單側性與雙側性過肩運動之肩關節活動度特徵：游泳與網球之比較

The Characteristics of Shoulder Range of Motion for Unilateral and Bilateral Overhead Sports: Swimming vs Tennis

10.6222/pej.4701.201403.1204

林謙如(Chien-Ju Lin)；張曉昀(Hsiao-Yun Chang)

柔軟度 ； 上肢 ； 肩部傷害 ； 水中運動 ； 持拍性運動 ； flexibility ； upper extremity ； shoulder injury ； aquatic sports ； racquet sports

體育學報

47卷1期（2014 / 03 / 01）

35 - 45

繁體中文

目的：肩關節的疼痛常發生於過肩運動之運動員，過肩運動包括單側或雙側的運動模式，如游泳、網球。本研究目的是比較單側性（網球）與雙側性（游泳）過肩運動項目選手的肩關節活動角度。方法：實驗參與者共18名（7名雙側性運動項目選手及11名單側性運動項目選手），測量其肩彎曲、過度伸展、肩內轉／外轉、及水平內收，使用關節量角器進行測量，以相依樣本t檢定比較選手慣用與非慣用側之差異，並以獨立樣本t檢定分析單側性與雙側性過肩運動項目選手之差異。結果：雙側性過肩項目（游泳）的慣用側與非慣用側肩關節活動度經比較後並無顯著差異，兩側的關節活動度較均衡，但是單側性過肩項目（網球）的慣用側與非慣用側肩關節活動度測量中，外轉角度及水平內收角度慣用側大於非慣用側、內轉角度慣用側小於非慣用側；比較單側性與雙側性之肩關節活動度差異發現，慣用側除肩關節彎曲角度之外，其餘角度均達顯著差異，其中過度伸展、外轉、水平內收呈現單側性大於雙側性項目，內轉及旋轉全角度呈現雙側性大於單側性項目。結論：本研究顯示因單側性運動項目的特殊性（如網球）而導致肩部活動度的適應。

Purpose: Shoulder pain often occurs in overhead athletes. Overhead sports included unilateral or bilateral arms used, such as tennis or swim. The purpose of this study was to measure and compare the difference of shoulder range of motion (ROM) between healthy unilateral and bilateral shoulder used players. Methods: Eighteen overhead athletes participated in this study (7 bilateral and 11 unilateral shoulder used players). The shoulder flexion, hyperextension, internal/external rotation, and horizontal adduction were measured by using goniometer for both arms. Independent t-test was used to analyze the difference between unilateral and bilateral shoulder used players and paired T-test was used to compare the difference between their dominant and non-dominant shoulder respectively. Results: No significant difference was found in dominant and non-dominant shoulder comparison for bilateral shoulder used players (p＞.05). However, we found the ROM of external rotation and horizontal adduction of dominant shoulder had larger degree than non-dominant side, the ROM of internal rotation of dominant shoulder was less than non-dominant shoulder. All ROM had showed significant difference, except shoulder flexion, when we compared the unilateral and bilateral shoulder used events players. Conclusions: We found the shoulder ROM adaptation in unilateral shoulder used players.

1. 王甯、劉有德(2007)。從動作協調探討提升游泳速度之要素。中華體育季刊，21，135-142。
   連結：
2. 雲春萍(2003)。從動力學的觀點探究影響蝶泳成績表現之因素。中華體育季刊，17，49-56。
   連結：
3. 劉佳哲(2013)。健康網球選手肩部肌力與關節活動度之關係。體育學報，46，131-141。
   連結：
4. 鄭世忠、張曉昀、陳百鍊、楊卿潔(2011)。棒球投手盂肱關節內旋活動度缺損：可能傷害機轉與預防之道。運動教練科學，24，1-12。
   連結：
5. Abrams, G. D.,Renstrom, P. A.,Safran, M. R.(2012).Epidemiology of musculoskeletal injury in the tennis player.British Journal of Sports Medicine,46,492-498.
6. Bak, K.(2010).The practical management of swimmer's painful shoulder: Etiology, diagnosis, and treatment.Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine,20,386-390.
7. Borsa, P. A.,Laudner, K. G.,Sauers, E. L.(2008).Mobility and stability adaptations in the shoulder of the overhead athlete: A theoretical and evidence-based perspective.Sports Medicine,38,17-36.
8. Decicco, P. V.,Fisher, M. M.(2005).The effects of proprioceptive neuromuscular facilitation stretching on shoulder range of motion in overhand athletes.Journal of Sports Medicine and Physical Fitness,4,183-187.
9. Dwelly, P. M.,Tripp, B. L.,Tripp, P. A.,Eberman, L. E.,Gorin, S.(2009).Glenohumeral rotational range of motion in collegiate overhead-throwing athletes during an athletic season.Journal of Athletic Training,44,611-616.
10. Ellenbecker, T. S.,Roetert, E. P.,Piorkowski, P. A.,Schulz, D. A.(1996).Glenohumeral joint internal and external rotation range of motion in elite junior tennis players.Journal of Orthopaedic and Sports Physical Therapy,26,2336-2341.
11. Fusco, A.,Foglia, A.,Musarra, F.,Testa, M.(2008).The shoulder in sport: Management, rehabilitation and prevention.New York:Churchill Livingstone.
12. Heinlein, S. A.,Cosgarea, A. J.(2010).Biomechanical considerations in the competitive swimmer's shoulder.Sports Health,2,519-525.
13. Ireland, A.,Maden-Wilkinson, T.,McPhee, J.,Cooke, K.,Narici, M.,Degens, H.,Rittweger, J.(2013).Upper limb muscle-bone asymmetries and bone adaptation in elite youth tennis players.Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise,45,1749-1758.
14. Jansson, A.,Saartok, T.,Werner, S.,Renstrom, P.(2005).Evaluation of general joint laxity, shoulder laxity and mobility in competitive swimmers during growth and in normal controls.Scandinavian Journal of Medicine and Science in Sports,15,169-176.
15. Kovacs, M.,Ellenbecker, T.(2011).An 8-stage model for evaluating the tennis serve: Implications for performance enhancement and injury prevention.Sports Health,3,504-513.
16. Laudner, K. G.,Sipes, R. C.,Wilson, J. T.(2008).The acute effects of sleeper stretches on shoulder range of motion.Journal of Athletic Training,43,359-363.
17. Lyman, S.,Fleisig, G. S.,Andrews, J. R.,Osinski, E. D.(2002).Effect of pitch type, pitch count, and pitching mechanics on risk of elbow and shoulder pain in youth baseball pitchers.American Journal of Sports Medicine,30,463-468.
18. Lyman, S.,Fleisig, G. S.,Waterbor, J. W.,Funkhouser, E. M.,Pulley, L.,Andrews, J. R.(2001).Longitudinal study of elbow and shoulder pain in youth baseball pitchers.Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise,33,1803-1810.
19. Marcondes, F. B.,Jesus, J. F.,Bryk, F. F.,Vasconcelos, R. A.,Fukuda, T. Y.(2013).Posterior shoulder tightness and rotator cuff strength assessments in painful shoulders of amateur tennis players.Brazilian Journal of Physical Therapy,17,185-194.
20. McMaster, W. C.,Roberts, A.,Stoddard, T.(1998).A correlation between shoulder laxity and interfering pain in competitive swimmers.American Journal of Sports Medicine,26,83-86.
21. Myers, J. B.,Laudner, K. G.,Pasquale, M. R.,Bradley, J. P.,Lephart, S. M.(2006).Glenohumeral range of motion deficit and posterior shoulder tightness in throwers with pathologic internal impingement.American Journal of Sports Medicine,34,385-391.
22. Riemann, B. L.,Witt, J.,Davies, G. J.(2011).Glenohumeral joint rotation range of motion in competitive swimmers.Journal of Sports Sciences,29,1191-1199.
23. Schmidt-Wiethoff, R.,Rapp, W.,Mauch, F.,Schneider, T.,Appell, H. J.(2004).Shoulder rotation characteristics in professional tennis players.International Journal of Sports Medicine,25,154-158.
24. Sein, M. L.,Walton, J.,Linklater, J.,Appleyard, R.,Kirkbride, B.,Kuah, D.,Murrell, G. A. C.(2010).Shoulder pain in elite swimmers: Primarily due to swim-volume-induced supraspinatus tendinopathy.British Journal of Sports Medicine,44,105-113.
25. Tate, A.,Turner, G. N.,Knab, S. E.,Jorgensen C.,Strittmatter, A.,Michener, L. A.(2012).Risk factors associated with shoulder pain and disability across the lifespan of competitive swimmers.Journal of Athletic Training,47,149-58.
26. Torres, R. R.,Gomes, J. L.(2009).Measurement of glenohumeral internal rotation in asymptomatic tennis players and swimmers.American Journal of Sports Medicine,37,1017-1023.
27. Tyler, T. F.,Nicholas, S. J.,Roy, T.,Gleim, G. W.(2000).Quantification of posterior capsule tightness and motion loss in patients with shoulder impingement.American Journal of Sports Medicine,28,668-673.
28. Vad, V. B.,Gebeh, A.,Dines, D.,Altechek, D.,Norris, B.(2003).Hip and shoulder internal rotation range of motion deficits in professional tennis players.Journal of Sports Science and Medicine,6,71-75.
29. Walker, H.,Gabbe, B.,Wajswelner, H.,Blanch, P.,Bennell, K.(2012).Shoulder pain in swimmers: A 12-month prospective cohort study of incidence and risk factors.Physical Therapy in Sport,13,243-249.
30. 吳昇光(2003)。肌肉骨骼評估：關節活動度與徒手肌力測量。臺北市:合記。
31. 張曉昀、陳佳琳、鍾宇政、林志峰、王淳厚(2007)。青棒選手運動傷害發生率之調查報告：一年期前瞻性研究。物理治療，32，193-199。
32. 黃鱗棋、卓俊伶(1998)。關節自由度對間斷動作表現的影響：個案研究。體育學報，25，229-237。

1. 黃子涵,周昆佑,吳婉鈴(2022)。青少年女性排球選手肩部及軀幹活動度特徵。華人運動生物力學期刊，19(2)，32-39。
2. 林謙如(2018)。一週短期衝浪訓練對大學游泳選手之效果。運動教練科學，50，11-21。
3. 林威秀、何致穎(2017)。大專甲組雙、單打羽球選手肩關節肌力與關節活動範圍之比較。華人運動生物力學期刊，14(1)，8-16。
4. 鄭世忠、張曉昀、張碧峰、吳婉鈴(2016)。比較有無肩內轉角度缺損投手之肩關節活動度及肩部穩定性的差異。體育學報，49(3)，303-316。