题名

社區型社會企業與生態系統發展－價值共創觀點

并列篇名

Development of CBSE and Ecosystem: Value Co-Creation perspective

作者

蔡振義(CHEN-YI TSAI)

关键词

社區型社會企業 ； 在地鑲嵌 ； 制度鑲嵌 ； 生態系統 ； 價值共創 ； Community-Based Social Enterprise ； local embeddedness ； Institutional Embeddedness ； Ecosystem ； Value Co-creation

期刊名称

輔仁管理評論

卷期/出版年月

28卷1期（2021 / 01 / 01）

页次

69 - 106

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

社區型社會企業發展脈絡以及其所鑲嵌的在地與外部環境是本文探討的重點。勞動部多元計畫方案支撐社區型社會企業發展，但非每個社區創業計畫皆能成功轉型發展。「擁有類似的制度支持，為何有些社區型社會企業有較佳的績效？」採用在地及制度鑲嵌的生態系統，與價值共創觀點，回答上述研究問題。社區創業是社會創業活動與在地脈絡、制度力量三者間互動的過程。驅動社區發展的力量，來自於社區創業者，與複雜的產、官、學研力量交融互動的生態系統。以個案歷程分析，探究仕安社區合作社發展歷程。長期觀察，半結構化訪談，輔以內外部文件、社群媒體等次級資料，完成個案歷程與所鑲嵌的生態系統描繪，後續資料分析浮現多重鑲嵌、價值共創機轉與社區發展的關聯性。嘗試從社區創業與在地脈絡、制度力量互演化歷程，建構社區創業生態系統。研究結果指出價值共創是鏈結社會創業者、在地社區、返鄉青年與外部制度機構的關鍵機轉。換言之，社區創業者與在地鑲嵌及制度鑲嵌的價值共創作為，是社區型社會企業與在地社區持續發展的主要驅動力量。研究結論對社會創業、價值共創與生態系統研究做出貢獻；也浮現制度資源融入社區脈絡的機制，提供社區型社會企業發展建議。據此，提出未來的研究方向。
英文摘要

This study focus on the co-evolution of Community-based social enterprise (CBSE) and the ecosystem within which the CBSE is embedded. The Multi-channel Employment Service Program (launched by Taiwan Council of Labor Affairs) pushed the development of CBSE in Taiwan's rural communities. However, not all CBSEs became successful and sustainable. The phenomenon raises our research question. ＂Why some CBSEs outperform than others with the same institutional supports?＂ This paper adopted the ecosystem, within which CBSEs are embedded, and value co-creation perspectives to answer the research question. Prior studies indicated social entrepreneurship is affected by the interaction among local context, and institutional forces. Especially, the development of CBSE is surrounded with community context. At the same time, CBSEs are also embedded within institutional environments. Regional development scholars suggested that drivers of community development are originated from community entrepreneurs, and interaction among community enterprises, and institutional environment. Therefore, we argued that CBSEs can benefit from the ecosystem, which originated from the interaction among entrepreneurs, local community and institutional forces. However, value co-creation among various stakeholders is the main mechanism that inspires and sustains the development of the CBSE. This was a longitudinal case study of community-based social enterprise (ShihAn community cooperative in north of Tainan, Taiwan). Author participated and observed the origin and evolution of the CBSE for 7 years. I conducted semi-structured interviews with members of CBSE, including founders, board members, managers, contract farmers, resident. In order to collected data of institutions, we also interviewed with stakeholders from institutions, including government institution, university, and NGO. The secondary data are also collected. Through this process, we collected a wide range of archival material, including meeting minute, annual reports, brochures, reports from social media, etc. In the process of data analysis, we firstly reported the longitudinal evolution of the CBSE and the ecosystem CBSE being embedded. In the second stage of analysis, the dynamic interaction among local and institutional embeddedness, value co-creation mechanism and CBSE development are emerged and discussed. The study depicted the ecosystem of CBSE. The results suggested that value co-creation mechanism plays the key role on dynamic interaction among social entrepreneurs, local community, and institutional environment. The results contribute social entrepreneurship, ecosystem, and value co-creation research. The conclusions also inspired practical implications for community development. Future directions are discussed.
主题分类 社會科學 > 管理學
参考文献
  1. 謝如梅,劉常勇(2009)。創新機會辨識:創業警覺能力、先前知識與資訊獲取之關聯性研究。組織與管理，2(2)，77-108。
    連結：
  2. Adner, R.(2017).Ecosystem as structure: an actionable construct for strategy.Journal of Management,43(1),39-58.
  3. Adner, R.,Kapoor, R.(2010).Value creation in innovation ecosystems: how the structure of technological interdependence affects firm performance in new technology generations.Strategic Management Journal,31(3),306-333.
  4. Anderson, J. C.,Narus, J. A.,Van Rossum, W.(2006).Customer value propositions in business markets.Harvard business review,84,1-4.
  5. Battilana, J.,Besharov, M. L.,Mitzinneck, B.(2017).On hybrids and Hybrid Organizing: A Review and Roadmap for future.The SAGE Handbook of Organizational Institutionalism,Thousand Oaks:
  6. Battilana, J.,Lee, M.(2014).Advancing Research on Hybrid Organizing – Insights from the Study of Social Enterprises.The Academy of Management Annals,8(1),397-441.
  7. Battilana, J.,Sengul, M.,Pache, A.-C.,Model, J.(2015).Harnessing Productive Tensions in Hybrid Organizations: The Case of Work Integration Social Enterprises.Academy of Management Journal,58(6),1658-1685.
  8. Bosse, D. A.,Coughlan, R.(2016).Stakeholder relationship bonds.Journal of Management Studies,53(7),1197-1222.
  9. Bowman, C.,Ambrosini, V.(2000).Value creation versus value capture: towards a coherent definition of value in strategy.British Journal of Management,11(1),1-15.
  10. Brandenburger, A. M.,Stuart, H. W.(1996).Value‐based Business Strategy.Journal of Economics & Management Strategy,5(1),5-24.
  11. Bridoux, F.,Stoelhorst, J.(2014).Microfoundations for stakeholder theory: Managing stakeholders with heterogeneous motives.Strategic Management Journal,35(1),107-125.
  12. Bridoux, F.,Stoelhorst, J.(2016).Stakeholder relationships and social welfare: A behavioral theory of contributions to joint value creation.Academy of Management Review,41(2),229-251.
  13. Castro-Arce, K.,Vanclay, F.(2020).Transformative social innovation for sustainable rural development: An analytical framework to assist community-based initiatives.Journal of Rural Studies,74,45-54.
  14. Dacin, M. T.,Dacin, P. A.,Tracey, P.(2011).Social Entrepreneurship: A Critique and Future Directions.Organization Science,22(5),1203-1213.
  15. Davis, J. P.(2016).The group dynamics of interorganizational relationships: Collaborating with multiple partners in innovation ecosystems.Administrative Science Quarterly,61(4),621-661.
  16. Ebrahim, A.,Battilana, J.,Mair, J.(2014).The governance of social enterprises: Mission drift and accountability challenges in hybrid organizations.Research in Organizational Behavior,34,81-100.
  17. Frow, P.,McColl-Kennedy, J. R.,Hilton, T.,Davidson, A.,Payne, A.,Brozovic, D.(2014).Value propositions: A service ecosystems perspective.Marketing Theory,14(3),327-351.
  18. Frow, P.,McColl-Kennedy, J. R.,Payne, A.(2016).Co-creation practices: Their role in shaping a health care ecosystem.Industrial Marketing Management,56,24-39.
  19. Garcia‐Castro, R.,Aguilera, R. V.(2015).Incremental value creation and appropriation in a world with multiple stakeholders.Strategic Management Journal,36(1),137-147.
  20. Gawell, M.,Pierre, A.,Friedrichs, V. Y.(2014).Societal Entrepreneurship – a Cross-Boundary Force for Regional and Local Development Cherished for Multiple Reasons.Scandinavian Journal of Public Administration,18(4),109-130.
  21. Granovetter, M.(1985).Economic Action and Social Structure: The Problem of Embeddedness.American Journal of Sociology,91(3),481-510.
  22. Grönroos, C.,Voima, P.(2013).Critical service logic: making sense of value creation and co-creation.Journal of the academy of marketing science,41(2),133-150.
  23. Gulati, R.(1998).Alliances and networks.Strategic Management Journal,19(4),293-317.
  24. Gupta, P.,Chauhan, S.,Paul, J.,Jaiswal, M. P.(2020).Social entrepreneurship research: A review and future research agenda.Journal of Business Research,113,209-229.
  25. Hertel, C.,Bacq, S.,Belz, F.-M.(2019).It Takes a Village to Sustain a Village: A Social Identity Perspective on Successful Community-Based Enterprise Creation.Academy of Management Discoveries,5(4),438-464.
  26. Hoopes, D. G.,Madsen, T. L.,Walker, G.(2003).Guest editors' introduction to the special issue: why is there a resource‐based view? Toward a theory of competitive heterogeneity.Strategic Management Journal,24(10),889-902.
  27. Johannisson, B.(1990).Community entrepreneurship - cases and conceptualization.Entrepreneurship & Regional Development,2(1),71-88.
  28. Kohler, T.(2015).Crowdsourcing-based business models: how to create and capture value.California management review,57(4),63-84.
  29. Koschmann, M. A.,Kuhn, T. R.,Pfarrer, M. D.(2012).A communicative framework of value in cross-sector partnerships.Academy of Management Review,37(3),332-354.
  30. Kuan, Y.-Y.,Wang, S.-T.(2015).ICSEM Working PapersICSEM Working Papers,Liege:The International Comparative Social Enterprise Models (ICSEM) Project.
  31. Langley, A.(1999).Strategies for theorizing from process data.Academy of Management Review,24(4),691-710.
  32. Lazzarini, S. G.(2020).The Nature of the Social Firm: Alternative Organizational Forms for Social Value Creation and Appropriation.Academy of Management Review,45(3),620-645.
  33. Lusch, R. F.,Vargo, S. L.(2006).Service-dominant logic: reactions, reflections and refinements.Marketing Theory,6(3),281-288.
  34. Lusch, R. F.,Vargo, S. L.(2014).The service-dominant logic of marketing: Dialog, debaand directions.Routledge.
  35. McColl-Kennedy, J. R.,Vargo, S. L.,Dagger, T. S.,Sweeney, J. C.,Kasteren, Y. v.(2012).Health care customer value cocreation practice styles.Journal of Service Research,15(4),370-389.
  36. McIntyre, D. P.,Srinivasan, A.(2017).Networks, platforms, and strategy: Emerging views and next steps.Strategic Management Journal,38(1),141-160.
  37. Orlikowski, W. J.,Yates, J.(2002).It's about time: Temporal structuring in organizations.Organization Science,13(6),684-711.
  38. Ozcan, P.,Eisenhardt, K.(2009).Origin of alliance portfolios: entrepreneurs, network strategies, and firm performance.The Academy of Management Journal (AMJ),52(2),246-279.
  39. Parker, W. N.(1954).Entrepreneurship, Industrial Organization, and Economic Growth: A German Example.The Journal of Economic History,14(4),380-400.
  40. Payne, A. F.,Storbacka, K.,Frow, P.(2008).Managing the co-creation of value.Journal of the academy of marketing science,36(1),83-96.
  41. Payne, A.,Frow, P.,Eggert, A.(2017).The customer value proposition: evolution, development, and application in marketing.Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science,1-23.
  42. Peredo, A. M.,Chrisman, J. J.(2006).Toward a theory of community-based enterprise.Academy of Management Review,31,309-328.
  43. Peredo, A. M.,Chrisman, J. J.(2017).Conceptual foundations: Community-based enterprise and community development.Entrepreneurial Neighbourhoods: Towards an Understanding of the Economies of Neighbourhoods and Communities,Cheltenham, UK:
  44. Pierre, A.,Friedrichs, V. Y.,Wincent, J.(2014).Entrepreneurship in Society: A Review and Definition of Community-Based Entrepreneurship Research.Social Entrepreneurship: : Leveraging Economic, Political, and Cultural Dimensions,Switzerland:
  45. Pitelis, C.(2012).Clusters, entrepreneurial ecosystem co-creation, and appropriability: a conceptual framework.Industrial and Corporate Change
  46. Pitelis, C. N.,Teece, D. J.(2009).The (new) nature and essence of the firm.European Management Review,6(1),5-15.
  47. Prahalad, C. K.,Ramaswamy, V.(2004).The future of competition: Co-creating unique value with customers.Harvard Business Press.
  48. Priem, R. L.(2007).A consumer perspective on value creation.Academy of management review,32(1),219-235.
  49. Ramaswamy, V.,Gouillart, F.(2010).Building the co-creative enterprise.Harvard business review,88(10),100-109.
  50. Ramirez, R.(1999).Value co-production: intellectual origins and implications for practice and research.Strategic Management Journal,20(1),49-65.
  51. Rivera-Santos, M.,Holt, D.,Littlewood, D.,Kolk, A.(2015).Social Entrepreneurship in Sub-Saharan Africa.The Academy of Management Perspectives,29(1),72-91.
  52. Santos, F. M.(2012).A Positive Theory of Social Entrepreneurship.Journal of Business Ethics,111(3),335-351.
  53. Sassmannshausen, S. P.,Volkmann, C.(2018).The Scientometrics of Social Entrepreneurship and Its Establishment as an Academic Field.Journal of Small Business Management,56(2),251-273.
  54. Shane, S.(2012).Reflections on the 2010 AMR Decade Award: Delivering on the promise of entrepreneurship as a field of research.Academy of Management Review,37(1),10-20.
  55. Shane, S.(2000).Prior Knowledge and the Discovery of Entrepreneurial Opportunities.Organization Science,11(4),448-469.
  56. Shane, S.,Venkataraman, S.(2000).The Promise of Entrepreneurship as a Field of Research.The Academy of Management Review,25(1),217-226.
  57. Shepherd, D. A.,Williams, T. A.,Patzelt, H.(2014).Thinking About Entrepreneurial Decision Making: Review and Research Agenda.Journal of Management
  58. Somerville, P.,McElwee, G.(2011).Situating community enterprise: A theoretical exploration.Entrepreneurship & Regional Development,23(5-6),317-330.
  59. Sweeney, J. C.,Danaher, T. S.,McColl-Kennedy, J. R.(2015).Customer effort in value cocreation activities: Improving quality of life and behavioral intentions of health care customers.Journal of Service Research,18(3),318-335.
  60. Tantalo, C.,Priem, R. L.(2016).Value creation through stakeholder synergy.Strategic Management Journal,37(2),314-329.
  61. Uzzi, B.(1996).The sources and consequences of embeddedness for the economic performance of organizations: The network effect.American sociological review,674-698.
  62. Van Alstyne, M. W.,Parker, G. G.,Choudary, S. P.(2016).Pipelines, platforms, and the new rules of strategy.Harvard business review,94(4),54-62.
  63. Vargo, S. L.(2011).Market systems, stakeholders and value propositions: Toward a service‐dominant logic ‐ based theory of the market.European journal of marketing,45(1/2),217-222.
  64. Vargo, S. L.,Lusch, R. F.(2004).Evolving to a new dominant logic for marketing.Journal of marketing,68(1),1-17.
  65. Vargo, S. L.,Lusch, R. F.(2011).It's all B2B… and beyond: Toward a systems perspective of the market.Industrial Marketing Management,40(2),181-187.
  66. Vestrum, I.,Rasmussen, E.,Carter, S.(2017).How nascent community enterprises build legitimacy in internal and external environments.Regional Studies,51(11),1721-1734.
  67. Welter, F.(2011).Contextualizing entrepreneurship - conceptual challenges and ways forward.Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice,35(1),165-184.
  68. Williamson, P. J.,De Meyer, A.(2012).Ecosystem advantage: How to successfully harness the power of partners.California management review,55(1),24-46.
  69. Xie, C.,Bagozzi, R. P.,Troye, S. V.(2008).Trying to prosume: toward a theory of consumers as co-creators of value.Journal of the academy of marketing science,36(1),109-122.
  70. Yin, R. K.(2009).Case Study Research: Design and Methods.London:Sage.
  71. Zahra, S. A.,Newey, L. R.,Li, Y.(2014).On the Frontiers: The Implications of Social Entrepreneurship for International Entrepreneurship.Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice,38(1),137-158.
  72. 方世杰 (2020)， 「價值共創的迷思與省思. 金屬工業網大師專欄之智庫專欄」，Retrieved from http://mii.mirdc.org.tw/Article/ViewDetail?nid=29075#_
  73. 林鍵樺(2017)。林鍵樺 (2017)，「世代平安地方誌：合作找幸福」，台南市後壁區：嬉遊境空間構築工作室。
  74. 社企流(2014).社企力 ！：社會企業.台北:果力文化.
  75. 孫智麗(2016)。我國農業社會企業案例分析與現況調查。農業生技產業特刊，46，62-66。
  76. 陳志遠,張勝立,魏式琦,楊金展(2007)。人格特質、社會資本、先前知識對創業機警性影響之實證研究：創業家與經理人的比較分析。創業管理研究，2(4)，25-56。
print cancel