體育課促進青少年正向發展之研究分析

The analysis of promoting positive youth development in physical education

10.3966/102472972017095003001

徐偉庭(Wei-Ting Hsu)

身體活動 ； 個人與社會責任模式 ； 課程與教學 ； physical activity ； teaching personal and social responsibility model ； curriculum and instruction

體育學報

50卷3期（2017 / 09 / 01）

239 - 256

繁體中文

近年來國內外探究體育課效益的研究多聚焦於學生的全人發展上，在此脈絡下，透過體育課促進青少年正向發展亦為運動教育學的熱門研究議題。基於此，本文先介紹青少年正向發展之內涵與研究場域，以及體育課與青少年正向發展的關係，而後再依序將現有研究分成「削弱」(減少負向行為)、「增強」(增加正向行為)、以及「遷移」(應用在非體育課情境) 等三種研究類型，並歸納出研究現況、面臨挑戰與未來方向。由目前此議題之相關文獻可發現，雖然體育課促進青少年正向發展的議題已受重視，但無論是削弱、增強、或遷移類型的研究都存有許多不足處，尤其在實證研究成果、學理基礎探究、以及研究方法應用上都有相當大的成長空間。另外，在增強與遷移的研究類型上，現有研究多以個人與社會責任模式為基礎，但運動和平模式與文化研究模式等尚有相當大的開拓潛力，後續研究者可考慮將其應用於國內體育課，並針對研究缺口加以檢驗。整體而言，本文就實證研究成果、學理基礎探究、以及研究方法應用上對於未來研究提出建議，期望未來有更多學者投入此議題的研究，把握契機營造更有利於學生學習的體育課環境，並且對學生的福祉做出更大的貢獻。

In recent years, student holistic development has received much attention on the outcomes of physical education. In the context, promoting positive youth development through physical education has also become one of the popular topics in the field of sport pedagogy. Therefore, this article first introduced the contents and contexts of positive youth development, as well as the relationship between physical education and positive youth development. Then the previous studies were categorized as extinction (diminish students’ negative behaviors), reinforcement (increase students’ positive behaviors), and transfer (application of the outcomes in non-physical educational contexts) which were followed by proposing current status, challenges, and future directions. This article also indicated that the topic of positive youth development had received much attention in the field of sport pedagogy; however, the outcomes of extinction, reinforcement, and transfer research were relatively insufficient. There are still a lot of gaps should be filled in the aspect of empirical studies, grounding theories, as well as research methods. Furthermore, previous reinforcement and transfer studies were mostly based on the model of teaching personal and social responsibility (TPSR); nevertheless, numerous potential research of sport for peace model and culture studies were worthy of being explored. Finally, most of the model-based studies were implemented in western education contexts, these findings should be cautiously interpreted when considering different age groups or cultural backgrounds. Researchers may examine these research gaps among the outcomes of physical education and adopt the models in domestic physical education context. To sum up, this article indicated there were still insufficiencies in all three study approaches. Suggestions on empirical outcomes, theoretical foundations, and applications for future studies were provided in expected to urge more scholars to be involved in this issue in order to create better learning environments and further contribute to the well-being of students in physical education.

1. 周宏室、徐偉庭(2012)。個人與社會責任課程模式之探究。中華體育季刊，26(1)，101-108。
   連結：
2. 邱奕銓、洪升呈、周宏室(2013)。大學生體育課情意量表之編製。大專體育學刊，15(2)，182-194。
   連結：
3. 徐偉庭、周宏室、潘義祥(2014)。以自我決定理論為架構檢驗體育課學生的責任發展。體育學報，47(3)，425-436。
   連結：
4. 陳龍弘、張文馨、張硯評(2015)。正向心理學與運動心理學的相逢。體育學報，48(2)，123-138。
   連結：
5. 顏志龍(2014)。實驗法的原理及其在運動和體育研究上的運用。體育學報，47(4)，475-488。
   連結：
6. 教育部 (2014)。102 學年度學校體育統計年報。臺北市：作者。[Ministry of Education (2014). Annual statistics report of school physical education 2013. Taipei: Author.]
7. Agbuga, B.,Xiang, P.,McBride, R.(2010).Achievement goals and their relations to children's disruptive behaviors in an after-school physical activity program.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,29,278-294.
8. Agbuga, B.,Xiang, P.,McBride, R. E.(2015).Relationship between achievement goals and students' self-reported personal and social responsible behaviors in high school physical education.The Spanish Journal of Psychology,18,22-30.
9. Bailey, R. P.(2005).Evaluating the relationship between physical education, sport and social inclusion.Education Review,57,71-90.
10. Bailey, R.,Armour, K.,Kirk, D.,Jess, M.,Pickup, I.,Sandford, R.(2009).The educational benefits claimed for physical education and school sport: An academic review.Research Papers in Education,24(1),1-27.
11. Bandura, A.(1999).Moral disengagement in the perpetration of inhumanities.Personality & Social Psychology Review,3,193-209.
12. Beaudoin, S.(2012).Using responsibility-based strategies to empower in-service physical education and health teachers to learn and implement TPSR.Ágora,14(2),161-177.
13. Blanton, J.,Oregon, E.,Flett, M. R.,Gould, D.,Pfieffer, K.(2013).The feasibility of using nature-based settings for physical activity programming: View from urban youth and program providers.American Journal of Health Education,44(6),324-334.
14. Brunelle, J.,Danish, S. J.,Forneris, T.(2007).The impact of a sport-based life skill program on adolescent prosocial values.Applied Developmental Science,11(1),43-55.
15. Cecchini, J. A.,Montero, J.,Alonso, A.,Izquierdo, M.,Contreras, O.(2007).Effects of personal and social responsibility on fair play in sports and self-control in school-aged youths.European Journal of Sport Science,7(4),203-211.
16. Coakley, J.(2011).Youth Sports: What counts as "positive development?".Journal of Sport and Social Issues,35,306-324.
17. Cothran, D. J.,Kulinna, P. H.,Garrahy, D.(2009).Attributions for and consequences of student misbehavior.Physical Education & Sport Pedagogy,14,155-167.
18. Cothran, D.,Kulinna, P. H.(2007).Students' reports of misbehavior in physical education.Research Quarterly for Exercise & Sport,78,216-224.
19. D'Amatoa, L. G.,Krasny, M.(2011).Outdoor adventure education: Applying transformative learning theory to understanding instrumental learning and personal growth in environmental education.The Journal of Environmental Education,42(4),237-254.
20. Danish, S.(2002).SUPER (Sports United to Promote Education and Recreation) program: Leader manual.Richmond, VA:Virginia Commonwealth University.
21. Danish, S. J.,Forneris, T.,Wallace, I.(2005).Sport-based life skills programming in the schools.Journal of Applied School Psychology,21,41-62.
22. Destani, F.,Hannon, J. C.,Podlog, L.,Brusseau, T. A.(2014).Promoting character development through teaching wrestling in physical education using the personal and social responsibility instructional model approach.Journal of Physical Education, Recreation, & Dance,85,23-29.
23. Durlak, J. A.,Dupre, E. P.(2008).Implementation matters: A review of research on the influence of implementation on program outcomes and the factors affecting implementation.American Journal of Community Psychology,41,327-350.
24. Durlak, J. A.,Weissberg, R. P.,Dymnicki, A. B.,Taylor, R. D.,Schellinger, K. B.(2011).Enhancing students' social and emotional development promotes success in school: Results of a meta-analysis.Child Development,82,405-432.
25. Durlak, J. A.,Weissberg, R. P.,Pachan, M.(2010).A meta-analysis of after-school programs that seek to promote personal and social skills in children and adolescents.American Journal of Community Psychology,45,294-309.
26. Emmer, E. T.(Ed.),Sabornie, E. J.(Ed.)(2015).Handbook of Classroom Management.New York, NY:Routledge.
27. Ennis, C. D.(1999).Creating a culturally relevant curriculum for disengaged girls.Sport, Education & Society,4,31-49.
28. Ennis, C. D.,Solmon, M. A.,Satina, B.,Loftus, S. J.,Mensch, J.,McCauley, M. T.(1999).Creating a sense of family in urban schools using the "sport for peace" curriculum.Research Quarterly for Exercise & Sport,70(3),273-285.
29. Escarti, A.,Gutierrez, M.,Pascual, C.,Llopis, R.(2010).Implementation of the personal and social responsibility model to improve self-efficacy during physical education classes for primary school children.International Journal of Psychology & Psychological Therapy,10,387-402.
30. Fernandez-Rio, J.(2014).Another step in models-based practice: Hybridizing cooperative learning and teaching for personal and social responsibility.Journal of Physical Education, Recreation & Dance,85,3-5.
31. Fraser-Thomas, J. L.,Côté, J.,Deakin, J.(2005).Youth sport programs: An avenue to foster positive youth development.Physical Education & Sport Pedagogy,10,19-40.
32. Gordon, B.(2010).An examination of the responsibility model in a New Zealand secondary school physical education program.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,29,21-37.
33. Gordon, B.(2005).New Zealand,Massey University.
34. Gordon, B.,Thevenard, L.,Hodis, F.(2011).Teaching for personal and social responsibility.Journal of Physical Education New Zealand,44(1),18-21.
35. Goudas, M.,Dermitzaki, E.,Leondari, A.,Danish, S.(2006).The effectiveness of teaching a life-skills program in a physical education context.European Journal of Psychology of Education,21,429-438.
36. Goudas, M.,Giannoudis, G.(2008).A team-sports-based life-skills program in a physical education context.Learning & Instruction,18,528-536.
37. Gould, D.,Carson, S.(2008).Life skills development through sport: Current status and future directions.International Review of Sport & Exercise Psychology,1,58-78.
38. Goyette, R.,Dore', R.,Dion, E.(2000).Pupils' misbehaviors and the reactions and causal attributions of physical education student teachers: A sequential analysis.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,2,3-14.
39. Hammond-Diedrich, K. C.,Walsh, D.(2006).Empowering youth through a responsibility-based cross-age teacher program: An investigation into impact and possibilities.Physical Educator,63(3),134-142.
40. Hayden, L. A.(2012).Developing responsibility using physical activity: A case study of team support.Ágora,14(2),264-281.
41. Hellison, D.(2011).Teaching responsibility through physical activity.Champaign, IL:Human Kinetics.
42. Hellison, D.(1995).Teaching responsibility through physical activity.Champaign, IL:Human Kinetics.
43. Hellison, D.,Walsh, D.(2002).Responsibility-based youth programs evaluation: Investigating the investigations.Quest,54,292-307.
44. Hemphill, M. A.,Templin, T. J.,Wright, P. M.(2015).Implementation and outcomes of a responsibility-based continuing professional development protocol in physical education.Sport, Education & Society,20(3),398-419.
45. Holt, N. L.(Ed.)(2008).Positive youth development through sport.London, England:Routledge.
46. Holt, N. L.,Neely, K. C.(2011).Positive youth development through sport: A review.RIPED,6,299-316.
47. Holt, N. L.,Sehn, Z. L.,Spence, J. C.,Newton, A. S.,Ball, G. D. C.(2012).Physical education and sport programs at an inner city school: Exploring possibilities for positive youth development.Physical Education and Sport Pedagogy,17(1),97-113.
48. Holt, N. L.,Tamminen, K. A.,Jones, M. I.(2007).Promoting positive youth development through teaching games in physical education.Physical & Health Education Journal,73(3),8-13.
49. Hsu, W. T.,Pan, Y.,Chou, H.,Lu, J. H.(2014).Measuring students' responsibility in physical education: Instrument development and validation.International Journal of Sport Psychology,45(5),487-503.
50. Jacobsa, J. M.,Wright, P. M.(2014).Fitness games that promote personal and social responsibility: Implications for Practitioners.Journal of Physical Education, Recreation & Dance,85,44-45.
51. Jung, J.,Wright, R.(2012).Application of Hellison's responsibility model in South Korea: A multiple case study of "at-risk" middle school students in physical education.Ágora,14(2),140-160.
52. Kaplan, A.,Gheen, M.,Midgley, C.(2002).Classroom goal structure and student disruptive behavior.The British Journal of Educational Psychology,72,191-211.
53. Kinchin, G. D.,O'Sullivan, M.(1999).Making physical education meaningful for high school students.Journal of Physical Education, Recreation & Dance,70,40-44.
54. Kinchin, G.,O'Sullivan, M.(2003).Incidences of student support for and resistance to a curricular innovation in high school physical education.Journal of teaching in physical education,22,245-260.
55. Kirk, D.(Ed.),Macdonald, D.(Ed.),O'Sullivan, M.(Ed.)(2006).The handbook of physical education.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
56. Krech, P.,Kulinna, P. H.,Cothran, D. J.(2010).Development of a short-form version of the physical education classroom instrument: Measuring secondary pupils' disruptive behaviors.Physical Education & Sport Pedagogy,15,209-225.
57. Kulinna, P. H.,Cothran, D. J.,Regualos, R.(2003).Refinement of an instrument to measure student disruptive behavior.Measurement in Physical Education & Exercise Science,7,25-41.
58. Kulinna, P. H.,Cothran, D. J.,Regualos, R.(2006).Teachers' reports of student misbehavior in physical education.Research Quarterly for Exercise & Sport,77,32-40.
59. Lee, O.,Kim, Y.,Kim, O. J.(2012).Relations of perception of responsibility to intrinsic motivation and physical activity among Korean middle school students.Perceptual & Motor Skills,115(3),944-952.
60. Little, S. G.,Akin-Little, K. A.(2008).Psychology's contributions to classroom management.Psychology in the Schools,45,227-234.
61. Lund, J.(Ed.),Tannehill, D.(Ed.)(2014).Standards-based physical education curriculum development.Burlington, MA:Jones & Bartlett.
62. Lund, J.(Ed.),Tannehill, D.(Ed.)(2005).Standards-based physical education curriculum development.Sudbury, MA:Jones & Bartlett.
63. Lund, J.,Tannehill, D.(2005).Standards-Based Curriculum Development in Physical Education.Sudbury, MA:Jones & Bartlett Publishers.
64. Martinek, T.,Hellison, D.(1997).Service-bonded inquiry: The road less traveled.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,17,107-121.
65. Martinek, T.,Ruiz, L.M.(2005).Promoting positive youth development through a values-based sport program.International Journal of Sport Science,1(1),1-13.
66. Martinek, T.,Schilling, T.(2003).Developing compassionate leadership in underserved youth.Journal of Physical Education, Recreation, & Dance,74,33-39.
67. McCormack, A.(1997).Classroom management problems, strategies and influences in physical education.European Physical Education Review,3,102-115.
68. McKenzie, T. L.,Lounsbery, M. A. F.(2009).School physical education: The pill not taken.American journal of lifestyle medicine,3,219-225.
69. Mowling, C. M.,Brock, S. J.,Hastie, P. A.(2011).African-American children's representation of personal and social responsibility.Sport, Education & Society,16,89-109.
70. Newton, M.,Sandberg, J.,Watson, D. L.(2001).Utilizing adventure education within the model of moral action.Quest,53,483-494.
71. Nie, Y.,Lau, S.(2009).Complementary roles of care and behavioral control in classroom management: The self-determination theory perspective.Contemporary Educational Psychology,34,185-194.
72. Papacharisis, V.,Goudas, M.,Danish, S.,Theodorakis, Y.(2005).The effectiveness of teaching a life skills program in a school-based sport context.Journal of Applied Sport Psychology,17,247-254.
73. Sánchez-Alcaraz, B. J.,Gómez-Mármol, A.,Valero, A.,De la Cruz, E.(2013).Implementation of a program to improve personal and social responsibility in physical education lessons.European Journal of Human Movement,30,121-129.
74. Sandford, R. A.,Armour, K. M.,Warmington, P. C.(2006).Re-engaging disaffected youth through physical activity programs.British Educational Research Journal,32,251-271.
75. Schilling, T.,Martinek, T.,Tan, C.(2002).Fostering youth development through empowerment.Sport in the 21st century: Alternatives for the new millennium,Boston, MA:
76. Schinke, R. J.(ed.),Hanrahan, S. J.(ed.)(2012).Sport for development, peace and social justice.Morgantown, WV:Fitness Information Technology.
77. Severinsen, G.(2014).Teaching personal and social responsibility to juniors through physical education.Asia-Pacific Journal of Health, Sport and Physical Education,5,83-100.
78. Shirilla, P.(2009).Adventure-based programming and social skill development in the lives of diverse youth: Perspectives from two research projects.The Journal of Experiential Education,31(3),410-414.
79. Sibthorp, J.,Morgan, C.(2011).Adventure-based programming: Exemplary youth development practice.New Directions for Youth Development,130,105-119.
80. Silverman, S.(Ed.),Ennis, C.(Ed.)(2003).Student learning in physical education.Champaign, IL:Human Kinetics.
81. Supaporn, S.,Dodds, P.,Griffin, L.(2003).An ecological analysis of middle school misbehavior through student and teacher perspectives.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,22,328-349.
82. Trudeau, F.,Shephard, R. J.(2008).Is there a long-term health legacy of required physical education?.Sports Medicine,38,265-270.
83. Turnnidge, J.,Côté, J.,Hancock, D. J.(2014).Positive youth development from sport to life: Explicit or implicit transfer?.Quest,66(2),203-217.
84. Walsh, D.(2008).Helping youth in underserved communities envision possible futures: An extension of the teaching personal and social responsibility model.Research Quarterly for Exercise & Sport,79(2),209-221.
85. Walsh, D.(2007).Supporting youth development outcomes: An evaluation of a responsibility model-based program.The Physical Educator,64(1),48-56.
86. Walsh, D. S.,Veri, M. J.,Willard, J. J.(2015).The kinesiology career club: Undergraduate student mentor perspectives of a physical activity-based TPSR program.The Physical Educator,72,317-339.
87. Walsh, D.,Ozaeta, J.,Wright, P.(2010).Transference of responsibility model goals to the school exploring the impact of coaching club program.Physical Education & Sport Pedagogy,15(1),15-28.
88. Ward, S.,Parker, M.(2013).The voice of youth: Atmosphere in positive youth development program.Physical Education & Sport Pedagogy,18(5),534-548.
89. Weiss, M. R.(2006).The First Tee 2005 research summary: Longitudinal effects of the First Tee Life Skills Educational Program on positive youth development.St. Augustine, FL:The First Tee.
90. Weiss, M. R.,Stuntz, C. P.,Bhalla, J. A.,Bolter, N. D.,Price, M. S.(2013).More than a game: Impact of the first tee life skills program on positive youth development: Project introduction and year 1 findings.Qualitative Research in Sport, Exercise, & Health,5,214-244.
91. Whitley, M. A.,Forneris, T.,Barker, B.(2014).The reality of evaluating community-based sport and physical activity programs to enhance the development of underserved youth: Challenges and potential strategies.Quest,66,218-232.
92. Wright, P. M.,Li, W.(2009).Exploring the relevance of positive youth development in urban physical education.Physical Education & Sport Pedagogy,14(3),241-251.
93. Wright, P.,Burton, S.(2008).Implementation and outcomes of a responsibility- based physical activity program integrated into an intact high school physical education class.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,27,138-154.
94. Wright, P.,Li, W,Ding, S.,Pickering, M.(2010).Integrating a personal and social responsibility program into a Wellness course for urban high school students: Assessing implementation and educational outcomes.Sport, Education & Society,12(3),277-298.
95. Wright, P.,White, K.,Gaebler-Spira, D.(2004).Exploring the relevance of the personal and social responsibility model in adapted physical activity: A collective case study.The Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,23,71-87.
96. 周宏室(2014)。我國體育課程發展的新思維。國民體育季刊，43(4)，6-10。
97. 國家教育研究院(2014)。十二年國民基本教育課程綱要說明手冊。新北市=New Taipei:作者=Author。
98. 教育部(2013)。體育運動政策白皮書。臺北市=Taipei:作者=Author。

1. 蔡沂蓁,潘義祥,李宏文(2021)。體育教師專業成長之路－以自我實現及自我設限理論為取向。臺灣運動教育學報，16(2)，33-56。
2. 羅健銘,陳盈如(2020)。探勘大學生的壓力來源推薦紓壓運動。Journal of Data Analysis，15(3)，27-44。
3. 羅玉枝(2018)。不同運動習慣學生對體育課程選修動機考量因素的差異性探討。運動與健康研究，7(1)，1-17。
4. 潘義祥,吳惠蓮,吳兆紅(2023)。與繩共舞：以跳繩運動促進國小學童生活技能之發展與轉移。臺灣體育學術研究，75，1-22。
5. 闕月清,李柏昂(2023)。個人與社會責任模式融入偏鄉國小飛盤課程之研究。中等教育，74(2)，46-67。
6. 鄭至展,楊雅婷,江維鈞,王振興(2021)。智慧手環暨綠幣獎勵制度對國中生身體活動和學業成績之影響。體育學報，54(2)，161-177。