體育課程模式實施之學生觀點文獻分析－以體育教學期刊（JTPE）為例

A Literature Analysis of Students' Perspectives in Implementing Physical Education Curriculum Models: Taking Journal of Teaching Physical Education (JTPE) for Example

10.6223/qcpe.2701.201303.1303

顏宛平(Wan-Ping Yan)；掌慶維(Ching-Wei Chang)

學生中心課程 ； 學習者主體 ； 經驗課程 ； 教學模式 ； student-centered ； student-centered ； experienced curriculum ； instruct tional models

中華體育季刊

27卷1期（2013 / 03 / 01）

15 - 22

繁體中文

本研究旨在分析體育教學期刊（Journal of Teaching Physical Education, JTPE）從1991至2012年之間，體育課程模式實施之學生觀點研究，以瞭解該研究議題的國際現況，做為臺灣體育課程教學研究與實務推展者之參考。文獻蒐集採逐篇檢視，獲得文獻15篇，包含運動教育模式、合作學習模式、責任模式與探索教育模式等4種課程模式，利用歸納法進行分析，形成「經驗與態度」、「小組運作」、「角色扮演」與「學習遷移」四個主題，從文獻中歸結出體育課程模式在實施過程中，學生所建構的經驗意義以正向為主，呼應教育改革之理念，但教師仍需透過教學策略協助小組運作與角色扮演，以降低學生負向經驗的產生，而如何具體幫助學生學習遷移的意義連結，則仍需做進一步的探討。

The purpose of this study was to analyze empirical studies of students' perspectives on implementing physical education curriculum models from Journal of Teaching Physical Education (1991-2012) so that we could understand the research agenda of the international status quo, providing Taiwanese physical education researchers and practitioners referential guidelines of quality physical education curriculum and instruction. Articles were examined one by one, and 15 were collected, which included Sport Education model, Cooperative Learning model, Responsibility model, and Adventure Education model. By using the inductive method analysis, the four themes ”experience and attitudes”, ”group operation”, ”role-playing” and ”transfer of learning” were abstracted. Finally, it was concluded that students constructed positive meaning in the process of implementing physical education curriculum models, which echoed the philosophy of education reforms, but teachers still needed to help group operation and role-playing by using teaching reflections and strategies to reduce students' negative experience. As for how to help students to link the meaningful learning, further studies will be required.

1. Azzarito, L.,Ennis, C.(2003).A sense of connection: Toward social constructivist physical education.Sport, Education & Society,8(2),179-198.
2. Bunker, D.,Thorpe, R.(1982).A model for the teaching of games in the secondary school.Bulletin of Physical Education,10,9-16.
3. Carlson, T. B.(1995).We hate gym: Student alienation from physical education.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,14(4),467-477.
4. Carlson, T. B.,Hastie, P. A.(1997).The student social system within sport education.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,16,176-195.
5. Cothran, D. J.,Kulinna, P. H.(2006).Students' perspectives on direct, peer, and inquiry teaching strategies.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,25,166-181.
6. Dyson, B.(2002).The implementation of cooperative learning in an elementary school physical education program.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,22,69-85.
7. Dyson, B.(2001).Cooperative learning in an elementary physical education program.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,20,264-281.
8. Dyson, B. P.(1995).Students' voices in two alternative elementary physical education programs.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,14,394-407.
9. Dyson, B.,Linehan, N.,Hastie, P. A.(2010).The ecology of cooperative learning in elementary physical education classes.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,29,113-130.
10. Gehris, J.,Kress, J.,Swalm, R.(2010).Students' views on physical development and physical self-concept in adventure physical education.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,29,146-166.
11. Goodlad, J.(1979).Curriculum inquiry: The study of curriculum practice.New York:McGraw-Hill.
12. Gordon, B.(2010).An examination of the responsibility model in a New Zealand secondary school physical education program.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,29,21-37.
13. Gurvitch, R.,Metzler, M.(2010).Keeping the purpose in mind: The implementation of instructional models in physical education settings.Strategies,23(3),32-35.
14. Hastie, P. A.(1996).Student role involvement during a unit of sport education.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,16,88-103.
15. Hastie, P. A.(1998).The participation and perception of girls within a unit of sport education.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,17,157-171.
16. Hastie, P. A.(2000).An ecological analysis of a sport education season.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,19,355-373.
17. Hellison, D.(1978).Beyond balls and bats: Alienated (and other) youth in the gym.Washington, DC:AAHPER.
18. Jackson, P. W.(Ed.)(1992).The handbook of research on curriculum: A project of the American Research Association.New York:Macmillan.
19. Kinchin, G. D.,O''Sullivan, M.(2003).Incidences of student support for and resistance to curricular innovation in high school physical education.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,22,245-260.
20. Lee, A. M.,Solmon, A. M.(1992).Cognitive conceptions of teaching and learning motor skills.Quest,44,57-71.
21. Macdonald, D.(Ed.),Kirk, D.(Ed.),O''Sullivan, M.(Ed.)(2006).The handbook of physical education.Great Britain:Sage.
22. MacPhail, A.,Kirk, D.,Kinchin, G.(2004).Sport education: Promoting team affiliation through physical education.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,23,106-122.
23. Mowling, C. M.,Brock, S. J.,Hastie, P. A.(2006).Fourth grade students' drawing interpretations of a sport education soccer unit.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,25,9-35.
24. Nugent, P.,Faucette, N.(1995).Marginalized voices: Constructions of and responses to physical education and grading practices by students categorized as gifted or learning disabled.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,14,418-430.
25. Oliver, K. L.,Lalik, R.(2004).Critical inquiry on the body in girls' physical education classes: A critical poststructural perspective.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,23(2),162-195.
26. Sanders, S.,Graham, G.(1995).Kindergarten children's initial experiences in physical education: The relentless persistence for play clashes with the zone of acceptable responses.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,14,365-372.
27. Siedentop, D.(1968).Bloomington, IN.,Indiana University.
28. Sinelnikov, O. A.,Hastie, P. A.(2010).Students' autobiographical memory of participation in multiple sport education seasons.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,29,167-83.
29. Smith, S. J.(1991).Where is the children in physical education research?.Quest,43,37-54.
30. Trout, J.,Graber, K.(2009).Perceptions of overweight students concerning their experiences in physical education.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,28,272-292.
31. Wright, P. M.,Burton, S.(2008).Implementation and outcomes of responsibility-based physical activity program integrated into an intact high school physical education class.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,27,138-154.

1. 黃正杰、林靜萍(2016)。高中生在校課間及課後運動經驗探討─以新北市某高中學生為例。臺灣運動教育學報，11(1)，35-50。
2. 林靜萍、呂亦航(2016)。國中體育課之學生文化。靜宜體育，10，26-36。
3. 闕月清、黃志成(2017)。國小理解式排球教學之教室生態。臺灣運動教育學報，12(2)，15-34。
4. 謝豐宇(2016)。大學生運動參與情形與體育課程滿意度之研究─以北部一所綜合大學為例。臺灣運動教育學報，11(2)，21-38。