元代《四書》學的繼承與開創－以元儒許謙爲例

Inheritance and New Development of the Study of the Four Books in Yuan Dynasty-Hsu Ch'ien as an Example

10.29726/TJCL.200907.0004

廖雲仙(Yu-Hsien Liao)

元代 ； 四書 ； 許謙 ； 讀四書叢說 ； The Yuan Dynasty ； Four Books ； Hsu Chien ； Collected Annotations on the Four Books

東海中文學報

21期（2009 / 07 / 01）

67 - 87

繁體中文

朱子集宋學之大成，著爲《四書章句集注》。朱子歿未久，蒙元入主中國，有識之士多絕意仕進，隱逸山林，著書以終。其所讀之書，多爲朱子之作；其所著之篇，亦多是研究朱子學說之心得。其中尤以《四書》類著述，最爲重要。論者多以元儒《四書》類著述僅在發明疏釋朱子《四書章句集注》而已。實則元儒治學崇尚務實，其訂補朱子《集注》，多有所據，非僅依人爲學，墨守舊說而已。元代《四書》類著作有其繼承之一面。也有其開創性之一端。今取元儒許謙爲例，蓋許謙爲金華學者，最得朱子之正傳，但細看其《讀四書叢說》一書，既有推尊朱子、發明朱子者；更有補充朱子、訂正朱子者。許謙如此治學成果，固然是他個人深造所得，尤其受他的老師王柏、金履祥的影響。本文將就元代《四書》類著述狀況、許謙生平與著述、許謙對朱子《四書章句集注》的因襲與開創等方面作多方探討，希能補正一般經學史輕忽元代的偏見，有助於元代《四書》學之深化。

Chu Hsi is the main scholar of Song Dynasty Confucian studies and his major writing is Collected Annotations on The Four Books. Soon after Chu Hsi died, the Mongolian Yuan ruled China. Most of the Han intellectuals were not willing to serve as officials. They lived in seclusion and spent their days writing books. They read Chu Hsi's writings and wrote most of their scholarly essays and books on Chu Hsi. The most important books these intellectuals wrote are the works on The Four Books. Many scholars thought the works on The Four Books of the Yuan Dynasty Confucian scholars only explained Chu His's Collected Annotations. In fact, the Yuan scholars were quite practical; they supplemented and revised Chu His's Collected Annotations based on supporting evidence without relying on other scholars' opinion or being limited to any hidebound explanation. The Yuan Dynasty works on The Four Books displayed both inheritance and new development. This article takes Yuan scholar Hsu Ch'ien as an example, because Hsu Ch'ien was a Jinhua scholar, a true successor to Chu Hsi. By examining Hsu Ch'ien's Du Sishu Congshuo carefully, we discover that he not only esteemed and exalted Chu His's theory, but also supplemented and revised it. Hsu Ch'ien's academic performance resulted not only from his in-depth studies, but also from his teachers’ influence, especially from Wang Bo and Jin Luxiang. I discuss from varied perspectives the Yuan Dynasty works on The Four Books, Hsu Ch'ien's life and his writings, and Hsu Ch'ien's inheritance and development of Chu His's Collected Annotations. I hope my research will make up for negligence of and prejudice against Yuan Dynasty researches in history of Confucian Classics Studies, and it will be helpful in enhancing the Yuan Dynasty Four Books studies.

1. 朱熹撰(1995)。新編諸子集成：四書章句集注。北京:中華書局。
2. 朱熹撰、郭齊點校、尹波點校(1996)。四部叢刊：朱熹集。四川:教育出版社。
3. 朱彝尊撰(1979)。四部備要：經義考。臺北:中華書局。
4. 何晏、集解、邢昺疏(1979)。論語注疏。台北:藝文印書館。
5. 吳師道撰、國立中央圖書館編印(1970)。元代珍本文集彙刊：吳正傳先生文集。臺北:國立中央圖書館。
6. 宋濂撰(1992)。元史。臺北:鼎文書局。
7. 汪克寬撰(1986)。四庫全書：環谷集。臺北:臺灣商務印書館。
8. 柳貫撰(1983)。四庫全書：待制集。臺北:臺灣商務印書館。
9. 紀昀纂(1989)。四庫全書總目。臺北:藝文印書館。
10. 胡炳文撰(1971)。通志堂經解·四書類：四書通。台北:漢京文化事業公司。
11. 倪燦撰、盧文弨補(1959)。二十五史補編：補遼金元藝文志。臺北:開明書店。
12. 倫明撰、江翰撰、中國科學院圖書館整理(1993)。續修四庫全書提要。北京:中華書店。
13. 許謙撰(1986)。四庫全書：白雲集。臺北:臺灣商務印書館。
14. 許謙撰(1966)。四部叢刊續編‧經部：讀四書叢說。臺北:臺灣商務印書館。
15. 陳澧撰(1981)。四部備要：東塾讀書記。臺北:中華書局。
16. 陳鐵凡撰(1984)。論孟研究論集。臺北:黎明文化事業公司。
17. 傅武光撰、楊家駱指導(1973)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。臺灣師範大學國文研究所。
18. 程樹德撰、程俊英點校、蔣見元點校(1996)。論語集釋。北京:中華書局。
19. 黃宗羲撰、全祖望續修、王梓材校補(1975)。宋元學案。臺北:河洛圖書出版社。
20. 黃溍撰(1986)。四庫全書：文獻集。臺北:臺灣商務印書館。
21. 廖雲仙撰(2008)。「朱注猶經」－元代《四書》類著作疏釋風尚。「第二屆全國經學研討會」會議論文，高雄:
22. 廖雲仙撰(2005)。元代論語學考述。臺北:新文豐出版股份有限公司。
23. 劉寶楠撰、劉恭勉述(1998)。論語正義。北京:中華書局。
24. 黎靖德編、楊繩其校點、周嫻君校點(1997)。四庫全書：朱子語類。湖南:岳麓書社。
25. 錢穆撰(1991)。孔子與論語。臺北:聯經出版事業公司。