專案融資運用於武器研製之研究－系統動態觀點

The Study of Project Finance in Weapon development: the Perspective of System Dynamics

10.29416/JMS.202001_27(1).0004

劉代洋(Day-Yang Liu)；汪家淦(Jia-Gan Wang)；方崇懿(Chung-Yi Fang)；劉培林(Pei-Leen Liu)

國防主要武器裝備自製 ； 專案融資 ； 系統動態學 ； 系統思考 ； MDE Self-production ； Project Finance ； System Dynamics ； Systems Thinking

管理與系統

27卷1期（2020 / 01 / 01）

77 - 97

繁體中文

國防主要武器裝備（Major Defense Equipment, MDE）自製包含自主研發、生產與構成武器產業鏈等三方面，藉由發展國防亦可同步提升國家的產業競爭力。MDE自製以軍用目的為導向，具複雜度高、整合度強、資本投資大、技術門檻高與回收期長等特性，除了政府整體規劃與政策的推動外，也需要民間廠商參與，然而民間廠商普遍存在財力條件不足之情況，常需藉由專案融資（Project Financing）取得所需資金。專案融資需具備高度專業及評估能力，而國內銀行長期缺乏專案建造、營運技術等評估能力與經驗，將影響融資風險控管，專案融資亦可能遭到廠商挪用，最後將會影響軍購的履約。因此，專案融資在MDE自製中扮演重要角色，強化MDE自製專案融資的治理工作及系統管理是重要議題。MDE自製與專案融資需考量因素很多，各種因素彼此相互影響、互為因果、環環相扣，利害關係人包含政府、民間廠商與銀行之間互動關係動態複雜，必須以整體與結構性的系統觀點來思考，較能瞭解問題的全貌，進而提出適切的政策。然少有文獻以系統觀點探討MDE自製與專案融資的研究，因此本研究採用系統動態學方法論，以系統思考建構臺灣MDE自製與專案融資質性系統動態分析模式，從政府、民間廠商與銀行三個利害關係人的角度，闡述MDE自製與專案融資因素之因果互動關係，提出改善系統結構之建議，提供決策者政策制訂之參考。

Self-production of major defense equipment (MDE) involves three dimensions, namely, self-research and development, production, and forming an arms industry chain. Through developments in national defense, the competitiveness of national industries can be enhanced simultaneously. MDE self-production is generally oriented toward military use, features high complexity, integration, investment capital, and technological requirements, as well as long payback periods. To meet national defense needs and enhance industrial competitiveness, in addition to overall planning and policy promotion by the government, the technological skills and financial conditions of private sector manufacturers must be considered. Likewise, to meet defense needs and enhance industrial competitiveness, project financing from banks, the establishment of a supervision framework and testing mechanism, and improvements to governance mechanisms concerning military acquisition and defense procurement as well as management of complex systems are necessary. Regarding MDE self-production and project financing, numerous factors must be considered. Moreover, these factors show interaction or causal effects, so they cannot be considered independently. Additionally, stakeholders include the government, private sector manufacturers, and banks, whose interaction relationships are generally complex. Therefore, comprehensive and structurally systematic perspectives must be adopted when engaging in MDE self-production and project financing issues. However, because few studies have systematically examined these issues, this study adopts system dynamics to construct a system dynamics model for analyzing MDE self-production and project financing in Taiwan through systems thinking. From the perspective of three stakeholders, namely, the government, private sector manufacturers, and banks, the causal and interaction relationships between factors of MDE production and project financing are described, and key methods for improving the system structure are proposed to serve as a reference for policy decision-makers.

1. 林達榮,林安成(2004)。提前違約風險下專案融資之評價模式。風險管理學報，6(1)，57-83。
   連結：
2. 劉代洋,方崇懿,劉培林(2015)。國際觀光度假區系統動態模式建構─以澎湖為例。管理與系統，22(4)，431-458。
   連結：
3. 劉佳怡,蕭志同,劉仲戌(2017)。社會企業之永續經營模式：以里仁公司為例。管理與系統，24(3)，455-476。
   連結：
4. Baker, S. H.(2010).Unmasking Project Finance: Risk Mitigation, Risk Inducement, and an Invitation to Development Disaster.Tex. J. Oil Gas & Energy L.,6,273.
5. Benoit, E.(1978).Growth & Defense in Developing Countries.Economic Development & Cultural Change,26(2),271-280.
6. Broome, L. L.(2002).Framing the Inquiry: The Social Impact of Project Finance--A Comment on Bjerre.Duke J. Comp. & Int'l L.,12,439.
7. Chen, J. H.,Jan, T. S.(2005).A Variety-increasing View of the Development of the Semiconductor Industry in Taiwan.Technological Forecasting and Social Change,72(7),850-865.
8. Chen, J. H.,Jan, T. S.(2005).A System Dynamics Model of the Semiconductor Industry Development in Taiwan.Journal of the Operational Research Society,56(10),1141-1150.
9. Coyle, G.(1998).The Practice of System Dynamics: Milestones, Lessons and Ideas from 30 years.System Dynamic Review,14(4),343-365.
10. Coyle, R. G.(1997).System Dynamics Modelling-A Practical Approach.Journal of the Operational Research Society,48(5),544-544.
11. Doyle, J. K.,Ford, D. N.(1998).Mental Models Concepts for System Dynamics Research.System Dynamic Review,14(1),3-29.
12. Finnerty, J. D.(1996).Project Financing: Asset-Based Financial Engineering.John Wiley & Sons.
13. Finnerty, J. D.(2013).Project Financing: Asset-Based Financial Engineering.John Wiley & Sons.
14. Ford, A.(1997).System Dynamics and the Electric Power Industry.System Dynamic Review,13(1),57-85.
15. Ford, D. N.,Sterman, J. D.(1998).Expert knowledge elicitation to improve formal and mental models.System Dynamics Review,14(4),309-340.
16. Gatti, S.(2013).Project Finance in Theory and Practice: Designing, Structuring, and Financing Private and Public Projects.UK: London:Academic Press.
17. Head, R. C.(1974).Comparative Defense Policy.Bahimore:The Johns Hopkins University Press.
18. Hsiao, C. T.(2014).Industrial Development Research by Systems Approach in NICs: The Case in Taiwan.Systems Research and Behavioral Science,31(2),258-267.
19. Hsiao, C. T.,Chang, P. L.,Chen, C. W.,Huang, H. H.(2011).A Systems View for the High-Tech Industry Development: A Case Study of Large-Area TFT-LCD Industry in Taiwan.Asian Journal of Technology Innovation,19(1),117-132.
20. Hsiao, C. T.,Liu, C. S.(2012).Dynamic Modeling of the Development of the DRAM Industry in Taiwan.Asian Journal of Technology Innovation,20(2),277-293.
21. James, G. M.(1978).Living Systems.Mcgraw-Hill Book Company.
22. Jan, C. G.(2005).Defense Technology in Society Lessons from Large Arms Importers.Technology in Society,27(2),181-197.
23. Jan, T. S.,Hsiao, C. T.(2004).A Four-role Model of the Automotive Industry Development in Developing Countries: a Case in Taiwan.Journal of the Operational Research Society,55(11),1145-1155.
24. Kakimoto, R.,Senneviratne, P. N.(2000).Financial risk of port infrastructure development.Journal of Waterway, Port, Costal, and Ocean Engineering,126(6),281-287.
25. Landau, D.(1992).The Impact of Military Spending on Economic Growth in LDCs.Washington, DC:Mimeo.
26. Liu, P. L.(2014).The Development of a Military Aircraft Industry for Latecomers: The Case of Taiwan.The Korean Journal of Defense Analysis,26(1),97-115.
27. Meadows, D. H.,Meadow, D. L.,Randers, J.,Behrens, W. W.(1972).The Limits to Growth: a Report of the Club of Rome’s Project on the Predicament of Mankind.New York:Chelsea Green Publishing Company.
28. Meadows, D. H.,Randers, J.,Meadow, D. L.(2004).Limits to Growth: The 30-Year Update.New York:Chelsea Green Publishing Company.
29. Mohamed, S.,McCowan, A. K.(2001).Modeling Project Investment Decisions under Uncertainty Using Possibility Theory.International Journal of Project Management,19(4),231-241.
30. Schilling, M. A.(2010).Strategic Management Of Technological Innovation.New York:McGRAW-Hill.
31. Senge, P.(1990).The Fifth Dimension: The Art and Practice of the Learning Organization.New York:Doubleday.
32. Shen, L. Y.,Wu, Y. Z.(2005).Risk Concession Model for Built/Operate/Transfer Contract Projects.Journal of Construction Engineering and Management,131(2),211-220.
33. Sterman, J.(2000).Business Dynamics: Systems Thinking and Modeling for a Complex World.Irwin:McGraw-Hill.
34. Sterman, J. D.(1988).Modeling the Formation of Expectations: The History of Energy Demand Forecasts.International Journal of Forecasting,4(2),243-259.
35. Trappey, A. J. C.,Trappey, C. V.,Hsiao, C.T.,Ou, J-R.,Li, S-J.,Chen, K. W. P.(2012).An Evaluation Model for Low Carbon Island Policy: The Case of Taiwan’s Green Transportation Policy.Energy Policy,45,510-515.
36. Yeo, K. T.,Tiong, R. L.(2000).Positive Management of Difference for Risk Reduction in BOT Projects.International Journal of project Management,18(4),257-265.
37. 田家綺(2011)。國防大學政治作戰學院政治學系。
38. 吳海甸(1994)。國防武器系統自主研發策略省思。中山科學研究院新新雙月刊，22(3)，209-228。
39. 吳愛娟(2012)。逢甲大學工業工程與系統管理學研究所。
40. 周佑倫(2009)。成功大學法律學系。
41. 邱奕哲(2011)。交通大學土木工程學系。
42. 柯國華(2007)。開放式創新的國防科技研發策略之探討。國防雜誌，22(2)，27-40。
43. 倪耿(1996)。系統需求產生概論。新新雙月刊，24(5)，103-124。
44. 徐作聖,陳仁帥(2004)。我國武器系統自力研發策略之探討。國家政策季刊，3(3)，203-218。
45. 袁正綱,李春鶯(2009)。我國防科技政策執行績效平衡計分卡評估模型構建之研究。評價學報，2，27-35。
46. 國防部(2002)。強化國防科技體系，促進國防軍備發展。第七次全國科學技術會議，台北:
47. 屠益民,張良政(2010).系統動力學理論與運用.臺北市:智勝文化.
48. 張家揚(2010)。國防大學資源管理及決策研究所。
49. 許家銘(2009)。中山大學企業管理學系研究所。
50. 陳美智(2007)。國立成功大學都市計劃學系。
51. 曾章瑞,陳漢華(2003)。亟待建立國防科技結合戰略分析之整合機制。和平論壇
52. 童兆陽,劉興岳,邵敏毅(1995)。我國武獲策略之研究。第三屆國防管理學術研討會
53. 黃仁志(2003)。國防產業的創新擴散：借鏡以色列的經驗。經濟前瞻，169，71-77。
54. 楊棻海(2005)。新版巴賽爾資本協定與銀行信用風險測度模型的發展：兼論對我國銀行體系與央行政策的影響。中央銀行季刊，27(1)，47-86。
55. 楊慶宗(1990)。楊慶宗，「系統工程管理，降低武器系統發展風險及大型系統發展，整合的關鍵技術」，設計家雜誌社，民國79年。
56. 葉康洋(2007)。銘傳大學資訊管理學系。
57. 詹秋貴(2001)。我國國防科技政策的淨評估。第九屆國防管理學術研討會，台北:
58. 詹秋貴(2000)。交通大學經營管理研究所。
59. 劉大溶,林曉琪(2018)。國際離岸風電專案融資與盡職調查之概述及借鏡。臺灣經濟研究月刊，41(4)，8-65。
60. 劉培林(2007)。交通大學管理科學系。
61. 潘東豫(2000)。國軍國防科技獲得模式之研究。第8屆國防管理學術暨實務研討會論文集
62. 潘雅慧(2004)。新巴塞爾資本協定與我國因應之道。中央銀行季刊，26(2)，31-48。
63. 蕭志同,戴俞萱,柳淑芬(2010).決策分析與模擬：組織機構與企業產業發展的途徑.臺北:東華書局.
64. 韓光渭(2000).系統工程與倫理.元智大學.
65. 羅義春(2006)。國防大學後勤管理研究所。
66. 蘇民(2011)。國防大學國防科學研究所。

1. (2022)。以系統動態觀點探討光學元件廠商之策略創業。產業與管理論壇，24(4)，48-73。