题名

危機還是轉機？異地重建下觀光產業對社區復原力之影響

并列篇名

A Crisis or a Chance? Exploring Post-Disaster Community Resilience from the Tourism Industry Perspectives

DOI

10.6267/JTLS.202104_27(1).0001

作者

林信宏(Hsin-Hung (Sean) Lin)；張景煜(Ching-Yu (Richard) Chang)

关键词

災後觀光 ； 社區復原力 ； 異地重建 ； 好茶社區 ； 文化觀光 ； post-disaster tourism ； community resilience ； community relocation ； Kucapungane community

期刊名称

觀光休閒學報

卷期/出版年月

27卷1期（2021 / 04 / 01）

页次

1 - 31

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

過去災後觀光相關研究顯少探討原以第一級產業為生的社區如何透過發展觀光產業使其能永續發展。爰此，本研究以遷村三次的好茶社區為研究對象，希望透過其異地重建的過程來探討觀光產業發展與災後社區的復原力的影響關係。經由質性方法的聚焦，本研究歸納出觀光產業在災後社區發展所產生的六大復原力影響因素包括經濟價值、族群精神、資源掌握、支持的循環、投入參與、社區意識等。並發現觀光產業發展與社區復原力因素在災後社區會形成互補式的循環模式。本研究期能透過觀光發展與復原力因素的發現帶給災後社區在災後重建過程中逐漸走出陰霾與傷痛，也能在未來不可避免的災難發生後讓世界各地的受災社區和管理單位可以更有效地處理與面對。
英文摘要

Previous post-disaster tourism literature has largely focused on how tourism-based communities recover from various disasters. However, there is little attention on the role of tourism development in affecting ＂non-tourism-based＂ communities' post-disaster recovery and resilience. To reduce this knowledge gap, this study aims to explore the relationship between tourism development and post-disaster community resilience, by using the case of Kucapungane community, a non-tourism based community which has been relocated three times due to two natural disasters. By adopting a qualitative research approach, the findings revealed that tourism development has contributed to post-disaster community resilience in six directions, namely, economic value, ethnic ethos, resource control, continuous support, involvement and participation, and sense of community. The study concludes that tourism development can provide a sense of hope and rebirth to the community during the post-disaster reconstruction process. The study findings is one of the first few attempts to acknowledge the value of tourism development in community resilience and provide the foundation for subsequent management of such incidents in the future.
主题分类 人文學 > 地理及區域研究
社會科學 > 體育學
参考文献
  1. 林信宏, H. H.,張景煜, C. Y. R.,黃宥勝, Y. S.(2019)。災後原住民社區在觀光發展下之社區認同。島嶼觀光研究，12(1)，1-27。
    連結：
  2. 陳永龍, Yong-Long(2010)。莫拉克災後原住民部落再生成的主體化運動。台灣社會研究季刊，78，403-435。
    連結：
  3. 謝志誠, J.-C.,張紉, R.,蔡培慧, P.-H.,王俊凱, C.-K.(2008)。臺灣災後遷村政策之演變與問題。住宅學報，17(2)，81-97。
    連結：
  4. Abhas, K. J.,Duyne, J. E.(2010).Safer homes, stronger communities: A handbook for reconstructing after natural disasters.World Bank.
  5. Adger, W. N.(2000).Social and ecological resilience: are they related?.Progress In Human Geography,24(3),347-364.
  6. Benight, C. C.,Ironson, G.,Klebe, K.,Carver, C. S.,Wynings, C.,Burnett, K.,Greenwood, D.,Baum A,Schneiderman, N.(1999).Conservation of resources and coping self-efficacy predicting distress following a natural disaster: A causal model analysis where the environment meets the mind.Anxiety, Stress And Coping,12(2),107-126.
  7. Berkes, F.,Ross, H.(2013).Community resilience: Toward an integrated approach.Society & Natural Resources,26(1),5-20.
  8. Biggs, D.,Hall, C. M.,Stoeckl, N.(2012).The resilience of formal and informal tourism enterprises to disasters: Reef tourism in Phuket, Thailand.Journal of Sustainable tourism,20(5),645-665.
  9. Biran, A.,Liu, W.,Li, G.,Eichhorn, V.(2014).Consuming post-disaster destinations: The case of Sichuan, China.Annals of Tourism Research,47,1-17.
  10. Blaikie, P.,Cannon, T.,Davis, I.,Wisner, B.(2014).At risk: Natural hazards.Routledge.
  11. Boeije, H.(2010).Analysis in qualitative research.Sage Publications.
  12. Bonanno, G. A.(2008).Loss, trauma, and human resilience: Have we underestimated the human capacity to thrive after extremely aversive events?.American Psychologist,59(1),20.
  13. Brown, D. D.,Kulig, J. C.(1996).The concepts of resiliency: Theoretical lessons from community research.Health and Canadian Society,4(1),29-50.
  14. Bruneau, M.,Chang, S. E.,Eguchi, R. T.,Lee, G. C.,O’Rourke, T. D,Reinhorn, A. M.,Shinozuka, M.,Tierney, K.,Wallace, W. A.,Von Winterfeldt, D.(2003).A framework to quantitatively assess and enhance the seismic resilience of communities.Earthquake Spectra,19(4),733-752.
  15. Buckle, P.,Marsh, G.,Smale, S.(2001).Assessing resilience and vulnerability: principle, strategies and actions.Emergency Management Australia.
  16. Bukvic, A.(2015).Integrated framework for the Relocation Potential Assessment of Coastal Communities (RPACC): Application to Hurricane Sandy-affected areas.Environment Systems and Decisions,35(2),264-278.
  17. Cahyanto, I.,Pennington-Gray, L.(2017).Toward a comprehensive destination crisis resilience framework.Oral presentation at TTRA.,Quebec City, Canada:
  18. Carlsen, J.(2006).Post-tsunami tourism strategies for the Maldives.Tourism Review International,10(1-2),69-79.
  19. Carlsen, J. C.,Hughes, M.(2008).Tourism market recovery in the Maldives after the 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami.Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing,23(2-4),139-149.
  20. Cartier, E. A.,Taylor, L. L.(2020).Living in a wildfire: The relationship between crisis management and community resilience in a tourism-based destination.Tourism Management Perspectives,34,100635.
  21. Cernea, M. M.(1996).Understanding and preventing impoverishment from displacement.Understanding impoverishment: The consequences of developmentinduced displacement
  22. Cheer, J. M.,Milano, C.,Novelli, M.(2019).Tourism and community resilience in the Anthropocene: Accentuating temporal overtourism.Journal of Sustainable Tourism,27(4),554-572.
  23. Coles, E.,Buckle, P.(2004).Developing community resilience as a foundation for effective disaster recovery.Australian Journal of Emergency Management,19(4),6.
  24. Comerio, M. C.(2014).Disaster recovery and community renewal: Housing approaches.Cityscape,16(2),51.
  25. Creswell, J. W.,Clark, V. L. P.(2007).Designing and conducting mixed methods research.Sage.
  26. de Vries, H.,Hamilton, R.(2016).Why stay? The resilience of small firms in Christchurch and their owners.Business and post-disaster management: Business, organisational and consumer resilience and the Christchurch earthquakes,Abingdon:
  27. Drabek, T.E.(1996).Disaster evacuation behavior-Tourists and other transients.Institute of Behavioral Science, University of Colorado.
  28. Espeso-Molinero, P.,Pastor-Alfonso, M. J.(2020).Governance, community resilience, and indigenous tourism in Nahá, Mexico.Sustainability,12(15),5973.
  29. Evans, N.,Elphick, S.(2005).Models of crisis management: An evaluation of their value for strategic planning in the international travel industry.International Journal of Tourism Research,7(3),135-150.
  30. Farrell, S. J.,Aubry, T.,Coulombe, D.(2004).Neighborhoods and neighbors: Do they contribute to personal well‐being?.Journal of Community Psychology,32(1),9-25.
  31. Faulkner, B.(2001).Towards a framework for tourism disaster management.Tourism Management,22(2),135-147.
  32. Fiore, J.,Becker, J.,Coppel, D. B.(1983).Social network interactions: A buffer or a stress.American Journal of Community Psychology,11(4),423-439.
  33. Geertz, C.(1973).The interpretation of cultures: Selected essays.Basic.
  34. Ghaderi, Z.,Som, A. P. M.,Henderson, J. C.(2015).When disaster strikes: The Thai Floods of 2011 and tourism industry response and resilience.Asia Pacific Journal of Tourism Research,20(4),399-415.
  35. Granville, F.,Mehta, A.,Pike, S.(2016).Destinations, disasters and public relations: Stakeholder engagement in multi-phase disaster management.Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Management,28,73-79.
  36. Gurtner, Y.(2016).Returning to paradise: Investigating issues of tourism crisis and disaster recovery on the island of Bali.Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Management,28,11-19.
  37. Gurwitch, R. H.,Pfefferbaum, B.,Montgomery, J. M.,Klopm, R. W.,Reissman, D. B.(2007).Building community resilience for children and families.National Child Traumatic Stress Network.
  38. Hajibaba, H.,Karlsson, L.,Dolnicar, S.(2017).Residents open their homes to tourists when disaster strikes.Journal of Travel Research,56(8),1065-1078.
  39. Hall, C. M.,Malinen, S.,Vosslamber, R.,Wordsworth, R.(2016).Business and post-disaster management: business, organisational and consumer resilience and the christchurch earthquakes.Routledge.
  40. Hammersley, M.(2008).Troubles with triangulation.Advances in mixed methods research
  41. Hassan, A.,Ramkissoon, H.,Shabnam, S.(2017).Community resilience of the Sundarbans: Restoring tourism after oil spillage.Journal of Hospitality and Tourism,15(1),1-18.
  42. Holling, C. S.(1973).Resilience and stability of ecological systems.Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics,4(1),1-23.
  43. Hsu, M.,Howitt, R.,Miller, F.(2015).Procedural vulnerability and institutional capacity deficits in post-disaster recovery and reconstruction: Insights from Wutai Rukai experiences of Typhoon Morakot.Human Organization,74(4),308-318.
  44. Hughey, K.,Becken, S.(2016).Value-engaged evaluation of a tourism-specific disaster management plan.Tourism Management Perspectives,19,69-73.
  45. Ingram, J. C.,Franco, G.,Rio, C. R.-d.,Khazai, B.(2006).Post-disaster recovery dilemmas: challenges in balancing short-term and long-term needs for vulnerability reduction.Environmental Science & Policy,9(7),607-613.
  46. Iuchi, K.,Mutter, J.(2020).Governing community relocation after major disasters: An analysis of three different approaches and its outcomes in Asia.Progress in Disaster Science,6,1-8.
  47. Jha, A. K.,Barenstein, J. D.,Phelps, P. M.,Pittet, D.,Sena, S.(2010).Safer homes, stronger communities: A handbook for reconstruction after natural disasters.The World Bank.
  48. Jick, T. D.(1979).Mixing qualitative and quantitative methods: Triangulation in action.Administrative Science Quarterly,24(4),602-611.
  49. Jogia, J.,Kulatunga, U.,Yates, G.,Wedawatta, G.(2014).Culture and the psychological impacts of natural disasters: Implications for disaster management and disaster mental health.Built and Human Environment Review,7(1),1.
  50. Jurowski, C.,Gursoy, D.(2004).Distance effects on residents’ attitudes toward tourism.Annals of Tourism Research,31(2),296-312.
  51. Kaplan, S., & Fritz, A. (2018). Climate change was behind 15 weather disasters in 2017. The Washington Post. Retrieved December 10, 2018, from: https://www.washingtonpost.com/science/2018/12/10/climate-change-was-behind-weather-disasters/?utm_term=.14452d715a96.
  52. Kirmayer, L. J.,Sehdev, M.,Isaac, C.(2009).Community resilience: Models, metaphors and measures.International Journal of Indigenous Health,5(1),62-117.
  53. Korstanje, M. E.,Tarlow, P.(2013).Disasters, tourism and mobility, the case of Japan earthquake.PASOS. Revista de Turismo y Patrimonio Cultural,11(3),17-32.
  54. Kulatunga, U.(2011).Influence of culture towards disaster risk: The case of Barguna, Bangladesh.International Conference on Building Resilience,Kandalama, Sri Lanka:
  55. Kulig, J. C.,Edge, D. S.,Townshend, I.,Lightfoot, N.,Reimer, W.(2013).Community resiliency: Emerging theoretical insights.Journal of Community Psychology,41(6),758-775.
  56. Lauer, C.(2002).Enrolments in higher education: Do economic incentives matter?.Education+ Training,44(4/5),179-185.
  57. Lincoln, Y. S.,Guba, E. G.(1985).Naturalistic inquiry.Sage.
  58. Mbaiwa, J. E.(2003).The socio-economic and environmental impacts of tourism development on Okavango Delta, North-western Botswana.Journal of Arid Environments,54(2),447-467.
  59. Midgley, J.,Hall, A.,Hardiman, M.,Narine, D.(1986).Community participation, social development and the state.Methuen and Co. Ltd..
  60. Morse, J. M.(2003).Principles of mixed methods and multimethod research design.Handbook of mixed methods in social and behavioral research
  61. Musavengane, R.,Kloppers, R.(2020).Social capital: An investment towards community resilience in the collaborative natural resources management of community-based tourism schemes.Tourism Management Perspectives,34,100654.
  62. Muskat, B.,Nakanishi, H.,Blackman, D.,Ritchie, B.,Campiranon, K.(2015).Integrating tourism into disaster recovery management: The case of the Great East Japan Earthquake and Tsunami 2011.Tourism crisis and disaster management in the Asia-pacific
  63. Nalau, J.,Handmer, J.(2018).Improving development outcomes and reducing disaster risk through planned community relocation.Sustainability,10(10),3545.
  64. Nepal, S.(2015).Natural disasters and tourism.Annual Meeting of the Association of American Geographers,San Francisco, CA:
  65. Norris, F. H.,Stevens, S. P.,Pfefferbaum, B.,Wyche, K. F.,Pfefferbaum, R. L.(2008).Community resilience as a metaphor, theory, set of capacities, and strategy for disaster readiness.American Journal of Community Psychology,41(1-2),127-150.
  66. Norris, F. H.,Uhl, G. A.(1993).Chronic stress as a mediator of acute stress: The case of Hurricane Hugo.Journal of Applied Social Psychology,23(16),1263-1284.
  67. NRC, National Research Council(2012).Disaster resilience: A national imperative.The National Academies Press.
  68. Orchiston(2013).Tourism business preparedness, resilience and disaster planning in a region of high seismic risk: the case of the Southern Alps, New Zealand.Current Issues in Tourism,16(5),477-494.
  69. Patton, M. Q.(2002).Qualitative evaluation and research methods.Sage Publications.
  70. Paul, S.(1987).Community participation in development projects.World Bank.
  71. Pennington-Gray, L.(2018).Reflections to move forward: Where destination crisis anagement research needs to go.Tourism Management Perspectives,25,136-139.
  72. Pérez, E. A.,Nadal, J. R.(2005).Host community perceptions a cluster analysis.Annals of Tourism Research,32(4),925-941.
  73. Pilquimán-Vera, M.,Cabrera-Campos, G.,Tenorio-Pangui, P.(2020).Experiences of resilience and Mapuche community based tourism in the pre-cordilleran territories of Panguipulli, Southern Chile.Sustainability,12(3),817.
  74. Polletta, F.,Jasper, J. M.(2001).Collective identity and social movements.Annual Review of Sociology,27(1),283-305.
  75. Prayag, G.(2016).It’s not all dark! Christchurch residents’ emotions and coping strategies with dark tourism sites.Business and post-disaster management: business, organisational and consumer resilience and the christchurch earthquakes
  76. Prideaux, B.,Laws, E.,Faulkner, B.(2003).Events in Indonesia: Exploring the limits to formal tourism trends forecasting methods in complex crisis situations.Tourism Management,24(4),475-487.
  77. Richards, G.,Hall, D.(2003).Tourism and sustainable community development.Psychology Press.
  78. Rittichainuwat, B. N.(2008).Responding to disaster: Thai and Scandinavian tourists motivation to visit Phuket, Thailand.Journal of Travel Research,46(4),422-432.
  79. Robinson, L.,Jarvie, J. K.(2008).Post‐disaster community tourism recovery: The tsunami and Arugam Bay, Sri Lanka.Disasters,32(4),631-645.
  80. Ronan, K.,Johnston, D.(2005).Promoting community resilience in disasters: The role for schools, youth, and families.Springer Science & Business Media.
  81. Rosenberg, J.(2011).Natural disasters, climate change, and recovery: The sustainability question in post-Ivan Grenada.Community disaster recovery and resiliency: Exploring global opportunities and challenges
  82. Rossman, G. B.,Rallis, S. F.(2012).Learning in the field: An introduction to qualitative research.Sage.
  83. Ruiter, M. C. D.(2011).Post-disaster community recovery: Linking environmental and economic recovery.University of British Columbia.
  84. Scheyvens, R.(2002).Tourism for development: Empowering communities.Pearson Education.
  85. Shapiro, E. (2018). 5 natural disasters that devastated the US in 2018. ABC News. Retrieved, December 8, 2018. from https://abcnews.go.com/US/natural-disasters-devastated-us-2018/story?id=59367683.
  86. Sharpley, R.(2000).Tourism and sustainable development: Exploring the theoretical divide.Journal of Sustainable Tourism,8(1),1-19.
  87. Sheppard, V.,Williams, P.(2015).Systems-based and internal factors enhancing resort community resilience.TTRA International Conference,Portland, Oregon:
  88. Sina, D.,Chang-Richards, A. Y.,Wilkinson, S.,Potangaroa, R.(2019).What does the future hold for relocated communities post-disaster? Factors affecting livelihood resilience.International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction,34,173-183.
  89. Sina, D.,Chang-Richards, A. Y.,Wilkinson, S.,Potangaroa, R.(2019).A conceptual framework for measuring livelihood resilience: Relocation experience from Aceh, Indonesia.World Development,117,253-265.
  90. Smith, K.(2013).Environmental hazards: Assessing risk and reducing disaster.Routledge.
  91. Stacey, M.(2013).Methods of social research: Pergamon international library of science, technology, engineering and social studies.Pergamon.
  92. Sung, Y.-T.,Chang, K.-E.,Lee, Y.-H.,Yu, W.-C.(2008).Effects of a mobile electronic guidebook on visitors’ attention and visiting behaviors.Educational Technology and Society,11(2),67-80.
  93. Taiban, S.,Lin, H. N.,Ko, C. C.(2020).Disaster, relocation, and resilience: recovery and adaptation of Karamemedesane in Lily Tribal Community after Typhoon Morakot, Taiwan.Environmental Hazards,19(2),209-222.
  94. Taylor, R. D.(ed.),Wang, M. C.(ed.)(2012).Resilience across contexts: Family, work, culture, and community.Psychology Press.
  95. Tedeschi, R. G.,Calhoun, L. G.(1995).Trauma & transformation: Growing in the aftermath of suffering.Sage.
  96. Tobin, G. A.(1999).Sustainability and community resilience: The holy grail of hazards planning?.Global Environmental Change Part B: Environmental Hazards,1(1),13-25.
  97. Townshend, I.,Awosoga, O.,Kulig, J.,Fan, H.(2015).Social cohesion and resilience across communities that have experienced a disaster.Natural Hazards,76(2),913-938.
  98. Waller, M. A.(2001).Resilience in ecosystemic context: evolution of the concept.American Journal of Orthopsychiatry,71(3),290.
  99. Wright, D.,Sharpley, R.(2016).Local community perceptions of disaster tourism: The case of L'Aquila, Italy.Current Issues in Tourism,21(14),1569-1585.
  100. Xu, J.,Wang, Z.,Shen, F.,Ouyang, C.,Tu, Y.(2016).Natural disasters and social conflict: A systematic literature review.International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction,17,38-48.
  101. Yang, W.,Wang, D.,Chen, G.(2011).Reconstruction strategies after the Wenchuan earthquake in Sichuan, China.Tourism Management,32(4),949-956.
  102. Zahran, S.,Brody, S. D.,Peacock, W. G.,Vedlitz, A.,Grover, H.(2008).Social vulnerability and the natural and built environment: a model of flood casualties in Texas.Disasters,32(4),537-560.
  103. Zakour, M. J.(1997).Disaster research in social work.Journal of Social Service Research,22(1-2),7-25.
  104. Žiković, R. G.(2013).Coastal tourism resort development and challenges: a comparative study of Galveston, Texas USA and Opatija, Croatia.2nd International Scientific Conference Tourism in South East Europe: Crisis-a challenge of sustainable tourism development?,Opatija, Croatia:
  105. 台邦．撒沙勒, Sasala(2012)。災難、遷村與社會脆弱性：古茶波安的例子。臺灣人類學刊，10(1)，51-92。
  106. 行政院內政部營建署（2012），莫拉克永久屋興建成果。【線上資料】，來源：http://www.cpami.gov.tw/chinese/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=14534&Itemid=54 [2016, January 20]【Construction and Planning Agency Ministry of the Interior, C.P.A.M.I. Republic of China. (2012). Construction of the morako permanent house. Retrieved January 20, 2016, from: http://www.cpami.gov.tw/chinese/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=14534&Itemid=54】
  107. 茂林國家風景區，（2020），遊客人次統計。【線上資料】，來源： https://www.maolin-nsa.gov.tw/04007525.html [2020, August 27 ]【Maolin National Scenic Area Administration. (2020). Visitor statistics. Retrieved August 27, 2020, from: https://www.maolin-nsa.gov.tw/04007525.html】
  108. 許俊才, Kasirisir(2014)。翻「牆」回「家」?kulaluce 部落災後重建生活適應之研究。臺灣原住民族的文化發展及遷移適應，花蓮=Hualien:
  109. 奧威尼．卡露斯=Auvini-Kadresengan(1996).雲豹的傳人.台中=Taichung:晨星=Morning Star.
print cancel