题名

Comparison of battle rope training using high-intensity interval and power-oriented protocols on softball-specific performance in adolescent female softball players

并列篇名

高強度間歇及爆發力導向的戰繩訓練對青少女壘球選手專項表現之比較

DOI

10.6222/pej.202209_55(3).0002

作者

陳韋翰(Wei-Han Chen);劉雅甄(Ya-Chen Liu);楊雯雯(Wen-Wen Yang);陳美分(Mei-Fen Chen);黃長福(Chen-Fu Huang);劉強(Chiang Liu)

关键词

power rope ; ballistic movement ; kinetic chain ; performance ; specificity ; 力量繩 ; 彈震式動作 ; 動力鏈 ; 運動表現 ; 專項特殊性

期刊名称

體育學報

卷期/出版年月

55卷3期(2022 / 09 / 01)

页次

245 - 261

内容语文

英文

中文摘要

Introduction: This study compared the effects of battle rope (BR) training combined with high-intensity interval training (HIIT) or power-oriented training (POT) on the performance of adolescent female softball players. Methods: Sixteen female softball players (fielders aged 12-14 years) recruited from the same team were randomly assigned to either the HIIT or the POT group. Both groups received 10 weeks of BR training involving three sessions per week; the protocol consisted of 4-5 consecutive sets of four whole-body BR exercises. In the HIIT group, each exercise was performed for 15 s (eight repetitions), with a 45-s rest interval between exercises. In the POT group, each exercise included eight repetitions, with 5-s and 120-s rest intervals between repetitions and exercises, respectively. A paired t-test was used to assess the difference between pretraining and posttraining performance. An independent t-test was used to compare the percentage change in performance from pretraining to posttraining between groups. Results: Both groups exhibited significant improvements in aerobic capacity (1600-m running time), finger strength, trunk rotational power, bat swing velocity, and throwing velocity (p < .05). The HIIT and POT groups did not differ significantly in the rate of change in performance in all tests. Notably, among players with slower swing velocity (45-67 km/h) at pretraining, the POT group (n = 4) showed greater posttraining improvement (26.7%) in bat swing velocity than the HIIT group (n = 4; 19.7%)(Mann-Whitney U test; p < .05). Conclusion: BR training combined with HIIT and that combined with POT have similar effects on adolescent female softball players' performance. BR training with HIIT is time-efficient, while that with POT appears more advantageous for improving bat swing velocity in players with lower skill levels. In practical applications, if the aim is time-efficient improvement of softball performance of adolescent players, the BR program with HIIT is recommended. If the goal of training is maximization of one-time explosive movement performance, specifically the bat swing of players with a low skill level, the BR program with POT is recommended.

英文摘要

前言:本研究比較戰繩訓練採用高強度間歇訓練(high-intensity interval training, HIIT)和力量導向訓練(power-oriented training, POT)處方對青少女壘球選手專項表現的影響。方法:16位來自同一支球隊的女壘球員(12-14歲,外野手)被隨機分配到HIIT組或POT組。兩組均接受每週3次,共10週的戰繩訓練;每次訓練包括4個全身性戰繩動作,共執行4至5組。在HIIT組中,每個動作皆進行15秒連續最大反覆甩繩(約8下重複),每個動作之間休息45秒。在POT組中,每個動作進行8下非連續最大反覆甩繩,每下反覆之間休息5秒、每個動作之間休息120秒。使用相依樣本t檢定評估組內訓練前和訓練後之間的差異。使用獨立樣本t檢定比較組間訓練前-後的變化率差異。結果:兩組的有氧能力(1600公尺跑步時間)、手指肌力、軀幹旋轉爆發力、揮棒速度和投球速度均顯著進步(p < .05)。HIIT和POT組之間所有測驗項目的訓練前-後變化率均無顯著差異。值得注意的是,在訓練前揮棒速度較慢(45-67公里/小時)的球員中,POT組(n = 4; 26.7%)比HIIT組(n = 4; 19.7%)有較佳的進步率(p < .05);此統計結果是使用Mann-Whitney U檢定所得。結論:採用HIIT或POT處方的戰繩訓練對青少女壘球選手專項表現具有相似的訓練效果。值得注意的是,採用HIIT處方的戰繩訓練具有較佳的時間效率,而採用POT處方的戰繩訓練則似乎在提高技術水平較低的球員在揮棒速度方面具有更好的優勢。在實務應用中,如果訓練的目的是要在有時間效率下提高青少年壘球選手的各項專項表現,推薦使用HIIT的戰繩訓練。如果訓練的目標是最大限度地提高一次性爆發力動作表現,尤其是針對揮棒技術水平較低的球員,則建議採用POT的戰繩訓練。

主题分类 社會科學 > 體育學
参考文献
  1. Chen, J. H.,Chan, C. N.,Tang, W. T.,Ting Heng, S.(2019).The differences of physical characteristics and physical fitness between elite children and adolescent golfers.Journal of Sports Performance,6(1),43-48.
    連結:
  2. Chen, W. H.,Huang, C. F.,Liu, C.(2018).Battle rope training methods and effects: A systematic review.Quarterly of Chinese Physical Education,32(4),303-320.
    連結:
  3. Lin, C. L.,Huang, C. F.(2011).The correlation between trunk rotation and ball speed in baseball pitching.Chinese Journal of Sports Biomechanics,4,10-17.
    連結:
  4. Lin, H. F.(2000).Correlation among 1600mrunning, 1600m fast-walking and maximal oxygen uptake.Physical Education Journal,28,379-388.
    連結:
  5. Sato, K.,Driggers, A.(2019).Strength and conditioning transferring to performance from baseball perspective.Physical Education Journal,52(3),281-293.
    連結:
  6. Wu, T. H.,Chou, K. Y.,Chang, M. J.,Hsu, H. J.,Chang, H. Y.(2018).Comparison of different jumping direction of plyometric training on lower limbs jumping ability and agility for collegiate athletes.Chinese Journal of Sports Biomechanics,15(1),43-50.
    連結:
  7. Antony, B.,Maheswri, M. U.,Palanisamy, A.(2015).Impact of battle rope and Bulgarian bag high intensity interval training protocol on selected strength and physiological variables among school level athletes.Indian Journal of Applied Research,1(8),403-406.
  8. Balsalobre-Fernández, C.,Santos-Concejero, J.,Grivas, G. V.(2016).Effects of strength training on running economy in highly trained runners: A systematic review with meta-analysis of controlled trials.Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research,30(8),2361-2368.
  9. Balyi, I.,Hamilton, A.(2004).Long-term athlete development: Trainability in childhood and adolescence.Olympic Coach,16(1),4-9.
  10. Chen, W. H.,Wu, H. J.,Lo, S. L.,Chen, H.,Yang, W. W.,Huang, C. F.,Liu, C.(2018).Eight-week battle rope training improves multiple physical fitness dimensions and shooting accuracy in collegiate basketball players.Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research,32(10),2715-2724.
  11. Chen, W. H.,Yang, W. W.,Lee, Y. H.,Wu, H. J.,Huang, C. F.,Liu, C.(2020).Acute effects of battle rope exercise on performance, blood lactate levels, perceived exertion, and muscle soreness in collegiate basketball players.Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research,34(10),2857-2866.
  12. Cohen, J. D.,Usher, M.,McClelland, J. L.(1998).A PDP approach to set size effects within the Stroop task: Reply to Kanne, Balota, Spieler, and Faust (1998).Psychological Review,105(1),188-194.
  13. Derenne, C.,Ho, K. W.,Murphy, J. C.(2001).Effects of general, special, and specific resistance training on throwing velocity in baseball: A brief review.Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research,15(1),148-156.
  14. DiStefano, L. J.,DiStefano, M. J.,Frank, B. S.,Clark, M. A.,Padua, D. A.(2013).Comparison of integrated and isolated training on performance measures and neuromuscular control.Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research,27(4),1083-1090.
  15. Escamilla, R. F.,Ionno, M.,Scott deMahy, M.,Fleisig, G. S.,Wilk, K. E.,Yamashiro, K.,Mikla, T.,Paulos, L.,Andrews, J. R.(2012).Comparison of three baseballspecific 6-week training programs on throwing velocity in high school baseball players.Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research,26(7),1767-1781.
  16. Fountaine, C. J.,Schmidt, B. J.(2015).Metabolic cost of rope training.Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research,29(4),889-893.
  17. Gabbett, T.,Georgieff, B.,Domrow, N.(2007).The use of physiological, anthropometric, and skill data to predict selection in a talent-identified junior volleyball squad.Journal of Sports Sciences,25(12),1337-1344.
  18. Gibala, M. J.,Little, J. P.,MacDonald, M. J.,Hawley, J. A.(2012).Physiological adaptations to low‐volume, high‐intensity interval training in health and disease.The Journal of physiology,590(5),1077-1084.
  19. Hardee, J. P.,Lawrence, M. M.,Utter, A. C.,Triplett, N. T.,Zwetsloot, K. A.,McBride, J. M.(2012).Effect of inter-repetition rest on ratings of perceived exertion during multiple sets of the power clean.European Journal of Applied Physiology,112(8),3141-3147.
  20. Kuklick, C. R.,Martino, M. A.,Black, C. D.(2013).Throwing velocity and stamina in baseball pitchers as a function of training methods.Journal of Australian Strength and Conditioning,21(2),19-31.
  21. Lehman, G.,Drinkwater, E. J.,Behm, D. G.(2013).Correlation of throwing velocity to the results of lower-body field tests in male college baseball players.Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research,27(4),902-908.
  22. Liu, C.,Liu, Y. C.,Kao, Y. C.,Shiang, T. Y.(2011).Effects of training with a dynamic moment of inertia bat on swing performance.Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research,25(11),2999-3005.
  23. Morales-Artacho, A. J.,García-Ramos, A.,PérezCastilla, A.,Padial, P.,Gomez, A. M.,Peinado, A. M.,Pérez-Córdoba, J. L.,Feriche, B.(2019).Muscle activation during power-oriented resistance training: Continuous vs. cluster set configurations.Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research,33,95-102.
  24. Nakata, H.,Nagami, T.,Higuchi, T.,Sakamoto, K.,Kanosue, K.(2013).Relationship between performance variables and baseball ability in youth baseball players.Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research,27(10),2887-2897.
  25. Oliver, G. D.,Keeley, D. W.(2010).Pelvis and torso kinematics and their relationship to shoulder kinematics in high-school baseball pitchers.Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research,24(12),3241-3246.
  26. Pappas, A. M.,Zawacki, R. M.,Sullivan, T. J.(1985).Biomechanics of baseball pitching: A preliminary report.American Journal of Sports Medicine,13(4),216-222.
  27. Pedegana, L. R.,Elsner, R. C.,Roberts, D.,Lang, J.,Farewell, V.(1982).The relationship of upper extremity strength to throwing speed.American Journal of Sports Medicine,10(6),352-354.
  28. Pion, J. A.,Fransen, J.,Deprez, D. N.,Segers, V. I.,Vaeyens, R.,Philippaerts, R. M.,Lenoir, M.(2015).Stature and jumping height are required in female volleyball, but motor coordination is a key factor for future elite success.Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research,29(6),1480-1485.
  29. Potter, D. L.,Johnson, L. V.(2007).Softball: Steps to success.Human Kinetics.
  30. Raaj, K. M. P.,Rosario, C. K.(2017).Impact of battle rope training on selected physical fitness components and performance variables among volleyball players.PARIPEX-Indian Journal of Research,6(4),579-580.
  31. Ratamess, N. A.,Rosenberg, J. G.,Klei, S.,Dougherty, B. M.,Kang, J.,Smith, C. R.,Ross, R. E.,Faigenbaum, A. D.(2015).Comparison of the acute metabolic responses to traditional resistance, body-weight, and battling rope exercises.Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research,29(1),47-57.
  32. Ratamess, N. A.,Smith, C. R.,Beller, N. A.,Kang, J.,Faigenbaum, A. D.,Bush, J. A.(2015).Effects of rest interval length on acute battling rope exercise metabolism.Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research,29(9),2375-2387.
  33. Salonia, M. A.,Chu, D. A.,Cheifetz, P. M.,Freidhoff, G. C.(2004).Upper-body power as measured by medicine-ball throw distance and its relationship to class level among 10-and 11-year-old female participants in club gymnastics.Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research,18(4),695-702.
  34. Seroyer, S. T.,Nho, S. J.,Bach, B. R.,Bush-Joseph, C. A.,Nicholson, G. P.,Romeo, A. A.(2010).The kinetic chain in overhand pitching: Its potential role for performance enhancement and injury prevention.Sports Health,2(2),135-146.
  35. Slimani, M.,Chamari, K.,Miarka, B.,Del Vecchio, F. B.,Chéour, F.(2016).Effects of plyometric training on physical fitness in team sport athletes: A systematic review.Journal of Human Kinetics,53,231.
  36. Spaniol, F.(2002).Physiological predictors of bat speed and throwing velocity in adolescent baseball players.Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research,16,16.
  37. Stodden, D. F.,Campbell, B. M.,Moyer, T. M.(2008).Comparison of trunk kinematics in trunk training exercises and throwing.Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research,22(1),112-118.
  38. Szymanski, D. J.,DeRenne, C.,Spaniol, F. J.(2009).Contributing factors for increased bat swing velocity.Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research,23(4),1338-1352.
  39. Szymanski, D. J.,Mcintyre, J. S.,Szymanski, J. M.,Bradford, T. J.,Schade, R. L.,Madsen, N. H.,Pascoe, D. D.(2007).Effect of torso rotational strength on angular hip, angular shoulder, and linear bat velocities of high school baseball players.Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research,21(4),1117-1125.
  40. Szymanski, D. J.,Szymanski, J. M.,Schade, R. L.,Bradford, T. J.(2008).Relationship between physiological variables and linear bat swing velocity of high school baseball players.Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise,40(5),422.
  41. Turner, T.,Moody, J. A.,Byrne, P. J.,Hughes, M. G.,Smith, P. M.,Cooper, S. M.(2018).Effect of upper-body high intensity interval training on exercise performance in professional cricket players.Open Access Journal of Sports Medicine,2(1),10.
  42. Van Den Tillaar, R.(2004).Effect of different training programs on the velocity of overarm throwing: A brief review.Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research,18(2),388-396.
  43. Yanagisawa, O.,Taniguchi, H.(2018).Changes in lower extremity function and pitching performance with increasing numbers of pitches in baseball pitchers.Journal of Exercise Rehabilitation,14(3),430.
  44. Young, W. B.(2006).Transfer of strength and power training to sports performance.International Journal of Sports Physiology and Performance,1(2),74-83.
被引用次数
  1. (2024)。創新之動態轉動慣量球棒對揮擊期間揮棒速度與肌肉活化之影響。體育學報,57(2),141-153。