義同憶異：飯店產品知識與訊息類型於適配下提高說服與記憶

The Same Message Makes Different Memories: Proper Matches of Hotel Product Knowledge and Message Types Strengthen Persuasion and Memory

10.6267/JTLS.201808_24(2).0001

陳建中(Chien-Chung Chen)；廖淯菘(Yu-Sung Liao)

產品知識 ； 訊息類型 ； 資源適配理論 ； 說服力 ； 記憶 ； product knowledge ； message types ； resource-matching theory ； persuasion ； memory

觀光休閒學報

24卷2期（2018 / 08 / 01）

117 - 142

繁體中文

飯店產品知識高低不同的消費者對於飯店廣告訊息，是以詳細的數字或術語來說明較具說服力且印象深刻？還是用簡單文字敘述產品利益才有說服力而不易忘記？合宜地把消費者產品知識能力與業者廣告訊息做適切搭配，本研究解析了兩兩配對下優劣得失的邏輯理路，據以提出適配組合下較佳說服力與記憶表現之行銷溝通效果。兩個實驗法實徵的結果顯示：飯店知識能力低者適配利益訊息，相較於採用屬性訊息，其訊息說服力、再認記憶、自由回憶皆能表現較高；相反地，飯店知識能力高者適配屬性訊息，對比採用利益訊息，其訊息說服力與自由回憶表現較高。本研究在學術上對資源適配理論做了擴充與深化，在實務上可為供需雙方提供策略示範與指引。

For consumers with different product knowledge, which types of hotel messages are more persuasive and easy to remember: details of numbers and technical terms or simply words describing product benefits? Proper matches of consumers' product knowledge and type of advertisement messages will create better marketing communication effects. This study analyzed advantages and disadvantages of different matches to recommend the proper match that works the best for persuasion and memory performance. The results of two experimental studies show that benefit messages are more persuasive to consumers with lower hotel knowledge and create better performance in recognition and free recall. On the other hand, attribute messages are more persuasive to consumers with higher hotel knowledge and create better performance in free recall. Theoretically this study expands the resource-matching theory and offers practical strategies and guidelines for the hotel industry.

1. 陳茹玲、蘇宜芬(2005)。類比故事的表面特徵與結構特徵在不同年齡層對故事回想表現的影響。教育心理學報，37(2)，123-146。
   連結：
2. Aertsens, J.,Mondelaers, K.,Verbeke, W.,Buysse, J.,Van Huylenbroeck, G.(2011).The influence of subjective and objective knowledge on attitude, motivations and consumption of organic food.British Food Journal,113(11),1353-1378.
3. Anand, P.,Sternthal, B.(1989).Strategies for designing persuasive messages: Deduction from the resources matching hypothesis.Cognitive and affective responses to advertising,Lexington, MA:
4. Assael, H.(2004).Consumer behavior: A strategic approach.Boston, MA:Houghton Mifflin.
5. Braun, K. A.,Ellis, R.,Loftus, E. F.(2002).Make my memory: How advertising can change our memories of the past.Psychology and Marketing,19(1),1-23.
6. Braun-LaTour, K. A.,LaTour, M. S.(2004).Assessing the long-term impact of a consistent advertising campaign on consumer memory.Journal of Advertising,33(2),49-61.
7. Brucks, M.(1985).The effects of product class knowledge on information search behavior.Journal of Consumer Research,12(1),1-16.
8. Cacioppo, J. T.,von Hippel, W.,Ernst, J. M.(1997).Mapping cognitive structures and processes through verbal content: The thought-listing technique.Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology,65(6),928-940.
9. Catrambone, R.(2002).The effects of surface and structural feature matches on the access of story analogs.Journal of Experimental Psychology,28(2),318-334.
10. Chi, M. T. H.,Feltovich, P. J.,Glaser, R.(1982).Categorization and represention of physics problems by experts and novices.Cognitive Science,5,121-152.
11. Chiappe, P.,Siegel, L. S.,Hasher, L.(2000).Working memory, inhibitory control, and reading disability.Memory & Cognition,28(1),8-17.
12. Darcy, S.(2010).Inherent complexity: Disability, accessible tourism and accommodation information preferences.Tourism Management,31(6),816-826.
13. DeCarlo, T. E.,Laczniak, R. N.,Leigh, T. W.(2013).Selling financial services: The effect of consumer product knowledge and salesperson commission on consumer suspicion and intentions.Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science,41(0),418-435.
14. Dijksterhuis, A.(2004).Think different: The merits of unconscious thought in preference development and decision making.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,87(5),586-598.
15. Eagle, L.,Chamberlain, K.(2004).Prescription medication advertising: Professional discomfort and potential patient benefits: Can the two be balanced?.International Journal of Advertising,23(1),69-90.
16. Florenthal, B.(2008).Attribute-benefit matrix: The impact on experts and novices.Indian Journal of Economics and Business,1,45-52.
17. Friebe, K., & Campbell, D. (2010). Social media in the hospitality and leisure industry. DLA Piper. Retrieved from http://www.dlapipercentralcms.com/export/system/central-cms/publications/files/2010/hospitality-and-leisure/uk/UK_Social_Media_Hosp_and_Leisure_Sep_10.pdf
18. Graeff, T. R.(1997).Comprehending product attributes and benefits: The role of product knowledge and means-end chain inferences.Psychology and Marketing,14(2),163-183.
19. Gursoy, D.,McCleary, K. W.(2004).Travelers' prior knowledge and its impact on their information search behavior.Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Research,28(1),66-94.
20. Haugtvedt, C. P.,Petty, R. E.,Cacioppo, J. T.(1992).Need for cognition and advertising: Understanding the role of personality variables in consumer behavior.Journal of Consumer Psychology,1(3),239-260.
21. Helms, J.,Weichbold, V.,Baumann, U.,von Specht, H.,Schön, F.,Müller, J.,Esser, B.,Ziese, M.,Anderson, I.,D'Haese, P.(2004).Analysis of ceiling effects occurring with speech recognition tests in adult cochlear-implanted patients.ORL,66(3),130-135.
22. Hernandez, J. M. C.,Wright, S. A.,Ferminiano Rodrigues, F.(2015).Attributes versus benefits: The role of construal levels and appeal type on the persuasiveness of marketing messages.Journal of Advertising,44(3),243-253.
23. Hunt, R. R.,Einstein, G. O.(1981).Relational and item-specific information in memory.Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior,20(5),497-514.
24. Hyde, K.,Teichmann, K.(2011).Expertise, experience and self-confidence in consumers' travel information search.International Journal of Culture, Tourism and Hospitality Research,5(2),184-194.
25. Jae, H.,DelVecchio, D. S.,Childers, T. L.(2011).Are low-literate and high-literate consumers different? Applying resource-matching theory to ad processing across literacy levels.Journal of Consumer Psychology,21(3),312-323.
26. Just, M. A.,Carpenter, P. A.(1992).A capacity theory of comprehension: Individual differences in working memory.Psychological Review,99(1),122-149.
27. Kadous, K.,Koonce, L.,Towry, K. L.(2005).Quantification and persuasion in managerial judgment.Contemporary Accounting Research,22(3),643-686.
28. Kent, R. J.,Machleit, K. A.(1990).The differential effects of within-brand and between-brand processing on the recall and recognition of television commercials.Journal of Advertising,19(2),4-14.
29. Kim, E. E. K.,Mattila, A. S.,Baloglu, S.(2011).Effects of gender and expertise on consumers' motivation to read online hotel reviews.Cornell Hospitality Quarterly,52(4),399-406.
30. LaTour, K. A.,Carbone, L. P.(2014).Sticktion: Assessing memory for the customer experience.Cornell Hospitality Quarterly,55(4),342-353.
31. Lee, B. K.,Lee, W. N.(2011).The impact of product knowledge on consumer product memory and evaluation in the competitive ad context: The item-specific-relational perspective.Psychology and Marketing,28(4),360-387.
32. Lee, C. T.,Wang, M. Y.(2017).Appeals of product pictures on the product detail page -The effect of mental imagery.Human-computer interaction, user interface design, development and multimodality,Vancouver, BC:
33. Lerman, D.,Garbarino, E.(2002).Recall and recognition of brand names: A comparison of word and nonword name types.Psychology and Marketing,19(7-8),621-639.
34. Leung, X. Y.,Bai, B.,Erdem, M.(2017).Hotel social media marketing: A study on message strategy and its effectiveness.Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Technology,3(3),211-225.
35. Leung, X. Y.,Bai, B.,Stahura, K. A.(2015).The marketing effectiveness of social media in the hotel industry: A comparison of Facebook and Twitter.Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Research,39(2),147-169.
36. Li, Y. Z.,Han, X.(2015).A content analysis of hotel advertisements in China.Journal of Economics, Business and Management,3(2),188-193.
37. Lynch, J. G.,Srull, T. K.(1982).Memory and attentional factors in consumer choice: Concepts and research methods.Journal of Consumer Research,9(1),18-37.
38. MacKay, K. J.,Smith, M. C.(2006).Destination advertising: Age and format effects on memory.Annals of Tourism Research,33(1),7-24.
39. Maheswaran, D.,Sternthal, B.(1990).The effects of knowledge, motivation, and type of message on ad processing and product judgments.Journal of Consumer Research,17(1),66-73.
40. Martin, B. A. S.,Sherrard, M. J.,Wentzel, D.(2005).The role of sensation seeking and need for cognition on web-site evaluations: A resource-matching perspective.Psychology and Marketing,22(2),109-126.
41. McCarthy, L.,Stock, D.,Verma, R.(2010).How travelers use online and social media channels to make hotel-choice decisions.Cornell Hospitality Report,10(18),6-18.
42. Na, S.,Dennis, R.,Bixuan, S.(2015).How to make your Facebook posts attractive: A case study of a leading budget hotel brand fan page.International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management,27(8),1772-1790.
43. Nowlis, S. M.,Shiv, B.(2005).The influence of consumer distractions on the effectiveness of food-sampling programs.Journal of Marketing Research,42(2),157-168.
44. Pan, B.,Zhang, L.,Law, R.(2013).The complex matter of online hotel choice.Cornell Hospitality Quarterly,54(1),74-83.
45. Park, C. W.,Moon, B. J.(2003).The relationship between product involvement and product knowledge: Moderating roles of product type and product knowledge type.Psychology and Marketing,20(11),977-997.
46. Park, C. W.,Mothersbaugh, D. L.,Feick, L.(1994).Consumer knowledge assessment.Journal of Consumer Research,21(2),71-82.
47. Park, D. H.,Kim, S.(2008).The effects of consumer knowledge on message processing of electronic word-of-mouth via online consumer reviews.Electronic Commerce Research and Applications,7(4),399-410.
48. Peracchio, L. A.,Meyers-Levy, J.(1997).Evaluating persuasion-enhancing techniques from a resource-matching perspective.Journal of Consumer Research,24(2),178-191.
49. Pieters, R. G. M.,Bijmolt, T. H. A.(1997).Consumer memory for television advertising: A field study of duration, serial position, and competition effects.Journal of Consumer Research,23(4),362-372.
50. Roberson, Q. M.,Collins, C. J.,Oreg, S.(2005).The effects of recruitment message specificity on applicant attraction to organizations.Journal of Business and Psychology,19(3),319-339.
51. Schweizer, K.(2016).A confirmatory factor model for the investigation of cognitive data showing a ceiling effect: An example.Quantitative psychology research: The 80th Annual Meeting of the Psychometric Society,Cham, Switzerland:
52. Simons, H. W.,Jones, J. G.(2011).Persuasion in society.London, UK:Taylor & Francis.
53. Sparks, B. A.,Browning, V.(2011).The impact of online reviews on hotel booking intentions and perception of trust.Tourism Management,32(6),1310-1323.
54. Tung, V. W. S.,Lin, P.,Qiu Zhang, H.,Zhao, A.(2017).A framework of memory management and tourism experiences.Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing,34(7),853-866.
55. Velikova, N.,Howell, R. D.,Dodd, T.(2015).The development of an objective wine knowledge scale: The item response theory approach.International Journal of Wine Business Research,27(2),103-124.
56. Verma, R.,Victorino, L.,Karniouchina, K.,Feickert, J.(2007).Segmenting hotel customers based on the technology readiness index [Electronic article].Cornell Hospitality Report,7(13),6-13.
57. Vermeulen, I. E.,Seegers, D.(2009).Tried and tested: The impact of online hotel reviews on consumer consideration.Tourism Management,30(1),123-127.
58. Viswanathan, M.,Torelli, C. J.,Xia, L.,Gau, R.(2009).Understanding the influence of literacy on consumer memory: The role of pictorial elements.Journal of Consumer Psychology,19(3),389-402.
59. Walker, B.,Celsi, R.,Olson, J.(1987).Exploring the structural characteristics of consumers' knowledge.Advances in Consumer Research,Provo, UT:
60. Wei, S.,Ruys, H. F.,van Hoof, H. B.,Combrink, T. E.(2001).Uses of the internet in the global hotel industry.Journal of Business Research,54(3),235-241.
61. Wu, L. L.,Lin, J. Y.(2006).The quality of consumers decision-making in the environment of e-commerce.Psychology & Marketing,23(4),297-311.
62. Xie, H.,Miao, L.,Kuo, P. J.,Lee, B. Y.(2011).Consumers' responses to ambivalent online hotel reviews: The role of perceived source credibility and pre-decisional disposition.International Journal of Hospitality Management,30(1),178-183.
63. 中華人民共和國國家旅遊局，(2017)，2016 年中國旅遊業統計公報【線上資料】，來源：http://www.cnta.gov.cn/zwgk/lysj/201711/t20171108_846343.shtml [2017, November 10]。【China National Tourism Administration. (2017). China tourism statistical bulletin. Retrieved November 10, 2017, from http://www.cnta.gov.cn/zwgk/lysj/201711/t20171108_846343.shtml】