鄭多燕塑（健）身操書中的性別議題

Ggendered representation in Jung Dayeon's fitness texts

10.3966/102472972018035101009

黃雅倩(Ya-Chien Huang)

鄭多燕 ； 塑(健)身操文本 ； 女性身體 ； 性別再現 ； Jung Dayeon ； fitness texts ； female body ； gender representation

體育學報

51卷1期（2018 / 03 / 01）

127 - 141

繁體中文

緒論：塑(健)身操是少數幾項女性被鼓勵參加的休閒活動，不論是塑(健)身操的指導者或參與者都以女性為多。近年來，來自南韓的鄭多燕和她自創的塑(健)身操(figurobics)在東亞各國蔚為風潮，許多臺灣女性亦趨之若鶩。然而學者們對塑(健)身操中對女性身體及女性主體性的呈現卻一直有分歧的看法。方法：有鑑於此，本文針對近年來鄭多燕所著的自助塑(健)身叢書加以敘事分析，並將其文本中自述經驗和相關女性主義理論做連結與辯證。結果：分析發現鄭多燕的自助塑(健)身操書籍中以戲劇化的自身減重經驗作為基調，透過醫療、飲食、自我成長、掌控命運、休閒等概念來包裝「精瘦為美」且「分區雕塑」的女性身體，強調女性主動追求「完美曲線」的重要性，並將父權社會中的對女性身體約束加深並合理化，高度模糊塑(健)身操中追求健康休閒及追求美麗性感間的界線。結論：塑(健)身相關書籍不但承載了社會上對女性身體及女性健康的期望，也是社會上性別意識型態運作下的產物，其內容中再現的性別價值觀實值得吾人省思。

Introduction: Aerobics is one of the sports that women are encouraged to participate in and predominantly participated by women. In 2011, Jung Dayeon, a South Korean lady, who successfully shed 30 kilograms through diet and self-styled figurobics, has created a fitness sensation in East Asia. Her fitness books and DVDs have been one of the most popular in Taiwan and her name has become synonymous with the ideal toned female body. However, academics have long held polarized opinions on commercial fitness texts and their impact on women's development since the publication of Jane Fonda's Workout Book in 1981. Methods: This paper used narrative analysis to investigate the ways in which relationships among gender ideology, body images, fitness and health are represented in the texts authored by Jung Dayeon. Results: Analysis shows that the texts play up her dramatic physical transformations in a narrative assisted by medical, diet, health, self-improvement, and leisure discourses in order to package and promote a slim, muscular and sculpted female body. Jung's texts have deployed images and words which normalize the dominant heterosexual gender ideologies in society and obscured the lines between the pursuit of fitness and the pursuit of beauty. Conclusion: It is vital to examine fitness texts, as they do not only carry social expectations on women’s body and health, but also shape the gender ideologies in society.

1. 吳秀瑾(2007)。身體在世：傅柯和布爾迪厄身體觀和施為者之對比。臺灣社會研究季刊，68，75-118。
   連結：
2. 謝秀芳(2004)。運動社會支持與女性運動行為之探討。大專體育，74，110-114。
   連結：
3. Andreasson, J.,Johansson, T.(2014).The fitness revolution: Historical transformations in the global gym and fitness culture.Sport Science Review,23(3-4),91-112.
4. Berger, J.、陳志梧譯(1992)。看的方法：繪畫與社會關係七講。臺北=Taipei:明文書局=Ming Wen Shu Ju。
5. Bolin, A.(Ed.),Granskog, J.(Ed.)(2003).Athletic intruders-ethnographic research on women, culture, and exercise.Albany:State university of New York press.
6. Bordo, S.(Ed.)(1993).Unbearable Weight: Feminism, Western Culture, and the Body.Berkeley:University of California Press.
7. Bosworth, P.(2012).Jane Fonda: The private life of a public woman.Boston:Houghton Mifflin Harcourt.
8. Cohen, C. Ballerino(Ed.)(1992).Body contours: Deciphering scripts of gender and power.New Brunswick, NJ:Rutgers University Press.
9. Crowley, H.(Ed.),Himmelweit, S.(Ed.)(1992).Knowing women: Feminism and knowledge.Cambridge:Polity Press.
10. Fonda, J.(1981).Jane Fonda's workout book.New York:Simon & Schuster.
11. Foucault, M.,Sheridan, Alan(trans.)(1977).Discipline and punish: the birth of the prison.Harmondsworth:Penguin.
12. Giddens, A.(1991).Modernity and self-Identity: Self and society in the late modern age.stanford, California:Stanford University Press.
13. Gordon, C.(Ed.)(1980).Power/Knowledge: selected interview and other writings 1972-1977.New York:Pantheon.
14. Hall, S.(Ed.),Hobson, D.(Ed.),Lowe, A.(Ed.),Willis, P.(Ed.)(1980).Culture, Media, Language.London:Hutchinson.
15. Harvey, J.(Ed.),Cantelon, G.(Ed.)(1988).Not just a game.Altona, MB:University of Ottawa Press.
16. Hibbard, J. H.,Pope, C. R.(1987).Women's role, interest in health behavior.Women & Health,12(2),67-84.
17. Kagan, E.,Morse, M.(1988).The body electronic: Aerobic exercise on video: Women's search for empowerment and self-transformation.The Drama Review,32(4),164-180.
18. Kenen, R. L.(1987).Double messages, double images: Physical fitness, self-concepts, and women's exercise classes.Journal of Physical Education, Recreation, and Dance,58(6),74-79.
19. Labov, W.(Ed.)(1972).Language in the inner city.Philadelphia, PA:University of Pennsylvania Press.
20. Lieblich, A.、Tuval-Mashiach, R.、Ziber, T.、吳芝儀譯(2008)。敘事分析與研究。嘉義=Chiayi:濤石=Tao shi。
21. Llyod, M.(1996).Feminism, aerobics and the politics of the body.Body and Society,2(2),79-98.
22. Maguire, J. S.(2002).Body lessons: fitness publishing and the cultural production of the fitness consumer.International Review for the Sociology of Sport,37(3-4),449-464.
23. Mansfield, L.(2011).'Sexercise': Working out heterosexuality in Jane Fonda's fitness books.Leisure Studies,30(2),237-255.
24. Markula, P.(1995).Firm but shapely, fit but sexy, strong but thin: The post-modern aerobicizing female bodies.Sociology of Sport Journal,12(4),424-453.
25. McDonald, M.(2002).The peculiar case of the Women's National Basketball Association.Sociological Perspectives,45(4),379-396.
26. Mutrie, N.,Choi, P. Y. L.(2000).Is 'fit' a feminist issue? Dilemmas for exercise psychology.Feminism and Psychology,10(4)
27. Rothblum, E.(Ed.),Solovay, S.(Ed.)(2009).The fat studies reader.New York:New York University Press.
28. Tasker, Y.(Ed.),Negra, D.(Ed.)(2007).Interrogating Postfeminism.Durham:Duke University Press.
29. Ylanne, V.(Ed.)(2012).Representing ageing.London:Palgrave Macmillan.
30. 朱影編(2012)。西方女性研究。北京=Beijing:中國人民大學出版社=People University Press。
31. 張錦華(1994)。傳播批判理論。臺北=Taipei:黎明文化=Li Ming Wen Hua。
32. 張錦華(2002)。女為悅已者瘦？媒介效果與主體研究。臺北=Taipei:正中書局=Zheng Zhong Shu Ju。
33. 陳儒修、高玉芳(1994)。我美故我在：論美體工程、女性身體、與女性主義。傳播文化，3，193-208。
34. 黃海榮(2007)。「男性凝視」與色情。文化研究，6，1-4。
35. 鄭多燕(2012)。塑身女皇美胸、美腹、美臀DANCE。臺北=Taipei:方智=Fang Zhi。
36. 鄭多燕(2011)。塑身女皇教你打造完美曲線。臺北市=Taipei city:方智=F?ng zhi。
37. 鄭多燕(2012)。塑身女皇完美曲線伸展操。臺北市=Taipei city:方智=F?ng zhi。
38. 鄭多燕(2015)。塑身女皇鄭多燕打造三百六十度完美曲線：胸、腰、臀、腿、肩、背美的大進擊。臺北=Taipei:瑞麗美人國際媒體=Rui Li Mei Ren Guo Ji Mei Ti。
39. 蕭蘋(2003)。或敵或友？流行文化與女性主義。臺灣社會學刊，30，135-164。
40. 謝幸珠(1995)。塑身操對大學女生健康體能的影響。中華體育季刊，9(3)，111-118。

1. 陳上迪,張德勝,姜美松(2023)。當休閒遇見性別：從性別平等教育議題探討不同性別面向的休閒阻礙。中華體育季刊，37(1)，41-60。