中強度連續性有氧與高強度間歇訓練對停經後婦女心率變異度之影響

Causal model of affecting collutcomes

10.6223/qcpe.202203_36(1).0002

楊婷貽(Ting-Ying Yang)；錢桂玉(Kuei-Yu Chien)；林信甫(Hsin-Fu Lin)

自律神經 ； 兒茶酚胺 ； 雌激素 ； autonomic function ； estrogen ； catecholamine

中華體育季刊

36卷1期（2022 / 03 / 01）

13 - 22

繁體中文

婦女在停經後缺乏雌激素會造成肥胖、血脂異常及心血管疾病等風險急遽上升，並伴隨自律神經失調的情況。運動訓練是改善心血管健康的策略，而心率變異度（heart rate variability, HRV）是非侵入性評估自律神經的方法，目前已知規律有氧訓練可以改善心率變異度，而高強度間歇訓練（high-intensity interval training, HIIT）在心肺適能的提升以及體脂肪改變顯著優於中強度連續性有氧訓練，對停經後婦女族群的心率變異度變化影響為何，目前較少研究整理討論，故本文經回顧相關運動介入文獻，歸納出以下結論：中強度連續性有氧訓練及高強度間歇訓練皆可透過提高血管壓力反射來增加心率變異度，而高強度間歇訓練後增加兒茶酚胺產生更大的交感神經活動有助減少體脂肪，在短時間內改善心血管功能，對於停經後婦女而言是能夠維持或增加心率變異度的有效運動策略。

Postmenopausal women often encounter risks such as obesity, dyslipidemia, and cardiovascular disease accompanied with autonomic disorders and exercise training has been proposed as a strategy to improve cardiovascular health. Heart rate variability (HRV) is a noninvasive tool to assess autonomic nervous system. It has been demonstrated that regular aerobic training improves HRV. On the other hand, high-intensity interval training is getting more popularity and has significant advantages in improving cardiorespiratory fitness and body composition. Yet, studies that systemically reviewed the effect of high-intensity interval training on HRV were sparse in the Chinese literature. Therefore, in the present literature review, we specifically focus on the effects of high-intensity interval exercise training and moderate-intensity continuous training on HRV changes and we sum up that both moderate-intensity continuous training and high-intensity interval training can increase HRV via improving baroreceptor reflex sensitivity. Increased catecholamine release as the consequence of greater sympathetic nerve activity following high-intensity interval training might be also favorable for body fat reduction and cardiovascular function in a short time. Collectively, it is an effective exercise strategy to maintain or increase HRV for cardiovascular health in postmenopausal population.

1. 王顯智,黃美雲(2007)。心率變異度的發展與臨床應用。中華體育季刊，21(3)，1-9。
   連結：
2. 何松諺,陳竑廷,鍾雨純,王止俞,劉祐君,吳慧君(2018)。短時間高強度循環訓練對中高齡女性身體組成、代謝症候群、下肢肌力及相關血液指標之影響。體育學報，51(2)，155-168。
   連結：
3. 林嘉慶,黎俊彥(2008)。規律運動訓練對心率變異性之影響。中華體育季刊，22(4)，13-22。
   連結：
4. Abdeen, H. A.,El Nahas, E. M.,AbdAllah, G. A.(2017).Impact of high intensity interval versus moderate intensity continuous training on modulating cardiovascular disease risk factors in postmenopausal women.International Journal of Physiotherapy and Research,5(5),2405-2412.
5. Alansare, A.,Alford, K.,Lee, S.,Church, T.,Jung, H. C.(2018).The effects of high-intensity interval training vs. moderate-intensity continuous training on heart rate variability in physically inactive adults.International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health,15(7),1508.
6. Alvarez, G. E.,Beske, S. D.,Ballard, T. P.,Davy, K. P.(2002).Sympathetic neural activation in visceral obesity.Circulation,106(20),2533-2536.
7. Boidin, M.,Gayda, M.,Henri, C.,Hayami, D.,Trachsel, L. D.,Besnier, F.,Lalonge, J.,Juneau, M.,Nigam, A.(2019).Effects of interval training on risk markers for arrhythmic death: A randomized controlled trial.Clinical Rehabilitation,33(8),1320-1330.
8. Buch, A. N.,Coote, J. H.,Townend, J. N.(2002).Mortality, cardiac vagal control and physical training-What's the link?.Experimental Physiology,87(4),423-435.
9. Cassidy, S.,Vaidya, V.,Houghton, D.,Zalewski, P.,Seferovic, J. P.,Hallsworth, K.,MacGowan, G. A.,Trenell, M. I.,Jakovljevic, D. G.(2019).Unsupervised high-intensity interval training improves glycaemic control but not cardiovascular autonomic function in type 2 diabetes patients: A randomised controlled trial.Diabetes and Vascular Disease Research,16(1),69-76.
10. Chang, W.-D.,Lai, P.-T.(2013).Different exercise behaviors influence heart rate variability, autonomic nerve system function and menopausal symptoms in post-menopausal women.Journal of Physical Therapy Science,25(4),477-481.
11. Clark, H.(2013).NCDs: A challenge to sustainable human development.The Lancet,381(9866),510-511.
12. Dupuit, M.,Rance, M.,Morel, C.,Bouillon, P.,Pereira, B.,Bonnet, A.,Maillard, F.,Duclos, M.,Boisseau, N.(2020).Moderate-intensity continuous training or high-intensity interval training with or without resistance training for altering body composition in postmenopausal women.Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise,52(3),736-745.
13. Ferreira, L. F.,Rodrigues, G. D.,Soares, P. P. d. S.(2017).Quantity of aerobic exercise training for the improvement of heart rate variability in older adults.International Journal of Cardiovascular Sciences,30(2),157-162.
14. Fletcher, G. F.,Balady, G. J.,Amsterdam, E. A.,Chaitman, B.,Eckel, R.,Fleg, J.,Froelicher, V. F.,Leon, A. S.,Piña, I. L.,Rodney, R.,Simon Morton, D. A.,Williams, M. A.,Bazzarre, T.(2001).Exercise standards for testing and training.Circulation,104(14),1694-1740.
15. Hadase, M.,Azuma, A.,Zen, K.,Asada, S.,Kawasaki, T.,Kamitani, T.,Kawasaki, S.,Sugihara, H.,Matsubara, H.(2004).Very low frequency power of heart rate variability is a powerful predictor of clinical prognosis in patients with congestive heart failure.Circulation Journal,68(4),343-347.
16. Harlow, S. D.,Gass, M.,Hall, J. E.,Lobo, R.,Maki, P.,Rebar, R. W.,Sherman, S.,Sluss, P. M.,de Villiers, T. J.(2012).Executive summary of the stages of reproductive aging workshop + 10: Addressing the unfinished agenda of staging reproductive aging.Menopause,19(4),387-395.
17. Hemingway, H.,Shipley, M.,Brunner, E.,Britton, A.,Malik, M.,Marmot, M.(2005).Does autonomic function link social position to coronary risk?.Circulation,111(23),3071-3077.
18. Jabbour, G.,Iancu, H. D.(2021).Comparison of performance and health indicators between perimenopausal and postmenopausal obese women: The effect of high-intensity interval training (HIIT).Menopause,28(1),50-57.
19. Jarczok, M. N.,Kleber, M. E.,Koenig, J.,Loerbroks, A.,Herr, R. M.,Hoffmann, K.,Fischer, J.E.,Benyamini, Y.,Thayer, J. F.(2015).Investigating the associations of self-rated health: heart rate variability is more strongly associated than inflammatory and other frequently used biomarkers in a cross sectional occupational sample.PLoS One,10(2),0117196.
20. Jurca, R.,Church, T. S.,Morss, G. M.,Jordan, A. N.,Earnest, C. P.(2004).Eight weeks of moderate-intensity exercise training increases heart rate variability in sedentary postmenopausal women.American Heart Journal,147(5),8-15.
21. Kannel, W. B.,Hjortland, M. C.,McNamara, P. M.,Gordon, T.(1976).Menopause and risk of cardiovascular disease.Annals of Internal Medicine,85(4),447-452.
22. Kapoor, E.,Collazo-Clavell, M. L.,Faubion, S. S.(2017).Weight gain in women at midlife: A concise review of the pathophysiology and strategies for management.Mayo Clinic Proceedings,92(10),1552-1558.
23. Kimura, T.,Matsumoto, T.,Akiyoshi, M.,Owa, Y.,Miyasaka, N.,Aso, T.,Moritani, T.(2006).Body fat and blood lipids in postmenopausal women are related to resting autonomic nervous system activity.European Journal of Applied Physiology,97(5),542-547.
24. Koenig, J.,Thayer, J. F.(2016).Sex differences in healthy human heart rate variability: A metaanalysis.Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews,64,288-310.
25. Leeners, B.,Geary, N.,Tobler, P. N.,Asarian, L.(2017).Ovarian hormones and obesity.Human Reproduction Update,23(3),300-321.
26. Maillard, F.,Pereira, B.,Boisseau, N.(2018).Effect of high-intensity interval training on total, abdominal and visceral fat mass: A metaanalysis.Sports Medicine,48(2),269-288.
27. Malik, M.,Bigger, J. T.,Camm, A. J.,Kleiger, R. E.,Malliani, A.,Moss, A. J.,Schwartz, P. J.(1996).Heart rate variability: Standards of measurement, physiological interpretation and clinical use.European Heart Journal,17(3),354-381.
28. McCraty, R.,Shaffer, F.(2015).Heart rate variability: New perspectives on physiological mechanisms, assessment of self-regulatory capacity, and health risk.Global Advances in Health and Medicine,4(1),46-61.
29. Mensah, G. A.,Roth, G. A.,Fuster, V.(2019).The global burden of cardiovascular diseases and risk factors.Journal of the American College of Cardiology,74(20),2529-2532.
30. Michael, S.,Graham, K. S.,Davis, G. M.(2017).Cardiac autonomic responses during exercise and post-exercise recovery using heart rate variability and systolic time intervals-A review.Frontiers in Physiology,8,301.
31. Moodithaya, S. S.,Avadhany, S. T.(2009).Comparison of cardiac autonomic activity between pre and post menopausal women using heart rate variability.Indian Journal of Physiology and Pharmacology,53(3),227-234.
32. Mouridsen, M. R.,Bendsen, N. T.,Astrup, A.,Haugaard, S. B.,Binici, Z.,Sajadieh, A.(2013).Modest weight loss in moderately overweight postmenopausal women improves heart rate variability.European Journal of Preventive Cardiology,20(4),671-677.
33. Mullahy, J.,Robert, S. A.(2010).No time to lose: Time constraints and physical activity in the production of health.Review of Economics of the Household,8(4),409-432.
34. Pichot, V.,Roche, F.,Denis, C.,Garet, M.,Duverney, D.,Costes, F.,Barthélémy, J.-C.(2005).Interval training in elderly men increases both heart rate variability and baroreflex activity.Clinical Autonomic Research,15(2),107-115.
35. Ramírez-Vélez, R.,Tordecilla-Sanders, A.,Téllez-T, L. A.,Camelo-Prieto, D.,Hernández-Quiñonez, P. A.,Correa-Bautista, J. E.,Garcia-Hermoso, A.,Ramírez-Campillo, R.,Izquierdo, M.(2020).Effect of moderate-versus high-intensity interval exercise training on heart rate variability parameters in inactive LatinAmerican adults: A randomized clinical trial.Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research,34(12),3403-3415.
36. Ramos, J. S.,Dalleck, L. C.,Borrani, F.,Beetham, K. S.,Mielke, G. I.,Dias, K. A.,Wallen, M.P.,Keating, A.E.,Fassett, R.G.,Coombes, J. S.(2017).High-intensity interval training and cardiac autonomic control in individuals with metabolic syndrome: A randomised trial.International Journal of Cardiology,245,245-252.
37. Ramos, J. S.,Dalleck, L. C.,Tjonna, A. E.,Beetham, K. S.,Coombes, J. S.(2015).The impact of high-intensity interval training versus moderateintensity continuous training on vascular function: A systematic review and metaanalysis.Sports Medicine,45(5),679-692.
38. Rheim, A.,Ibrahim, H.,Saad, A.,Amin, M.(2017).The effect of long-term aerobic exercises on autonomic imbalance in postmenopausal women.Cardiology and Angiology: An International Journal,6(1),1-9.
39. Shaffer, F.,Ginsberg, J. P.(2017).An overview of heart rate variability metrics and norms.Frontiers in Public Health,5,258.
40. Sherman, S.(2005).Defining the menopausal transition.The American Journal of Medicine,118(12),3-7.
41. Subhashri, S.,Pal, P.,Papa, D.,Nanda, N.,Pal, G. K.,Packirisamy, R. M.(2019).Assessment of heart rate variability in early post-menopausal women.International Journal of Clinical and Experimental Physiology,6(1),11-14.
42. Swenne, C. A.(2013).Baroreflex sensitivity: Mechanisms and measurement.Netherlands Heart Journal,21(2),58-60.
43. Trapp, E. G.,Chisholm, D. J.,Freund, J.,Boutcher, S. H.(2008).The effects of highintensity intermittent exercise training on fat loss and fasting insulin levels of young women.International Journal of Obesity,32(4),684-691.
44. Tsuji, H.,Larson, M. G.,Venditti, F. J.,Manders, E. S.,Evans, J. C.,Feldman, C. L.,Levy, D.(1996).Impact of reduced heart rate variability on risk for cardiac events.Circulation,94(11),2850-2855.
45. Weston, K. S.,Wisløff, U.,Coombes, J. S.(2014).High-intensity interval training in patients with lifestyle-induced cardiometabolic disease: A systematic review and meta-analysis.British Journal of Sports Medicine,48(16),1227-1234.
46. World Health Organization(1981).Research on the menopause: Report of a WHO scientific group.Author.
47. Yadav, R. L.,Yadav, P. K.,Yadav, L. K.,Agrawal, K.,Sah, S. K.,Islam, M. N.(2017).Association between obesity and heart rate variability indices: An intuition toward cardiac autonomic alteration-a risk of CVD.Diabetes, Metabolic Syndrome and Obesity: Targets and Therapy,10,57-64.
48. Zhao, D.,Guallar, E.,Ouyang, P.,Subramanya, V.,Vaidya, D.,Ndumele, C. E.,Lima, J. A.,Allison, M. A.,Shah, S. A.,Bertoni, A. G.,Budoss, M. J.,Post, W. S.,Michos, E. D.(2018).Endogenous sex hormones and incident cardiovascular disease in post-menopausal women.Journal of the American College of Cardiology,71(22),2555-2566.
49. Zouhal, H.,Jacob, C.,Delamarche, P.,GratasDelamarche, A.(2008).Catecholamines and the effects of exercise, training and gender.Sports Medicine,38(5),401-423.