邁向批判運動社會學／身體文化研究

Toward a Critical Sociology of Sport / Physical Cultural Studies

10.6222/pej.4504.201212.0808

陳子軒(Tzu-Hsuan Chen)

運動社會學 ； 身體文化研究 ； 集體記憶 ； 社會空間 ； 質性研究方法 ； sociology of sport ； physical cultural studies ； collective memory ； social space ； qualitative research method

體育學報

45卷4期（2012 / 12 / 01）

267 - 278

繁體中文

本文撰寫目的，在於統整並回應當前歐美關於運動社會學與身體文化研究間的論戰，身體文化研究學者對於運動社會學的範圍與研究方法有所反思，並擴展相關研究領域；然而，本文疾呼兩者間實乃殊途同歸，並無本質上絕對的斷裂，並將相關論戰置於臺灣的學術脈絡下，呼籲兩者應該求同存異，反思運動社會學／身體文化研究中的時間與空間向度，以社會記憶與社會空間為取徑，在傳統史學與地理學之外另闢蹊徑，同時關注大眾傳播與媒體對於運動／身體文化的影響，更有利於我們邁向一個屬於臺灣觀點的批判性運動社會學／身體文化研究。

This essay aims to summarize and respond to the arguments between Sociology of Sport and Physical Cultural Studies in European and American academic societies. Physical Cultural Studies scholars critique the limitation and methodology of traditional Sociology of Sport and argue for broader research terrains. However, this essay counters that these two schools are virtually and essential alike despite appearing otherwise. In the context of Taiwanese academic environment, the two schools should co-exist and search for common goals by adding spatial and temporal dimensions into their research. By approaching sport and physical culture with sociology of memory and study of social space, and examining the influence of mass communication and media on sport/physical culture, we will be better equipped to march toward a critical Sociology of Sport/Physical Cultural Studies of our native, Taiwanese perspective.

1. 陳子軒(2008)。公共電視運動轉播與國族認同建構─以公視王建民經驗與CBC的【hockey night in canada】為例。新聞學研究，96，213-259。
   連結：
2. 湯志傑(2009)。體育與運動之間─從迥異於西方「國家／市民社會」二分傳統的發展軌跡談運動在臺灣的現況。思與言，47(1)，1-126。
   連結：
3. 劉昌德(2008)。帝國搖旗，國族吶喊：棒球勞動國際分工與運動國族論述之轉變。臺灣社會研究，70，33-77。
   連結：
4. Andrews, D. L.(2008).Kinesiology's inconvenient truth and the physical cultural studies imperative.Quest,60,45-62.
5. Ang, I.(1985).Watching dallas: Soap opera and the melodramatic imagination.New York:Methuen.
6. Atkinson, M.(2011).Physical cultural studies [redux].Sociology of Sport Journal,28(1),135-144.
7. Bairner, A.(2009).Sport, intellectuals and public sociology: Obstacles and opportunities.International Review for the Sociology of Sport,44(2-3),115-130.
8. Bairner, A.(2012).For a sociology of sport.Sociology of Sport Journal,29(1),102-117.
9. Bale, J.(2003).Sports geography.London:Routledge.
10. Bale, J.(1994).Landscapes of modern sport.Leicester:Leicester University Press.
11. Bale, J.(1982).Sport and place: A geography of sport in england, scotland and wales.Lincoln:University of Nebraska Press.
12. Bale, J.(2001).Sport, space, and the city.Caldwell, NJ:The Blackburn Press.
13. Barthes, R.(1972).Mythologies.New York:Hill and Wang.
14. Benjamin, W.(2002).The arcades project.Cambridge, Mass:Harvard University Press.
15. Cho, Younghan(2008).Broadcasting major league baseball as a governmental intrument in south korea.Journal of Sport and Social,32(3),240-254.
16. Denzin, N. K.(Ed.),Lincoln, Y. S.(Ed.)(1994).Handbook of qualitative research.Thousand Oaks:Sage.
17. Freire, P.(1970).Pedagogy of the oppressed.New York:Herder and Herder.
18. Friedman, M. T.,van Ingen, C.(2011).Bodies in space: Spatializing physical cultural studies.Sociology of Sport Journal,28(1),85-105.
19. Giardina, M. D.,Newman, J.(2011).What is this "physical" in physical cultural studies?.Sociology of Sport Journal,28(1),36-63.
20. Giddens, A.(1990).The consequences of modernity.Stanford, Calif.:Stanford University Press.
21. Gramsci, A.(1971).Selections from the prison notebook.London:Lawrence and Wishart.
22. Grossberg, L.(1997).Cultural studies: What's in a name? (one more time).Bringing it all back home: Essays on cultural studies,Durham:
23. Harris, J.(2006).Sociology of sport: Expanding horizons in the subdiscipline.Quest,58,71-91.
24. Herzfeld, M.(2005).Cultural intimacy: Social poetics in the nation-state.New York:Routledge.
25. Jhally, S.(1989).Cultural studies and the sports/media complex.Media, sports, and society,Newbury Park:
26. Kirk, J.,Miller, M. L.(1988).Reliability and validity in qualitative research.Newbury Park:Sage.
27. Lefebvre, H.(1991).The production of space.Cambridge:Blackwell.
28. Lincoln, Y. S.,Guba, E. G.(1985).Naturalistic inquiry.Beverly Hills, Calif.:Sage Publications.
29. McCarthy, A.(2001).Ambient television: Visual culture and public space.Durham:Duke University Press.
30. Mears, A.(2008).Discipline of the catwalk: Gender, power, and uncertainty in fashion modeling.Ethnography,9(4),429-456.
31. Morley, D.(1980).The nationwide audience.London:British Film Institute.
32. Newman, J. I.(2010).Embodying dixies: Studies in the body pedagogies of southern whiteness.Melbourne, Australia:Common Good.
33. Newman, J. I.,Giardina, M. D.(2008).Nascar and the 'southernization' of america: Spectatorship, subjectivity, and the confederation of identity.Cultural Studies <,8(4),479-506.
34. Orwell, G.(1950).1984.New York:Signet Classic.
35. Rich, E.(2011).Exploring the relationship between pedagogy and physical cultural studies: The case of new health imperatives in schools.Sociology of Sport Journal,28(1),64-84.
36. Silk, M. L.,Andrews, D. L.(2011).Toward a physical cultural studies.Sociology of Sport Journal,28(1),4-35.
37. Smith, B.,Caddick, N.(2012).Qualitative methods in sport: A concise overview for guiding social scientific sport research.Asia Pacific Journal of Sport and Social Science,1(1),60-73.
38. Thorpe, H.,Barbour, K.,Bruce, T.(2011)."Wandering and wondering": Theory and representation in feminist physical cultural studies.Sociology of Sport Journal,28(1),106-134.
39. Tuan, Yi-fu.(1974).Topophilia: A study of environmental perception, attitudes, and values.Englewood Cliffs:Prentice-Hall.
40. Wenner, L. A.(1998).Mediasport.London:Routledge.
41. Wenner, L. A.(1989).Media, sports, and society.Newbury Park, Calif.:Sage Publications.
42. White, E.(2001).The flâneur: A stroll through the paradoxes of paris.London:Bloomsbury.
43. 吳姿萱譯、Morris, A.(2007)。從文化親密的觀點閱讀臺灣少棒。文化研究月報，68
44. 胡幼慧(1996)。質性研究─理論、方法及本土女性研究實例。臺北:巨流。
45. 高堂堯(2007)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。臺北市，世新大學。
46. 陳逸純譯、Bourdieu, P.(1987)。所述之言：布赫迪厄反思社會學文集。臺北:麥田。
47. 葉啟政(2003)。臺灣社會學的知識─權力遊戲。政治大學社會學報，35，1-34。
48. 葉啟政(2008)。邁向修養社會學。臺北:三民。

1. 陳子威,李建興,石明宗(2022)。東西相遇：瑜伽籃球訓練課程之實踐研究。大專體育學刊，24(3)，301-312。
2. 姜穎(2013)。臺灣國族與運動：一個後現代主義觀點的討論。體育學報，46(2)，167-182。
3. 蕭文滔(2021)。重建「聖地」─戰後臺北重點籃球賽事場館之空間生產歷程。運動文化研究，39，79-134。
4. (2017)。台灣女性旅人的媒體再現與性別意涵（1980-2000）。傳播與社會學刊，41，181-215。