精實智慧製造：概念架構與策略性解決共創平台

Lean Smart Manufacturing: A Conceptual Framework and Solution Based Co-Creative Platform

10.29416/JMS.202004_27(2).0005

黎立仁(Lih-Ren Li)；吳銀澤(Eun-Teak Oh)；劉仁傑(Ren-Jye Liu)

精實智慧製造 ； 工業4.0 ； 網宇實體系統 ； 精實生產 ； 策略性解決共創平台 ； Lean Smart Manufacturing ； Industry 4.0 ； Cyber Physical System(CPS) ； Lean Production ； Strategic Solution Based Co-Creative Platform

管理與系統

27卷2期（2020 / 04 / 01）

191 - 211

繁體中文

2011年德國倡導工業4.0，在各先進國家的政策推動下，導入工業4.0新技術的「智慧製造」，作為製造業的創新策略，在學術與實務上廣受矚目。然而，宣揚工業4.0的「智慧製造」在產業製造現場，由於龐大投資與個別企業差異化等問題，與政府推動政策出現了落差，以致於智慧製造之進展有限，尚未找到明確的發展力向。鑑於此一情況，本研究結合產業界個別企業的實踐動向，開發能實現顧客價值、結合精實生產與智慧製造的「精實智慧製造」實踐架構。亦即，本研究檢視工業4.0風潮、研究文獻與企業的智慧製造實踐，從價值創造的本質提出「精實智慧製造」的概念架構與解決方案平台。本研究所提示的「精實智慧製造」架構，首先從實體系統的持續改善開始，進行系統的數位化、連結化與智慧化之第一階段。其次透過由實體系統匯集至網宇系統的數位資訊所建構的策略性共創平台，整合供應商與顧客形成問題解決機制之第二階段所構成，最終達至創造顧客價值的實踐架構。最後，本研究提示「精實智慧製造」的理論意涵，以及就日本與台灣製造業如何以實體系統為中心繼續確立差異化優勢問題，提出實務與政策的意涵。

Industry 4.0, started in Germany in 2011, was fervently promoted by various advanced countries and followed by the introduction of ＂smart manufacturing＂. As an innovative strategy of the manufacturing industry ＂smart manufacturing＂ has attracted considerable attention in the field of academic and practice. However, the issues of huge investment and differentiation of individual enterprises have created a big gap between policy promotion and production at the site of actual industrial manufacturing and resulted in limited progress in smart manufacturing and failure to find a clear development direction. In view of the situation, this study is made to develop in relation to the practice of individual companies in the industry a practical structure of ＂Lean Smart Manufacturing＂ combining lean production with smart manufacturing to achieve customer value. That is to say, after examining industry 4.0 trend, research literature and practice of smart manufacturing this study therefore proposes a conceptual framework of ＂Lean Smart Manufacturing＂ and ＂strategic solution based co-creative platform＂ from the essence of value creation. The framework proposed begins with continuous improvement of the physical system which includes digitizing, linking, and intelligent using. Secondly, through the strategic co-creative platform built by digital information which is collected in the cyber system from physical system, problem-solving mechanism integrating suppliers with customers and eventually creation of customer value is to be made. In conclusion, this study is offering a theoretical implication of ＂Lean Smart Manufacturing＂ and practical measure as to how the Japanese and Taiwanese manufacturing continue to establish differentiated advantages centered on the physical system.

1. Almada-Lobo, F.(2016).The Industry 4.0 Revolution and The Future of Manufacturing Execution Systems (MES).Journal of Innovation Management,3(4),16-21.
2. Buer, S. V.,Strandhagen, J. O.,Chan, F. T.(2018).The Link Between Industry 4.0 and Lean Manufacturing: Mapping Current Research and Establishing a Research Agenda.International Journal of Production Research,56(8),2924-2940.
3. Colombo, A. W.,Karnouskos, S.,Bangemann, T.(2014).Towards the Next Generation of Industrial Cyber-Physical Systems.Industrial Cloud-Based Cyber-Physical Systems,1-22.
4. Dalenogare, L. S.,Benitez, G. B.,Ayala, N. F.,Frank, A. G.(2018).The Expected Contribution of Industry 4.0 Technologies for Industrial Performance.International Journal of Production Economics,204,383-394.
5. De Jong, M.,van Dijk, M.(2015).Disrupting Beliefs: a New Approach to Business-Model Innovation.McKinsey Quarterly,3,66-75.
6. Dombrowski, U.,Richter, T.,Krenkel, P.(2017).Interdependencies of Industrie 4.0 & Lean Production Systems: A Use Cases Analysis.Procedia Manufacturing,11,1061-1068.
7. Herterich, M. M.,Uebernickel, F.,Brenner, W.(2015).The Impact of Cyber-Physical Systems on Industrial Services in Manufacturing.Procedia CIRP,30,323-328.
8. Kagermann, H.(2015).Management of permanent change.Wiesbaden:Springer Gabler.
9. Kang, H. S.,Lee, J. Y.,Choi, S.,Kim, H.,Park, J. H.,Son, J. Y.,Do Noh, S.(2016).Smart Manufacturing: Past Research, Present Findings, and Future Directions.International Journal of Precision Engineering and Manufacturing-Green Technology,3(1),111-128.
10. Kindström, D.,Kowalkowski, C.(2009).Development of Industrial Service Offerings: A Process Framework.Journal of service Management,20(2),156-172.
11. Kolberg, D.,Zühlke, D.(2015).Lean Automation Enabled by Industry 4.0 Technologies.IFAC-Papers On Line,48(3),1870-1875.
12. Lee, J.,Bagheri B.,Kao H. A.(2015).A Cyber-Physical Systems Architecture for Industry 4.0-Based Manufacturing Systems.Manufacturing Letters,3,18-23.
13. Lee, J.,Davari, H.,Singh, J.,Pandhare, V.(2018).Industrial Artificial Intelligence for Industry 4.0-based Manufacturing Systems.Manufacturing Letters,18,20-23.
14. Lee, J.,Kao, H. A.,Yang, S.(2014).Service Innovation and Smart Analytics for Industry 4.0 and BigData Environment.Procedia CRIP,16(1),3-8.
15. Liao, Y.,Deschamps, F.,Loures, E. D. F. R.,Ramos, L. F. P.(2017).Past, Present and Future of Industry 4.0-A Systematic Literature Review and Research Agenda Proposal.International journal of production research,55(12),3609-3629.
16. Lu, Y.(2017).Industry 4.0: A Survey on Technologies, Applications and Open Research Issues.Journal of Industrial Information Integration,6,1-10.
17. Mayr, A.,Weigelt, M.,Kühl, A.,Grimm, S.,Erll, A.,Potzel, M.,Franke, J.(2018).Lean 4.0-A Conceptual Conjunction of Lean Management and Industry 4.0.Procedia CIRP,72(1),622-628.
18. Mora, E.,Gaiardelli, P.,Resta, B.,Powell, D.(2017).Exploiting Lean Benefits through Smart Manufacturing: A Comprehensive Perspective.IFIP International Conference on Advances in Production Management Systems
19. Mrugalska, B an,Wyrwicka, M. K.(2017).Towards Lean Production in Industry 4.0.Procedia Engineering,182,466-473.
20. Müller, J. M.,Maier, L.,Veile, J.,Voigt, K. I.(2017).Cooperation Strategies among Smes for Implementing Industry 4.0.Proceedings of the Hamburg International Conference of Logistics (HICL)
21. Müller, J. M.,Voigt, K. I.(2018).Sustainable Industrial Value Creation in SMEs: A Comparison between Industry 4.0 and Made in China 2025.International Journal of Precision Engineering and Manufacturing-Green Technology,5(5),659-670.
22. Nikolic, B.,Ignjatic, J.,Suzic, N.,Stevanov, B.,Rikalovic, A.(2018).Predictive Manufacturing Systems In Industry 4.0: Trends, Benefits And Challenges.Annals of DAAAM & Proceedings
23. Pawar,K. S,Beltagui, A.,Riedel, J. C. K. H.(2009).The PSO triangle: Designing product, service and organisation to create value.International Journal of Operations & Production Management,29(5),468-493.
24. Piccarozzi, M.,Aquilani, B.,Gatti, C.(2018).Industry 4.0 in Management Studies: A Systematic Literature Review.Sustainability,10(10),1-24.
25. Porter, M. E.,Heppelmann, J. E.(2015).How Smart, Connected Products are Transforming Companies.Harvard Business Review,97-114.
26. Prahalad, C. K.,Ramaswamy, V.(2004).The future of competition: Co-creating unique value with customers.Boston:Harvard Business Press.
27. Rüßmann, M.,Lorenz, M.,Gerbert, P.,Waldner, M.,Justus, J,Engel, P.,Harnisch, M.(2015).Industry 4.0: The Future of Productivity and Growth in Manufacturing Industries.Boston Consulting Group
28. Schuh, G.,Potente, T.,Wesch-Potente, C.,Weber, A. R.,Prote, J. P.(2014).Collaboration Mechanisms to Increase Productivity in the Context of Industrie 4.0.Procedia CIRP,19,51-56.
29. Storbacka, K.(2011).A Solution Business Model: Capabilities and Management Practices for Integrated Solutions.Industrial Marketing Management,40(5),699-711.
30. Storbacka, K.,Pennanen, R.(2014).Solution Business: Building a Platform for Organic Growth.Berlin:Springer Verlag.
31. Tortorella, G. L.,Fettermann, D.(2018).Implementation of Industry 4.0 and Lean Production in Brazilian Manufacturing Companies.International Journal of Production Research,56(8),2975-2987.
32. Tuli, K. R.,Kohli, A. K.,Bharadwaj, S. G.(2007).Rethinking Customer Solutions: from Product Bundles to Relational Processes.Journal of Marketing,71(3),1-17.
33. Vandermerwe, S.,Rada, J.(1988).Servitization of Business: Adding Value by Adding Services.European Management Journal,6(4),314-324.
34. Zhou, K.,Liu, T.,Zhou, L.(2015).Industry 4.0: Towards Future Industrial Opportunities and Challenges.2015 12th International Conference on Fuzzy Systems and Knowledge Discovery (FSKD)
35. 一宮美幸(2019)。東海大學工業工程與經營資訊學系。
36. 大野治(2016)。IoTで激変する日本型製造業ビジネスモデル。東京:日刊工業新聞社。
37. 日本機械工業連合会(2017)。,日本機械工業連合会。
38. 日経ビジネス(2016)。IoTが変える世界：データ資本主義。日経ビジネス，2016年5月23日，38-41。
39. 日経情報ストラテジー(2015)。ウエアラブル端末、大活躍！。日経情報ストラテジー，5月?，28-33。
40. 光山博敏、中沢孝夫(2017)。インダストリー４．０の崩壊とその先にあるもの。一橋ビジネスレビュー，65(3)，108-121。
41. 西岡健一、南知恵子(2017)。造業のサービス化戦略。東京:中央経済社。
42. 尾木蔵人(2015)。インダストリー 4.0: 第4次産業革命の全貌。東京:東洋経済新報社。
43. 延岡健太郎(2017)。顧客価値の暗黙化。一橋ビジネスレビュー，64(4)，20-30。
44. 酒井健(2014)。製造業のサービス能力の無効化：キャタピラーとコマツの競争を事例として。日本経営学会誌，15-25。
45. 朝岡崇史(2016)。IoT時代のエクスペリエンス・デザイン。東京:ファーストプレス。
46. 資策會產業情報研究所 (MIC) 「 CPS 於智慧製造之應用探索」， 民國 105 年 。https://mic.iii.org.tw/Industryobservation_MIC02views.aspx?sqno=165 (民國107年10月5日瀏覽)。
47. 劉仁傑,吳銀澤,巫茂熾,邱創鈞,桑原喜代和(2018).面對未來的智造者：工業4.0的困惑與下一波製造業再興.台北:大寫出版.
48. 劉仁傑,陳國民(2014).世界工廠大移轉.台北:大寫出版.
49. 藤本隆弘(2017)。インダストリー4.0と日本のデジタルモノづくり。グローバル経営，7/8月合併，22-25。
50. 藤本隆宏(2004)。日本のもの造り哲学。東京:日本経済新聞社。
51. 藤本隆宏(2017)。現場から見上げる企業戦略論─ デジタル時代にも日本に勝機はある。東京:角川新書。
52. 奥村洋(2017)。CPS 研究の世界的潮流と日本の現状。研究技術計画，32(3)，251-265。
53. 徳増伸二(2017)。インダストリー4.0との時代のわが国製造業の変革の方向性。密工学会誌，83(1)，13-16。