運動競賽成敗結果、歸因、以及情緒之關研究：驗證Weiner(1985)成就動機和情緒的歸因理論

Influence of Causal Attribution on Emotions: An Examination of Weiner's (1985) Attributional Theory of Achievement Motivation and Emotion

10.6222/pej.0035.200309.2412

劉從國(Tsung-Kuo Liu)；盧俊宏(Jing-Horng Lu)

競賽成敗結果 ； 歸因 ； 情緒 ； competition outcome ； Attribution ； emotion

體育學報

35期（2003 / 09 / 01）

127 - 141

繁體中文

本研究主要目的在以Weiner(1985)成就動機和情緒的歸因理論為研究模式，探討運動員賽後的情緒、成敗歸因、和歸因伴隨情緒的關係。研究對象為參加九十學年度大專運動會151位卓球代表隊下場比賽選手。其中男生88位，女生63位，平均年齡為21.39(SD= ±3.12)歲。本研究微得受試者同意後，填寫競賽結果第二代因果歸因量表(Causal Dimension Scale-II, McAuley, Duncan, & Russell, 1993)與情緒反應量表(Affection Reaction Scale, 彭文蓉，1995)。原始資料以獨立樣本t考驗、皮爾遜積差相關進行統計分析。研究結果如下：一、以結果伴隨情緒而言：運動員比賽成功者在滿意、非常棒、感激、快樂和自信心的情緒均高於失敗者，而失敗者在沒面子、罪惡感、可憐、生氣、沮喪和失望的情緒則高於成功者。二、以成敗後的歸因而言：運動比賽後成功者把成敗原因歸因於穩定性向度比失敗者為多；但因果根源、外在探制和個人探制向度方面則無差異。三、以歸因和情緒的關係而言：在成功的情境下，「因果根源」的歸因與非常棒、驕傲、自信心等情緒有正相關存在；「穩定性」的歸因與驕傲情緒有正相關存在；在失敗的情境下，只有「外在控制」的歸因與生氣情緒有正相關存在。本研究發現，運動成敗不但對運動員結果伴隨情緒有重大影響，對其歸因方向也有顯著影響，本研究結果支持過去(Weiner, 1985, 1986; McAulley, Russell & Gross, 1983; McAuley, 1985)等人之研究，且結論指出比賽結果，成敗歸因和情緒對為影響運動員動機的主要影響因素。本研究建議未來研究可以更深入探討成就動機情境下人格與情緒因素對運動成就動機之影響，以及歸因對情緒與行為的影響等等。

Based on Weiner's (l985) Attributional Theory of Achievement Motivation and Emotion, the purpose of this study was to examine athletes' emotional responses after success and failure, and the relation between attribution and emotion. One hundred and fifty-one intercollegiate table-tennis players (males = 88; females= 63) with a mean age of 21.39 years(SD= + 3.12) who participated in the 2002 Intercollegiate Athletic Meet in Taiwan were sampled for this study. After the first round of the table tennis competition, participants were asked to write down their competition outcome and complete Causal Dimension Scale- II , (McAuley, Duncan, & Russell, 1993). After completing these two tasks, participants were asked to complete an Affection Reaction Scale Peng, 1995) to rate their emotional responses to the success and failure. Independent t-tests found successful players were higher on satisfaction, terrific, great, appreciation, happy, and confidence than failure players, while failure players were higher on shame, guilt, poor, anger, depression, and hopelessness than successful players. In addition, successful players attributed their competition outcome more to stability than failure players, but there were no differences between the two groups in locus of causality, external control, and personal control dimensions. Moreover, this study found in the winning situation, the locus of causality positively correlated with terrific, pride, and confidence, while stability positively correlated with pride. Finally, in the losing situation, only external control positively correlated with anger. In general, this study supports most tenets of Weiner's (l985) Attributional Theory of Achievement Motivation and Emotion and McAuley, Russell & Gross' (l983) research. This study concluded that competition outcome and emotional responses play important roles in influencing achievement motivation. Future research could extend this study and explore which personality factors moderate competition outcome and emotional responses.

1. 邱秀霞、盧俊宏(2002)。運動員主客觀對成敗其歸因差異之研究 : 以九十學年度大專運動會桌球賽選手為例。大專體育學刊，4(2)
   連結：
2. Biddle, S. J. H.,Hill, A. B.(1988).Causal attributions and emotional reactions to outcome in a sporting contest.Personaliy and Individual Differences,9(2)
3. Biddle, S. J. H.,Hill, A. B.(1992).Attributions for objective and emotional reactions to outcome in a sporting contest.Britsh Journal of Social Psychology,31(3)
4. Bradley, G. W.(1978).Self-serving bias in the attribution process: Are-examination of the fact or fiction question.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,36
5. Heider, F.(1985).The psychology of interpersonal relations.
6. Horn, T. S.(1992).Advances in psychology.
7. Jones, E. E.,Davis, K. E.(1965).In L. Berkowitz(Ed.): Advances in experimental social psychology.
8. Kelly, H. H.(1973).The process of causal attribution.American Psychologist,28
9. Lu, J.(1998).Unpublished Daissebtarion, University of North Carolina.
10. Mark, M. M.,Mutrie, N.,Brooks, D. R.,Harris, D. V.(1984).Causal attribution of winners and losers in individual competitive sports: Toward a reformulation of the self-serving bias.Journal of Sport Psychology,6
11. McAuley, E.(1985).Success and causality in sport: The influence of perception.Journal of Sport Psychology,7
12. McAuley, E.,Duncan, T. E.(1989).Causal attribution and affective reactions to disconfirming outcomes in motor performance.Journal of Sport & Exercise Psychology,11
13. McAuley, E.,Duncan, T. E.(1990).Cognitive appraisal and affective reactions following physical achievement outcomes.Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology,12
14. McAuley, E.,Duncan, T. E.,Russell, D.W.(1993).Measuring causal attributions: The revised Causal Dimension Scale CDS-11 Behavior in middle-aged adults.Journal of Behavioral Medicine,15(1)
15. McAuley, E.,Russell, D.,Gross, J. B.(1983).Affective consequences of winning and losing: An attributional analysis.Journal of Sport Psychology,5(3)
16. McAulry, E.,Gross, J.B.(1983).Perception of causality in sport: An application of the Causal Dimension Scale.Journal of Sport Psychology,5
17. Peterson, C.(1980).Attribution in the sport pages: An archibal investigation of the covariation hypothesis.Social Psychology Quarterly,43
18. Robinson, D. W.,Howe, B. L.(1989).Appraisal variable/affect relationships in youth sport: a test of Weiner's attributional model.Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology,11(4)
19. Russell, D.(1982).The Causal Dimension Scale: A measuring causal attributions of how individuals perceive causes.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,42
20. Santamaria, V. L.,Furst, D. M.(1994).Distance runner's causal attributions for most successful and least successful races.Journal of sport behavior,17(1)
21. Tenenbaum, G.,Furst, D. M.(1986).Consistency of attributional responses by individuals and groups differing in gender, perceived ability and expectations for success.British Journalof Social Psychology,25
22. Vallerand, R. J.(1987).Antecedents of self-related affects in sport: Preliminary evidence on the intuitive-reflective appraisal model.Journal of Sport Psychology,9
23. Vallerand, R. J.,Richer, F.(1988).On the use of the causal dimension scale in a field setting: A test with confirmatory factor analysis in success and failure situation.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,54
24. Vlachopoulos, S.,Biddle, S.,Fox, K.(1996).A social-cognitive investigation into the mechanisms of affect generation in children's physical activity.Journal of Sport & Exercise Psychology,18
25. Watkins, D.(1986).The Journal of Social Psychology.
26. Weary, G.(1979).Self-serving attribution bias: Perceptual or response distortions?.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,37
27. Weiner, B.(1986).An attributional theory of motivation and emotion.
28. Weiner, B.(1985).An attributional theory of achievement motivation and emotion.Psychological Review,92
29. Weiner, B.(1972).Theories of motivation: From mechanism to cognition.
30. Weiner, B.(1979).A theory of motivation for some classroom experience.Journal of Educational Psychology,71
31. Weiner, B.(1974).Achievement motivation and attribution theory.
32. Weiner, B., Russell, D., & Lerman, D.(1979).The cignition-emotion process in achievement-related contexts.Journal of Personality Social Psychology,37
33. Zuckerman, M.(1979).Attribution of success and failure revisited; or The motivational bias is alive well in attribution theory.Journal of Personality,47
34. 彭文蓉(1995)。國立體育學院運動科學研究所碩士論文。

1. 蔡鵑如、潘義祥、劉季諺、許吉越、王明月(2011)。大專學生運動精進信念與運動涉入傾向之關連性。台東大學體育學報，14，15-27。
2. 陳偉瑀(2009)。不同結果獲悉下之競爭與非競爭羽球發短球競賽表現和成敗歸因。運動教練科學，13，63-80。
3. 黃崇儒、陳怡婷、洪聰敏(2011)。優秀桌球選手最佳運動表現的心理狀態。大專體育學刊，13(1)，44-54。
4. 王明月(2016)。桌球選手比賽臨場感與勝負結果之關係。大專體育學刊，18(3)，221-233。