Female Self-Possession and Material Feminism in Elizabeth Stoddard's "A Study for a Heroine" (1885)

在伊麗莎白斯史塔特〈女主角的研究〉中的女性自主權和唯物女權主義（1885）

10.30095/SYJH.201207.0006

Michaela Keck

性別 ； 自主權 ； 唯物女權主義 ； 伊麗莎白斯史塔特 ； 十九世紀後期的美國女性書寫 ； Gender ； self-possession ； material feminism ； Elizabeth Stoddard ； late nineteenth-century American women's writing

中山人文學報

33期（2012 / 07 / 01）

133 - 149

英文

這篇有關自主權的論文，是從十九世紀後期美國婦女小說和非小說組成的話語論述來探討有關女權主義和婦女的（財產）權利。習於在兩性平等的爭戰中取得權利的女權主義者，通常會聲明：攸關女性財產權益的法律和習俗是由女性以外的其他人來決定的。無論到底是由哪種方式決定，女性為擁有自主權的奮鬥，往往涉及非傳統的行動和不尋常的物質生活條件。在這種情況下，伊麗莎白斯史塔特的短篇小說〈一個女主角研究〉（1855），便反映了薩拉‧布雷特終身追求自主權的奮鬥。這個故事不是由政治，也不是由精神動機來推動，它綜合了企業和資本主義的工作、個人和社會的樂趣、公共和私人的空間、家務和社交的生活。它的特色是女性自主權加上了「唯物女權主義」的思想，而家庭和公眾的界限模糊則體現在物質化的化妝、薩拉房子的空間安排、及其工作與婚姻。這是史塔特的後期作品中一個接近自我所有權的獨特方法；這篇小說展現了家務勞動被看成社會勞動的過程，這也是美國女權主義者有關轉型經濟、空間和唯物的議程。

The issue of self-possession is integral to the discourse of feminism and women's (property) rights in late nineteenth-century America both in women's fiction and non fiction. Oftentimes articulated by feminists as a right to be gained in the struggle for gender equality, others had already laid claim to it by equity law and custom. Either way, the struggle for female self-possession often involved unorthodox actions and unusual material living conditions. In this context, Elizabeth Stoddard's short story, ”A Study for a Heroine” (1855), reflects Sarah Brett's lifelong struggle for self-possession. Fuelled neither by political nor by spiritual motives, the story blends corporate and capitalist work, personal and social pleasures, public and private space, housework and communal life. This particular understanding of female self-possession is coupled with ”material feminism” in that the blurring of domestic and public boundaries manifests itself in the material make-up and spatial arrangements of Sarah's house, work, and marriage. A unique late approach to self-ownership in Stoddard's works, the short story thus represents domestic work as social labour, which corresponds to the material feminists' agenda of economic, spatial, and material transformation of American culture.

1. Stoddard, Elizabeth. Temple House. NY: G.W. Carleton, 1867
2. Albinski, Nan Bowman(1988).Utopia Reconsidered: Women Novelists and Nineteenth-Century Utopian Visions.Signs,13(4),830-41.
3. Basch, Norma(1979).Invisible Women: The Legal Fiction of Marital Unity in Nineteenth-Century America.Feminist Studies,5(2),346-66.
4. Boesenberg, Eva(2010).Money and Gender in the American Novel, 1850-2000.Heidelberg:Winter.
5. Brownlee, W. Elliot,Brownlee, Mary M.(1976).Women in the American Economy: A Documentary History, 1675-1929.New Haven:Yale UP.
6. Buell, Lawrence(ed.),Zagarell, Sandra A.(ed.)(1984).The Morgesons and Other Writings, Published and Unpublished by Elizabeth Stoddard.Philadelphia:U of Pennsylvania P.
7. Ç ellikol, Ayse(2006).The Morgesons, Aesthetic Predicaments, and the Competitive Logic of the Market Economy.American Literature,78(1),29-57.
8. Crumbley, Paul(2003).Haunting the House of Print: The Circulation of Disembodied Texts in 'Collected by a Valetudinarian' and 'Miss Grief.'.American Culture, Canons, and the Case of Elizabeth Stoddard,Tuscaloosa:
9. Dublin, Thomas(1991).Rural Putting-Out Work in Early Nineteenth-Century New England: Women and the Transition to Capitalism in the Countryside.The New England Quarterly,64(4),531-37.
10. Feldman Jessica R.(2003).A Talent for the Disagreeable:' Elizabeth Stoddard Writes The Morgesons.Nineteenth-Century Literature,58(2),202-29.
11. Geddes, Rick,Lueck, Dean(2002).The Gains from Self-Ownership and the Expansion of Women's Rights.The American Economic Review,92(4),1079-92.
12. Giovani, Regula(2003)."I Believe I Shall Die an Impenetrable Secret": The Writings of Elizabeth Barstow Stoddard.Bern:Peter Lang.
13. Guarneri, Carl J.(1991).The Utopian Alternative. Fourierism in Nineteenth-Century America.Ithaca:Cornell UP.
14. Hayden, Dolores(1981).The Grand Domestic Revolution: A History of Feminist Designs for American Homes, Neighborhoods, and Cities.Cambridge, MA:The MIT P.
15. Herbert, Walter T., Jr.(1991).The Erotics of Purity: The Marble Faun and the Construction of Sexuality.Representations,36,114-32.
16. Kerber, Linda K.(1988).Separate Spheres, Female Worlds, Woman's Place: The Rhetoric of Women's History.Journal of American History,75(1),9-39.
17. Matlack, James Hendrickson(1968).The Literary Career of Elizabeth Barstow Stoddard.Ann Arbor:UMI.
18. Matlack, James Hendrickson(1968).Yale U.
19. McClure Smith, Robert(ed.),Weinauer, Ellen(ed.)(2003).American Culture, Canons, and the Case of Elizabeth Stoddard,Tuscaloosa:
20. Morris, Lloyd(1951).Incredible New York. High Life and Low Life from 1850 to 1950.NY:Random.
21. Opfermann, Susanne(ed.),Roth, Yvonne(ed.)(2003).Stories. Elizabeth Stoddard.Boston:Northeastern UP.
22. Poulson, Barry W.(1981).Economic History of the United States.NY:Macmillan.
23. Putzi, Jennifer(2000).Tattooed still': The Inscription of Female Agency in Elizabeth Stoddard's The Morgesons.Legacy,17(2),165-73.
24. Ryan, Susanna(2003).Perversions of Volition.' Self-Starvation and Self-Possession in Dickinson and Stoddard.American Culture, Canons, and the Case of Elizabeth Stoddard,Tuscaloosa:
25. Smith-Rosenberg, Carroll(1985).Disorderly Conduct. Visions of Gender in Victorian America.NY:Oxford UP.
26. Spengler, Birgit(2009).Visual Negotiations and Medical Discourse in Nineteenth-Century American Women's Writing.Amerikastudien/American Studies,54(1),35-58.
27. Stockton, Elizabeth(2006).A Crusade against Duty': Property, Self-Possession, and the Law in the Novels of Elizabeth Stoddard.The New England Quarterly,79(3),413-38.
28. Stockton, Elizabeth,Buell(ed.),Zagarell(ed.)(1984).The Morgesons and Other Writings, Published and Unpublished by Elizabeth Stoddard.Philadelphia:U of Pennsylvania P.
29. Stockton, Elizabeth,Putzi, Jennifer(ed.)(2008).Two Men.Lincoln:U of Nebraska P.
30. Weinauer, Ellen,Smith, Robert McClure(2003).Introduction. Crossing Can(n)on Street.American Culture, Canons, and the Case of Elizabeth Stoddard,Tuscaloosa:
31. Zagarell, Sandra A.(2003).Biographical Foreword. Elizabeth Drew Barstow Stoddard (1823-1902).American Culture, Canons, and the Case of Elizabeth Stoddard,Tuscaloosa:
32. Zagarell, Sandra A.(1985).The Repossession of a Heritage: Elizabeth Stoddard's The Morgesons.Studies in American Fiction,13,45-56.