關係連結對服務失誤補救滿意度和再購意願間關係之干擾效果

The Moderating Effect of Relational Tie on the Relationship between Satisfaction in Service Failure Recovery and Repurchasing Intent

10.29416/JMS.202010_27(4).0003

黃銘章(Ming-Chang Huang)；呂鴻德(Horng-Der Leu)；洪千惠(Chien-Hui Hung)；陳彥寧(Yan-Ning Chen)

服務補救矛盾 ； 補救滿意度 ； 再購意願 ； 關係連結 ； Service Recovery Paradox ； Service Failure Recovery ； Recovery Satisfaction ； Repurchasing Intent ； Relational Tie

管理與系統

27卷4期（2020 / 10 / 01）

409 - 436

繁體中文

曩昔有相當多的研究探討，服務失誤與補救的連結，所產生服務失誤矛盾的現象，然而，研究結果也相當多不一致。本研究認為關係連結，係為影響服務補救矛盾是否發生的重要因素，服務補救滿意度與顧客再購意願之間的關係，也會受到關係連結的影響。本研究藉由兩個2 X 2實驗設計進行資料收集並進行假說驗證。實驗一的目的在於檢視在不同的關係連結下，是否會發生服務失誤補救的矛盾；實驗二的目的，則是檢視關係連結對於補救滿意度與再購意願間關係的影響。進行實驗時，受測者被隨機指派到不同的實驗情境，觀賞不同情境的影片。篩選完無效問卷，實驗一有效問卷為558份，實驗二有效問卷獲致274份。本研究結果顯示，於強連結情境下，會發生服務補救矛盾的現象；另於強連結情境下，補救滿意度對再購意願間的影響則較強。

Numerous studies explore the linkage between service failure and recovery that lead to service paradox with inconsistent results. This study suggests that strong tie is a critical that results in service paradox. The relational tie will also moderate the relationship between satisfaction in service failure recovery and repurchasing intention. Two 2 X 2 experiments are designed to collect data and test our hypotheses. The aim of first experiment tests the relationship between relational tie and service paradox. The purpose of second experiment tests the moderating effect of relational tie on the relationship between the satisfactions in service failure recovery and repurchase intention. The objects of this study are invited and randomly assigned to each experimental situation. After deleting invalid questionnaires, 558 and 274 valid questionnaires are obtained from these two experiments. The result shows that the service recovery paradox occurs under the strong tie. Under the situation of strong tie, high satisfaction in service failure recovery can have higher repurchase intention.

1. 黃識銘,方世榮(2008)。服務補救策略的研究─關係行銷觀點。管理與系統，15(1)，1-31。
   連結：
2. Abu Bakar, S. Z.(2017).Southern Illinois University at Carbondale.
3. Bamford, D.,Xystouri, T.(2005).A Case Study of Service Failure and Recovery within an International Airline.Management Service Quality,15(3),306-322.
4. Bejou, D.,Ennew, C. T.,Palmer, A.(1998).Trust, Ethics and Relationship Satisfaction.International Journal of Bank Marketing,16(4),170-175.
5. Bejou, D.,Palmer, A.(1998).Service Failure and Loyalty: An Exploratory Empirical Study of Airline Customers.Journal of Service Marketing,12(1),7-22.
6. Brock, C.,Blut, M.,Evanschitzky, H.,Voorhees, C.(2017).Service Failure and Customer Loyalty:Testing the Boundary Conditions of the Service Recovery Paradox.AMA Winter Educators'Conference Proceedings
7. Chen, T.,Ma, K.,Bian, X.,Zhang C.,Dedvlin, J.(2018).Is High Recovery More Effective than Expected Recovery in Addressing Service Failure?- A Moral Judgment Perspective.Journal of Business Research,82,1-9.
8. Choi, B.,Choi, B.(2014).The Effects of Perceived Service Recovery Justice on Customer Affection, Loyalty, and Word-of-Mouth.European Journal of Marketing,49(1/2),108-131.
9. Chou, P-F.(2015).An Analysis of the Relationship between Service Failure, Service Recovery and Loyalty for Low Cost Carrier Travelers.Journal of Air Transport Management,47,119-125.
10. Chuang, S-C,Cheng, Y-H.,Chang, C-J.,Yang, S-W.(2012).The Effect of Service Failure Types and Service Recovery on Customer Satisfaction: A Mental Accounting Perspective.The Service Industries Journal,32(2),257-271.
11. de Matos, C. A.,Henrique, J. L.,Rossi, C. A. V.(2007).Service Recovery Paradox: A Meta-Analysis.Journal of Service Research,10(1),60-77.
12. de Matos, C. A.,Rossi, C. A. V.,Veiga, R. T.,Vierira, V. A.(2009).Consumer Reaction to Service Failure and Recovery: The Moderating Role of Attitude toward Complaining.Journal of Service Marketing,23(7),462-475.
13. Garg, A.(2013).Service Recovery Paradox in Indian Banking Industry: An Empirical Investigation.The South East Asian Journal of Management,7(2),23-38.
14. Gelbrich, K.,Roschk, H.(2011).A Meta-Analysis of Organizational Complaint Handling and Customer Responses.Journal of Service Research,14(1),24-43.
15. Gohary, A.,Hamzelu, B.,Pourazizi, L.(2016).A Little Bit More Value Creation and a lot of Less Value Destruction! Exploring Service Recovery Paradox in Value Context: A Study in Travel Industry.Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Management,20,189-203.
16. Gustafsson, A.(2009).Customer Satisfaction with Service Recovery.Journal of Business Research,62(11),1220-1222.
17. Harrison-Walker, L. J.(2019).The Critical Role of Customer Forgiveness in Successful Service Recovery.Journal of Business Research,95,376-391.
18. Hazée, S.,Vaerenbergh, Y. V.,Armirotto V.(2017).Co-Creating Service Recovery after Service Failure: The Role of Brand Equity.Journal of Business Research,74,101-109.
19. Hedrick, N.,Beverland, M.,Minahan, S.(2007).An Exploration of Relational Customers’ Response to Service Failure.Journal of Service Marketing,21(1),64-72.
20. Hess,Ganesan, S.,Klein, N. M.(2003).Service Failure and Recovery: The Impact of Relationship Factors on Customer Satisfaction.Journal of Academy of Marketing Science,31(2),127-145.
21. Hocutt, M. A.,Bowers, M. R.,Donavan, D. T.(2006).The Art of Service Recovery: Fact or Fiction?.Journal of Service Marketing,20(3),199-207.
22. Holloway, B. B.,Wang, S.,Beatty, S. E.(2009).Betrayal? Relationship Quality Implications in Service Recovery.Journal of Services Marketing,23(6),385-396.
23. Iglesias, V.(2009).The Attribution of Service Failures: Effect on Consumer Satisfaction.The Service Industries Journal,29(2),127-141.
24. Jung, N. Y.,Seock, Y-K.(2017).Effect of Service Recovery on Customers’ Perceived Justice, Satisfaction, and Word-Of-Mouth Intentions on Online Shopping Websites.Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services,37,23-30.
25. Karande, K.,Magnini, V. P.,Tam, L.(2007).Recovery Voice and Satisfaction after Service Failure.Journal of Service Research,10(2),187-203.
26. Kau, A.,Loh, E. W. Y.(2006).The Effects of Service Recovery on Consumer Satisfaction: A Comparison between Complainants and Non-complainants.Journal of Services Marketing,20(2),101-111.
27. Kelley, S. W.,Davis, M. A.(1994).Antecedents to Customer Expectations for Service Recovery.Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science,22(1),52-62.
28. Khalifa, A. H.,Saad, M.(2017).The Determinants of Trust in The Customer-Service Provider Relationship: The Case of Tunisian Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises (SMEs).International Journal of Technology Management & Sustainable Development,16(3),295-310.
29. Kim, T(T).,Kim, W. G.,Kim, H-B.(2009).The Effects of Perceived Justice on Recovery Satisfaction, Trust, Word-of-Mouth, and Revisit Intention in Upscale Hotels.Tourism Management,30(1),51-62.
30. Knox, G.,van Oest, R.(2014).Customer Complaints and Recovery Effectiveness: A Customer Base Approach.Journal of Marketing,78(5),42-57.
31. Lastner, M. W.,Folse, J. A. G.,Mangus, S. M.,Fennell, P.(2016).The Road to Recovery: Overcoming Service Failures through Positive Emotions.Journal of Business Research,69,4237-4286.
32. Lin, H-H.,Wang, Y-S.,Chang, L-K.(2011).Consumer Responses to Online Retailer's Service Recovery after a Service Failure: A Perspective of Justice Theory.Managing Service Quality,21(5),511-534.
33. Liu, H.,Jayawardhena, C.,Dibb, S.,Ranaweera, C.(2019).Examining the Trade-off between Compensation and promptness in eWOM-triggered Service Recovery: A Restorative Justice Perspective.Tourism Management,75,381-392.
34. Magnini, V. P.,Ford, J. B.,Markowski, E. P.,Honeycutt, E. D. Jr.(2007).The Service Recovery Paradox: Justifiable Theory or Smoldering Myth?.Journal of Services Marketing,21(3),213-225.
35. Mandl, L.,Hogreve, J.(2020).Buffering Effects of Brand Community Identification in Service Failure: The Role of Customer Citizenship Behaviors.Journal of Business Research,107,1301-137.
36. Mattila, A. S.(2001).The Impact of Relationship Type on Customer Loyalty in a Context of Service Failures.Journal of Service Research,4(2),91-101.
37. Mattila, A. S.,Cho, W.,Ro, H.(2009).The Joint Effects of Service Failure Mode, Recovery Effort, and Gender on Customers’ Post-Recovery Satisfaction.Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing,26(2),120-128.
38. Maxham, J. G. III,Netemeyer, R. G.(2002).A Longitudinal Study of Complaining Customers’ Evaluations of Multiple Service Failures and Recovery Efforts.Journal of Marketing,66(4),57-71.
39. McCollough, M. A.(2009).The Recovery Paradox: The Effect of Recovery Performance and Service Failure Severity on Post-Recovery Customer Satisfaction.Academy of Marketing Studies Journal,13(1),89-104.
40. McCollough, M. A.,Berry, L. L.,Yadav, M. S.(2000).An Empirical Investigation of Customer Satisfaction after Service Failure and Recovery.Journal of Service Research,3(2),121-137.
41. Michel, S.,Meuter, M. L.(2008).The Service Recovery Paradox: True but Overrated?.International Journal of Service Industry Management,19(4),441-451.
42. Mount, D. J.,Mattila, A.(2009).The Relationship of Reliability and Recovery to Satisfaction and Return Intent at the Hotel Unit Level.Journal of Quality Assurance in Hospitality & Tourism,10(4),301-310.
43. Nikbin, D.,Marimuthu M.,Hyun S. S.,Ismail, I.(2014).Relationships of Perceived Justice to Service Recovery, Service Failure Attributions, Recovery Satisfaction, and Loyalty in the Context of Airline Travelers.Asia Pacific Journal of Tourism Research,20(3),239-262.
44. Ok, C.,Back, K-J.,Shanklin, C. W.(2007).Mixed Findings on the Service Recovery Paradox.The Service Industries Journal,27(6),671-686.
45. Oliver, R. L.(1993).Cognitive, Affective, and Attribute Bases of the Satisfaction Response.Journal of Consumer Research,20(3),418-430.
46. Ozkan-Tektas, O.,Basgoze, P.(2017).Pre-recovery Emotions and Satisfaction: A Moderated Mediation Model of Service Recovery and Reputation in the Banking Sector.European Management Journal,35(3),388-395.
47. Rashid, M. H. A.,Ahmad F. S.,Othman A. K.(2014).Does Service Recovery Affect Customer Satisfaction? A Study on Co-Created Retail Industry.Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences,130,455-460.
48. Río-Lanza, A. B.,Vázquez-Casielles, R.,Díaz-Martín, A. M.(2009).Satisfaction with Service Recovery: Perceived Justice and Emotional Responses.Journal of Business Research,62(8),775-781.
49. Smith, J. S.,Nagy, P. F.,Karwan, K. R.,Ramirez, E.(2012).The Contingent Nature of Service Recovery System Structures.International Journal of Operations & Production Management,32(7),877-903.
50. Soares, R. V. R. S. F.(2014).Soares. S. F.University of do Porto.
51. Sparks, B. A.,Mccoll-Kennedy, J. R.(2001).Justice Strategy Options for Increased Customer Satisfaction in a Services Recovery Setting.Journal of Business Research,54(3),209-218.
52. Swanson, S. R.,Hsu, M. K.(2009).Critical Incidents in Tourism: Failure, Recovery, Customer Switching, and Word-of-Mouth Behaviors.Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing,26(2),180-194.
53. Tax, S. S.,Brown, S. W.,Chandrashekaran, M.(1998).Customer Evaluations of Service Complaint Experiences: Implications for Relationship Marketing.Journal of Marketing,62(2),60-76.
54. Van Vaerenbergh, Y.,Orsingher, C.(2016).Service Recovery: An Integrative Framework and Research Agenda.Academy of Management Perspective,30(3),328-346.
55. Varela-Neira, C.,Vázquez-Casielles, R.,Iglesias-Argüelles, V.(2008).The Influence of Emotions on Customer’s Cognitive Evaluations and Satisfaction in a Service Failure and Recovery Context.The Service Industries Journal,28(4),497-512.
56. Wang, Y-S.,Wu, S-C.,Lin, H-H.,Wang, Y-Y.(2011).The Relationship of Service Failure Severity, Service Recovery Justice and Perceived Switching Costs with Customer Loyalty in the Context of e-Tailing.International Journal of Information Management,31(4),350-359.
57. Weitzl, W. J.,Einwiller, S. A.(2019).Profiling (Un-)committed Online Complainants: Their Characteristics and Post-webcare Reactions.Journal of Business Research
58. Wen, B.,Chi, C. G-Q.(2013).Examine the Cognitive and Affective Antecedents to Service Recovery Satisfaction: A Field Study of Delayed Airline Passengers.International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management,25(3),306-327.
59. 黃銘章(2011)。黃銘章，機位被取消了怎麼辦，臺北：台灣管理個案中心，民國 100 年，個案編號：AR0001621。

1. 林秀英,吳敏華(2022)。負面報導是偶然？物流服務補救黃金時間之資料探勘。管理與系統，29(2)，187-221。