Efficacy of aerobic exercise program on anthropometric measurements and glucose metabolism in obese adolescents with impaired glucose tolerance: A randomized controlled trial

有氧運動計畫對肥胖症合併葡萄糖不耐症青少年身體組成及胰臟β 細胞功能之影響：隨機試驗

10.3966/102472972016094903002

李書芬(Shu-Fen Lee)；鄭綺(Jeng Chii)

中心式運動計畫 ； 居家式運動計畫 ； 中等強度運動 ； 糖尿病前期 ； 肥胖症 ； center-based exercise program ； home-based walking program ； moderate exercise pre diabetes ； obesity

體育學報

49卷3期（2016 / 09 / 01）

263 - 272

英文

緒論：儘管身體活動能改善身體組成並降低罹患代謝症候群的風險，然而，不同的有氧運動計劃對身體組成的影響是否相似及目前有氧運動對胰臟β 細胞功能的改善仍不明確。故本研究的目的是比較居家式與中心式有氧運動計畫在身體組成改變和胰臟β 細胞功能改善上是否具相同的影響。方法：招募肥胖症且合併葡萄糖不耐症之青少年共33位，採隨機分派為三組，每組11 位，分別進行8 週有氧運動介入，分別為中心式運動計畫 (CP)，每週三次，每次30 分鐘達中等強度的跑步機運動；居家式運動計畫 (HP)，每週三日，每日配戴計步器且達日累計萬步的走路運動；控制組，維持目前生活型態。受試者在介入前一週及8 週介入結束後一週內，分別接受身體組成測量和胰臟β 細胞功能評估。結果：兩組運動 (CP vs. HP) 組在體脂肪 (-1.58 vs. -1.80) (F = 9.95, p ＜ .001)、腰圍 (-3.78 vs. -4.88) (F = 12.24, p ＜ .001)、臀圍 (-1.55 vs. -2.25) 及腰臀比 (-0.02 vs. -0.03)(F = 4.28, p = .025) 變項上達顯著減少，胰臟β 細胞功能之胰島素敏感性 (BIGTT-SI) (0.60vs.0.63) (F = 6.89, p = .004) 和葡萄糖代謝率 (DI) (5.54 vs. 5.66) (F = 7.51, p ＜ .001) 顯著改善，且兩組運動組之改變量無差異。結論：本研究顯示，居家式與中心式有氧運動計畫在身體組成及胰臟β 細胞功能上具相似的影響。

Introduction: Although physical activity improves the body composition and minimizes risks of metabolic diseases, whether different exercise programs result in similar effects on anthropometric measurements and pancreatic β-cell function is not clear. The purpose of this study was to verify whether a home-based walking program has the same effects in anthropometric measurements and pancreatic β-cell function as a center-based aerobic exercise program. Methods: Obese adolescents with impaired glucose tolerance (n = 33) were recruited and randomly assigned to a center-based program (CP) group (exercise on a treadmill with moderate intensity for 30 min, 3 times per week for 8 weeks; n = 11), a home-based program (HP) group (walk with a pedometer to accumulate 10,000 steps per day for at least 3 days per week for 8 weeks; n = 11), or a control (CG) group (maintain one's normal daily activities; n = 11). Anthropometric parameters and pancreatic β-cell function were measured at the baseline and after 8 weeks of exercise programs. An analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) was conducted to test the overall effects. Results: Both exercise groups showed significant improvements in the fat mass (-1.58 vs. -1.80) (F = 9.95, p ＜ .001), waist circumference (-3.78 vs. -4.88) (F = 12.24, p ＜ .001), hip circumference (-1.55 vs. -2.25) (F = 17.90, p ＜ .001), and waist-hip ratio (-0.02 vs. -0.03) (F = 4.28, p = .025) compared to the control group. Pancreatic β-cell function in both exercise groups significantly improved, which was reflected by the insulin action by insulin sensitivity (BIGTT-SI) (0.60 vs.0.63) (F = 6.89, p = .004) and deposition index (DI) (5.54 vs. 5.66) (F = 7.51, p ＜ .001). Differences in all measurements between two groups were not observed. Conclusion: The findings suggested that a home-based walking program has similar effects as center-based aerobic exercise program on anthropometric measurements and pancreatic β-cell function.

1. Hsieh, S. S.,Li, T. L.,Fang, C. L.(2013).Effects of exercise on type 2 diabetes-induced cognitive dysfunction.Journal of Exercise Physiology and Fitness,17,17-27.
   連結：
2. Lu, H. C.,Chen, L. W.,Shen, C. H.,Kao, W. Y.,Cheng, I. S.,Lin, F. C.(2012).Effects of two kilogram weight loss on insulin sensitivity in non-obese adults.Journal of Exercise Physiology and Fitness,15,1-6.
   連結：
3. Centers for disease control and prevention. (2014). Borg Rating of Perceived Exertion Scale. Retrieved from http://www.cdc.gov/physicalactivity/everyone/measuring/exertion.html
4. Health promotion administration. (2014). Obesity prevention. Retrieved from http://www.hpa.gov.tw/English/ClassShow.a spx?No=201401270007
5. American Diabetes Association(2011).Clinical practice recommendation.Diabetes Care,34(1),1.
6. Armstrong, M. J.,Boulé, N. G.,Sigal, R. J.(2011).Exercise interventions and glycemic control in patients with diabetes.Journal of the American Medical Association,306(6),607-610.
7. Bartoli, E.,Fra, G. P.,Schianca, G. P. C.(2011).The oral glucose tolerance test (OGTT) revisited.European Journal of Internal Medicine,22(1),8-12.
8. Bi, Y.,Zhu, D.,Jing, Y.,Hu, Y.,Feng, W.,Shen, S.,Yang, D.(2010).Decreased beta cell function and insulin sensitivity contributed to increasing fasting glucose in Chinese.Acta Diabetologica,49(1),51-58.
9. Bouche, C.,Lopez, X.,Fleischman, A.,Cypess, A. M.,O'Shea, S.,Stefanovski, D.,Goldfine, A. B.(2010).Insulin enhances glucose-stimulated insulin secretion in healthy humans.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,107(10),4770-4775.
10. Bravata, D. M.,Smith-Spangler, C.,Sundaram, V.,Gienger, A. L.,Lin, N.,Lewis, R.,Sirard, J. R.(2007).Using pedometers to increase physical activity and improve health: A systematic review.Journal of the American Medical Association,298(19),2296-2304.
11. Canapari, C. A.,Hoppin, A. G.,Kinane, T. B.,Thomas, B. J.,Torriani, M.,Katz, E. S.(2011).Relationship between sleep apnea, fat distribution, and insulin resistance in obese children.Journal of Clinical Sleep Medicine,7(3),268-273.
12. Chan, J. C. N.,Malik, V.,Jia, W.,Kadowaki, T.,Yajnik, C. S.,Yoon, K. H.,Hu, F. B.(2009).Diabetes in Asia: Epidemiology, risk factors, and pathophysiology.Journal of the American Medical Association,301(20),2129-2140.
13. Choi, B. C. K.,Pak, A. W. P.,Choi, J. C. L.,Choi, E. C. L.(2007).Daily step goal of 10,000 steps: A literature review.Clinical and Investigative Medicine,30(3),146-151.
14. Diedrich, A.,Munroe, D. J.,Romano, M.(2010).Promoting physical activity for persons with diabetes.Diabetes Educator,36(1),132-140.
15. Ha, C. H.,Swearingin, B.,Jeon, Y. K.,Lee, M.(2015).Effects of combined exercise on HOMA-IR, HOMA β-cell and atherogenic index in Korean obese female.Sport Sciences for Health,11(1),49-55.
16. Hansen, T.,Drivsholm, T.,Urhammer, S. A.,Palacios, R. T.,Vølund, A.,Borch-Johnsen, K.,Pedersen, O.(2007).The BIGTT test: A novel test for simultaneous measurement of pancreatic β-cell function, insulin sensitivity, and glucose tolerance.Diabetes Care,30(2),257-262.
17. Kan, N. W.,Chi, C. P.(2011).The effeteness of exercise training on insulin resistance, and lipid association regulating hormone Mechanism.Quarterly of Chinese of physical education,25(2),213-225.
18. Khaodhiar, L.,Cummings, S.,Apovian, C. M.(2009).Treating diabetes and prediabetes by focusing on obesity management.Current Diabetes Reports,9(5),348-354.
19. Lee, C. H.(2010).Kaohsiung,Shu-Te University.
20. Leon, B.,Miller, B. V.,Zalos, G.,Courville, A.B.,Sumner, A. E.,Powell-Wiley, T. M.,Cannon, R. O.(2014).Weight loss programs may have beneficial or adverse effects on fat mass and insulin sensitivity in overweight and obese black women.Journal of Racial Ethnic Health Disparities,1(3),140-147.
21. McClean, C. M.,McNeilly, A. M.,Trinick, T. R.,Murphy, M. H.,Duly, E.,McLaughlin, J.,Davison, G. W.(2009).Acute exercise and impaired glucose tolerance in obese humans.Journal of Clinical Lipidology,3(4),262-268.
22. Pillay, J. D.,Kolbe-Alexander, T. L.,Proper, K.I.,Van Mechelen, W.,Lambert, E. V.(2014).Steps that count: Physical activity recommendations, brisk walking, and steps per minute-how do they relate?.Journal of Physical Activity and Health,11(3),502-508.
23. Slentz, C. A.,Tanner, C. J.,Bateman, L. A.,Durheim, M. T.,Huffman, K. M.,Houmard, J. A.,Kraus, W. E.(2009).Effects of exercise training intensity on pancreatic β-cell function.Diabetes Care,32(10),1807-1811.
24. Tsai, M. S.,Wu, Y. T.(2009).A preliminary study of children's physical activity in Taiwan.Formosan Journal of Medicine,13(1),23-32.
25. Tudor-Locke, C.,Bassett Jr, D. R.(2004).How many steps/day are enough? Preliminary pedometer indices for public health.Sports Medicine,34(1),1-8.
26. Zhu, S.,Ma, X.,Tang, J. L.(2011).What is the optimal body mass index for Chinese people?.Canadian Medical Association Journal,183(6),645-646.

1. 高麗娟、高曉蓉、王亭文、王文宜(2018)。臺灣肥胖學童體育課學習經驗之多重個案研究。體育學報，51(2)，237-252。
2. 邱逸翔,林子文,何宜芳(2019)。體育課融入認知與執行功能的概念：提升過重／肥胖兒童學習效果。大專體育，151，24-32。