比較結構式有氧運動與萬步運動對胰島β細胞功能、代謝指標及身體組成之影響：以第二型糖尿病病患為例

Comparison of pedometer-based million step training verses structured centred-based program on pancreatic β cell function, metabolism parameters, and anthropometries among type II diabetes patients

10.3966/102472972018095103002

李書芬(Shu-Fen Lee)

結構式有氧運動 ； 萬步運動 ； 胰島β細胞功能 ； 身體組成 ； 代謝指標 ； structured based program ； pedometerbased million step training ； pancreatic β cell ； function ； anthropometries ； metabolism parameters

體育學報

51卷3期（2018 / 09 / 01）

293 - 305

繁體中文

緒論：規律運動是糖尿病照護的基礎，然政府推動之每日萬步對糖尿病患血糖控制是否有實質效果，需進一步釐清及驗證，研究之目的為探討結構式有氧與萬步運動對胰島β細胞功能、身體組成及代謝指標之影響。方法：本研究為12週橫斷式運動介入性研究，樣本為北部某教學醫院新陳代謝門診之第二型糖尿病病患共109位，隨機分派實驗組為結構式有氧組36位及萬步組37位；及控制組36位，維持原靜態生活形態。個案在介入前後分別接受身體組成及血液指標之測量，另，透過2小時葡萄糖耐糖試驗(OGTT)之多點血糖與胰島素值，運用BIGTT的數學模式計算出胰島素敏感性(BIGTT-SI)及急性胰島素反應(BIGTT-AIR)做為胰島細胞功能之指標。結果：血糖調控機制在12週運動介入後，結構式有氧運動相較控制組，降低空腹血糖值(Δ= -32.63%, p ＜ .001)、2小時葡萄糖耐糖值(Δ= -24.64%, p = 0.047)及糖化血色素(Δ= -0.77%, p ＜ .001)，並增加急性胰島素反應分泌量Δ = 0.91%, p ＜ .001)；萬步組相較控制組，降低空腹血糖值(Δ= -33.43%, p ＜ .001)、2小時葡萄糖耐糖值(Δ= -29.09%, p = 0.036)及糖化血色素(Δ= -0.69%, p ＜ .0001)，並增加急性胰島素反應分泌量(Δ= 0.63%, p ＜ .001)結論：本研究結果證實每日累計萬步運動相似於結構式有氧運動在葡萄糖代謝上具正面效益，進而能改善胰島β細胞功能。因此，鼓勵坐式生活型態的個案能以累計萬步運動取代結構式有氧運動，將運動融入生活並建立規律運動習慣。

Introduction: Regular exercise training has demonstrated beneficial effects on glycemic control. However, it is unknown if a pedometer-based intervention with a daily accumulation of a million steps would improve insulin action. This study's aim was to evaluate the efficacy of two types of exercise training as compared with a control group on pancreatic β-cell function. Methods: We conducted a randomized controlled trial of 109 diabetes patients, who were recruited from an Endocrinology & Metabolism outpatient clinic. Patients were randomly assigned into training groups, including 36 in a structured based (SB) and 37 in a pedometer-based million step (PBMS), and 36 in unchanged lifestyle control group (CC). All participants in training groups followed the indicated exercise protocols during experimental period of 12 weeks. Anthropometric measurements and related biochemistry were assessed before and after treatments. The pancreatic β-cell function were mainly evaluated by BIGTT-AIR (Beta-cell function, Insulin sensitivity, and Glucose Tolerance Test, acute insulin response) or BIGTT-SI (insulin sensitivity). Results: After 12weeks exercise intervention, the SB group was significantly decreased in FG (Δ = -32.63%, p ＜ .001), 2-h glucose (Δ = -24.64%, p = 0.047) and HbA1C(Δ = -0.77%, p ＜ .001), and improved BIGTT-AIR (Δ = 0.91%, p ＜ .001) as compared to control group; the PBMS group was significantly decreased in dreased (Δ = -32.63%, p ＜ .001), 2-h glucose (Δ = -24.64%, p = 0.047) and HbA1C (Δ = -0.77%, p ＜ .001), therefore significantly improved BIGTT-AIR (Δ = 0.91%, p ＜ .001). Conclusion: The study proved that pedometer-based million step training had the same effect as structured based group training, were effective in enhancing insulin action and in improving pancreatic β cell function. Hence, the pedometer-based million steps exercise will be the best choice, in deed can instead of structured based exercise for the sedentary people to build up the regular exercise behavior.

1. 甘乃文、祁崇溥(2011)。運動訓練對改善胰島素阻抗及調節脂締素地機制之探討。中華體育季刊，25(2)，213-225。
   連結：
2. 吳一德(2009)。大學新生健康體能商、血脂質及代謝症候群相關之研究。運動生理暨體能學報，9，41-52。
   連結：
3. 胡巧欣、吳一德(2010)。金門地區青少年健康體適能與運動行爲之研究。運動與遊憩研究，4(4)，1-16。
   連結：
4. 黃蒼海(2015)。耐力運動與飲食控制型塑骨骼系統之骨代謝與能量代謝觀。體育學報，48(1)，1-18。
   連結：
5. Asministration, Ministry of health and Welfare. (2016). Health 99 education resource department of health, executive yuan BMI test. Received from http://health99.hpa.gov.tw/OnlinkHealth/Onlink_BMI.aspx
6. Basu, R.,Breda, E.,Oberg, A. L.,Powell, C. C.,Dalla, M. C.,Basu, A.,Rizza, R. A.(2003).Mechanisms of the age-associated deterioration in glucose tolerance: Contribution of alterations in insulin secretion, action, and clearance.Diabetes,52(7),1738-1748.
7. Bloem, C. J.,Chang, A. M.(2009).Short-term exercise improves β cell function and insulin resistance in older people with impaired glucose tolerance.Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism,93(2),387-392.
8. Bohannon, R. W.(2007).Number of pedometer-assessed steps taken per day by adults: A descriptive meta-analysis.Physical Therapy,87(12),1642-1650.
9. Booth, F. W.,Gordon, S. E.,Carlson, C. J.,Hamilton, M. T.(2000).Waging war on modern chronic diseases: Primary prevention through exercise biology.Journal of Applied Physiology,88(2),774-787.
10. Campbell, H. M, Khan, N.,Cone, C.,Raisch, D. W.(2011).Relationship between diet, exercise habits, and health status among patients with diabetes.Research in Social and Administrative Pharmacy,7(2),151-161.
11. Chou, P.,Li, C. L.,Wu, G. S.,Tsai, S. T.(1998).Progression to type 2 diabetes among high-risk groups in Kin-Chen, Kinmen: Exploring the natural history of type 2 diabetes.Diabetes Care,21(7),1183-1187.
12. Egede, L. E.,Poston, M. E.(2004).Racial/ethnic differences in leisure-time physical activity levels among individuals with diabetes.Diabetes Care,27(10),2493-2494.
13. Eriksson, K. F.,Lindgarde, F.(1991).Prevention of type 2 (non-insulin-dependent) diabetes mellitus by diet and physical exercise. The 6-year Malmo feasibility study.Diabetologia,34(12),891-898.
14. Farin, H. M.,Abbasi, F.,Reaven, G. M.(2006).Body mass index and waist circumference both contribute to differences in insulin-mediated glucose disposal in nondiabetic adults.Am J Clin Nutr.,83(1),47-51.
15. Flakoll, P. J.,Kent, P.,Neyra, R.,Levenhagen, D.,Chen, K. Y.,Ikizler, T. A.(2004).Bioelectrical impedance vs air displacement plethysmography and dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry to determine body composition in patients with end-stage renal disease.Journal of parenteral and enteral nutrition,28(1),13-21.
16. Goodyear, L. J.,Hirshman, M. F.,Valyou, P. M.,Horton, E. S.(1992).Glucose transporter number, function, and subcellular distribution in rat skeletal muscle after exercise training.Diabetes,41(9),1091-1099.
17. Guion, W. K.,Carter, C. A.,Corwin, S. J.(1999).Knowledge of exercise in patients with diabetes mellitus.Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise,31,S361.
18. Hansen, T.,Drivsholm, T.,Urhammer, S. A.,Palacios, R. T.,Volund, A.,Borch-Johnsen, K.,Pedersen, O.(2007).The BIGTT test: A novel test for simultaneous measurement of pancreatic β-cell function, insulin sensitivity, and glucose tolerance.Diabetes Care,30(2),257-262.
19. Hays, L. M.,Clark, D. O.(1999).Correlates of physical activity in a sample of older adults with type 2 diabetes.Diabetes Care,22(5),706-712.
20. Laaksonen, D. E.,Lindström, J.,Lakka, T. A.,Eriksson, J. G.,Niskanen, L.,Wikström, K.,Uusitupa, M.(2005).Physical activity in the prevention of type 2 diabetes: The finnish diabetes prevention study.Diabetes,54(1),158-165.
21. McLaughlin, T.,Yee, G.,Glassford, A.,Lamendola, C.,Reaven, G.(2011).Use of a two-stage insulin infusion study to assess the relationship between insulin suppression of lipolysis and insulin-mediated glucose uptake in overweight/obese, nondiabetic women.Metabolism: Clinical and Experimental,60(12),1741-1747.
22. Michishita, R.,Shono, N.,Kasahara, T.,Tsuruta, T.(2008).Effects of low intensity exercise therapy on early phase insulin secretion in overweight subjects with impaired glucose tolerance and type 2 diabetes mellitus.Diabetes Research and Clinical Practice,82(3),291-297.
23. Nelson, K. M.,Reiber, G.,Boyko, E. J.(2002).Diet and exercise among adults with type 2 diabetes: Findings from the third national health and nutrition examination survey (NHANES III).Diabetes Care,25(10),1722-1728.
24. Pan, X. R.,Li, G. W.,Hu, Y. H.,Wang, J. X.,Yang, W. Y.,An, Z. X.,Howard, B. V.(1997).Effects of diet and exercise in preventing NIDDM in people with impaired glucose tolerance: The Da Qing IGT and diabetes study.Diabetes Care,20(4),537-544.
25. Shaw, J.(2011).Diagnosis of prediabetes.Medical Clinics of North America,95(2),341-352.
26. Shih, S. R.,Tseng, C. H.(2009).The effects of aging on glucose metabolism.Taiwan Geriatrics & Gerontology,4(1),27-38.
27. Slentz, C. A.,Tanner, C. J.,Bateman, L. A.,Durheim, M. T.,Huffman, K. M.,Houmard, J. A.,Kraus, W. E.(2009).Effects of exercise training intensity on pancreatic β-cell function.Diabetes Care,32(10),1807-1811.
28. Stumvoll, M.,Goldstein, B. J.,Van Haeften, T. W.(2005).Type 2 diabetes: Principles of pathogenesis and therapy.Lancet,365(9467),1333-1346.
29. Sweet, S. N.,Fortier, M. S.,Guérin, E.,Tulloch, H.,Sigal, R. J.,Kenny, G. P.,Reid, R. D.(2009).Understanding physical activity in adults with type 2 diabetes after completing an exercise intervention trial: A mediation model of self-efficacy andautonomous motivation.Psychology, Health & Medicine,14(4),419-429.
30. Taylor, L. M.,Spence, J. C.,Raine, K.,Plotnikoff, R. C.,Vallance, J. K.,Sharma, A. M.(2010).Physical activity and health-related quality of life in individuals with prediabetes.Diabetes Research and Clinical Practice,90(1),15-21.
31. Tsao, C. C.,Lin, K. H.,Lai, J. S.,Lan, C.(1995).Reliability of body fat measurement: Skindfold, bioelectrical impedance analysis and infrared.Journal of the Physical Therapy Association of the R.O.C.,20(2),102-109.
32. Tudor-Locke, C.,Bassett, D. R., Jr(2004).How many steps/day are enough? Preliminary pedometer indices for public health.Sports Medicine,34(1),1-8.
33. UK Prospective Diabetes Study=UKPDS(1995).Overview of six years' therapy of type 2dabetes-a progressive disease.Diabetes,44,1249-1258.
34. Wei, M.,Gibbons, L. W.,Kampert, J. B.,Nichaman, M. Z.,Blair, S. N.(2000).Low cardiorespiratory fitness and physical inactivity as predictors of mortality in men with type 2 diabetes.Annals of Internal Medicine,132(8),605-611.
35. Welk, G. J.,Differding, J. A.,Thompson, R. W.,Blair, S. N.,Dziura, J.,Hart, P.(2000).The utility of the digi-walker step counter to assess daily physical activity patterns.Medicine & Science in Sports and Exercise,32(9 Suppl),S481-S488.
36. Zhao, G.,Ford, E. S, Li, C.,Mokdad, A. H.(2008).Compliance with physical activity recommendations in US adults with diabetes.Diabetic Medicine,25(2),221-227.
37. 吳一德(2012)。身體活動、代謝症候群與健康生活品質相關之探討。中華體育季刊，24(2)，1-9。
38. 郭育倫(2007)。花蓮=Hualien，慈濟大學=Tzu Chi University。
39. 陳朝欽、雷孟桓(2010)。一個負面研究結果的正面含意─ACCORD 研究與第二型糖尿病人危險因子的控制。內科學誌，21，391-400。
40. 蔡明燕、黃盈翔、吳晉祥、張智仁、楊宜青(2007)。臺灣糖尿病衛教師執行運動諮詢現況調查。實證護理，4(2)，157-166。
41. 鄭綺(1997)。心臟病患者居家運動指導。護理雜誌，44(1)，24-29。

1. 蕭詠勳,張珍瑋,李柏勳,吳婉如(2023)。步行運動對糖尿病控制改善成效：統合分析。源遠護理，17(1)，70-80。