题名

廣義虛擬實境的發展軌跡與未來趨勢

并列篇名

Developmental Trajectory and Trend of the Broad Virtual Reality

DOI

10.29416/JMS.201910_26(4).0002

作者

盧煜煬(Louis Y. Y. Lu)；劉顯仲(John S. Liu)；謝志宏(Chih-Hung Hsieh)；陳淑娟(Shu Juan Chen)

关键词

虛擬實境 ； 擴增實境 ； 混合實境 ； 發展軌跡 ； 主路徑分析 ； Virtual Reality (VR) ； Augmented Reality (AR) ； Mixed Reality (MR) ； Development Trajectory ； Main Path Analysis

期刊名称

管理與系統

卷期/出版年月

26卷4期（2019 / 10 / 01）

页次

427 - 449

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

本研究將虛擬實境（VR）、擴增實境（AR）與混合實境（MR）統稱為廣義的虛擬實境（the broad VR），從學術與專利資料庫中檢索相關文獻，進行過去發展軌跡的探索與未來研發趨勢之預測。由學術資料庫與專利資料庫中各獲得28,566及25,134篇文獻，針對學術文獻的引用資料建立引用網絡，再對引用網絡做主路徑分析，以得到總體發展軌跡，另做集群分析與文字雲分析獲得八大研究主題分別為：VR用於外科手術訓練、VR用於暴露治療、行動AR的應用、VR用於復健、VR用於產品開發、VR用於學習、AR用於手術導航以及VR用於腦部研究。接著，將兩種文獻中所有相關論文的名稱與摘要做文字探勘，找出出現頻率較高的關鍵詞，以了解研究者較有興趣的研究議題，並得知學術研究與專利研究的時間差為0到6年。最後，統計近四年學術研究的新興主題，以指引未來專利佈局的重點方向，此結果可供產官學界在擬定廣義虛擬實境未來發展方針之參考。本研究展示一個整合式的分析步驟，成功且有效地完成廣義VR技術發展與應用的軌跡，並預測未來專利研發的方向，為有興趣做科學發展文獻回顧與技術預測的研究者提供一個新的選擇。
英文摘要

This study combines virtual reality (VR), augmented reality (AR), and mixed reality (MR), and names it ＂the broad VR＂. The purpose of the study is to explore the overall development trajectory and foresee the future trend of the broad VR technology. We retrieve the broad VR relevant academic literature from Web of Science and Scopus, and relevant patent literature from Derwent Innovation. By using query (＂virtual reality＂ OR ＂augmented reality＂ OR ＂mixed reality＂), we retrieve 28,536 and 25,134 articles from academic and patent databases respectively. After applying the main path analysis and cluster analysis to the citation network of the academic literature, we explore the overall development trajectory of the broad VR research and identify eight major research themes, including VR in surgery training, VR in exposure treatment, mobile AR, VR in rehabilitation, VR in learning, AR in surgery navigation, and VR in brain study. We further apply text mining to the title and abstract of all literature to identify the most mentioned terms for representing the most interesting research topics. Top 20 terms in academic literature and patent literature are identified and the time lag between them ranging from 0 to 6 years. Finally, we identify the emerging research topics in academia as the reference for future patent development. We successfully demonstrate an integrated approach for exploring the overall development trajectory of scientific literature of the broad VR technology and forecasting the future direction for patent deployment. This study provides an alternative solution for researchers who are interested in conducting a literature review and technological forecasting.
主题分类 基礎與應用科學 > 統計
社會科學 > 財金及會計學
社會科學 > 管理學
参考文献
  1. Lee, C. F.,Tseng, F. M.,Lu, L. Y. Y.(2018)。The Development Trajectory of Virtual Reality Literature in Main Areas。Journal of Technology Management，23(2)，61-96。
    連結：
  2. Aggarwal, R.,Grantcharov, T. P.,Eriksen, J. R.,Blirup, D.,Kristiansen, V. B.,Funch-Jensen, P.,Darzi, A.(2006).An Evidence-Based Virtual Reality Training Program for Novice Laparoscopic Surgeons.Annals of Surgery,244(2),310-314.
  3. Aggarwal, R.,Ward, J.,Balasundaram, I.,Sains, P.,Athanasiou, T.,Darzi, A.(2007).Proving the Effectiveness of Virtual Reality Simulation for Training in Laparoscopic Surgery.Annals of Surgery,246(5),771-779.
  4. Aromaa, S.,Väänänen, K.(2016).Suitability of Virtual Prototypes to Support Human Factors/Ergonomics Evaluation during the Design.Applied Ergonomics,56,11-18.
  5. Artaud, A.,Richards, M. C.(trasn.)(1958).The Theater and Its Double.New York:Groove Press.
  6. Arvanitis, T. N.,Petrou, A.,Knight, J. F.,Savas, S.,Sotiriou, S.,Gargalakos, M.,Gialouri, E.(2009).Human Factors and Qualitative Pedagogical Evaluation of a Mobile Augmented Reality System for Science Education Used by Learners with Physical Disabilities.Personal and Ubiquitous Computing,13(3),243-250.
  7. Aydin, A.,Raison, N.,Khan, M. S.,Dasgupta, P.,Ahmed, K.(2016).Simulation-based Training and Assessment in Urological Surgery.Nature Reviews Urology,13(9),503-519.
  8. Azuma, R. T.(1997).A Survey of Augmented Reality.Presence: Teleoperators and Virtual Environments,6(4),355-385.
  9. Batagelj, V.(2003).Efficient Algorithms for Citation Network Analysis.University of Ljubljana, Institute of Mathematics, Physics and Mechanics, Preprint series,41(897)
  10. Baumhauer, M.,Feuerstein, M.,Meinzer, H. P.,Rassweiler, J.(2008).Navigation in Endoscopic Soft Tissue Surgery: Perspectives and Limitations.Journal of Endourology,22(4),751-766.
  11. Bernhardt, S.,Nicolau, S. A.,Soler, L.,Doignon, C.(2017).The Status of Augmented Reality in Laparoscopic Surgery as of 2016.Medical Image Analysis,37,66-90.
  12. Botella, C.,Banos, R. M.,Perpina, C.,Villa, H.,Alcaniz, M.,Rey, A.(1998).Virtual Reality Treatment of Claustrophobia: A Case Report.Behaviour Research and Therapy,36(2),239-246.
  13. Burgess, N.,Maguire, E. A.,O'Keefe, J.(2002).The Human Hippocampus and Spatial and Episodic Memory.Neuron,35(4),625-641.
  14. Burgess, N.,Maguire, E. A.,Spiers, H. J.,O'Keefe, J.(2001).A Temporoparietal and Prefrontal Network for Retrieving the Spatial Context of Lifelike Events.NeuroImage,14(2),439-453.
  15. Cabrilo, I.,Bijlenga, P.,Schaller, K.(2014).Augmented Reality in the Surgery of Cerebral Arteriovenous Malformations: Technique Assessment and Considerations.Acta Neurochirurgica,156(9),1769-1774.
  16. Carlin, A. S.,Hoffman, H. G.,Weghorst, S.(1997).Virtual Reality and Tactile Augmentation in the Treatment of Spider Phobia: A Case Report.Behaviour Research and Therapy,35(2),153-158.
  17. Carmigniani, J.,Furht, B.,Anisetti, M.,Ceravolo, P.,Damiani, E.,Ivkovic, M.(2011).Augmented Reality Technologies, Systems and Applications.Multimedia Tools and Applications,51(1),341-377.
  18. Carpenter, M. P.,Cooper, M.,Narin, F.(1980).Linkage between Basic Research Literature and Patents.Research-Technology Management,23,30-35.
  19. Chen, C. M.,Hicks, D.(2004).Tracing Knowledge Diffusion.Scientometrics,59(2),199-211.
  20. Chirico, A.,Yaden, D. B.,Riva, G.,Gaggioli, A.(2016).The Potential of Virtual Reality for the Investigation of Awe.Frontiers in Psychology,7(1766)
  21. Chittaro, L.,Ranon, R.(2007).Web3D Technologies in Learning, Education and Training: Motivations, Issues, Opportunities.Computers and Education,49(1),3-18.
  22. Choi, S.,Jung, K.,Noh, S. D.(2015).Virtual Reality Applications in Manufacturing Industries: Past Research, Present Findings, and Future Directions.Concurrent Engineering Research and Applications,23(1),40-63.
  23. Chu, C. C. P.,Dani, T. H.,Gadh, R.(1998).Evaluation of Virtual Reality Interface for Product Shape Designs.IIE Transactions,30(7),629-643.
  24. Coleman, J.,Nduka, C. C.,Darzi, A.(1994).Virtual Reality and Laparoscopic Surgery.British Journal of Surgery,81(12),1709-1711.
  25. Dalgarno, B.,Lee, M. J. W.(2010).What Are the Learning Affordances of 3-D Virtual Environments?.British Journal of Educational Technology,41(1),10-32.
  26. Dani, T. H.,Gadh, R.(1997).Creation of Concept Shape Designs via a Virtual Reality Interface.CAD Computer Aided Design,29(8),555-563.
  27. Deng, W.,Li, F.,Wang, M.,Song, Z.(2014).Easy-to-use Augmented Reality Neuronavigation Using a Wireless Tablet PC.Stereotactic and Functional Neurosurgery,92(1),17-24.
  28. Ewers, R.,Schicho, K.,Truppe, M.,Seemann, R.(2004).Computer-aided Navigation in Dental Implantology: 7 Years of Clinical Experience.Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery,62(3),329-334.
  29. Fletcher, C.,Ritchie, J.,Lim, T.,Sung, R.(2013).The Development of an Integrated Haptic VR Machining Environment for the Automatic Generation of Process Plans.Computers in Industry,64(8),1045-1060.
  30. Frank, R. M.,Wang, K. C.,Davey, A.,Cotter, E. J.,Cole, B. J.,Romeo, A. A.,Bush-Joseph, C. A.,Bach, B. R.,Verma, N. N.(2018).Utility of Modern Arthroscopic Simulator Training Models: A Meta-analysis and Updated Systematic Review.Arthroscopy--The Journal of Arthroscopic and Related Surgery,34(5),1650-1677.
  31. Garcia-Palacios, A.,Hoffman, H.,Carlin, A.,Furness, T. A., III,Botella, C.(2002).Virtual Reality in the Treatment of Spider Phobia: A Controlled Study.Behaviour Research and Therapy,40(9),983-993.
  32. Ge, S.,Zhu, Z.,Wu, B.,McConnell, E. S.(2018).Technology-Based Cognitive Training and Rehabilitation Interventions for Individuals with Mild Cognitive Impairment: A Systematic Review.BMC Geriatrics,18(213),2-19.
  33. Girvan, M.,Newman, M. E.(2002).Community Structure in Social and Biological Networks.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,99(12),7821-7826.
  34. Gleason, P. L.,Kikinis, R.,Altobelli, D.,Wells, W.,Alexander, E., III,Black, P. M. L.,Jolesz, F.(1994).Video Registration Virtual Reality for Non-linkage Stereotactic Surgery.Stereotactic and Functional Neurosurgery,63(1-4),139-143.
  35. Gron, G.,Wunderlich, A. P.,Spitzer, M.,Tomczak, R.,Riepe, M. W.(2000).Brain Activation during Human Navigation: Gender-Different Neural Networks as Substrate of Performance.Nature Neuroscience,3(4),404-408.
  36. Hassfeld, S.,Muhling, J.(2001).Computer Assisted Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery - A Review and an Assessment of Technology.International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery,30(1),2-13.
  37. Hoffman, H. G.,Richards, T. L.,Coda, B.,Bills, A. R.,Bloughm D.,Richards, A. L.,Sharar, S. R.(2004).Modulation of Thermal Pain-Related Brain Activity with Virtual Reality: Evidence from fMRI.Neuroreport,15(8),1245-1248.
  38. Hollerer, T.,Feiner, S.,Terauchi, T.,Rashid, G.,Hallaway, D.(1999).Exploring MARS: Developing Indoor and Outdoor User Interfaces to a Mobile Augmented Reality System.Computers and Graphics (Pergamon),23(6),779-785.
  39. Hummon, N. P.,Doreian P(1989).Connectivity in a Citation Network: The Development of DNA Theory.Social Networks,11(1),39-63.
  40. Jang, S.,Vitale, J. M.,Jyung, R. W.,Black, J. B.(2017).Direct Manipulation is Better than Passive Viewing for Learning Anatomy in a Three-Dimensional Virtual Reality Environment.Computers and Education,106,150-165.
  41. Jayaram, S.,Vance, J.,Gadh, R.,Jayaram, U.,Srinivasan, H.(2001).Assessment of VR Technology and Its Applications to Engineering Problems.Journal of Computing and Information Science in Engineering,1(1),72-83.
  42. Jayaram, U.,Jayaram, S.,Shaikh, I.,Kim, Y.,Palmer, C.(2006).Introducing Quantitative Analysis Methods into Virtual Environments for Real-Time and Continuous Ergonomic Evaluations.Computers in Industry,57(3),283-296.
  43. Kaufmann, H.,Schmalstieg, D.(2003).Mathematics and Geometry Education with Collaborative Augmented Reality.Computers & Graphics-UK,27(3),339-345.
  44. Kumar, A.,Smith, R.,Patel, V. R.(2015).Current status of Robotic Simulators in Acquisition of Robotic Surgical Skills.Current Opinion in Urology,25(2),168-174.
  45. Liss, M. A.,Abdelshehid, C.,Quach, S.,Lusch, A.,Graversen, J.,Landman, J.,McDougall, E. M.(2012).Validation, Correlation, and Comparison of the Da Vinci Trainer and the Da Vinci Surgical Skills Simulator Using the Mimic Software for Urologic Robotic Surgical Education.Journal of Endourology,26(12),1629-1634.
  46. Liu, J. S.,Lu, L. Y. Y.(2012).An Integrated Approach for Main Path Analysis: The Development of the Hirsch Index as an Example.Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,63(3),528-542.
  47. Liu, J. S.,Lu, L. Y. Y.,Ho, M. H-C.(2019).A Few Notes on Main Path Analysis.Scientometrics,119(1),379-391.
  48. Maguire, E. A.,Burgess, N.,Donnett, J. G.,Frackowiak, R. S. J.,Frith, C. D.,O'Keefe, J.(1998).Knowing Where and Getting There: A Human Navigation Network.Science,280(5365),921-924.
  49. Maguire, E. A.,Frith, C. D.,Burgess, N.,Donnett, J. G.,O'Keefe, J.(1998).Knowing Where Things Are: Parahippocampal Involvement in Encoding Object Locations in Virtual Large-Scale Space.Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience,10(1),61-76.
  50. Marescaux, J.,Clement, J. M.,Tassetti, V.,Koehl, C.,Cotin, S.,Russier, Y.,Mutter, D.,Delingette, H.,Ayache, N.(1998).Virtual Reality Applied to Hepatic Surgery Simulation: The Next Revolution.Annals of Surgery,228(5),627-634.
  51. Maselli, A.,Slater, M.(2013).The Building Blocks of the Full Body Ownership Illusion.Frontiers in Human Neuroscience,7(83),2374-2391.
  52. Merchant, Z.,Goetz, E. T.,Cifuentes, L.,Keeney-Kennicutt, W.,Davis, T. J.(2014).Effectiveness of Virtual Reality-Based Instruction on Students' Learning Outcomes in K-12 and Higher Education: A Meta-analysis.Computers and Education,70,29-40.
  53. Mikropoulos, T. A.,Natsis, A.(2011).Educational Virtual Environments: A Ten-Year Review of Empirical Research (1999-2009).Computers and Education,56(3),769-780.
  54. Neequaye, S. K.,Aggarwal, R.,Brightwell, R.,van Herzeel, I.,Darzi, A.,Cheshire, N. J. W.(2007).Identification of Skills Common to Renal and Iliac Endovascular Procedures Performed on a Virtual Reality Simulator.European Journal of Vascular and Endovascular Surgery,33(5),525-532.
  55. Newman, M. E.(2006).Modularity and Community Structure in Networks.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,103,8577-8582.
  56. Nguyen, H.,Pontonnier, C.,Hilt, S.,Duval, T.,Dumont, G.(2017).VR-based Operating Modes and Metaphors for Collaborative Ergonomic Design of Industrial Workstations.Journal on Multimodal User Interfaces,11(1),97-111.
  57. Palmarini, R.,Erkoyuncu, J. A.,Roy, R.,Torabmostaedi, H.(2018).A Systematic Review of Augmented Reality Applications in Maintenance.Robotics and Computer-Integrated Manufacturing,49,215-228.
  58. Parong, J.,Mayer, R. E.(2018).Learning Science in Immersive Virtual Reality.Journal of Educational Psychology,110(6),785-797.
  59. Parsons, T. D.,Gaggioli, A.,Riva, G.(2017).Virtual Reality for Research in Social Neuroscience.Brain Sciences,7(4),42.
  60. Peugnet, F.,Dubois, P.,Rouland, J. F.(1997).Clinical Assessment of a Training Simulator for Retinal Photocoagulation.Cvrmed-Mrcas'97: First Joint Conference - Computer Vision, Virtual Reality and Robotics in Medicine and Medical Robotics and Computer-Assisted Surgery, Vol. 1205
  61. Plancher, G.,Tirard, A.,Gyselinck, V.,Nicolas, S.,Piolino, P.(2012).Using Virtual Reality to Characterize Episodic Memory Profiles in Amnestic Mild Cognitive Impairment and Alzheimer's Disease: Influence of Active and Passive Encoding.Neuropsychologia,50(5),592-602.
  62. Ploder, O.,Wagner, A.,Enislidis, G.,Ewers, R.(1995).Computer-Assisted Intraoperative Visualization of Dental Implants - Augmented Reality in Medicine.Radiologe,35(9),569-572.
  63. Rankohi, S.,Waugh, L.(2013).Review and Analysis of Augmented Reality Literature for Construction Industry.Visualization in Engineering,1(1),1-9.
  64. Repetto, C.,Serino, S.,Macedonia, M.,Riva G(2016).Virtual Reality as an Embodied Tool to Enhance Episodic Memory in Elderly.Frontiers in Psychology,4(1839)
  65. Riva, G.(2003).Applications of Virtual Environments in Medicine.Methods of Information in Medicine,42(5),524-534.
  66. Riva, G.,Banos, R. M.,Botella, C.,Mantovani, F.,Gaggioli, A.(2016).Transforming Experience: The Potential of Augmented Reality and Virtual Reality for Enhancing Personal and Clinical Change.Frontiers in Psychiatry,7(164)
  67. Rothbaum, B. O.,Hodges, L. F.,Kooper, R.,Opdyke, D.,Williford, J. S.,North, M.(1995).Effectiveness of Computer-Generated (Virtual-Reality) Graded Exposure in the Treatment of Acrophobia.American Journal of Psychiatry,152(4),626-628.
  68. Rothbaum, B. O.,Hodges, L.,Watson, B. A.,Kessler, G. D.,Opdyke, D.(1996).Virtual Reality Exposure Therapy in the Treatment of Fear of Flying: A Case Report.Behaviour Research and Therapy,34(5-6),477-481.
  69. Roussos, M.,Johnson, A.,Moher, T.,Leigh, J.,Vasilakis, C.,Barnes, C.(1999).Learning and Building Together in an Immersive Virtual World.Presence-Teleoperators and Virtual Environments,8(3),247-263.
  70. Sanchez-Vives, M. V.,Slater, M.(2005).From Presence to Consciousness through Virtual Reality.Nature Reviews Neuroscience,6(4),332-339.
  71. Serino, S.,Pedroli, E.,Tuena, C.,de Leo, G.,Stramba-Badiale, M.,Goulene, K.,Mariotti, N. G.,Riva, G.(2017).A Novel Virtual Reality-Based Training Protocol for the Enhancement of the "Mental Frame Syncing" in Individuals with Alzheimer's Disease: A Development-of-Concept Trial.Frontiers in Aging Neuroscience,9,240-250.
  72. Seth, A.,Vance, J. M.,Oliver, J. H.(2011).Virtual Reality for Assembly Methods Prototyping: A Review.Virtual Reality,15(1),5-20.
  73. Shin, H.,Kim, K.(2015).Virtual Reality for Cognitive Rehabilitation after Brain Injury: A Systematic Review.Journal of Physical Therapy Science,27(9),2999-3002.
  74. Slater, M.(2009).Place Illusion and Plausibility can Lead to Realistic Behaviour in Immersive Virtual Environments.Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences,364(1535),3549-3557.
  75. SuperData Research, “Virtual Reality Industry Report,” 2017, retrieved from http://www.superdataresearch.com/market-data/virtual-reality-industry-report/
  76. Teber, D.,Baumhauer, M.,Guven, E. O.,Rassweiler, J.(2009).Robotic and Imaging in Urological Surgery.Current Opinion in Urology,19(1),108-113.
  77. Toledo-Morales, P.,Sanchez-Garcia, J. M.(2018).Use of Augmented Reality in Social Sciences as Educational Resource.Turkish Online Journal of Distance Education,19(3),38-52.
  78. Van Bennekom, M. J.,de Koning, P. P.,Denys, D.(2017).Virtual Reality Objectifies the Diagnosis of Psychiatric Disorders: A Literature Review.Frontiers in Psychiatry,8(163),1-7.
  79. Van Herzeele, I.,Aggarwal, R.,Neequaye, S.,Hamady, M.,Cleveland, T.,Darzi, A.,Cheshire, N.,Gaines, P.(2008).Experienced Endovascular Interventionalists Objectively Improve Their Skills by Attending Carotid Artery Stent Training Courses.European Journal of Vascular and Endovascular Surgery,35(5),541-550.
  80. Vincelli, F.(1999).From Imagination to Virtual Reality: The Future of Clinical Psychology.Cyberpsychology and Behavior,2(3),241-248.
  81. Wacker, F. K.,Vogt, S.,Khamene, A.,Jesberger, J. A.,Nour, S. G.,Elgort, D. R.,Sauer, F.,Duerk, J. L.,Lewin, J. S.(2006).An Augmented Reality System for MR Image-Guided Needle Biopsy: Initial Results in a Swine Model.Radiology,238(2),497-504.
  82. Wagner, A.,Ploder, O.,Enislidis, G.,Truppe, M.,Ewers, R.(1996).Image-guided surgery.International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery,25(2),147-151.
  83. Wagner, A.,Ploder, O.,Enislidis, G.,Truppe, M.,Ewers, R.(1995).Virtual Image Guided Navigation in Tumor Surgery - Technical Innovation.Journal of Cranio-Maxillofacial Surgery,23(5),271-273.
  84. Walsh, C.,Lydon, S.,Byrne, D.,Madden, C.,Fox, S.,O'Connor, P.(2018).The 100 Most Cited Articles on Healthcare Simulation: A Bibliometric Review.Simulation in Healthcare,13(3),211-220.
  85. Wang, X.,Kim, M. J.,Love, P. E. D.,Kang, S. C.(2013).Augmented Reality in Built Environment: Classification and Implications for Future Research.Automation in Construction,32,1-13.
  86. Wang, X.,Ong, S. K.,Nee, A. Y. C.(2016).Real-virtual Components Interaction for Assembly Simulation and Planning.Robotics and Computer-Integrated Manufacturing,41,102-114.
  87. Weniger, G.,Irle, E.(2008).Allocentric Memory Impaired and Egocentric Memory Intact as Assessed by Virtual Reality in Recent-Onset Schizophrenia.Schizophrenia Research,101(1-3),201-209.
  88. Weniger, G.,Ruhleder, M.,Lange, C.,Wolf, S.,Irle, E.(2011).Egocentric and Allocentric Memory as Assessed by Virtual Reality in Individuals with Amnestic Mild Cognitive Impairment.Neuropsychologia,49(3),518-527.
  89. Weniger, G.,Siemerkus, J.,Schmidt-Samoa, C.,Mehlitz, M.,Baudewig, J.,Dechent, P.,Irle, E.(2010).The Human Parahippocampal Cortex Subserves Egocentric Spatial Learning during Navigation in a Virtual Maze.Neurobiology of Learning and Memory,93(1),46-55.
被引用次数
  1. 辜玉潔,童秋霞,陳瓊燕,邱紹群(2023)。疫情限制Pokémon GO玩家的續玩意願嗎？。管理資訊計算，12(2)，162-180。
  2. (2023)。運用虛擬實境於室內設計教學之學習成效探討。設計學報，28(4)，95-114。
print cancel