球迷理性嗎－自利歸因偏誤的觀點

Are the fans rational! The perspective of self-serving attributional bias

10.6223/qcpe.202106_35(2).0001

許建民(Chien-Ming Hsu)；黃煜(Yu Huang)

內團體 ； 球隊認同 ； 因果歸因 ； in-group ； team identification ； causal attribution

中華體育季刊

35卷2期（2021 / 06 / 01）

69 - 76

繁體中文

閒暇時間觀賞運動賽事已成為一種普遍的現象，觀眾們因為各別理由而有各自支持的球隊，因而產生了不同的球迷團體。一些對團體有高度認同的球迷會將所屬團體視為自己的延伸，為避免自尊受威脅，會透過團體間的有利比較來維持正向認同，因而有了自利歸因偏誤的產生，不過這個自利歸因偏誤的產生通常和特定的人士與情境有關。也因為國內論述較少針對球迷這種因共通點而相聚的團體進行瞭解，因而凸顯出探討此議題的必要性。經由本文之分析，也給管理實務和未來研究提供相關之建議。

It is common habit for people to watch sport events during their leisure time. Spectators support a specific sport team for various reasons. These fans tend to form fan groups to show support to their favorite team. Fans who are highly identified with their supporting groups consider the group as an extension of themselves. When confronted with a threat to their self-esteem, they create favorable comparisons between their own group and out-group to maintain a positive social identity. Thus, the fans display self-serving bias to their in-group members. However, the bias effect would be most pronounced toward some specific individuals and situations. In Taiwan, scant attention was devoted to those social group of which membership were gathered in similarity, thus, highlighted the importance of this research issue. This paper furthermore presents recommendations for academic communities as well as practitioners in the future.

1. 許建民(2017)。SBL 現場觀賞刺激來源量表發展與驗證。體育學報，50(1)，83-94。
   連結：
2. 許建民,黃賢哲,黃煜,葉靜秀(2020)。職棒裁判判決與球迷知覺公平的關係：團體偏私的效果。臺灣運動心理學報，20(2)，1-17。
   連結：
3. 廖主民,黃鈴雯,何鈺雯(2008)。職棒球迷支持因素、戰績歸因對球迷忠誠度之預測。體育學報，41(3)，43-55。
   連結：
4. Dietz-Uhler, B.,Murrell, A.(1999).Examining fan reactions to game outcomes: A longitudinal study of social identity.Journal of Sport Behavior,22(1),15-27.
5. Dwyer, B.,Eddy, T.,LeCrom, C. W.(2014).Destined to succeed? Team identification and the attributional bias of NFL fans.Journal of Sport Behavior,37(4),333-350.
6. Fink, J. S.,Parker, H. M.,Brett, M.,Higgins, J.(2009).Off-field behavior of athletes and team identification: Using social identity theory and balance theory to explain fan reactions.Journal of Sport Management,23(2),142-155.
7. Hall, G.,Wann, D.(2012).Examining an in-group’s perception of an out-group’s trustworthiness in two popular sports in the United Kingdom.Journal of Contemporary Athletics,6(3),149-158.
8. Havard, C. T.,Reams, L.(2016).Investigating difference in fan rival perceptions between conferences in intercollegiate athletics.Journal of Sport Behavior,39(2),126-146.
9. Havard, C. T.,Reams, L.,Gray, D. P.(2013).Perceptions of highly identified fans regarding rival teams in US intercollegiate football and men’s basketball.International Journal of Sport Management and Marketing,14(1),116-132.
10. Hewstone, M.,Rubin, M.,Willis, H.(2002).Intergroup bias.Annual Review of Psychology,53,575-604.
11. Madrigal, R.,Chen, J.(2008).Moderating and mediating effects of team identification in regard to causal attributions and summary judgments following a game outcome.Journal of Sport Management,22(6),717-733.
12. Mann, L.(1974).On being a sore loser: How fan react to their team’s failure.Australian Journal of Psychology,26(1),37-47.
13. Martin, L. J.,Carron, A. V.(2012).Team attributions in sport: A meta-analysis.Journal of Applied Sport Psychology,24(2),157-174.
14. Shapiro, S. L.,Drayer, J.,Dwyer, B.(2014).Exploring fantasy baseball consumer behavior: Examining the relationship between identification, fantasy participation, and consumption.Journal of Sport Behavior,37(1),77-93.
15. Spinda, J. S. W.(2012).Perceptual biases and behavioral effects among NFL fans: An investigation of first-person, second-person, and third-person effects.International Journal of Sport Communication,5(3),327-347.
16. Tajfel, H.(1982).Social psychology of intergroup relations.Annual Review of Psychology,33,1-39.
17. Tarrant, M.,North, A. C.(2004).Explanations for positive and negative behavior: The intergroup attribution bias in achieved groups.Current Psychology,23(2),161-172.
18. Taylor, D. M.,Doria, J. R.(1981).Self-serving and group-serving bias in attribution.The Journal of Social Psychology,113(2),201-211.
19. Wann, D. L.,Branscombe, N. R.(1993).Sports fans: Measuring degree of identification with the team.International Journal of Sport Psychology,24(1),1-17.
20. Wann, D. L.,Branscombe, N. R.(1995).Influence of identification with a sports team on objective knowledge and subjective beliefs.International Journal of Sport Psychology,26(4),551-567.
21. Wann, D. L.,Dolan, T. J.(1994).Attributions of highly identified sports spectators.The Journal of Social Psychology,134(6),783-792.
22. Wann, D. L.,Grieve, F. G.(2005).Biased evaluations of in-group and out-group spectator behavior at sporting events: The importance of team identification and threats to social identity.The Journal of Social Psychology,145(5),531-545.
23. Wann, D. L.,Koch, K.,Knoth, T.,Fox, D.,Aljubaily, H.,Lantz, C.(2006).The impact of team identification on biased predictions of player performance.The Psychological Record,56(1),55-66.
24. Wann, D. L.,Melnick, M. J.,Russell, G. W.,Pease, D. G.(2001).Sport fans: The psychology and social impact of spectators.NY:Routledge.
25. Wann, D. L.,Schrader, M. P.(2000).Controllability and stability in the self-serving attributions of sport spectators.The Journal of Social Psychology,140(2),160-168.
26. Weiner, B.(1986).An attribution theory of achievement motivation and emotion.NY:Springer.
27. Weiner, B.(1972).Theories of motivation: From mechanism to cognition.Chicago:Markham.
28. Wilson, S. M.,Grieve, F. G.,Ostrowski, S.,Mienaltowski, A.,Cyr, C.(2013).Roles of team identification and game outcome in sport fan superstitious behaviors.Journal of Sport Behavior,36(4),417-429.