Does interval duration or intensity during high-intensity interval training affect adherence and enjoyment in overweight and obese adults?

高強度間歇訓練的間歇持續時間或強度是否會影響過重／肥胖成年人之運動遵從度與愉悅感？

10.6223/qcpe.201906_33(2).0003

温蕙甄(Huei-Jhen Wen)；洪文賢(Boon Suen Ang)

moderate-intensity continuous training ； exercise competency ； weight management ； affective response ； aerobic training ； 中等強度連續運動 ； 運動能力 ； 體重管理 ； 情感反應 ； 有氧訓練

中華體育季刊

33卷2期（2019 / 06 / 01）

73 - 89

英文

Overweight and obesity have been associated with a variety of chronic diseases and impairment in executive function of all age groups. Both continuous aerobic exercise training and intermittent/ interval training were reported to be beneficial for overall health and cardiovascular fitness. In recent years, high-intensity interval training (HIIT) had been shown to be more effective and time-efficient as compared to moderate-intensity continuous training (MICT). Short-term moderate- to high-intensity interval training intervention had also induced modest body composition improvements in overweight and obese individuals. Although many studies reported HIIT to be more superior than MICT, with effective intensity ranging from moderate- to high-intensity intermittent or all-out. However, an effective and practical approach for managing overweight required a long-term strategy. This paper reviewed the adherence to HIIT in relation to its intensity, interval, and its applications in real world for overweight or obese adults. Reports on levels of affective response and enjoyment in MICT and HIIT are inconsistent, and could be due to discrepancies of the protocols and stages of training, as well as participants' fitness levels and competencies. Some studies indicated that lower intensity and/ or shorter interval in HIIT improved pleasure and enjoyment during exercise. Among inactive and overweight adults, increased in exercise intensity above the ventilatory threshold appeared to have a negative effect on the affective response. Exercise competency could also be a critical factor contributing to the enjoyment of HIIT. High enjoyment for variations of interval style training could be achieved if the intensity was reduced and duration of the interval was lengthened beyond the traditional 30-s all-out bouts, which ultimately improved a weight management program. For the enhancement of overall quality of the study on effectiveness and exercise adherence, a longer period of intervention should be considered. In future studies, other factors such as session attendance, adherence rate and adverse events should be included to ascertain their potential roles.

過重與肥胖已證實對不同年齡層的各種慢性疾病與執行功能障礙有關。連續的有氧運動訓練與間歇訓練兩者皆對整體健康及心肺適能有幫助。近年來，高強度間歇訓練（HIIT）相較於中等強度連續訓練（MICT）已被證實較為有效且省時，而短期有效的強度從中等到高強度間歇或盡全力之HIIT介入可適度改善超重與肥胖者的身體組成，然而，有效的體重管理需長期的策略。本文回顧HIIT的強度、間歇對過重或肥胖成人應用在真實世界的遵從度，但MICT與HIIT在情感反應與愉悅程度的結果並不一致，這可能由於訓練階段與流程、參與者體能程度及能力的差異所導致。研究指出HIIT較低強度或較短的間歇將能增加運動時的愉悅感／享受。較不活動與過重成人在運動強度增加超過換氣閾值時顯示和情感反應呈負相關。運動能力也可能是促進HIIT愉悅感的關鍵因素。若降低強度並延長間歇的持續時間（超過傳統一回合30秒的盡全力），則各種間歇式訓練的變化將能達到高度的愉悅感，進而改善HIIT在體重管理計劃的效果和實用性。為提高整體研究在運動遵從與有效性的品質，應考慮更長期的介入；未來的研究應納入其他變項如出席次數、遵從度與不良事件以確定其潛在角色。

1. Alkahtani, S. A.,King, N. A.,Hills, A. P.,Byrne, N. M.(2013).Effect of interval training intensity on fat oxidation, blood lactate and the rate of perceived exertion in obese men.SpringerPlus,2(1),532.
2. Boyd, J. C.,Simpson, C. A.,Jung, M. E.,Gurd, B. J.(2013).Reducing the intensity and volume of interval training diminishes cardiovascular adaptation but not mitochondrial biogenesis in overweight/obese men.PLoS One,8(7),e68091.
3. De Feo, P.(2013).Is high-intensity exercise better than moderate-intensity exercise for weight loss?.Nutrition, Metabolism and Cardiovascular Diseases,23(11),1037-1042.
4. Decker, E. S.,Ekkekakis, P.(2017).More efficient, perhaps, but at what price? Pleasure and enjoyment responses to high-intensity interval exercise in low-active women with obesity.Psychology of Sport and Exercise,28,1-10.
5. Donnelly, J. E.,Blair, S. N.,Jakicic, J. M.,Manore, M. M.,Rankin, J. W.,Smith, B. K.(2009).American College of Sports Medicine position stand. Appropriate physical activity intervention strategies for weight loss and prevention of weight regain for adults.Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise,41(2),459-471.
6. Ekkekakis, P.,Parfitt, G.,Petruzzello, S. J.(2011).The pleasure and displeasure people feel when they exercise at different intensities: Decennial update and progress towards a tripartite rationale for exercise intensity prescription.Sports Medicine,41(8),641-671.
7. Fisher, G.,Brown, A. W.,Bohan Brown, M. M.,Alcorn, A.,Noles, C.,Winwood, L.,Allison, D. B.(2015).High intensity interval- vs moderate intensity training for improving cardiometabolic health in overweight or obese males: a randomized controlled trial.PLoS One,10(10),e0138853.
8. Foster, C.,Farland, C. V.,Guidotti, F.,Harbin, M.,Roberts, B.,Schuette, J.,Porcari, J. P.(2015).The effects of high intensity interval training vs steady state training on aerobic and anaerobic capacity.Journal of Sports Science & Medicine,14(4),747-755.
9. Francois, M. E.,Little, J. P.(2015).Effectiveness and safety of high intensity interval training in patients with type 2 diabetes.Diabetes Spectrum,28(1),39-44.
10. Garber, C. E.,Blissmer, B.,Deschenes, M. R.,Franklin, B. A.,Lamonte, M. J.,Lee, I. M.,Swain, D. P.(2011).American College of Sports Medicine position stand. Quantity and quality of exercise for developing and maintaining cardiorespiratory, musculoskeletal, and neuromotor fitness in apparently healthy adults: Guidance for prescribing exercise.Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise,43(7),1334-1359.
11. Heinrich, K. M.,Patel, P. M.,O'Neal, J. L.,Heinrich, B. S.(2014).High-intensity compared to moderate-intensity training for exercise initiation, enjoyment, adherence, and intentions: An intervention study.BMC Public Health,14(1),789.
12. Heisz, J. J.,Tejada, M. G.,Paolucci, E. M.,Muir, C.(2016).Enjoyment for high-intensity interval exercise increases during the first six weeks of training: Implications for promoting exercise adherence in sedentary adults.PLoS One,11(12),e0168534.
13. Herget, S.,Reichardt, S.,Grimm, A.,Petroff, D.,Kapplinger, J.,Haase, M.,Bluher, S.(2016).High-intensity interval training for overweight adolescents: Program acceptance of a media supported intervention and changes in body composition.International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health,13(11),1099.
14. Jung, M. E.,Bourne, J. E.,Little, J. P.(2014).Where does HIT fit? An examination of the affective response to high-intensity intervals in comparison to continuous moderate- and continuous vigorous-intensity exercise in the exercise intensity-affect continuum.PLoS One,9(12),e114541.
15. Keating, S. E.,Machan, E. A.,O'Connor, H. T,Gerofi, J. A.,Sainsbury, A.,Caterson, I. D.,Johnson, N. A.(2014).Continuous exercise but not high intensity interval training improves fat distribution in overweight adults.Journal of Obesity,2014,1-12.
16. Kong, Z.,Fan, X.,Sun, S.,Song, L.,Shi, Q.,Nie, J.(2016).Comparison of high-intensity interval training and moderate to vigorous continuous training for cardiometabolic health and exercise enjoyment in obese young women: A randomized controlled trial.PLoS ONE,11(7),e0158589.
17. Lanzi, S.,Codecasa, F.,Cornacchia, M.,Maestrini, S.,Capodaglio, P.,Brunani, A.,Malatesta, D.(2015).Short-term HIIT and Fat max training increase aerobic and metabolic fitness in men with class II and III obesity.Obesity,23(10),1987-1994.
18. Lunt, H.,Draper, N.,Marshall, H. C.,Logan, F. J.,Hamlin, M. J.,Shearman, J. P.,Frampton, C. M.(2014).High intensity interval training in a real world setting: A randomized controlled feasibility study in overweight inactive adults, measuring change in maximal oxygen uptake.PLoS One,9(1),e83256.
19. Martinez, N.,Kilpatrick, M. W.,Salomon, K.,Jung, M. E.,Little, J. P.(2015).Affective and enjoyment responses to high-intensity interval training in overweight-to-obese and insufficiently active adults.Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology,37(2),138-149.
20. Martins, C.,Kazakova, I.,Ludviksen, M.,Mehus, I.,Wisloff, U.,Kulseng, B.,King, N.(2016).High-intensity interval training and isocaloric moderate-intensity continuous training result in similar improvements in body composition and fitness in obese individuals.International Journal of Sport Nutrition and Exercise Metabolism,26(3),197-204.
21. McMillan, A. G.,Phillips, K. A.,Collier, D. N.,Blaise Williams, D. S.(2010).Frontal and sagittal plane biomechanics during drop jump landing in boys who are obese.Pediatric Physical Therapy,22(1),34-41.
22. Moroshko, I.,Brennan, L.,O'Brien, P.(2011).Predictors of dropout in weight loss interventions: A systematic review of the literature.Obesity Reviews,12(11),912-934.
23. Parfitt, G.,Hughes, S.(2009).The exerciseintensity-affect relationship: Evidence and implications for exercise behavior.Journal of Exercise Science & Fitness,7(2, Supplement),S34-S41.
24. Racil, G.,Ben Ounis, O.,Hammouda, O.,Kallel, A.,Zouhal, H.,Chamari, K.,Amri, M.(2013).Effects of high vs. moderate exercise intensity during interval training on lipids and adiponectin levels in obese young females.European Journal of Applied Physiology,113(10),2531-2540.
25. Reljic, D.,Wittmann, F.,Fischer, J. E.(2018).Effects of low-volume high-intensity interval training in a community setting: A pilot study.European Journal of Applied Physiology,118(6),1153-1167.
26. Rosenbaum, M.,Hirsch, J.,Gallagher, D. A.,Leibel, R. L.(2008).Long-term persistence of adaptive thermogenesis in subjects who have maintained a reduced body weight.The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition,88(4),906-912.
27. Roy, M.,Williams, S. M.,Brown, R. C.,MeredithJones, K. A.,Osborne, H.,Jospe, M.,Taylor, R. W.(2018).High-intensity interval training in the real world: Outcomes from a 12-month intervention in overweight adults.Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise,50(9),1818-1826.
28. Saanijoki, T.,Nummenmaa, L.,Eskelinen, J. J.,Savolainen, A. M.,Vahlberg, T.,Kalliokoski, K. K.,Hannukainen, J. C.(2015).Affective responses to repeated sessions of high-intensity interval training.Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise,47(12),2604-2611.
29. Schjerve, I. E.,Tyldum, G. A.,Tjonna, A. E.,Stolen, T.,Loennechen, J. P.,Hansen, H. E.,Wisloff, U.(2008).Both aerobic endurance and strength training programmes improve cardiovascular health in obese adults.Clinical Science,115(9),283-293.
30. Schwingshackl, L.,Dias, S.,Strasser, B.,Hoffmann, G.(2013).Impact of different training modalities on anthropometric and metabolic characteristics in overweight/obese subjects: A systematic review and network meta-analysis.PLoS ONE,8(12),e82853.
31. Shepherd, S. O.,Wilson, O. J.,Taylor, A. S.,Thogersen-Ntoumani, C.,Adlan, A. M.,Wagenmakers, A. J.,Shaw, C. S.(2015).Low-volume high-intensity interval training in a gym setting improves cardio-metabolic and psychological health.PLoS ONE,10(9),e0139056.
32. Sijie, T.,Hainai, Y.,Fengying, Y.,Jianxiong, W.(2012).High intensity interval exercise training in overweight young women.The Journal of Sports Medicine and Physical Fitness,52(3),255-262.
33. Sim, A. Y.,Wallman, K. E.,Fairchild, T. J.,Guelfi, K. J.(2015).Effects of high-intensity intermittent exercise training on appetite regulation.Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise,47(11),2441-2449.
34. Smith-Ryan, A. E.(2017).Enjoyment of high-intensity interval training in an overweight/obese cohort: A short report.Clinical Physiology and Functional Imaging,37(1),89-93.
35. Smith-Ryan, A. E.,Melvin, M. N.,Wingfield, H. L.(2015).High-intensity interval training: modulating interval duration in overweight/obese men.The Physician and Sportsmedicine,43(2),107-113.
36. Thompson, W. R.(2017).Worldwide survey of fitness trends for 2018: The CREP edition.ACSM's Health & Fitness Journal,21(6),10-19.
37. Trost, S. G.,Owen, N.,Bauman, A. E.,Sallis, J. F.,Brown, W.(2002).Correlates of adults' participation in physical activity: Review and update.Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise,34(12),1996-2001.
38. Vella, C. A.,Taylor, K.,Drummer, D.(2017).High-intensity interval and moderate-intensity continuous training elicit similar enjoyment and adherence levels in overweight and obese adults.European Journal of Sport Science,17(9),1203-1211.
39. Wewege, M.,van den Berg, R.,Ward, R. E.,Keech, A.(2017).The effects of high-intensity interval training vs. moderate-intensity continuous training on body composition in overweight and obese adults: A systematic review and meta-analysis.Obesity Reviews,18(6),635-646.
40. Williams, D. M.,Dunsiger, S.,Jennings, E. G.,Marcus, B. H.(2012).Does affective valence during and immediately following a 10-min walk predict concurrent and future physical activity?.Annals of Behavioral Medicine,44(1),43-51.