What is in a concept? Mapping the history of sport management research in Taiwan and Korea using Leximancer text mining analysis.

臺灣與韓國運動管理研究之文獻分析：Leximancer文字資料探勘軟體之應用

10.3966/102472972018035101001

邱偉盛(Weisheng Chiu)；曾文永(Wenyung Tseng)

sport management ； data mining ； content analysis ； Leximancer ； Korea ； 運動管理 ； 資料採礦 ； 內容分析 ； Leximancer ； 韓國

體育學報

51卷1期（2018 / 03 / 01）

1 - 12

英文

Introduction: Sport management is a relatively young and fast-growing academic discipline. Through the dedication of scholars, the field has matured into a distinctive discipline in recent years. Meanwhile, many Asian scholars collaborated to organize the Asian Association for Sport management (AASM), an association created with the purpose of bringing together academics in the field of sport management to not only promote but also carry out practical research. In order to gain a better understanding of the evolution of sport management research in Asia, the purpose of this study was to map out the sport management research landscape in Taiwan and Korea. Methods: Leximancer (a text-mining tool for visualizing the structure of concepts and themes in the text) was used by analyzing data from articles published in the Journal of Taiwan Society for Sport Management (from 2002 to 2017) and the Korean Journal of Sport Management (from 1996 to 2017). These two journals were selected due to their relatively long histories of publication and their large volumes of articles, which allow for more thorough and accurate analyses of trends and themes in these two nations. Results: Between the two journals, the themes ＂Sport＂ and ＂Satisfaction＂ were shared. However, Taiwanese studies in sport management placed more emphasis on the themes ＂Leisure＂ and ＂Education,＂ while studies in Korea concentrated on ＂Professional＂ subjects. Taiwan studies also moved from a physical education focus toward participant experience in leisure activities, sporting events, and sports strategies over time. On the other hand, earlier studies in Korea focused more on the development of the sports industry and strategies to promote public sports, while recent articles emphasize sport participants' and spectators' behavior by empirically examining the relationship between variables such as satisfaction, service quality, value, brand image, attitude, and behavior. Conclusion: This study firstly examined and compared the sport management literature between Asian countries. The findings provide a better understanding of different patterns and trends of sport management research in Taiwan and Korea.

緒論：運動管理為一個正在發展茁壯的研究領域，為聯合亞洲區運動管理的研究，學者們成立了亞洲運動管理學會(AASM)，以推廣運動管理研究及促進實務結合為宗旨，目的在了解亞洲區運動管理的演變。本文旨在分析臺灣與韓國兩國之運動管理研究領域代表之主要期刊，自創刊至現今的運動管理研究構念發展及趨勢異同。方法：以臺灣運動管理學報自2002年創刊至2017年，及韓國運動管理期刊自1996年創刊至2017年為研究範圍，並應用文字資料探勘軟體Leximancer進行各篇研究英文摘要的整合分析。結果：兩本運動管理期刊之共同構念為「運動」及「滿意度」；然而臺灣運動管理研究偏重在「休閒」及「教育」兩大領域，韓國研究則集中關注於「職業運動」領域。臺灣的相關研究趨勢從最初的體育轉移至休閒活動參與、運動賽會及運動策略的研究脈絡；另一方面，韓國研究早期關注於運動產業發展及推廣全民運動策略上，近期研究則偏重於以滿意度、服務品質、價值、品牌形象、態度和行為來探討運動參與者與觀眾行為等實證研究為發展趨勢。結論：本研究首次將臺灣、韓國此兩個亞洲國家的運動管理研究，以文字資料採礦方式進行比較及文本分析，以了解兩國研究不同的構念發展及脈絡，研究成果可提供未來運動管理學門之研究酌參。

1. Hsu, C. M.,Huang, Y.,Teng, T. H.(2012).A study on Journal of Taiwan Society for Sport Management through content analysis.Journal of Taiwan Society for Sport Management,12(4),311-341.
   連結：
2. Hung, T. M.,Hwang, Y. J.(2009).An evaluation of physical education journal in Taiwan.Journal of Physical Education in Higher Education,11(1),1-5.
   連結：
3. Shih, C. P.,Chang, C.,Ni, Y. L.(2012).Sport Management: Current Status and Trend Analysis in Taiwan.Phusical Education Journal,45(3),167-178.
   連結：
4. (2008).Leximancer Manual. Leximancer: The Why, Not Just the What.Brisbane, Australia:Leximancer.
5. Anagnostopoulos, C.,Bason, T.(2015).Mapping the first 10 years with Leximancer: Themes and concepts in the Sports Management International Journal Choregia.Sport management International Journal,11(1),24-41.
6. Andrew, D. P.,Pedersen, P. M.,McEvoy, C. D.(2011).Research methods and design in sport management.Champaign, IL:Human Kinetics.
7. Angus, D.,Rintel, S.,Wiles, J.(2013).Making sense of big text: A visual-first approach for analysing text data using Leximancer and Discursis.International Journal of Social Research Methodology,16(3),261-267.
8. Chiu, W.,Bae, J. S.,Won, D.(2017).The experience of watching baseball games in Korea: An analysis of user-generated content on social media using Leximancer.Journal of Sport & Tourism,21(1),33-47.
9. Choo, N. Y.,Cho, S. H.(2013).An analysis of research trends of sport management in Korea.Korean Journal of Sport Management,18(3),53-63.
10. Ciomaga, B.(2013).Sport management: A bibliometric study on central themes and trends.European Sport Management Quarterly,13(5),557-578.
11. Cretchley, J.,Rooney, D.,Gallois, C.(2010).Mapping a 40-year history with Leximancer: Themes and concepts in the Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology.Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology,41(3),318-328.
12. Crofts, K.,Bisman, J.(2010).Interrogating accountability: An illustration of the use of Leximancer software for qualitative data analysis.Qualitative Research in Accounting & Management,7(2),180-207.
13. Doherty, A.(2012)."It takes a village:" Interdisciplinary research for sport management.Journal of Sport Management,27(1),1-10.
14. Hyndman, B.,Pill, S.(2017).What's in a concept? A Leximancer text mining analysis of physical literacy across the international literature.European Physical Education Review,24(1)
15. Johnston, M. A.,Spais, G. S.(2015).Conceptual foundations of sponsorship research.Journal of Promotion Management,21(3),296-312.
16. J-Stage(2017).Japanese Journal of Sport Management
17. Korea Professional Sports Association(2017).Korean professional sport survey report.Seoul, Korea:Korea Professional Sports Association.
18. Korea Sports Promotion Foundation. (2014). Sposumer Report-Golf industry. Retrieved from http://spois.kspo.or.kr/sposumer/front/index.do
19. Korean Citation Index. (2017). KCI journals list. Retrieved from https://www.kci.go.kr/kciportal/main.kci?locale=en
20. Leng, H. K.,Hsu, N. Y.(2015).Emerging trends and innovation in sports management and marketing in Asia.Hershey, PA:IGI Global.
21. Leximancer. (2017). Leximancer FAQ. Retrieved from https://www.leximancer.com/faq/
22. Peetz, T. B.,Reams, L.(2011).A content analysis of sport marketing quarterly: 1992-2011.Sport Marketing Quarterly,20(4),209.
23. Pitts, B. G.,Pedersen, P. M.(2005).Examing the body of scholarship in sport management: A content analysis of the Journal of Sport Management.The SMART Jounal,2(1),33-52.
24. Pitts, B.,Danylchuk, K.,Quarterman, J.(2014).Analysis of sport management literature: European Sport Management Quarterly.Sport management International Journal,10(2),45-72.
25. Shilbury, D.(2011).A bibliometric study of citations to sport management and marketing journals.Journal of Sport Management,25(5),423-444.
26. Shilbury, D.(2011).A bibliometric analysis of four sport management journals.Sport Management Review,14(4),434-452.
27. Shilbury, D.,Rentschler, R.(2007).Assessing sport management journals: A multi-dimensional examination.Sport Management Review,10(1),31-44.
28. Skinner, J.,Edwards, A.,Corbett, B.(2014).Research methods for sport management.Routledge.
29. Smith, A. E.,Humphreys, M. S.(2006).Evaluation of unsupervised semantic mapping of natural language with Leximancer concept mapping.Behavior research methods,38(2),262-279.
30. Sotiriadou, P.,Brouwers, J.,Le, T. A.(2014).Choosing a qualitative data analysis tool: A comparison of NVivo and Leximancer.Annals of Leisure Research,17(2),218-234.
31. Steimel, S.(2014).Mapping a history of applied communication research: Themes and concepts in the Journal of Applied Communication Research.Review of Communication,14(1),19-35.
32. Tseng, C.,Wu, B.,Morrison, A. M.,Zhang, J.,Chen, Y. C.(2015).Travel blogs on China as a destination image formation agent: A qualitative analysis using Leximancer.Tourism Management,46,347-358.
33. Wu, M. Y.,Wall, G.,Pearce, P. L.(2014).Shopping experiences: International tourists in Beijing's Silk Market.Tourism Management,41,96-106.
34. Yeh, K. T.(2007).The development of sport management in Taiwan.Asian Sport Management Review,1,7-14.

1. 陳龍弘,陳美燕,郭哲君,張文馨(2019).Psychological Empowerment Enhances Changes in Sport Service Job Performance and Job Satisfaction: The Moderating Role of Psychological Flexibility at Work.大專體育學刊,21(3),199-211.
2. 蔣任翔(2023)。From health promotion to winning medals: A policy analysis for the development of scottish sport and physical activity。體育學報，56(4)，405-428。