心跳率控制跑步速度與固定速度訓練的比較研究

The Aerobic Training Effect of Heart Rate Control Training and Constant Speed Training by RSV(subscript HRC)

10.6222/pej.4102.200806.0701

王順正(Soun-Cheng Wang)；程文欣(Wen-Hsing Cheng)；王予仕(Yu-Shih Wang)；黃彥鈞(Yan-Jiun Huang)；江泰儒(Tai-Ju Chiang)

心跳率控制跑速變異 ； 心肺適能 ； 心跳率控制 ； running speed variance by heart rate control ； cardiopulmonary fitness ； heart rate control

體育學報

41卷2期（2008 / 06 / 01）

1 - 13

繁體中文

目的：本研究採用心跳率控制(heart rate control, HRC)跑步速度與心跳率控制跑速變異(running speed variance by heart rate control, RSV(下標HRC))的固定速度，進行跑步機的八週耐力訓練，以便瞭解HRC與RSV(下標HRC)固定速度在耐力訓練效果的差異情形。方法：以自願參與實驗的大學學生33名（年齡19.8±1.8歲，身高173.08±6.64公分，體重68.88±9.14公斤）爲對象，依據平衡次序的方式，分別接受一次漸增強度的最大努力測驗與80%最大心跳率(HRmax)的RSV(下標HRC)測驗。漸增強度的最大努力測驗在獲得受試者的最大攝氧量(VO2max)、換氣閾值(VT)、與最大攝氧量速度(the velocity of VO2max, v VO2max)。接著受試者依能力分爲HRC訓練組11人、RSV(下標HRC)固定速度訓練組11人、控制組11人，進行八週、每週三次、每次30分鐘的跑步機有氧訓練；HRC訓練組以RSV(下標HRC)測得的速度爲起始速度，以80%HRmax爲跑步訓練時的目標心跳率（心跳率維持在80%HRmax與80%HRmax-5之間）；RSV(下標HRC)固定速度訓練組以RSV(下標HRC)的速度爲訓練速度；控制組則不進行訓練。八週訓練結束後，再進行一次漸增強度的最大努力測驗與RSV(下標HRC)測驗。結果：八週HRC訓練可以分別增加RSV(下標HRC) 20.58%、VO2max 10.12%、VT 11.56%、v VO2max 12.55%，RSV(下標HRC)固定速度訓練則爲21.43%、9.77%、9.57%、2.91%，控制組則僅4.59%、-0.01%、-0.01%、-3.35%；兩種訓練方法在RSV(下標HRC)、VO2max與VT 皆有顯著訓練效果，而且HRC訓練還具有顯著增進v VO2max的效果。結論：80%HRmax的HRC訓練是相當有效的耐力訓練方法，再加上安全與考量個別差異的訓練特性，相當值得進一步推廣採用。

Running speed variance by heart rate control (RSV(subscript HRC)) is a novel method to evaluate the cardiopulmonary fitness. Purpose: The study used two different methods of aerobic training on RSV(subscript HRC) and heart rate control (HRC) for eight weeks to compare the training effects of on cardiopulmonary fitness. Methods: Thirty-three college students (aged 19.8+1.8 years old, height 173.08+6.64 cm, weight 68.88+9.14 kg) were recruited into this study. By counter-balanced design, we tested them with a maximal oxygen uptake (VO2max) to obtain individual ventilatory threshold (VT), and the velocity of maximal oxygen intake (vVO2max). RSV(subscript HRC) of 80% maximal heart rate (80% HRmax) and HRmax were also obtained from each subject. We separated the subjects into three groups: HRC training (n=11), fixed speed running training (n=11), and control group (n=11) to carry on 8 weeks of aerobic training by treadmill for 30 minutes each time and 3 times a week. The training intensity of HRC group was set at 80% HRmax (80% max to 80% max-5bpm) and the training speed of fixed speed training group was set by individual RSV(subscript HRC). The control group did not do any training during this period. After eight weeks of training, all subjects were tested again with a maximal test and a RSV(subscript HRC). Results: RSVHRC, VO2max, VT, and v VO2max were improved by 21.43%, 9.77%, 9.57%, and 2.91% in RCV(subscript HRC), by 20.58%, 10.12%, 11.56%, and 12.55% in HRC group, and by 4.59%, -0.01%, -0.01%, and -3.3% in control group. There were significant training effects on both training groups as far as RSV(subscript HRC), VO2max, and VT is concerned. In addition, vVO2max improvement was also seen in HRC group. Conclusion: HRC training on 80%HRmax is an effective and safe method for aerobic training.

1. 王順正、吳顥照、王錠堯、林正常(2005)。單次間歇臨界速度測驗的效度研究。體育學報，38(2)，1-12。
   連結：
2. 鄭景峰、林煉傑、黃憲鐘(2002)。八週有氧或肌力訓練對身體組成的影響。大專體育學刊，4(2)，187-195。
   連結：
3. Aunola, S.,Rusko, H.(1992).Does anaerobic threshold correlate with maximal lactate steady-state?.Journal of Sports Science,10(4),309-323.
4. Billat, V. L.,Flechet, B.,Petit, B.,Muriaux, G.,Koralsztein, J. P.(1999).Interval training at VO2max: Effects on aerobic performance and overtraining markers.Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise,31(1),156-163.
5. Billat, V.,Lopes, P.,P. J. Maud,C. Foster (Eds.)(2006).Physiological assessment of human fitness.Champaign, IL:Human Kinetics.
6. Fox, E. L.,Bartels, R. L.,Billings, C. E.,O`Brien, R.,Bason, R.,Mathews, D. K.(1975).Frequency and duration of interval training programs and changes in aerobic power.Journal of Applied Physiology,38(3),481-484.
7. Jones, A. M.,Carter, H.,Doust, J. H.(1999).Effect of six weeks of endurance training on parameters of aerobic fitness.Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise,31(5),280.
8. Matsumoto, T.,Ito, K.,Moritani, T.(1991).The relationship between anaerobic threshold and electromyographic fatigue threshold in college women.European Journal of Applied Physiology,63,1-5.
9. McConnell, T. R.(1988).Practical consideration in the testing of □O2max in runner.Sports Medicine,5(1),57-68.
10. Miller, J. M.,Housh, T. J.,Coburn, J. W.,Cramer, J. T.,Johnson, G. O.(2003).A proposed test for determining physical working capacity at the oxygen comsumption threshold.Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise,35(5),275.
11. Moritani, T.,Nagata, A.,deVries, H. A.,Muro, M.(1981).Critical power as measure of physical work capacity and anaerobic threshold.Ergomomics,24(5),339-350.
12. Perry, S. R.,Housh, T. J.,Johnson, G. O.,Ebersole, K. T.,Bull, A. J.(2001).Heart rate and ratings of perceived exertion at the physical working capacity at the heart rate threshold.Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research,15(2),225-229.
13. Wagner, L. L.,Housh, T. J.(1993).A proposed test for determining physical working capacity at the heart rate threshold.Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,64(3),361-364.
14. Weir, L. L.,Weir, J. P.,Housh, T. J.,Johnson, G. O.(1997).Effect of an aerobic training rogram on physical working capacity at heart rate threshold.European Journal of Applied Physiology,75(4),351-356.
15. Young, C. C.,Morris, G. A.,Dempsey, R. L.,Virulhsri, P.,Ribar, M. A.,Gammons, M. R.(2004).The reproducibility of computerized heart rate monitoring as control for running studies.Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise,36(5),26.
16. 運動生理週訊
17. 王順正、林必寧、王予仕、余奕德、黃彥鈞、陳信良、程文欣、吳忠芳(2005)。跑步機固定心跳率跑速變異的效度與信度研究。第四屆華人運動生理與體適能學者學會學術研討會論文集，臺灣:
18. 王順正、林正常(1998)。呼吸循環穩定閾值的比較研究。我國大專運動科學86學年度研究獎助專刊，81-91。
19. 王鶴森(1992)。臺北市，國立臺灣師範大學。
20. 運動生理週訊
21. 林必寧(2006)。嘉義縣，國立中正大學。
22. 運動生理週訊
23. 胡文瑜、謝旻宏、王予仕、黃彥鈞、王順正(2006)。2006體育運動學術團體聯合年會體育學術論文發表會。臺北市:
24. 楊群正(2005)。嘉義縣，國立中正大學。

1. 郭堉圻、邱琴瑟(2011)。呼吸肌阻力訓練對游泳攝氧量與肺功能表現之影響。運動教練科學，24，69-80。
2. 鍾琁如,佘永吉(2021)。個別化跑步機運動訓練課程對大學視覺障礙學生健康體適能之介入成效。特殊教育季刊，159，13-28。