以內容分析法系統回顧2003-2017臺灣休閒潛水研究

A content analytical systematic review on SCUBA diving studies in Taiwan, 2003-2017

10.3966/102472972018095103001

溫卓謀(Cho-Mou Wen)；章勝傑(Simon Chang)；莊鑫裕(Hsin-Yu Chuang)

休閒運動 ； 文獻回顧 ； 質性研究 ； leisure sports ； literature review ； qualitative studies

體育學報

51卷3期（2018 / 09 / 01）

275 - 291

繁體中文

緒論：本研究的目的是呈現國內休閒潛水研究的概況，發現學者們關切的學術議題，並針對未來研究提出建議。方法：研究者以內容分析法系統性回顧過去15年131篇國內休閒潛水實徵研究，以2位編碼者採系統編碼的方式分析文獻。結果：相關研究篇數自2003年起逐漸上升，但在2013年後有逐漸下降的趨勢；研究發表以學位論文為主，以量化取向為大宗，研究者偏好以問卷及量表為工具從事調查與相關研究。性別、年齡、教育程度、職業、所得、潛水年資、潛水證照與潛水頻次等變項是研究中常見的背景變項；休閒動機、知覺風險、休閒阻礙與休閒涉入等構念則是研究關切的議題；研究大多聚焦在探討變項間的關聯性；認真性休閒、心流以及遊憩專門化理論是研究者常引用的理論。結論：過往國內潛水研究因偏重量化研究而有去脈絡化的傾向，在研究類型與主題上亦有明顯缺口。在研究類型上未來研究可以加入時間要素，以縱貫性研究檢視休閒潛水的趨勢，或者以質性研究探究潛水歷程中的個體經驗；也可多從事行動研究以解決在潛水現場中的問題，或者採用實驗研究法檢視潛水活動對潛水者身心的影響。在研究主題方面，未來研究可聚焦於潛水技能習得，探究影響技能習得的前置因素以及有效的教學方法，也可更多從事與潛水產業或風險管理有具體影響之研究。最後，國外潛水研究對於適應潛水的推廣、虛擬實境的應用、檢視潛水參與對於個體生理、認知、情緒影響的探究都是值得參考的取徑。

Introduction: This study was conducted to examine the profiles of SCUBA studies of past 15 years in Taiwan, to manifest important research issues in this field and to explore the possibilities of future research. Method: One hundred and thirty one empirical studies on leisure SCUBA diving published from 2003 to 2017 were systematically reviewed with content analysis method. All papers were coded by two coders with a structured coding sheet. Results: It was found that the number of papers published increased gradually from year 2003 and went down after peaked in 2013. Most of the studies were in the format of thesis and that quantitative studies outnumbered qualitative studies. It seemed that SCUBA diving researchers in Taiwan had strong preference for survey or correlative studies utilizing questionnaires and/or scales as research tools. Gender, age, level of education, job, income, diving years, diver certificates earned, and diving frequencies were among the most-examined background variables. Leisure motivation, perceived risks, leisure constraints, and leisure involvement are psychological constructs researched mostly. Theories on serious leisure, flow, and recreation specialization were applied more often than other theories. Conclusion: There was a tendency of de-contextualization for studies in this field, and there were needs of research on various issues. It is suggested that longitudinal studies can be employed to examine the research trends. Qualitative research might be helpful to examine the development processes of SCUBA diving participants. Action research or experimental studies could be conducted to solve realistic problems. Besides, the facilitating or handicapping factors on specific diving skill learning worth further exploration. The learning and instruction issues of SCUBA diving also deserve further researching. More focus could be put on the study of leisure industry or risk management. Finally, recently development of research topics such as adaptive SCUBA diving, the application of virtual reality, and examining the impact of SCUBA diving on participants' cognitive, emotional, and physical functions also worth trying.

1. 李明儒、陳元陽、陳宏斌(2003)。休閒潛水者的風險管理之研究。戶外遊憩研究，16(2)，49-67。
   連結：
2. 李德仁(2009)。認真休閒者之潛水休閒利益。北體學報，18，99-110。
   連結：
3. 林秉毅、李明倫(2015)。國內開放式水肺潛水發展之探討。中華體育季刊，29(3)，189-196。
   連結：
4. 林晏洲、林寶秀(2006)。「戶外遊憩研究」期刊之研究趨勢分析。戶外遊憩研究，19(2)，1-31。
   連結：
5. 施致平、張琪、倪瑛蓮(2012)。運動管理學：臺灣之研究現況與趨勢分析。體育學報，45(3)，167-178。
   連結：
6. 洪彰鴻(2010)。國內體適能博碩士論文研究趨勢分析。運動與遊憩研究，5(2)，50-62。
   連結：
7. 張育愷、宋岱芬、陳豐慈(2017)。國際綜評性論文之分析。體育學報，50(4)，375-384。
   連結：
8. 張育愷、洪聰敏(2014)。臺灣運動與體育領域學術期刊論文發表之現況分析。體育學報，47(1)，1-10。
   連結：
9. 許鎔鑠、蔡鋒樺、王宏義、張珈瑛(2014)。休閒水肺潛水運動者刺激尋求、參與動機與滿意度之研究─以墾丁潛水活動之大學生為例。中原體育學報，5，163-171。
   連結：
10. 陳奕仁、方介民、陳金海、張世沛、張富貴(2015)。我國羽球運動相關研究趨勢之探討。管理實務與理論研究，9(4)，39-51。
    連結：
11. 章國威、施志宜、賴學峰(2009)。臺灣銀髮族休閒旅遊研究趨勢探討。真理觀光學報，7，13-49。
    連結：
12. 湯子葳、林靜萍(2013)。臺灣游泳教學之文獻分析。靜宜體育，7，15-27。
    連結：
13. 歐榮聖(2002)。休閒遊憩觀光研究問與趨勢剖析。都市與計劃，29(2)，315-336。
    連結：
14. 歐榮聖、李美芬、李彥希、林建堯(2006)。休閒研究期刊1999 至2003 之研究趨勢分析。戶外遊憩研究，19(1)，26-50。
    連結：
15. 闕月清、陳詠儒(2015)。臺灣運動教育學博碩士學位論文研究趨勢：1994-2013。中華體育季刊，29(3)，181-188。
    連結：
16. Castro, F. G.,Kellison, J. G.,Boyd, S. J.,Kopak, A.(2010).A methodology for conducting integrative mixed methods research and data analysis.Journal of Mixed Methods,4(4),342-360.
17. Cooper, H.(Ed.),Hedges, L. V.(Ed.),Valentine, J. C.(Ed.)(1994).The Handbook of research synthesis and meta-analysis.New York, NY:Russell Sage Foundation.
18. Espiner, S.,Gidlow, B.,Cushman, G.(2011).Outdoor recreation and gendered space: The case of men's enthusiasms for hunting, fly-fishing and scuba diving.Annals of Leisure Research,14(2/3),176-193.
19. Fuchs, G.,Reichel, A.,Shani, A.(2016).Scuba divers: The thrill of risk or the search for tranquility.Tourism Recreation Research,41(2),145-156.
20. Hemelryck, W.,Germonpré, P.,Papadopoulou, V.,Rozloznik, M.,Balestra, C.(2013).Long term effects of recreational SCUBA diving on higher cognitive function.Scandinavian Journal of Medicine and Science in Sports,24(6),928-934.
21. Henderson, K. A.,McFadden, K.(2013).Characteristics of leisure research: Trends over three decades.International Leisure Review,2,119-134.
22. Ito, E.,Walker, G. J.,Liang, H.(2014).A systematic review of non-western and cross-cultural/national leisure research.Journal of Leisure Research,46(2),226-239.
23. Jain, D.,Sra, M.,Gro, J.,Marques, R.,Wu, R.,Chiu, J.,Schmandt, C.(2016).Immersive scuba diving simulator using virtual reality.Proceedings of the 29th Annual Symposium on User Interface Software and Technology,Tokyo, Japan:
24. Kleiber, D. A.,Walker, G. J.,Mannell, R. C.(2011).A social psychology of leisure.State College, PA:Venture Publishing.
25. Kler, B. K.,Tribe, J.(2012).Flourishing through scuba: Understanding the pursuit of dive experiences.Tourism in Marine Environment,8(1/2),19-32.
26. Kovacs, C. R.,Paulsen, T. D.(2016).Effect of in-water SCUBA diving activities on response time in recreational divers.International Journal of Aquatic Research and Education,10(1),Article 2.
27. Lee, S, & Kim, W.(2016).The effect of empirical value of skin SCUBA diving participants on the emotional response and behavioral responses.Journal of Digital Convergence,14(7),497-506.
28. McQueen, D.,Kent, G.,Murrison, A.(1994).Self-reported long-term effects of diving and decompression illness in recreational SCUBA divers.British Journal of Sports Medicine,28(2),101-104.
29. Nagata, K.,Hatsushika, D.,Hashimoto, Y.(2017).Virtual scuba diving system utilizing the sense of weightlessness underwater.Entertainment Computing-ICEC 2017. ICEC 2017,Cham:
30. Pearson, H.(2016).Norwegian School of Sport Sciences.
31. Pourhashemi, S. F.,Sahraei, H.,Meflahi, G. H.,Hatef, B.,Gholipour, B.(2016).The effect of 20 minutes scuba diving on cognitive function of professional scuba divers.Asian Journal of Sports Medicine,7(3)
32. Straughan, E. R.(2012).Touched by water: The body in scuba diving.Emotion, Space, and Society,5,19-26.
33. Taylor, D. McD.,O'toole, K. S.,Ryan, C. M.(2003).Experienced scuba divers in Australia and the United States suffer considerable injury and morbidity.Wilderness and Environmental Medicine,14,83-88.
34. Terron-Sigler, A.,Leon-Muez, D.,Penalver-Duque, P.,Torre, F. E.(2016).The effects of SCUBA diving on the endemic mediterranean coral astroides calyculais.Occean and Coastal Management,122,1-8.
35. Trevett, A.,Peck, D.,Forbes, R.(2010).The psychological impact of accidents on recreational divers: A prospective study.Journal of Psychosomatic Research,68,263-268.
36. Tzanakis, M.(2016).Scuba diving as a practice of self.Loisir et Société,39(3),451-466.
37. Wilks, J.,Davis, R. J.(2000).Risk management for scuba diving operators on Australia's great barrier reef.Tourism Management,21,591-599.
38. 高錦勝、方信淵、李委珈(2010)。臺灣水域休閒之研究趨勢分析。休閒運動保健學報，3，116-131。
39. 郭亭亞、王逸峰、謝秀雄(2012)。臺灣觀光休閒領域之研究趨勢分析─以TSSCI 期刊「觀光休閒學報」為例。商業現代化學刊，6(3)，49-66。
40. 劉月琪、劉永芳(2010)。潛水活動之健康危害及其處置與預防。中華職業醫學雜誌，17(4)，267-277。

1. 陳美燕,張家榮,洪佳君(2020)。科技始終來自人性：智慧科技於運動健身業之應用。體育學報，53(2)，215-233。
2. 溫卓謀,章勝傑(2019)。大學休閒水肺潛水課程參與者學習歷程的心流體驗與情緒經驗之研究。運動休閒管理學報，16(1)，1-22。
3. 溫卓謀,章勝傑(2019)。臺灣水肺潛水休閒運動之性別差異後設分析研究。運動休閒管理學報，16(2)，32-54。