部分錯誤參照有助於動作表現與學習

Partial Error Reference Benefits Motor Performance and Learning

10.6222/pej.4604.201312.1307

郭安婕(An-Chieh Kuo)；卓俊伶(Hank Jwo)

錯誤估計 ； 錯誤偵察能力 ； 動作修正 ； error estimation ； error detection capability ； movement correction

體育學報

46卷4期（2013 / 12 / 01）

383 - 392

繁體中文

目的：比較全部與部分距離的錯誤參照機制，對空間性動作表現與學習的影響。方法：二十四名年輕成人隨機分派至全部距離參照組或部分距離引導組，以單手進行空間性移動工作。實驗參與者於60次的獲得期試作結束後，分別在10分鐘與24小時後，進行各12次試作的立即與延遲保留測驗。全部距離參照組由實驗者提供全部目標距離為錯誤參照，而部分距離引導組則提供錯誤距離訊息為錯誤參照；參與者進行自我評估後，以口語告知錯誤距離。本研究的依變項為：絕對誤差、錯誤估計值、和修正誤差值，分別進行2（組間）×6（區間）混合設計二因子變異數分析，其中區間為重複量數，和獨立樣本t考驗統計分析。結果：部分距離引導組的絕對誤差、錯誤估計值、和修正誤差值在獲得期與立即和延遲保留測驗中皆顯著小於全部距離參照組。結論：部分距離引導對於空間性動作的表現和學習皆有助益。

Purpose: Comparing the effects of the whole and partial error distance references on spatial motor performance and learning. Methods: Twenty four participants were randomly assigned to either whole distance reference or partial distance reference groups, and were requested to practice a spatial task with one-hand. After 60 trials in acquisition phase, a 10-minute immediate retention test and a 24-hour delayed retention test were administered for 12 trials. Participants in whole distance reference group received reference for whole target distance to be a reference after completing the task, however, participants in partial distance reference group received the error distance information only. After receiving reference information, participants had to estimate the error of task before the actual error distance was provided to them. Absolute error (AE), error estimation (EE), and correction error were dependent variable in this study. A 2 (group) x 6 (block) mix-design ANOVA with repeated measure on block, and an independent t-test were used for immediate and delayed retention tests. Results: AE, EE, and correction error scores in partial distance reference group were found significantly less than that of whole distance reference group in both acquisition phase, and immediate and delayed retention test. Conclusions: Guidance with partial distance reference benefits spatial motor performance and learning.

1. 葉俊良、卓俊伶、林靜兒、陳重佑(2007)。自我控制回饋對動作表現、學習及錯誤估計的效應。大專體育學刊，9，23-35。
   連結：
2. Adams, J. A.(1971).A closed-loop theory of motor learning.Journal of Motor Behavior,3,111-149.
3. Adams, J. A.(1961).The second facet of forgetting: A review of warm-up decrement.Psychological Bulletin,58,257-273.
4. Carter, C. S.,Braver, T. S.,Barch, D. M.,Botvinick, M. M.,Noll, D.,Cohen, J. D.(1998).Anterior cingulate cortex, error detection, and the online monitoring of performance.Science,280,747-749.
5. Cohen, J.(1988).Statistical power analysis for the behavioral science (2nd ed.).Hillsdale, NJ:Erlbaum.
6. Coull, J.,Tremblay, L.,Elliott, D.(2001).Examining the specificity of practice hypothesis: Is learning modality specific?.Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,72,345-354.
7. Darling, W. G.,Cooke, J. D.(1987).Changes in the variability of movement trajectories with practice.Journal of Motor Behavior,19,291-309.
8. Evarts, E. V.(1973).Motor cortex reflexes associated with learned movement.Science,179,501-503.
9. Fleishman, E. A.,Hempel, W. E., Jr.(1995).The relation between abilities and improvement with practice in a visual discrimination reaction task.Journal of Experimental Psychology,49,301-312.
10. Franks, I. M.,Wilberg, R. B.,Fishburne, G. J.(1982).Consistency and error in motor performance.Human Movement Science,1,109-123.
11. Gehring, W. J.,Goss, B.,Coles, M. G. H.,Meyer,D. E.,Donchin, E.(1993).A neural system for error detection and compensation.Psychological Science,93,385-390.
12. Green, S.,Sherwood, D. E.(2000).The benefits of random variable practice for accuracy and temporal error detection in a rapid aiming task.Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,71,398-402.
13. Halsband, U.,Lange, R. K.(2006).Motor learning in man: A review of functional and clinical studies.Journal of Physiology,99,414-424.
14. Han, D. W.,Shea, C. H.(2008).Auditory model: Effects on learning under blocked and random practice schedules.Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,79,476-486.
15. Holding, D. H.(1970).Learning without errors.Psychology of motor learning,Chicago:
16. Holding, D. H.,Macrae, A. W.(1964).Guidance, restriction and knowledge of results.Ergonomics,7,289-295.
17. Magill, R. A.(2011).Motor learning and control: Concepts and applications (9th ed.).New York:McGraw-Hill.
18. Marchal-Crespo, L.,McHughen, S.,Cramer, S. C.,Reinkensmeyer, D. J.(2010).The effect of haptic guidance, aging, and initial skill level on motor learning of a steering task.Experimental Brain Research,201,209-220.
19. Miltner, W. H. R.,Braun, C. H.,Coles, M. G. H.(1997).Event-related brain potentials following incorrect feedback in a time-estimation task: Evidence for a"generic" neural system for error detection.Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience,9,788-798.
20. Mowbraya, G. H.,Rhoadesa, M. V.(1959).On the reduction of choice reaction times with practice.Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology,11,16-23.
21. Rodríguez-Fornells, A.,Kurzbuch, A. R.,Münte, T. F.(2002).Time course of error detection and correction in humans: Neurophysiological evidence.Journal of Neuroscience,22,9990-9996.
22. Schmidt, R. A.(1975).A schema theory of discrete motor skill learning.Psychological Review,82,225-260.
23. Schmidt, R. A.,Lee, T. D.(2011).Motor control and learning: A behavioral emphasis (5th ed.).Champaign, IL:Human Kinetics.
24. Schmidt, R. A.,White, J. L.(1972).Evidence for an error detection mechanism in motor skills: A test of Adams' closed-loop theory.Journal of Motor Behavior,4,143-153.
25. Sherwood, D. E.(2009).Spatial error detection in rapid unimanual and bimanual aiming movements.Perceptual and Motor Skills,108,3-14.
26. Sherwood, D. E.(2010).Detecting and correcting errors in rapid aiming movements: Effects of movement time, distance, and velocity.Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,81,300-309.
27. Sherwood, D. E.(1996).The benefits of random variable practice for spatial accuracy and error detection in a rapid aiming task.Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,67,35-43.
28. Singer, R. N.,Pease, D.(1976).A comparison of discovery learning and guided instructional strategies on motor skill learning, retention, and transfer.Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,47,788-796.
29. Sparrow, W. A.(1983).The efficiency of skilled performance.Journal of Motor Behavior,15,237-261.
30. Tsutsui, S.,Imanaka, K.(2003).Effect of manual guidance on acquiring a new bimanual coordination pattern.Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,74,104-109.
31. Willingham, D. B.(1998).A neuropsychological theory of motor skill learning.Psychological Review,105,558-584.
32. Zelaznik, N.(Ed.)(1996).Advances in motor learning and control.Champaign, IL:Human Kinetics.
33. 張智惠、卓俊伶(1998)。不同情境干擾對自我配速動作空間準確性及錯誤偵察能力學習的影響。體育學報，25，209-218。