體感遊戲Wii和Kinect在技術特性與使用效果之比較

The Difference of Technology Characteristics and Usage Effect between Wii and Kinect

10.3966/102473002015092903009

張佑瑄(Yu-Hsuan Chang)；劉雅甄(Ya-Chen Liu)

體感遊戲 ； 虛擬運動 ； 任天堂 ； Xbox ； action video game ； virtual sports ； Nintendo ； Xbox

中華體育季刊

29卷3期（2015 / 09 / 01）

237 - 245

繁體中文

Wii與Kinect為市面上主要且最多人使用的體感遊戲，這兩款體感遊戲在技術應用上有所不同，Wii透過控制器進行操作，而Kinect則透過使用者全身肢體動作進行操作，這對於使用者的能量消耗、體適能、運動表現及運動傷害可能造成不同的影響。因此，本文主要是針對Wii和Kinect的技術特點、能量消耗、體適能、運動表現、視覺能力、運動傷害等方面進行文獻回顧與整理，結果發現使用Wii與Kinect能提升能量消耗、心肺能力、肌力、平衡能力、反應能力、視覺能力與桌球、棒球的運動技巧，雖然能有以上的益處，但體感遊戲仍與真實運動有些微差異；而利用全身進行控制且有較大活動範圍的Kinect比Wii有更多的效益。

Wii and Kinect are the most people use devices on the market of the action video game. The technology application are different between two action video games. Wii is operated by controller and Kinect is operated by user body movements. This difference might potentially causes different responses on energy expended, physical fitness, sport performance, visual ability and sport injury. Therefore, the purpose of this article was to review the research literatures on the topics of technical characteristics, energy expended, physical fitness, sport performance and sport injury between Wii and Kinect. The results showed that energy expended, cardiovascular function, muscle strength, balance ability, response ability, visual ability, table tennis and baseball skills improved after using Wii and/or Kinect. However, there was a slight difference between the real sports and the action video games. It concluded that Kinect, which was a wide range of movement due to operate by using body movements, has more benefits than Wii.

1. 江東軒、洪偉欽(2011)。玩Wii 所造成的運動傷害預防及處理。中華體育季刊，25(2)，253-261。
   連結：
2. 沈祖望、溫蕙甄(2011)。探討互動式遊戲介入模式對健康族群與疾病復健之影響。中華體育季刊，25(2)，262-272。
   連結：
3. 張哲千(2008)。遊戲機Wii 的運動體驗。大專體育，98，88-93。
   連結：
4. 陳上迪、姜義村(2013)。體感式遊戲對養護機構高齡者簡單反應力之影響。大專體育學刊，15(3)，277-287。
   連結：
5. Chiang, I. T.,Chen, M. L.,Chang, P. S.,Lee, J. Y.(2011).Effects of a video game-based intervention on balance learning for institution-dwelling elderly in veterans home.The 2011 International Educational Technology Conference,Istanbul, Turkey:
6. Chiang, I. T.,Tsai, J. C.,Chen, S. T.(2012).Using Xbox 360 kinect games on enhancing visual performance skills on institutionalized older adults with wheelchairs.2012 IEEE Fourth International Conference on Digital Game and Intell: Gent Toy Enhanced Learning,Talamatsu, Japan:
7. Clark, R. A.,Bryant, A. L.,Pua, Y.,McCrory, P.,Bennell, K.,Hunt, M.(2010).Validity and reliability of the Nintendo Wii Balance Board for assessment of standing balance.Gait & posture,31(3),307-310.
8. Davaasambuu, E.,Chiang, C.,Chiang, J. Y.,Chen, Y.,Bilgee, S.(2012).A Microsoft Kinect based virtual rehabilitation system.5th International Conference on Frontiers of Information Technology, Applications and Tools,Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia:
9. Graf, D. L.,Pratt, L. V.,Hester, C. N.,Short, K. R.(2009).Playing active video games increases energy expenditure in children.Pediatrics,124(2),534-540.
10. Graves, L.,Ridgers, N. D.,Stratton, G.(2008).The contribution of upper limb and total body movement to adolescents' energy expenditure whilst playing Nintendo Wii.European Journal of AppliedPhysiology,104(4),617-623.
11. Graves, L.,Stratton, G.,Ridgers, N. D.,Cable, N. T.(2007).Comparison of energy expenditure in adolescents when playing new generation and sedentary computer games: Cross sectional study.British Medical Journal,335(7633),1282-1284.
12. Green, C. S.,Bavelier, D.(2006).Enumeration versus multiple object tracking: The case of action video game players.Cognition,101(1),217-245.
13. Green, C. S.,Bavelier, D.(2007).Action-video-game experience alters the spatial resolution of vision.Psychological science,18(1),88-94.
14. Gribbon, A.,McNeil, J.,Jay, O.,Tremblay, M. S.,Chaput, J. P.(2015).Active video games and energy balance in male adolescents: A randomized crossover trial.The American journal of clinical nutrition,15,14-16.
15. Herring, S. A.,Nilson, K. L.(1987).Introduction to overuse injuries.Clinics in Sports Medicine,6(2),225-239.
16. Hertel, R.,Ballmer, F. T.,Lambert, S. M.,Gerber, C. H.(1996).Lag signs in the diagnosis of rotator cuff rupture.Journal of Shoulder and Elbow Surgery,5(4),307-313.
17. Huie, G.(2002).Diagnosing bursitis in the knee.JAAPA,15,14-16.
18. Jepsen, J. R.,Thomsen, G.(2006).A cross-sectional study of the relation between symptoms and physical findings in computer operators.BMC Neurology,6(1),40.
19. Lanningham-Foster, L.,Foster, R. C.,McCrady, S. K.,Jensen, T. B.,Mitre, N.,Levine, J. A.(2009).Activity-promoting video games and increased energy expenditure.The Journal of Pediatrics,154(6),819-823.
20. Leatherdale, S. T.,Woodruff, S. J.,Manske, S. R.(2010).Energy expenditure while playing active and inactive video games.American Journal of Health Behavior,34(1),31-35.
21. Lee, J. C.(2008).Hacking the nintendowii remote.Pervasive Computing, IEEE,7(3),39-45.
22. Li, R.,Polat, U.,Makous, W.,Bavelier, D.(2009).Enhancing the contrast sensitivity function through action video game training.Nature Neuroscience,12(5),549-551.
23. Mills, A.,Rosenberg, M.,Stratton, G.,Carter, H. H.,Spence, A. L.,Pugh, C. J.,Naylor, L. H.(2013).The effect of exergaming on vascular function in children.The Journal of Pediatrics,163(3),806-810.
24. Nett, M. P.,Collins, M. S.,Sperling, J. W.(2008).Magnetic resonance imaging of acute "wiiitis" of the upper extremity.Skeletal Radiology,37(5),481-483.
25. Nicholson, V. P.,McKean, M.,Lowe, J.,Fawcett, C.,Burkett, B.(2015).Six weeks of unsupervised nintendo wii fit gaming is effective at improving balance in independent older adults.Journal of Aging and Physical activity,23(1),153-158.
26. O'Donovan, C.,Hirsch, E.,Holohan, E.,McBride, I.,McManus, R.,Hussey, J.(2012).Energy expended playing Xbox Kinect™ and Wii™ games: A preliminary study comparing single and multiplayer modes.Physiotherapy,98(3),224-229.
27. Quaiser-Pohl, C.,Geiser, C.,Lehmann, W.(2006).The relationship between computer-game preference, gender, and mental-rotation ability.Personality and Individual Differences,40(3),609-619.
28. Ravussin, E.,Lillioja, S.,Anderson, T. E.,Christin, L.,Bogardus, C.(1986).Determinants of 24-hour energy expenditure in man. Methods and results using a respiratory chamber.Journal of Clinical Investigation,78(6),1568.
29. Robinson, R. J.,Barron, D. A.,Grainger, A. J.,Venkatesh, R.(2008).Wii knee.Emergency Radiology,15(4),255-257.
30. Rowland, J. L.,Rimmer, J. H.(2012).Feasibility of using active video gaming as a means for increasing energy expenditure in three nonambulatory young adults with disabilities.PM & R,4(8),569-573.
31. Scheer, K. C.,Siebrandt, S. M.,Brown, G. A.,Shaw, B. S.,Shaw, I.(2014).Wii, Kinect, move, heart rate, oxygen consumption, energy expenditure, and ventilation due to different physically active video game systems in college students.International Journal of Exercise Science,7(1),4.
32. Smallwood, S. R.,Morris, M. M.,Fallows, S. J.,Buckley, J. P.(2012).Physiologic responses and energy expenditure of Kinect active video game play in schoolchildren.Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine,166(11),1005-1009.
33. Sparks, D.,Chase, D.,Coughlin, L.(2009).Wii have a problem: A review of self-reported Wii related injuries.Informatics in Primary Care,17(1),55-57.
34. Vernadakis, N.,Derri, V.,Tsitskari, E.,Antoniou, P.(2014).The effect of Xbox Kinect intervention on balance ability for previously injured young competitive male athletes: A preliminary study.Physical Therapy in Sport,15(3),148-155.
35. White, K.,Schofield, G.,Kilding, A. E.(2011).Energy expended by boys playing active video games.Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport,14(2),130-134.
36. Willems, M.,Bond, T.(2009).Comparison of physiological and metabolic responses to playing Nintendo Wii Sports and brisk treadmill walking.Journal of Human Kinetics,22,43-49.
37. Zhang, Z.(2012).Microsoft kinect sensor and its effect.MultiMedia, IEEE,19(2),4-10.
38. 王艾伶(2013)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。臺北市，臺北市立大學。
39. 林子恩(2011)。探討虛擬遊戲對精神分裂症患者之體適能影響。休閒運動保健學報，1，66-75。
40. 許智翔(2011)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。臺南市，崑山科技大學。
41. 陳昱文(2008)。淺談新世代遊戲機─Wii 對提升身體健康之影響。臺中教育大學體育學系系刊，3，94-97。
42. 廖秀鈺(2011)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。雲林縣，國立雲林科技大學。
43. 廖美惠(2007)。從目前社會大眾對Wii 健康遊戲機接受及風行的情形，您認為其對民眾參與身體活動的影響如何？。中華體育季刊，21(4)，131-137。
44. 蔡宏泰(2010)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。臺南市，國立臺南大學。

1. 楊博軒,郭怡伶,王立亭(2021)。體感遊戲對高齡者認知功能影響之系統性文獻回顧。大專體育，156，35-53。