查核會計師的合法與專家權力重要嗎？財務風險客戶與審計品質觀點

Are Audit Partners' Legitimate and Expert Power Important? Clients' Financial Risk and Audit Quality Perspective

10.29416/JMS.202110_28(4).0003

孔繁華(Fan-Hua Kung)

合夥會計師 ； 合法權力 ； 專家權力 ； 產業專家 ； 審計品質 ； Audit Partners ； Legitimate Power ； Expert Power ； Auditor Industry Specialist ； Audit Quality

管理與系統

28卷4期（2021 / 10 / 01）

431 - 477

繁體中文

本文旨在探討會計師擁有權力是否會影響其風險態度，並反映在接受有財務風險客戶之委任及其審計品質上。擁有合法權力之會計師可能傾向將注意力集中於正向與酬賞的資訊，因此較注重風險行動中的回報，而忽視其潛在危險；或者，具備合法權力之會計師也可能更加注重聲譽維護，擔心高財務風險客戶之企業失敗使其需承擔可能發生之審計失敗與訴訟風險。再者，由於產業專家擁有較佳之查核品質，故若當會計師同時具備合法及專家權力時，對於高財務風險客戶之委任選擇及其審計品質，應存在一定程度之影響。實證結果發現當主簽或副簽會計師具備合法權力時，較不願意接受高財務風險客戶之委任；然而當主簽會計師同時擁有合法及專家權力時，則較會願意承擔高財務風險客戶之查核責任。在對裁決性應計數之結果上，發現具合法權力之主簽會計師查核的高財務風險公司較會進行盈餘向下之管理行為，惟當主簽會計師同時具備合法權力及產業專家身分時，則會遏制高財務風險公司進行盈餘向下之操弄，會有較高之審計品質。綜上可知，會計師之合法權力及產業專家身分，實為影響其接受高財務風險客戶委任及其審計品質之重要因素。就作者所知，本文為目前第一篇同時探討會計師合法及專家權力之實證文章。希冀透過本文結果，能補足會計師特性對於客戶委任選擇及審計品質影響文獻之闕漏，也企圖從不同面相的觀察，發現影響會計師委任偏好與其審計品質之關鍵因素。

The purpose of this paper is to examine whether power of audit partners is reflected in the composition of their client portfolios and audit quality. Audit partners with legitimate power tend to focus optimistically on the potential rewards. This makes them more likely to attach importance to potential returns from risk-related actions, thereby accepting clients with greater financial risk. Alternatively, audit partners with legitime power may be more concerned with reputation preservation, fearing that the business failure of a high financial risk client exposes him or her to the risk of possible audit failure and litigation. Furthermore, because auditor industry expertise has better audit quality, there should be some impact on the client selection and audit quality of high financial risk clients when audit partners have both legitimate and expert powers. The findings show that lead or concurring partners with legitimate power are inclined towards risk aversion in their client choice. Lead partners with both legitimate and expert powers tend to accept clients with higher financial risk. Moreover, clients with high financial risk that are audited by lead partners with legitimate power are inclined to permit the downward earnings management. Audit partners with both legitimate power and expert power provide higher audit quality. In summary, audit partners with legitimate power and expert power are important factors affecting their acceptance of appointments of high financial risk clients and their audit quality. This paper is the first empirical article exploring audit partners' legitimate power and expert power. Through the results of this paper, we hope to fill in the gaps in the literature on the influence of audit partner characteristics on the preference of client selection and audit quality.

1. 吳清在,邱正仁,鄭莉(2011)。財務危機公司內部治理對會計師簽發繼續經營疑慮意見的影響：台灣上市公司之實證研究。臺大管理論叢，21(2)，187-217。
   連結：
2. 李建然,陳信吉,湯麗芬(2013)。客戶重要性與審計品質—從簽證會計師角度分析。當代會計，14(2)，147-174。
   連結：
3. 官月緞,駱韋龍,張玲玲(2019)。簽證會計師性別與審計公費之關聯性。會計學報，8(1)，35-72。
   連結：
4. 林美鳳,金成隆,林良楓(2009)。股權結構、會計保守性與信用評等關係之研究。臺大管理論叢，20(1)，289-329。
   連結：
5. 曾乾豪,張瑀珊,薛敏正(2012)。個別會計師查核簽證家數與企業盈餘品質。中華會計學刊，8(2)，49-88。
   連結：
6. 劉嘉雯,王泰昌,賴信蒼(2009)。訴訟風險與大型會計師事務所之客戶財務風險可接受水準。臺大管理論叢，20(1)，1-40。
   連結：
7. 簡俱揚,陳玉梅(2009)。產業審計專家與獨立董監事對新發行公司債資金成本的影響。當代會計，10(1)，99-130。
   連結：
8. Altman, E. I.(1968).Financial Ratios, Discriminant Analysis and the Prediction of Corporate Bankruptcy.Journal of Finance,23(4),589-609.
9. Amir, E.,Kallunki, J. P.,Nilsson, H.(2014).The Association between Individual Audit Partners’ Risk Preferences and the Composition of Their Client Portfolios.Review of Accounting Studies,19(1),103-133.
10. Anderson, C.,Berdahl, J. L.(2002).The Experience of Power: Examining the Effects of Power on Approach and Inhibition Tendencies.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,83(6),1362-1377.
11. Anderson, C.,Brion, S.(2014).Perspectives on Power in Organizations.Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational Behavior,1,67-97.
12. Anderson, C.,Galinsky, A. D.(2006).Power, Optimism, and Risk-taking.European Journal of Social Psychology,36(4),511-536.
13. Balsam, S.,Krishnan, J.,Yang, J. S.(2003).Auditor Industry Specialization and Earnings Quality.Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory,22(2),71-97.
14. Beasley, M. S.,Petroni, K. R.(2001).Board Independence and Audit‐firm Type.Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory,20(1),97-114.
15. Bell, T.,Peecher, M.,Solomon, I.(2005).The 21st Century Public Company Audit: Conceptual Elements of KPMG’s Global Audit Methodology.KPMG, LLP.
16. Cahan, S. F.,Godfrey, J. M.,Hamilton, J.,Jeter, D. C.(2008).Auditor Specialization, Auditor Dominance, and Audit Fees: The Role of Investment Opportunities.The Accounting Review,83(6),1393-1423.
17. Cahan, S. F.,Jeter, D. C.,Naiker, V.(2011).Are all Industry Specialist Auditors the Same?.Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory,30(4),191-222.
18. Carcello, J. V.,Hermanson, D. R.,Huss, H. F.(1995).Temporal Changes in Bankruptcy Related Reporting.Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory,14(2),133-143.
19. Carey, P.,Simnett, R.(2006).Audit Partner Tenure and Audit Quality.The Accounting Review,81(3),653-676.
20. Chen, C. Y.,Lin, C. J.,Lin, Y. C.(2008).Audit-partner Tenure, Audit Firm Tenure, and Discretionary Accruals: Does Long Auditor Tenure Impair Earnings Quality.Contemporary Accounting Research,25(2),415-445.
21. Chen, Y. M.,Moroney, R.,Houghton, K.(2005).Audit Committee Composition and the Use of an Industry Specialist Audit Firm.Accounting and Finance,45(2),217-239.
22. Chi, H. Y.,Chin, C. L.(2011).Firm versus Partner Measures of Auditor Industry Expertise and Effects on Auditor Quality.Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory,30(2),201-229.
23. Chi, W.,Huang, H.,Liao, Y.,Xie, H.(2009).Mandatory Audit Partner Rotation, Audit Quality, and Market Perception: Evidence from Taiwan.Contemporary Accounting Research,26(2),359-391.
24. Chi, W.,Myers, L. A.,Omer, T. C.,Xie, H.(2017).The Effects of Audit Partner Pre-client and Client-specific Experience on Audit Quality and on Perceptions of Audit Quality.Review of Accounting Studies,22(1),361-391.
25. Chin, C. L.,Chi, S. Y.(2009).Reducing Restatements with Increased Industry Expertise.Contemporary Accounting Research,26(3),729-765.
26. Church, B. K.,Dai, N.T.,Kuang, X.,Liu, X.(2020).The Role of Auditor Narcissism in Auditor­Client Negotiations: Evidence from China.Contemporary Accounting Research
27. Cohen, D. A.,Dey, A.,Lys, T. Z.(2008).Real and Accrual Based Earnings Management in The Pre and Post Sarbanes Oxley Periods.The Accounting Review,83(3),757-787.
28. Cohen, D. A.,Zarowin, P.(2010).Accrual-Based and Real Earnings Management Activities around Seasoned Equity Offerings.Journal of Accounting and Economics,50(1),2-19.
29. Cohen, J. R.,Trompeter, G. M.(1998).An Examination of Factors Affecting Audit Practice Development.Contemporary Accounting Research,15(4),481-504.
30. Craswell, A. T.,Francis, J. R.,Taylor, S. L.(1995).Auditor Brand Name Reputations and Industry Specializations.Journal of Accounting and Economics,20,297-322.
31. DeFond, M. L.,Francis, J. R.,Wong, T. J.(2000).Auditor Industry Specialization and Market Segmentation: Evidence from Hong Kong.Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory,19(1),49-66.
32. Eichenseher, J. W.,Danos, R.(1981).The Analysis of Industry-specific Auditor Concentration: Towards an Explanatory Model.The Accounting Review,56(3),479-492.
33. Emerson, R. M.(1962).Power Dependence Relations.American Sociological Review,27(1),31-41.
34. Farmer, T. A.(1993).Testing the Effect of Risk Attitude on Auditor Judgment Using Multi-attribute Utility Theory.Journal of Accounting, Auditing & Finance,8(1),91-110.
35. Ferguson, A.,Francis, J.,Stokes, D.(2003).The Effects of Firm-wide and Office-level Industry Expertise on Audit Pricing.The Accounting Review,78(2),429-448.
36. Finkelstein, S.(1992).Power in Top Management Teams: Dimensions, Measurement, and Validation.Academy of Management Journal,35(3),505-538.
37. Fiske, S. T.(1993).Controlling other People: The Impact of Power on Stereotyping.American Psychologist,48(6),621-628.
38. Francis, J. R.,Krishnan, J.(1999).Accounting Accruals and Auditor Reporting Conservatism.Contemporary Accounting Research,16(1),139-165.
39. Francis, J. R.,Reichelt, K.,Wang, D.(2005).The Pricing of National and City-specific Reputations for Industry Expertise in the U.S. Audit Market.The Accounting Review,80(1),113-136.
40. French, J. R. P., Jr.,Raven, B.(1959).The Bases of Social Power.Studies in Social Power,Ann Arbor:
41. Galinsky, A. D.,Magee, J. C.,Inesi, M. E.,Gruenfeld, D. H.(2006).Power and Perspectives Not Taken.Psychological Science,17(12),1068-1074.
42. Gouldner, A.(1970).The Coming Crisis in Western Sociology.London:Heinemann.
43. Gul, F. A.,Wu, D.,Yang, Z.(2013).Do Individual Auditors Affect Audit Quality? Evidence from Archival Data.The Accounting Review,88(6),1993-2023.
44. Gunny, K. A.(2010).The Relation between Earnings Management Using Real Activities Manipulation and Future Performance: Evidence from Meeting Earnings Benchmarks.Contemporary Accounting Research,27(3),855-888.
45. Hardies, K.,Breesch, D.,Branson, J.(2015).The Female Audit Fee Premium.Auditing: A Journal of Practice and Theory,34(4),171-195.
46. Hardies, K.,Breesch, D.,Branson, J.(2016).Do (Fe)male Auditors Impair Audit Quality? Evidence from Going-concern Opinions.European Accounting Review,25(1),7-34.
47. He, X.,Pittman, J. A.,Rui, O. M.,Wu, D.(2017).Do Social Ties Between External Auditors and Audit Committee Members Affect Audit Quality?.The Accounting Review,92(5),61-87.
48. Hsieh, Y. T.,Lin, C. J.(2016).Audit Firms' Client Acceptance Decisions: Does Partner-level Industry Expertise Matter?.Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory,35(2),97-120.
49. Ittonen, K.,Vähämaa, E.,Vähämaa, S.(2013).Female Auditors and Accruals Quality.Accounting Horizons,27(2),205-228.
50. Kahneman, D.,Tversky, A.(1979).Prospect Theory.Econometrica,47(2),263-292.
51. Kallunki, J.,Niemi, L.,Nilsson, H.(2019).IQ and Audit Quality: Do Smarter Auditors Deliver Better Audits?.Contemporary Accounting Research,36(3),1373-1416.
52. Keltner, D.,Gruenfeld, D.,Anderson, C.(2003).Power, Approach, and Inhibition.Psychological Review,110(2),265-284.
53. Knechel, W. R.,Vanstraelen, A.,Zerni, M.(2015).Does the Identity of the Engagement Partners Matter? An Analysis of Audit Partner Reporting Decisions.Contemporary Accounting Research!,32(4),1443-1478.
54. Kothari, S. P.,Leone, A. J.,Wasley, C. E.(2005).Performance Matched Discretionary Accrual measures.Journal of Accounting and Economics,39(1),163-197.
55. Laurion, H.,Lawrence, A.,Ryans, J.(2017).U.S. Audit Partner Rotations.The Accounting Review,92(3),209-237.
56. Lee, H. S.,Nagy, A. L.,Zimmerman, A. B.(2019).Audit Partner Assignments and Audit Quality in the United States.The Accounting Review,94(2),297-323.
57. Lehman, E. W.(1969).Toward a Macrosociology of Power.American Sociological Review,34(4),453-465.
58. Lennox, C.,Wu, X.,Zhang, T.(2014).Does Mandatory Rotation of Audit Partners Improve Audit Quality?.The Accounting Review,89(5),1775-1803.
59. Li, L.,Qi, B.,Tian, G.,Zhang, G.(2017).The Contagion Effect of Low-quality Audits at the Level of Individual Auditors.The Accounting Review,92(1),137-163.
60. Lu, T.,Sapra, H.(2009).Auditor Conservatism and Investment Efficiency.The Accounting Review,84(6),1933-1958.
61. Magee, J. C,Galinsky, A. D.(2008).Social Hierarchy: The Self-reinforcing Nature of Power and Status.The Academy of Management Annals,2,351-398.
62. Messier, W. F.,Owhoso, V.,Rakovski, C.(2008).Can Audit Partners Predict Subordinates’ Ability to Detect Errors?.Journal of Accounting Research,46(5),1241-1264.
63. Miller, G. S.,Skinner, D. J.(1998).Determinants of the Valuation Allowance for Deferred Tax Assets under SFAS No. 109.The Accounting Review,73(2),213-233.
64. Reichelt, K.,Wang, D.(2010).National and Office-specific Measures of Auditor Industry Expertise and Effects on Audit Quality.Journal of Accounting Research,48(3),647-686.
65. Reynolds, J. K.,Francis, J. R.(2001).Does Size Matter? The Influence of Large Clients on Office-level Auditor Reporting Decisions.Journal of Accounting and Economics,30(3),375-400.
66. Romanus, R. N.,Maher, J. J.,Fleming, D. M.(2008).Auditor Industry Specialization, Auditor Changes, and Accounting Restatements.Accounting Horizons,22(4),389-413.
67. Roychowdhury, S.(2006).Earnings Management through Real Activities Manipulation.Journal of Accounting and Economics,42(3),335-370.
68. Schatzberg, J. W.,Sevcik, G. R.,Shapiro, B. P.,Thorne, L.,Wallace, R. S. O.(2005).A Reexamination of Behavior in Experimental Audit Markets: The Effects of Moral Reasoning and Economic Incentives on Auditor Reporting and Fees.Contemporary Accounting Research,22(1),229-264.
69. Simunic, D. A.,Stein, M.(1996).The Impact of Litigation Risk on Audit Pricing: A Review of the Economics and the Evidence.Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory,15,119-134.
70. Solomon, I.,Shields, M.,Whittington, O. R.(1999).What Do Industry-specialist Auditors Know?.Journal of Accounting Research,37(1),191-208.
71. Su, L. and Wu, D., “Is Audit Behavior Contagious? Teamwork Experience and Audit Quality by Individual Auditors. Working paper,” 2019. Available at: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2816435
72. Sundgren, S.,Svanstrom, T.(2014).Auditor-in-charge Characteristics and Going Concern Reporting.Contemporary Accounting Research,31(2),531-550.
73. Thibaut, J. W.,Kelley, H. H.(1959).The Social Psychology of Groups.New York:Wiley.
74. Velury, U.,Reisch, J. T.,O'Reilly, D. M.(2003).Institutional Ownership and the Selection of Industry Specialist Auditors.Review of Quantitative Finance and Accounting,21(1),35-48.
75. Weber, E. U.,Blais, A. R.,Betz, N. E.(2002).A Domain-specific Risk-attitude Scale: Measuring Risk Perceptions and Risk Behaviors.Journal of Behavioral Decision Making,15(4),263-290.
76. Wrong, D.(1979).Power: Its Forms, Bases and Uses.Oxford:Basil Blackwell.
77. Yukl, G.(1989).Managerial Leadership: A Review of Theory and Research.Journal of Management,15(2),251-289.
78. Zang, A. Y.(2012).Evidence on the Trade-Off between Real Activities Manipulation and Accrual-Based Earnings Management.The Accounting Review,87(2),675-703.
79. Zerni, M.(2011).Audit Partner Specialization and Audit Fees: Some Evidence from Sweden.Contemporary Accounting Research,29(1),312-340.
80. 張文瀞,吳幸螢(2005)。品牌聲譽、產業專業化與審計人員市場佔有率關連性：取消審計公費下限分析。會計評論，40，91-118。