例。證券市場發展季刊，16(2)，81-114。

1. 劉海清,傅英芬(2019)。台灣股價指數期貨訂價偏誤與價格反轉。中山管理評論，27(3)，631-673。