Lean Assessment Mechanism of Supplier Based on Multiple-to-Multiple Benchmarking Learning

以多對多標竿學習為基之精實供應商評核機制

10.29416/JMS.202004_27(2).0002

蕭堯仁(Yau-Ren Shiau)；王舜郁(Shun-Yu Wang)；簡家貴(Chia-Kuei Chien)

Supplier Assessment ； Multiple to Multiple Benchmarking Learning ； Lean Management ； DEA ； 供應商評核 ； 多對多標竿學習 ； 精實管理 ； 資料包絡分析法

管理與系統

27卷2期（2020 / 04 / 01）

123 - 144

英文

In competitive environments where the global economy is undergoing regionalization, enterprises must consider and improve how they manage efficiency in principal areas of their work, such as strengthening the effectiveness of supplier assessment mechanisms and improving supply chain performance through lean management. In the spirit of taking initiative, the current study identifies areas within the supplier assessment mechanism where suppliers can effectively learn from one another, by embracing lean management and continuous improvement. This process leads to the formation of an assessment mechanism that involves multiple-to-multiple benchmarking learning subjects, and projects that comprise an overall lean supply chain. Supplier assessment indicators are constructed from several dimensions, including quality, delivery, cost, and innovative research and development, and data envelopment analysis is used to establish the assessment mechanism for selecting MBL subjects and projects between suppliers. The multiple-to-multiple benchmarking learning decision selection model is then used to systematically promote the continuous improvement of lean management among suppliers, monitor their achievement of improvement targets, conduct regular assessments and reviews, and focus on and improve overall supply chain performance.

在全球經濟區域化之競爭環境下，企業亦須兼顧並提升基本面的管理效益，如強化供應商評核機制之效能，以精實提升供應鏈績效。基於化被動為主動的精神，本研究於供應商評核機制內，嵌入可有效挖掘出供應商間可相互學習及持續改善的精實之處，並形成多對多標竿學習的對象及項目之評核機制，以精實整體供應鏈之表現。本研究以品質、交期、成本、創新研發構面建構供應商評核指標，並引用資料包絡分析法建立評核機制，以篩選出供應商間可多對多相互學習的對象及項目。並藉由該決策選擇模型的系統，在多對多相互學習下，以系統化推動供應商精實管理的持續改善，追蹤改善目標達成，定期進行評核檢討作業，聚焦並提升供應鏈的整體績效表現。

1. Banker, R. D.,Charnes, A.,Cooper, W. W(1984).Some Models for Estimating Technical and Scale Inefficiencies in Data Envelopment Analysis.Management Science,30(9),1078-1092.
2. Boone, T.,Ganeshan, R.,Jayaraman, V.(2012).Sustainable Supply Chains.NY:Springer.
3. Chang, B.,Chang, C. W.,Wu, C. H.(2011).Fuzzy DEMATEL Method for Developing Supplier Selection Criteria.Expert Systems with Applications,38(3),1850-1858.
4. Chen, H. K.,Lin, Y. H.,Yih, J. M.(2018).Comparisons on the Benchmarking of School Efficiency Based on SFA and DEA.International Journal of Intelligent Technologies & Applied Statistics,10(4),207-220.
5. Chen, Y. J.(2011).Structured Methodology for Supplier Selection and Evaluation in a Supply Chain.Information Sciences,181(9),1651-1670.
6. Dobos, I.,Vörösmarty, G.(2014).Green Supplier Selection and Evaluation Using DEA-type Composite Indicators.International Journal of Production Economics,157,273-278.
7. Fallahpour, A.,Olugu, E. U,Musa, S. N.,Wong, K. Y.,Noori, S.(2017).A Decision Support Model for Sustainable Supplier Selection in Sustainable Supply Chain Management.Computers & Industrial Engineering,105,391-410.
8. Feyzioglu, O.,Büyüközkan, G.(2010).Evaluation of Green Suppliers Considering Decision Criteria Dependencies.Multiple Criteria Decision Making for Sustainable Energy and Transportation Systems,Berlin, Heidelberg:
9. Ghadimi, P.,Dargi, A.,Heavey, C.(2017).Sustainable Supplier Performance Scoring Using Audition Check-List Based Fuzzy Inference System: A Case Application in Automotive Spare Part Industry.Computers & Industrial Engineering,105,12-27.
10. Hashemia, S. H.,Karimi, A.,Tavana, M.(2015).An Integrated Green Supplier Selection Approach with Analytic Network Process and Improved Grey Relational Analysis.International Journal of Production Economics,159,178-191.
11. Maria Vanalle, R.,Blanco Santos, L.(2014).Green Supply Chain Management in Brazilian Automotive Sector.Management of Environmental Quality: An International Journal,25(5),523-541.
12. Mirmousa, S.,Dehnavi, H. D.(2016).Development of Criteria of Selecting The Supplier by Using The Fuzzy DEMATEL Method.Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences,230,281-289.
13. Novikov, V. A.,Sapun, O.,Shipulina, L.(2016).Accounting The Scale and Synergies in The DEA Analysis.LogForum,12(2),123-128.
14. Sarkis, J.,Dhavale, D. G.(2015).Supplier Selection for Sustainable Operations: A Triple-Bottom-Line Approach Using A Bayesian Framework.International Journal of Production Economics,166,177-191.
15. Shafiee, M.,Lotfi, F. H.,Saleh, H.(2014).Supply Chain Performance Evaluation with Data Envelopment Analysis and Balanced Scorecard Approach.Applied Mathematical Modelling,38(21),5092-5112.
16. Simić, D.,Kovačević, I.,Svirčević, V.,Simić, S.(2017).50 Years of Fuzzy Set Theory And Models for Supplier Assessment and Selection: A Literature Review.Journal of Applied Logic,24(2017),85-96.
17. Zhang, W.,Zhang, S.,Guo, S.,Yang, Y.,Chen, Y.(2017).Concurrent Optimal Allocation of Distributed Manufacturing Resources Using Extended Teaching-Learning-Based Optimization.International Journal of Production Research,55(3),718-735.
18. Zimmer, K.,Fröhling, M.,Schultmann, F.(2016).Sustainable Supplier Management - A Review of Models Supporting Sustainable Supplier Selection, Monitoring and Development.International Journal of Production Research,54,1412-1442.

1. 蕭堯仁,陳幼蘭(2019)。篩選產學合作夥伴及協商資源配置之機制。科技管理學刊，24(2)，31-59。