運動介入對高齡者平衡能力與步態之影響：系統性回顧

The influence of exercise interventions on balance and gait in older adults: A systematic review

10.6223/qcpe.202206_36(2).0004

李澤羲(Ze-Si Li)；邱文信(Wen-Hsin Chiu)；陳羿揚(Yi-Yang Chen)

關節穩定性 ； 複合式平衡訓練 ； 銀髮運動 ； 運動效益 ； 壓力中心 ； joint stability ； compound balance training ； exercise for the elderly ； exercise benefit ； center of pressure

中華體育季刊

36卷2期（2022 / 06 / 01）

137 - 154

繁體中文

行走步態被視為身體健康與生活功能的重點指標，透過運動治療以延緩老化速度與改善生理病痛為目前臨床醫學趨勢，若能事先瞭解不同形式運動介入對行走平衡與步態的改善效益，則可提升高齡者行走穩定性以減少跌倒發生機率。本研究目的為釐清不同運動介入對高齡者平衡能力與步態之效益，以關鍵字搜尋國內、外期刊資料庫，共納入16篇期刊進行探討，將運動介入對高齡者步態、平衡相關結果進行分類彙整，文獻結果顯示改善動、靜態平衡能力與步態表現取決於介入型態及強度，採用大量低姿勢重心轉移之太極拳與八段錦運動對壓力晃動中心與穩定限度改善具備良好的效益。此外，結合阻力與平衡的複合式運動介入有助於改善高齡者足底壓力分布與降低步態變異性，雖然可根據療效指標來判斷複合式運動介入的整體效益，但仍無法確切釐清複合式運動介入的劑量與反應關係。因此，需更進一步探究複合式運動介入對平衡能力與步態的具體效益。此外，建議未來高齡運動處方可著重於下肢多關節動作訓練為主，透過低負荷阻力器材與擾亂重心的動態活動編排，有利於調整運動強度，提升高齡者平衡能力與步態穩定性，達到預防及延緩老化之效益。

Walking gait is regarded as a key metrics of good health and life function. It is the current clinical trend to slow down the aging rate and improve physiological pain through exercise therapy. If the benefits of different forms of exercise interventions on walking gait and balance can be recognized in advance, the walking stability of elder people can be improved. This helps to decrease the probability of falling. The purpose of this study is to identify the benefits of different exercise interventions on the balance and gait in older adults. Both the domestic and the foreign journal databases were searched by keywords, and included 16 journals for discussion. The results that related to gait and balance of the elderly with exercise intervention were classified and aggregated. Literature results showed that the improvement of dynamic and static balance and gait performance were depended on the type and intensity of the intervention. Tai Chi and Eight Brocades exercises use a lot of low-position center of gravity transfer. They both have good effects on the improvement of the pressure swing center and the stability limit. In addition, a combination of resistance and balance compound exercise program can help improve plantar pressure distribution and reduce the variability of gait in elders. Even though the overall benefits of the compound exercise program can be determined according to efficacy indicators, the exact dose-response relationship of the compound exercise program is still unclear. Therefore, the specific benefits of a compound exercise program on balance and gait need to be further explored. Moreover, it is suggested that prescriptions of the elderly exercise in the future can focus on lower limb multi-joint exercise training. Through the low-load resistance equipment and the dynamic activity scheduling that disrupts the center of gravity, the exercise intensity can be easily adjusted. The balance ability and the gait stability of the elderly will be improved, then achieve the benefits of preventing and delaying aging.

1. 王純嵐,林岱潔,賴虹潣,蔡櫻蘭(2017)。12週平衡性動作訓練對高齡者穩定限度的影響之初步探討。長期照護雜誌，21(3)，251-263。
   連結：
2. 古博文,Stubbs, Brendon,陳上迪,陳俐蓉(2020)。青少年靜態行為與睡眠之系統性文獻回顧。體育學報，53(1)，21-44。
   連結：
3. 江政凌,劉宗翰,陳麗華(2009)。全身性震動訓練對高齡者肌肉生理功能的影響。大專體育，105，129-134。
   連結：
4. 念裕祥,湯文慈(2017)。太極拳運動對中年人姿勢及步態控制之影響。運動教練科學，47，47-56。
   連結：
5. 林宗緯(2015)。有氧運動對高齡者認知與執行功能之影響探討。嘉大體育健康休閒期刊，14(2)，176-185。
   連結：
6. 林岱潔,廖育嬋,蔡櫻蘭(2018)。12 週小型抗力球運動對高齡者跌倒風險的影響：以足底壓力為指標。長期照護雜誌，22(2)
   連結：
7. 林銀秋(2003)。健康老年人的跌倒危機：骨骼肌肉系統及步態分析之討論。中華體育季刊，17(3)，70-74。
   連結：
8. 邱文信,陳羿揚,黃依婷(2019)。規律走路運動對高齡者平衡能力的影響。大專體育學刊，21(4)，331-341。
   連結：
9. 張怡雯,陳俐蓉,羅明葵,陳緯蓉,吳鴻文(2017)。水中運動訓練對於老年人跨越障礙物步態參數的影響。華人運動生物力學期刊，14(1)，36-43。
   連結：
10. 郭家驊(2016)。最新觀點：運動強度與延長壽命的科學報導。大專體育學刊，18(1)
    連結：
11. 陳柏潔,黃長福(2016)。太極拳運動對老年人步態平衡與下肢關節生物力學之影響。大專體育學刊，18(2)，101-113。
    連結：
12. 陳羿揚,莎麗娃,邱文信(2020)。三軸加速規用於評估身體活動量的方法與應用。華人運動生物力學期刊，17(1)，45-53。
    連結：
13. 陳淑貞,錢桂玉,呂佳育(2015)。走路速度測量於社區高齡者衰弱防治之應用。運動生理暨體能學報，21，51-58。
    連結：
14. 溫玉瑭,楊秉祥(2013)。從生物力學來看運動處方對高齡者的健康效益與身體活動的建議。中華體育季刊，27(1)，73-82。
    連結：
15. 詹文祥,邱文信(2011)。老化現象對步態之影響。中華體育季刊，25(4)，667-685。
    連結：
16. 廖芳綿,蘇鈺雯,郭嘉昇,黃清雲,魏惠娟(2019)。多元運動方案介入對社區高齡者功能性體適能之成效探討。長期照護雜誌，23(1)，45-60。
    連結：
17. 蔡宗棋,曾櫻枝(2019)。步態訓練對社區重覆跌倒老人往前及往後步態之成效探討。新臺北護理期刊，21(2)，53-63。
    連結：
18. 蕭新榮,江文德,吳旻寰(2019)。個人化活動指標載具應用於提升高齡者運動量之研究分析。臺大體育學報，36，27-41。
    連結：
19. Adams, S. C.,Segal, R. J.,McKenzie, D. C.,Vallerand, J. R.,Morielli, A. R.,Mackey, J. R.,Courneya, K. S.(2016).Impact of resistance and aerobic exercise on sarcopenia and dynapenia in breast cancer patients receiving adjuvant chemotherapy: A multicenter randomized controlled trial.Breast Cancer Research and Treatment,158(3),497-507.
20. Alfieri, F. M.,Riberto, M.,Gatz, L. S.,Ribeiro, C. P.,Lopes, J. A.,Battistella, L. R.(2012).Comparison of multisensory and strength training for postural control in the elderly.Clinical Interventions Aging,7,119-125.
21. Buckworth, J.,Dishman, R. K.,O'Connor, P. J.,Tomporowski, P. D.(2013).Exercise psychology.Human Kinetics.
22. Bulat, T.,Hart-Hughes, S.,Ahmed, S.,Quigley, P.,Palacios, P.,Werner, D. C.,Foulis, P.(2007).Effect of a group-based exercise program on balance in elderly.Clinical Interventions Aging,2(4),655-660.
23. Cadore, E. L.,Rodríguez-Mañas, L.,Sinclair, A.,Izquierdo, M.(2013).Effects of different exercise interventions on risk of falls, gait ability, and balance in physically frail older adults: a systematic review.Rejuvenation Research,16(2),105-114.
24. Chow, D.,Tremblay, L.,Lam, C. Y.,Yeung, A.,Cheng, W.,Tse, P.(2021).Comparison between accelerometer and gyroscope in predicting level-ground running kinematics by treadmill running kinematics using a single wearable sensor.Sensors,21(14),4633.
25. Duque, G.,Boersma, D.,Loza-Diaz, G.,Hassan, S.,Suarez, H.,Geisinger, D.,Suriyaarachchi, P.,Sharma, A.,Demontiero, O.(2013).Effects of balance training using a virtual-reality system in older fallers.Clinical Interventions in Aging,8,257-263.
26. Eckardt, N.(2016).Lower-extremity resistance training on unstable surfaces improves proxies of muscle strength, power and balance in healthy older adults: A randomised control trial.BMC Geriatrics,16(1),191.
27. Franz, J. R.,Kram, R.(2013).How does age affect leg muscle activity/coactivity during uphill and downhill walking?.Gait & Posture,37(3),378-384.
28. Ganesan, M.,Kanekar, N.,Aruin, A. S.(2015).Direction-specific impairments of limits of stability in individuals with multiple sclerosis.Annals of Physical and Rehabilitation Medicine,58(3),145-150.
29. Gobbo, S.,Bergamin, M.,Sieverdes, JC.,Ermolao, A.,Zaccaria, M.(2014).Effects of exercise on dual-task ability and balance in older adults: A systematic review.Arch Gerontol Geriatr,58(2),177-187.
30. Gomeñuka, N. A.,Oliveira, H. B.,Silva, E. S.,Costa, R. R.,Kanitz, A. C.,Liedtke, G. V.,Schuch, F. B.,Peyré-Tartaruga, L. A.(2019).Effects of Nordic walking training on quality of life, balance and functional mobility in elderly: A randomized clinical trial.PloS one,14(1)
31. Granacher, U.,Muehlbauer, T.,Gollhofer, A.,Kressig, R. W.,Zahner, L.(2011).An intergenerational approach in the promotion of balance and strength for fall prevention-Aminireview.Gerontology,57(4),304-315.
32. Gschwind, Y. J.,Kressig, R. W.,Lacroix, A.,Muehlbauer, T.,Pfenninger, B.,Granacher, U.(2013).A best practice fall prevention exercise program to improve balance, strength /power, and psychosocial health in older adults: Study protocol for a randomized controlled trial.BMC Geriatrics,13,105.
33. Hong, Y.,Li, J. X.(2007).Biomechanics of tai chi: A review.Sports Biomechanics,6(3),453-464.
34. Hsu, H. C.,Jhan, L. J.(2008).Risk factors of falling among the elderly in Taiwan: A longitudinal study.Taiwan Geriatrics & Gerontology,3(2),141-154.
35. Ihlen, E. F.,Weiss, A.,Bourke, A.,Helbostad, J. L.,Hausdorff, J. M.(2016).The complexity of daily life walking in older adult communitydwelling fallers and non-fallers.Journal of Biomechanics,49(9),1420-1428.
36. Ippersiel, P.,Robbins, S. M.,Dixon, P. C.(2021).Lower-limb coordination and variability during gait: The effects of age and walking surface.Gait & Posture,85,251-257.
37. Keating, C. J.,Cabrera-Linares, J. C.,PárragaMontilla, J. A.,Latorre-Román, P. A.,Del Castillo, R. M.,García-Pinillos, F.(2021).Influence of resistance training on gait & balance parameters in older adults: A systematic review.International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health,18(4),1759.
38. Lee, A. C.,Harvey, W. F.,Price, L. L.,Han, X.,Driban, J. B.,Iversen, M. D.,Desai, S. A.,Knopp, H. E.,Wang, C.(2018).Doseresponse effects of Tai Chi and physical therapy exercise interventions in symptomatic knee osteoarthritis.PM & R: The Journal of Injury, Function, and Rehabilitation,10(7),712-723.
39. Lee, D. Y.,Seo, S. G.,Kim, E. J.,Lee, D. J.,Bae, K. J.,Lee, K. M.,Choi, I. H.(2017).Intersegmental motions of the foot: Differences between younger and older healthy adult females.Journal of Foot and Ankle Research,10,29.
40. Mahoney, J. M.,Rhudy, M. B.(2019).Methodology and validation for identifying gait type using machine learning on IMU data.Journal of Medical Engineering & Technology,43(1),25-32.
41. Marsh, A. P.,Miller, M. E.,Rejeski, W. J.,Hutton, S. L.,Kritchevsky, S. B.(2009).Lower extremity muscle function after strength or power training in older adults.Journal of Aging and Physical Activity,17(4),416-443.
42. Moher, D.,Liberati, A.,Tetzlaff, J.,Altman, D. G.,PRISMA Group(2009).Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement.PLoS Medicine,6(7),1006-1012.
43. Nicholson, V. P.,McKean, M. R.,Burkett, B. J.(2014).Twelve weeks of BodyBalance®training improved balance and functional task performance in middle-aged and older adults.Clinical Interventions in Aging,9,1895-1904.
44. Olson, S. L.,Chen, S. S.,Wang, C. Y.(2011).Effect of a home exercise program on dynamic balance in elderly with a history of falls.Journal of Aging and Physical Activity,19,291-305.
45. Orlin, M. N.,McPoil, T. G.(2000).Plantar pressure assessment.Physical Therapy,80(4),399-409.
46. Pamukoff, D. N.,Haakonssen, E. C.,Zaccaria, J. A.,Madigan, M. L.,Miller, M. E.,Marsh, A. P.(2014).The effects of strength and power training on single-step balance recovery in older adults: A preliminary study.Clinical Interventions in Aging,9,697-704.
47. Ramalho, F.,Santos-Rocha, R.,Branco, M.,Moniz-Pereira, V.,André, H. I.,Veloso, A. P.,Carnide, F.(2018).Effect of 6-month community-based exercise interventions on gait and functional fitness of an older population: A quasi-experimental study.Clinical Interventions in Aging,13,595-606.
48. Swift, D. L.,Johannsen, N. M.,Lavie, C. J.,Earnest, C. P.,Johnson, W. D.,Blair, S. N.,Church, T. S.,Newton, R. L., Jr.(2013).Racial differences in the response of cardiorespiratory fitness to aerobic exercise training in Caucasian and African American postmenopausal women.Journal of Applied Physiology,114(10),1375-1382.
49. Tsang, W. W. N.,Hui-Chan, C. W. Y.(2006).Standing balance after vestibular stimulation in Tai Chi-practicing and nonpracticing healthy older adults.Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation,87(4),546-553.
50. Verhagen, A. P.,Vet, H. C.,Bie, R. A.,Kessels, A. G.,Boers, M.,Bouter, L. M.,Knipschild, P. G.(1998).The Delphi list: A criteria list for quality assessment of randomized clinical trials for conducting systematic reviews developed by Delphi consensus.Journal of Clinical Epidemiology,51(12),1235-1241.
51. Wang, R. Y.,Wang, Y. L.,Cheng, F. Y.,Chao, Y. H.,Chen, C. L.,Yang, Y. R.(2015).Effects of combined exercise on gait variability in community-dwelling older adults.Age,37(3),9780.
52. Wu, R.,Delahunt, E.,Ditroilo, M.,Lowery, M.,De Vito, G.(2016).Effects of age and sex on neuromuscular-mechanical determinants of muscle strength.Age,38(3),57.
53. Zhang, C.,Mao, D.,Riskowski, J. L.,Song, Q.(2011).Strategies of stepping over obstacles: The effects of long-term exercise in older adults.Gait & Posture,34(2),191-196.
54. 中華民國衛生福利部 (2015)。預防及延緩失能照護計畫專區。https://1966.gov.tw/LTC/lp4024-201.html
55. 林芝羽(2018)。臺灣師範大學。
56. 邱懿瑩(2020)。休閒運動參與對高齡族群健康價值取向之探討。屏東大學體育，6，67-80。
57. 張淑芳(2014)。老年肌少症之診斷與治療。護理雜誌，61(2)，101-105。
58. 郭姵伶,林千玉,張立東,鄒碧鶴(2016)。高齡者阻力訓練實作模式建立與成效評估。福祉科技與服務管理學刊，4(1)，117-128。
59. 黃錦源,甘能斌,張璽儀,洪彰岑,黃佳惠(2018)。八段錦運動介入對社區中高年齡者骨質密度、身體組成及下肢步態穩定性提升成效之探討。健康管理學刊，16(1)，1-12。
60. 楊雅如,羅鴻基,黃維貞,吳泓熠,王瑞瑤(2017)。不同運動模式介入對於高齡者身體功能和活動之影響。物理治療，42(4)，257-267。
61. 蘇蕙芬(2013)。高齡者衰弱程度對運動介入效果之影響。休閒運動保健學報，5，76-100。

1. (2024)。GRADE方法：體育與運動科學領域中系統性回顧之證據可信度和建議強度的評估工具。中華體育季刊，38(1)，35-51。