運動情境中道德脫離之探究

Retrospect previous studies on moral disengagement in sports and propose future direction

10.3966/102473002017033101009

潘敏(Min Pan)；鄭溫暖(Wen-Nuan-Kara Cheng)；李光武(Kuang-Wu Lee)

運動道德脫測量工具 ； 反社會行為 ； 責備歸因 ； 責任推卸 ； moral disengagement in sports measurement ； antisocial behavior ； attribution of blame ； nonresponsibility

中華體育季刊

31卷1期（2017 / 03 / 01）

65 - 73

繁體中文

運動中的各種行為一直是相關領域研究的重點，而為了減少運動領域中的反社會行為的出現，研究者須瞭解此行為背後可能的成因。Boardley與Kavussanu (2007)將Bandura (1991)提出的道德脫離模式應用在運動脈絡中，研究運動中的道德脫離與反社會行為間的關係。為與時並進，本研究回顧至今有關運動中道德脫離之中英文文獻，整理重要結果：一、目前已發展出長、短各一之英文測驗量表，與兩款中文量表；二、統整發現運動脈絡中的道德脫離會導致反社會行為的出現，而參與團隊開放性運動之運動員相較於個人封閉性項目之運動員，有較高的道德脫離情況；男性運動員之道德脫離狀況高於女性運動員；競技水準較高之運動員也顯示有較高的道德脫離；三、教練的風格、情緒、自我定位、動機與人格特質都會對運動員的道德脫離產生影響。最後本研究建議未來如何改善現有量表，發展出適用於國內的測量工具，並進一步瞭解運動脈絡中道德脫離之其他因素，如何透過教育改善運動員的道德脫離狀況，以期在深入瞭解道德脫離後，能發展出有效改善運動員反社會行為之策略。

Behaviors in sports have been one of the research focuses for long. The possible causes of these deviant behaviors should be deterred to diminish such behaviors. Boardley and Kavussanu (2007) introduced the moral disengagement mechanisms by Bandura (1996) into the sport research to identify the relationship between moral disengagement and antisocial behaviors in sports. The studies on moral disengagement in sports gained great attention internationally since then however studies regarding such issue are rather scarce in Taiwan. Hence, the study reviewed the findings of domestic and international researches on moral disengagement in sport so forth and summarized: 1. current instruments available - moral disengagement in sports, moral disengagement in sports - short, and two Chinese version scales; 2. It has been proved that moral disengagement in sport would render antisocial behaviors in sport context. It is also found players in team contact sports (e.g. basketball, football, and hockey) have higher moral disengagement at play. Male athletes tend to have higher moral disengagement than their female counterparts. Athletes competing in higher level also show higher moral disengagement; 3. Factors such as coaching styles, emotion, self-orientation, motivation, and personality traits may deter the severity of moral disengagement of athletes hence further spur the antisocial behaviors in sports. Finally, it is suggested that a measurement of moral disengagement adequate for Taiwanese athletes and effective strategies for improving the antisocial behaviors should be developed based on the knowledge of moral disengagement in sports.

1. 周室宏、徐偉庭、陳文長(2011)。運動情境中的道德脫離：社會認知理論取向之新方向。臺灣運動教育學報，6(2)，19-30。
   連結：
2. 潘敏、鄭溫暖(2014)。大專運動員於競技情境中之道德脫離：量表編製與現況分析。成大體育學刊，46(1)，13-33。
   連結：
3. 蔡俊傑、羅鴻仁、管世弘(2012)。運動道德解離量表之編製。大專體育學刊，14(1)，40-53。
   連結：
4. (1991).Handbook of moral behavior and development: Theory, research, and applications.Hillsdale, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
5. Bandura, A.(2002).Selective moral disengagement in the exercise of moral agency.Journal of Moral Education,31,101-119.
6. Bandura, A.(1999).Moral disengagement in the perpetration of inhumanities.Personality and Social Psychology Review,3,193-209.
7. Bandura, A.,Barbaranelli, C.,Caprara, G. V.,Pastorelli, C.(1996).Mechanism of moral disengagement in the exercise of moral agency.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,71,364-374.
8. Boardley, I. D.,Grix, J.,Dewar, A.(2014).Moral disengagement and associated processes in performance enhancing drug use: A national qualitative investigation.Journal of Sport Sciences,32,836-844.
9. Boardley, I. D.,Kavussanu, M.(2008).The moral disengagement in sport scale - short.Journal of Sports Sciences,26(14),1507-1517.
10. Boardley, I. D.,Kavussanu, M.(2010).Effects of goal orientation and perceived value of toughness on antisocial behavior in soccer: The mediating role of moral disengagement.Journal of Sport & Exercise Psychology,32,176-192.
11. Boardley, I. D.,Kavussanu, M.(2009).The prosocial and antisocial behavior in sport scale.Journal of Sport & Exercise Psychology,31,97-117.
12. Boardley, I. D.,Kavussanu, M.(2009).The influence of social variables and moral disengagement on prosocial and antisocial behaviours in field hockey and netball.Journal of Sports Sciences,27(8),843-854.
13. Boardley, I. D.,Kavussanu, M.(2011).Moral disengagement in sport.International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology,4(2),93-108.
14. Boardley, I. D.,Kavussanu, M.(2007).Development and validation of the moral disengagement in sport scale.Journal of Sport & Exercise Psychology,29,608-628.
15. Caprara, G. V.,Capanna, C.(2005).Moral civic disengagement and values.Ricerche di Psicologia,28,67-84.
16. Cheng, W-N. K.,Hardy, L.,Markland, D.(2011).Cross-cultural validation of a three-dimensional measurement model of performance anxiety in the context of Chinese sports.International Journal of Sport Psychology,42(5),417-435.
17. Corrion, K.,Long, T.,Smith, A. L.,d'Arripe-Longueville, F.(2009)."It's not my fault; It's not serious": Athlete accounts of moral disengagement in competitive sport.The Sport Psychologist,23,388-404.
18. Duda, J. L.(Ed.)(1998).Advances in sport and exercise psychology measurement.Morgantown, WV:Fitness Information Technology.
19. Hodge, K.,Gucciardi, D. F.(2015).Antisocial and prosocial behavior in sport: The role of motivational climate, basic psychological needs, and moral disengagement.Journal of Sport & Exercise Psychology,37,257-273.
20. Hodge, K.,Hargreaves, E. A.,Gerrard, D.,Lonsdale, C.(2013).Psychological mechanisms underlying doping attitudes in sport: Motivation and moral disengagement.Journal of Sport & Exercise Psychology,35,419-432.
21. Hodge, K.,Lonsdale, C.(2011).Prosocial and antisocial behavior in sport: The role of coaching style, autonomous vs. controlled motivation, and moral disengagement.Journal of sport & exercise psychology,33,527-547.
22. Kavussanu, M.,Boardley, I. D.,Sagar, S. S.,Ring, C.(2013).Bracketed morality revisited: How do athletes behave in two contexts?.Journal of Sport & Exercise Psychology,35(5),449-463.
23. Kaye, M.,Hoar, S.(2015).Antisocial sport behaviors survey: Instrument development and initial validation.Journal of Sport & Exercise Psychology,37,164-179.
24. Li, J. B.,Nie, Y. G.,Boardley, I. D.,Situ, Q. M.,Dou, K.(2014).Moral disengagement moderates the predicted effect of trait self-control on self-reported aggression.Asian Journal of Social Psychology,17,312-318.
25. Lucidi, F.,Zelli, A.,Mallia, L.,Grano, C.,Russo, P. M.,Violani, C.(2008).The social cognitive mechanisms regulating adolescents' use of doping substances.Journal of Sports Sciences,26,447-456.
26. Nicholls, J. G.(1989).The competitive ethos and democratic education.Cambridge, MA:Harvard University Press.
27. Osofsky, M. J.,Bandura, A.,Zimbardo, P. G.(2005).The role of moral disengagement in the execution process.Law and Human Behavior,29(4),371-393.
28. Pan, M.,Cheng, W-N.K.(2015).Prediction of three-dimensional anxiety upon moral disengagement in sports.36th International Anxiety and Stress Conference,Tel Aviv, Israel:
29. Shields, D. L.,Funk, C. D.,Bredemeier, B. L.(2015).Predictors of moral disengagement in sport.Journal of Sport & Exercise Psychology,37,646-658.
30. Stanger, N.,Kavussanu, M.,Boardley, I. D.,Ring, C.(2012).The influence of moral disengagement and negative emotion on antisocial sport behavior.Sport, Exercise, and Performance Psychology,2(2),117-129.
31. Tasi, J. J.,Wang, C. H.,Lo, H. J.(2014).Locus of control, moral disengagement in sport, and rule transgression of athletes.Social Behavior & Personality: An International Journal,42(1),59-68.
32. Traclet, A.,Romand, P.,Moret, O.,Kavussanu, M.(2011).Antisocial behavior in soccer: A qualitative study of moral disengagement.International Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology,9(2),143-155.

1. 高三福,王志全(2019)。超競爭人格與反社會行為之關係：道德解離的調節效果。體育學報，52(3)，355-367。
2. 鍾佳芸,黃崇儒,翁正芬(2022)。知覺教練場上行為與青少年運動員利社會及反社會行為之關係：道德解離。臺大體育學報，43，29-40。