题名

"Strange Stories ": Collecting, Translating, and Imagining Mermaids in Early Nineteenth-Century Scotland

并列篇名

奇怪的故事:十九世紀早期蘇格蘭對美人魚的蒐集、翻譯與想像

DOI

10.30095/SYJH.201101.0002

作者

Sarah M. Dunnigan

关键词

美人魚 ; 哥德式 ; 民謠 ; 民俗復興 ; 古物研究 ; 設德蘭 ; 「海怪」 ; 中世紀主義 ; 奧德蘭 ; Mermaids ; Gothi ; ballad ; folk revival ; antiquarianism ; Shetland ; 'selkie' ; medievalism ; Orkney

期刊名称

中山人文學報

卷期/出版年月

30期(2011 / 01 / 01)

页次

23 - 50

内容语文

英文

中文摘要

在十九世紀早期蘇格蘭書寫中,美人魚角色所不斷形變與幻化不定的形象,經常成為眾作家的文學素材。歸結起來,美人魚主題主要是以三種方法表現在科學性、神話性、民俗性、美學性等不同性質的作品裡。首先,美人魚都被「收集」在擬科學的旅行文學裡,用以圖示蘇格蘭北方未知水域的地理和文化;其次,在古文物研究與收藏者當中,她們經常被「翻譯」而出現在蘇格蘭民間故事、民謠、傳奇故事,以尋求蘇格蘭之歌謠傳說,與其他日耳曼族及斯堪地那維亞等文化之同質性;其三,在蘇格蘭作家詩歌小說中,她們則被作者「創造」為一個受歡迎的、具有強烈藝術性的女性神話人物。本文主張,在蘇格蘭和歐洲其他地區,「美人魚崇拜」部分是受到「文化國族主義」的啟發,由於被加添在美人魚身上的傳說與傳奇,具有獨特的民俗及地域性,使得它成為民間故事與民謠採集者的重要題材。如John Leyden 在《詩意的殘留》中所稱的「北方傳說中的美人魚」,具有考古與復興民俗文化運動的普世價值。本文探究有關人魚,以及如奧克尼、設德蘭等封閉民族所特有富含神祕性與民俗性的蘇格蘭美人魚,是如何回應傳統中古世紀與浪漫文學裡有關美人魚與普通人的情色邂逅、以及描繪美人魚/封閉少女被移情而突顯出的脆弱形象。欲探討「北方美人魚」的新文化親屬關係,認識浪漫主義晚期及十九世紀早期民俗復興運動所抱持跨文化或國際主義態度是很重要的。本文討論了不同文本與作者的關聯性,女性本質相關之議題,以及使美人魚形象具體化的特定流行與神話概念。本文為美人魚一再作為一種創造力本質提供有趣的例證。

英文摘要

This essay pursues the different ways in which the mermaid is represented in early nineteenth-century Scottish writing, exploring how and why, as an intrinsically metamorphic and protean figure, she becomes a source of literary and cultural fascination for a variety of writers. It suggests that there are three principal ways in which the subject of mermaids draws together different discourses (scientific, mythic, folkloric, and aesthetic). Firstly, mermaids are ”collected” in quasi-scientific, ”travel” writing which charts the unknown northern waters of Scotland, both geographically and culturally; secondly, they are ”translated” in the work of antiquaries and collectors which seeks to discover affinities between Scottish folklore, ballads, and legends and those of other cultures, principally Germanic and Scandinavian; and, thirdly, they are ”invented” in new poetic fictions by Scottish writers which demonstrate their power to embody a popular, and artistically compelling, feminine mythology. The essay argues that in Scotland, as in Europe, the Romantic ”cult of the mermaid” is partly inspired by what might be termed ”cultural nationalism”; because the lore and legend attached to the mermaid has particular folkloric and regional specificity, it becomes a significant strand of the material gathered by folk and ballad collectors. The ”mermaid of the northern legends,” to use John Leyden's phrase (Poetical Remains), becomes valuable to the allied antiquarian and folk revival movements. The essay examines how the distinctive Scottish association of the mermaid with a larger mythic and folkloric body of material relating to mer-people and seal-folk (in Orkney and Shetland) produces narratives which echo traditional medieval and Romantic literary accounts of erotic encounters between mermaid and mortal, and yet strikingly portray the mermaid/seal-maiden as a figure of empathic fragility. Accordingly, the essay argues how the ”northern mermaid” finds new cultural kinship, important to the cross-cultural, or internationalist dimension, of the late Romantic and early nineteenth-century folk movement. Collectively, the different texts and writers which the essay newly considers in relation to one another offer an interesting illustration of the ways in which the figure of the mermaid embodies certain popular, mythic ideas about the nature of the feminine, and licenses the telling of various stories which renews her significance as a figure of, and about, the nature of creativity itself.

主题分类 人文學 > 人文學綜合
人文學 > 歷史學
人文學 > 藝術
参考文献
  1. Leyden, John. Poetical Remains. London, 1819.
  2. Spence, John. Shetland Folk-lore. Lerwick: Johnson & Greig, 1899.
  3. Nicholson, John. Historical and Traditional Tales, in Prose and Verse, Connected with the South of Scotland. Kirkcudbright: J. Nicholson, 1843.
  4. Scott, Walter, ed. Minstrelsy of the Scottish Border. 3 vols. Edinburgh: James Ballantyne, 1803.
  5. Chambers, Robert. The Book of Days. A Miscellany of Popular Antiquities. 2 vols. London & Edinburgh: Chambers, 1864.
  6. Keightley, Thomas. The Fairy Mythology. London, 1828.
  7. Motherwell, William. Minstrelsy: Ancient and Modern. Glasgow: J. Wylie, 1827.
  8. Pontopiddan, Erich. The Natural History of Norway. London: A. Linde, 1755.
  9. Maillet, Benoît de. Telliamed: or, Discussion between an Indian Philosopher and a French Missionary […] Being a Translation from the French Original. London: T. Osbourne, 1750.
  10. Waldron, George. History and Description of the Isle of Man. Dublin: E. Rider and J. Torbuck, 1742.
  11. Child, Francis James, ed. The English and Scottish Popular Ballads. 5 vols. Boston; New York: Houghton, Mifflin, 1883-98.
  12. Napier, James. “Old Ballad Folk-Lore.” The Folk-Lore Record 2 (1879): 92-126.
  13. (2004).Oxford Dictionary of National Biography.Oxford:Oxford UP.
  14. Finlay, John. Scottish Historical and Romantic Ballads. 2 vols. Edinburgh: J. Ballantyne, 1808.
  15. Jamieson, Robert. Popular Ballads and Songs, from Tradition, Manuscripts, and Scarce Editions. 2 vols. Edinburgh: Constable, 1806.
  16. Hibbert, Samuel. A Description of the Shetland Islands Comprising an Account of Their Geology, Scenery, Antiquities, and Superstitions. Edinburgh: Archibald Constable, 1822.
  17. Cromek, R.H., and Allan Cunningham. Remains of Nithsdale and Galloway Song. London, 1810.
  18. Bannerman, Anne. Poems. Edinburgh: Mundell & Son, 1800
  19. Wallace, James. Description of the Isles of Orkney by Master James Wallace, Late Minister of Kirkwall, Published after His Death by His Son. Edinburgh: John Reid, 1693.
  20. Saxby, Jessie Saxby. Shetland Traditional Lore. Edinburgh, 1932.
  21. Hibbert-Ware, Mary Clementine. Life and Correspondence of the Late Samuel Hibbert Ware. Manchester, 1882.
  22. Leyden, John. Journal of a Tour in the Highlands and Western Islands of Scotland in 1800. Ed. James Sinton. Edinburgh: Blackwood, 1903.
  23. Weber, H.W., R. Jamieson, and W. Scott, eds. Illustrations of Northern Antiquities, from the Earlier Teutonic and Scandinavian Romances; Being an Abstract of the Book of Heroes, and Nibelungen Lay; with Translations of Metrical Tales, from the Old German, Danish, Swedish and Icelandic languages; with Notes and Dissertations. Edinburgh: J. Ballantyne, 1814.
  24. Auerbach, Nina(1982).Woman and the Demon:the Life of a Victorian Myth.Cambridge, Mass:Harvard UP.
  25. Baigent, Elizabeth(rev.)(2004).Oxford Dictionary of National Biography.Oxford UP.
  26. Bell, A. S.(1981).The Scottish Antiquarian Tradition: Essays to Mark the Bicentenary of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland and its Museum 1780-1980.Edinburgh:Donald.
  27. Benwell, Gwen,Waugh, Arthur(1961).Sea Enchantress. The Tale of the Mermaid and Her Kin.London:Hutchinson.
  28. Black, G. F.,Thomas, Northcote W.(1994).County Folklore.Felinfach:Llanerch Publishers.
  29. Black, Ronald(ed.)(2007).To the Hebrides: Samuel Johnson's Journey to the Western Isles and James Boswell's Journal of a Tour.Edinburgh:Birlinn.
  30. Briggs, Katharine(1976).A Dictionary of Fairies.London:Penguin.
  31. Briggs, Katharine(1972).Folklore in 19th-Century English Literature.Folklore,83(3),194-209.
  32. Brown, Ian(ed.)(2007).The Edinburgh History of Scottish Literature.Edinburgh:Edinburgh UP.
  33. Brown, Mary Ellen(2001).William Motherwell"s Cultural Politics.Lexington, Ky:UP of Kentucky.
  34. Bruford, A. J.(ed.),MacDonald, D. A.(ed.)(2003).Scottish Traditional Tales.Edinburgh:Birlinn.
  35. Campbell, John Francis(1994).Popular Tales of the West Highlands.Edinburgh:Birlinn.
  36. Carruthers, Gerard(Ed.),Goldie, David(Ed.),Renfrew, Alastair(Ed.)(2011).Scotland and the Nineteenth Century World.Amsterdam:Rodopi.
  37. Clier-Colombani, Françoise(1991).La Fée Mélusine au Moyen Age. Images, Mythes et Symboles. Préface de Jaques Le Goff.Paris:Le Leopard d'Or.
  38. Connell, Philip(ed.),Leask, Nigel(ed.)(2009).Romanticism and Popular Culture in Britain and Ireland.Cambridge:Cambridge UP.
  39. Craciun, Adriana(2003).Fatal Women of Romanticism.Cambridge:Cambridge UP.
  40. Durie, Alastair J.(2003).Scotland for the Holidays: a History of Tourism in Scotland 1780-1939.East Linton:Tuckwell P.
  41. Evans, R. J. W.(ed.),Marr, Alexander(ed.)(2006).Curiosity and Wonder from the Renaissance to the Enlightenment.Aldershot:Ashgate.
  42. Fielding, Penny(2008).Scotland and the Fictions of Geography, North Britain, 1760-1830.Cambridge:Cambridge UP.
  43. Glendining, John(1997).High Road: Romantic Tourism, Scotland, and Literature 1720-1820.Basingstoke:Macmillan.
  44. Grenier, Katherine Haldane(2005).Tourism and Identity in Scotland: Creating Caledonia 1770-1914.Aldershot:Ashgate.
  45. Harf-Lancner, Laurence(1984).Les Fées au Moyen Âge: Morgane et Mélusine, la Naissance des Fees.Geneva:Slatkine.
  46. Kramer, Lawrence(1998).Franz Schubert: Sexuality, Subjectivity, Song.Cambridge:Cambridge UP.
  47. Luke, David(ed. trans.)(2005).Johann Wolfgang von Goethe. Selected Poetry.London:Penguin.
  48. Lyle, Emily(ed.)(1994).Scottish Ballads.Edinburgh:Canongate.
  49. Mack, Douglas(ed.)(1970).James Hogg: Selected Poems.Oxford:Clarendon P.
  50. Maddox, Donald(ed.),Sturm-Maddox, Sara(ed.)(1996).Melusine of Lusignan: Founding Fiction in Late Medieval France.U of Georgia P.
  51. Marwick, Ernest W.(1975).The Folklore of Orkney and Shetland.London:B.T. Batsford.
  52. Matthew, H. C. G.(ed.),Harrison, Brian(ed.)(2004).Oxford Dictionary of National Biography.Oxford:Oxford UP.
  53. Matthews, John(ed.)(1996).Myths of the Middle Ages.London:Blandford.
  54. Michaelis-Jena, Ruth(1975).Early Exchanges on Oral Traditions. Two unpublished Letters by Robert Jamieson and Wilhelm Grimm.Folklore,86(1),42-47.
  55. Miller, Hugh(1994).Scenes and Legends of the North of Scotland.Edinburgh:B & W P.
  56. Montgomerie, Norah,William(2008).Folk Tales of Scotland.Edinburgh:Birlinn.
  57. Myrone, Martin(ed.),Peltz, Lucy(ed.)(1999).Producing the Past: Aspects of Antiquarian Culture and Practice 1700-1850.Aldershot:Ashgate.
  58. Nicolson, James R.(1981).Shetland Folklore.London:Hale.
  59. Piggott, Stuart(1976).Ruins in a Landscape: Essays in Antiquarianism.Edinburgh:Edinburgh UP.
  60. Puhvel, Martin(1963).The Seal in the Folklore of Northern Europe.Folklore,74(1),326-33.
  61. Read, Dennis M.(1987).Cromek, Cunningham, and Remains of Nithsdale and Galloway Song: a case of literary duplicity.Studies in Bibliography,40,175-87.
  62. Thomson, Douglass H.(2008).Mingled Measures: Gothic Parody in Tales of Wonder and Tales of Terror.Romanticism and Victorianism on the Net,50
  63. Tully, Carol(ed.)(2000).Romantic Fairy Tales.London:Penguin.
  64. Waugh, Arthur(1960).The Folklore of the Merfolk.Folklore,71(2),73-84.
  65. Williams, David(1996).Deformed Discourse: the Function of the Monstrous in Medieval Thought and Literature.Exeter:U of Exeter P.
  66. Williamson, Duncan(1992).Tales of the Seal People.Edinburgh:Canongate.
  67. Wood, E. H. Harvey(1972).U of Edinburgh.
  68. Wood, Harriet Harvey(1971).Scott and Jamieson: the relationship between two ballad collectors.Studies in Scottish Literature,9,2-3+71-96.
  69. Wood, Harriet Harvey(2004).Dictionary of National Biography.Oxford:Oxford UP.
  70. Zug, Charles G.(1976).Sir Walter Scott, Robert Jamieson, and the New 'Minstrelsy.'.Music & Letters,57(4),398-403.