题名

分數重要還是人氣重要？自我建構對消費者觀看餐廳評論線索之影響

并列篇名

What's More Important: Reviews Volume or Rating? The Effect of Self-Construals on Consumers' Viewing of Restaurant Review Cues

DOI

10.6267/JTLS.202204_28(1).0004

作者

方正璽(Cheng-Hsi Fang)；李佳羚(Jia-Ling Li)；林孟彥(Tom, M.Y. Lin)

关键词

推薦系統 ； 網路評價 ； 自我建構 ； 決策支援系統 ； 線索診斷性框架 ； recommendation system ； online reviews ； self-construals ； decision support system ； cue diagnosticity framework

期刊名称

觀光休閒學報

卷期/出版年月

28卷1期（2022 / 04 / 01）

页次

99 - 129

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

消費者於消費前透過網站查詢評論已是日常慣例。實務上，常見評分高但評論人數少，亦或評論人數很多，但分數卻稍低的情況。評價分數反映餐廳品質、評量則反映餐廳的熱門程度，兩者隱含不同的訊息。根據線索診斷性框架，本研究認為不同自我建構的消費者會偏好不同類型的評論資訊。實驗一收集69份問卷，證實獨立我之自我建構消費者更重視評價分數；反之，相依我之自我建構消費者則更偏好以評論人數來做為決策依據。實驗二則加入產品類型的操弄，共計343份問卷。結果證實對體驗型產品（飯店下午茶）而言，上述假說再次獲得證實；但若為耐久性產品時，則所有消費者都偏好以評量做為判斷標準。在餐飲決策中，評量比評價更具診斷性，但消費者自我建構不同，其偏好之線索也有所不同。最後，本文於文末提出管理與實務意涵，以供學術與實務上參考。
英文摘要

It has become a daily practice for consumers to check reviews on websites before making a purchase. In practice, it's common to have a high score but few comments, or a large number of comments but a slightly lower score. The evaluation score reflects the quality of the restaurant, and the evaluation reflects the popularity of the restaurant, and the two imply different messages. Based on the cue diagnosticity framework, this study suggests that consumers with different self-construals will prefer different types of review information. In the first experiment, 69 questionnaires were collected, which confirmed that independent self-construal consumers paid more attention to evaluation scores; on the contrary, dependent self-construal consumers preferred the number of comments as the basis for decision-making. The second experiment added manipulation of product types, with a total of 343 questionnaires. The results confirmed that the above hypothesis was confirmed again for experiential products (afternoon tea in restaurants); but, for durable products, all consumers preferred to use evaluation as the judgment standard. In the food and beverage decision-making, assessment is more diagnostic than evaluation, but consumers' self-construals have different clues to their preferences. Finally, the management and practical implications are presented at the end of this paper for academic and practical reference.
主题分类 人文學 > 地理及區域研究
社會科學 > 體育學
参考文献
  1. 倪家珍, J. J.,王笠言, L. Y.,林孟彥, Tom M. Y.(2020)。住宿業訂房平台線上評論之比較性分析－以 Agoda 與Airbnb 為例。觀光休閒學報，26(3)，259-282。
    連結：
  2. Aaker, J. L.,Lee, A. Y.(2001).I” seek pleasures and “we” avoid pains: The role of selfregulatory goals in information processing and persuasion.Journal of Consumer Research,28(1),33-49.
  3. Aaker, J. L.,Williams, P.(1998).Empathy versus pride: The influence of emotional appeals across cultures.Journal of Consumer Research,25(3),241-261.
  4. Aerts, G.,Smits, T.,Verlegh, P. W. J.(2017).How online consumer reviews are influenced by the language and valence of prior reviews: A construal level perspective.Computers in Human Behavior,75,855-864.
  5. Agrawal, N.,Maheswaran, D.(2005).The effects of self-construal and commitment on persuasion.Journal of Consumer Research,31(4),841-849.
  6. Akdeniz, B.,Calantone, R. J.,Voorhees, C. M.(2013).Effectiveness of marketing cues on consumer perceptions of quality: The moderating roles of brand reputation and third‐party information.Psychology & Marketing,30(1),76-89.
  7. Aljukhadar, M.,Trifts, V.,Senecal, S.(2017).Consumer self-construal and trust as determinants of the reactance to a recommender advice.Psychology & Marketing,34(7),708-719.
  8. Baek, H.,Ahn, J.,Choi, Y.(2012).Helpfulness of online consumer reviews: Readers' objectives and review cues.International Journal of Electronic Commerce,17(2),99-126.
  9. Banerjee, S.,Bhattacharyya, S.,Bose, I.(2017).Whose online reviews to trust? Understanding reviewer trustworthiness and its impact on business.Decision Support Systems,96,17-26.
  10. Bansal, H. S.,Voyer, P. A.(2000).Word-of-mouth processes within a services purchase decision context.Journal of Service Research,3(2),166-177.
  11. Baum, D.,Spann, M.(2014).The interplay between online consumer reviews and recommender systems: An experimental analysis.International Journal of Electronic Commerce,19(1),129-162.
  12. Byun, K.,Ma, M.,Kim, K.,Kang, T.(2021).Buying a new product with inconsistent product reviews from multiple sources: The role of information diagnosticity and advertising.Journal of Interactive Marketing,55(1),81-103.
  13. Caciopp, J. T.,Petty, R. E.(1984).The elaboration likelihood model of persuasion.Advances in Consumer Research,11,673-675.
  14. Cheema, A.,Kaikati, A. M.(2010).The effect of need for uniqueness on word of mouth.Journal of Marketing Research,47(3),553-563.
  15. Chen, C. W.(2017).Five-star or thumbs-up? The influence of rating system types on users’ perceptions of information quality, cognitive effort, enjoyment and continuance intention.Internet Research,27(3),478-494.
  16. Chen, P. Y. S.,Wu, S. Y.,Yoon, J.(2004).The impact of online recommendations and consumer feedback on sales.Proceedings of the international conference on information systems. ICIS 2004 PROCEEDINGS
  17. Chena, Y.,Fay, S.,Wang, Q.(2011).The role of marketing in social media: How online consumer reviews evolve.Journal of Interactive Marketing,25(2),85-94.
  18. Cheung, C. M. K.,Thadani, D. R.(2012).The impact of electronic word-of-mouth communication: A literature analysis and integrative model.Decision Support Systems,54(1),461-470.
  19. Cheung, M. Y.,Luo, C.,Sia, C. L.,Chen, H.(2009).Credibility of electronic word-ofmouth: Informational and normative determinants of on-line consumer recommendations.International Journal of Electronic Commerce,13(4),9-38.
  20. Chevalier, J. A.,Mayzlin, D.(2006).The effect of word of mouth on sales: Online book reviews.Journal of Marketing Research,43(3),345-354.
  21. Chong, A. Y. L.,Ch’ng, E.,Liu, M. J.,Li, B.(2017).Predicting consumer product demands via Big Data: The roles of online promotional marketing and online reviews.International Journal of Production Research,55(17),5142-5156.
  22. Chow, C. W. C.,Chow, C. S. F.,Lai, J. Y. M.,Zhang, L. L.(2022).Online group-buying:The effect of deal popularity on consumer purchase intention.Journal of Consumer Behaviour,21(2),387-399.
  23. Chung, M.,Saini, R.(2022).Consumer self-uncertainty increases price dependency.Journal of Business Research,140,40-48.
  24. Cui, G.,Lui, H. K.,Guo, X.(2012).The effect of online consumer reviews on new product sales.International Journal of Electronic Commerce,17(1),39-58.
  25. Dellarocas, C.(2003).The digitization of word of mouth: Promise and challenges of online feedback mechanisms.Management Science,49(10),1407-1424.
  26. Doh, S. J.,Hwang, J. S.(2009).How consumers evaluate eWOM (electronic word-ofmouth) messages.CyberPsychology & Behavior,12(2),193-197.
  27. Duan, W.,Gu, B.,Whinston, A. B.(2008).Do online reviews matter? — An empirical investigation of panel data.Decision Support Systems,45(4),1007-1016.
  28. Escalas, J. E.,Bettman, J. R.(2005).Self-construal, reference groups, and brand meaning.Journal of Consumer Research,32(3),378-389.
  29. Fang, C.-H.,Lee, H.-J.(2009).Food-related lifestyle segments in Taiwan: Application of the food-related lifestyle instrument.American Journal of Applied Sciences,6(12),2036-2042.
  30. Filieri, R.(2015).What makes online reviews helpful? A diagnosticity-adoption framework to explain informational and normative influences in e-WOM.Journal of Business Research,68(6),1261-1270.
  31. Filieri, R.,Raguseo, E.,Vitari, C.(2018).When are extreme ratings more helpful? Empirical evidence on the moderating effects of review characteristics and product type.Computers in Human Behavior,88,134-142.
  32. Fretwell, L.,Stine, J.,Sethi, H.,Noronha, A.(2013).,CISCO Internet Business Solutions Group.
  33. Gu, B.,Park, J.,Konana, P.(2012).Research note-the impact of external word-of-mouth sources on retailer sales of high-involvement products.Information Systems Research,23(1),182-196.
  34. Gu, B.,Tang, Q.,Whinston, A. B.(2013).The influence of online word-of-mouth on long tail formation.Decision Support Systems,56,474-481.
  35. Gudykunst, W. B.,Lee, C. M.(2003).Assessing the validity of self construal scales: A response to Levine et al.Human Communication Research,29(2),253-274.
  36. Harb, C.,Smith, P. B.(2008).Self-construals across cultures: Beyond independence—interdependence.Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology,39(2),178-197.
  37. Hayes, A. F.(2018).Introduction to mediation, moderation, and conditional process analysis: A regression-based approach.Guilford Press.
  38. Hong, J.,Chang, H. H.(2015).I” follow my heart and “We” rely on reasons: The impact of self-construal on reliance on feelings versus reasons in decision making.Journal of Consumer Research,41(6),1392-1411.
  39. Kao, K. C.,Rao Hill, S.,Troshani, I.(2021).A cross-country comparison of online deal popularity effect.Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services,60,1-10.
  40. Kao, K. C.,Rao Hill, S.,Troshani, I.(2020).Effects of cue congruence and perceived cue authenticity in online group buying.Internet Research,30(3),945-970.
  41. Kassemeier, R.,Haumann, T.,Güntürkün, P.(2021).Whether, when, and why functional company characteristics engender customer satisfaction and customer-company identification: The role of self-definitional needs.International Journal of Research in Marketing
  42. Keh, H. T.,Ji, W.,Wang, X.,Sy-Changco, J. A.,Singh, R.(2015).Online movie ratings: A cross-cultural, emerging Asian markets perspective.International Marketing Review,32(3/4),366-388.
  43. Khare, A.,Labrecque, L. I.,Asare, A. K.(2011).The assimilative and contrastive effects of word-of-mouth volume: An experimental examination of online consumer ratings.Journal of Retailing,87(1),111-126.
  44. Kim, S. H.,Park, N.,Park, S. H.(2013).Exploring the effects of online word of mouth and expert reviews on theatrical movies' box office success.Journal of Media Economics,26(2),98-114.
  45. King, R. A.,Racherla, P.,Bush, V. D.(2014).What we know and don't know about online word-of-mouth: A review and synthesis of the literature.Journal of Interactive Marketing,28(3),167-183.
  46. Kordrostami, E.,Liu-Thompkins, Y.,Rahmani, V.(2021).Investigating the influence of regulatory focus on the efficacy of online review volume versus valence.European Journal of Marketing,55(1),297-314.
  47. Kwon, O.,Sung, Y.(2012).Shifting selves and product reviews: How the effects of product reviews vary depending on the self-views and self-regulatory goals of consumers.International Journal of Electronic Commerce,17(1),59-82.
  48. Langan, R.,Besharat, A.,Varki, S.(2017).The effect of review valence and variance on product evaluations: An examination of intrinsic and extrinsic cues.International Journal of Research in Marketing,34(2),414-429.
  49. Lee, A. Y.,Aaker, J. L.(2004).Bringing the frame into focus: The influence of regulatory fit on processing fluency and persuasion.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,86(2),205-218.
  50. Lee, A. Y.,Aaker, J. L.,Gardner, W. L.(2000).The pleasures and pains of distinct self-construals: The role of interdependence in regulatory focus.Journal of Personality & Social Psychology,78(6),1122-1134.
  51. Lee, D.,Kim, H. S.,Kim, J. K.(2012).The role of self-construal in consumers’ electronic word of mouth (eWOM) in social networking sites: A social cognitive approach.Computers in Human Behavior,28(3),1054-1062.
  52. Lee, E. J.,Shin, S. Y.(2014).When do consumers buy online product reviews? Effects of review quality, product type, and reviewer's photo.Computers in Human Behavior,31,356-366.
  53. Lee, K.,Shavitt, S.(2006).The use of cues depends on goals: Store reputation affects product judgments when social identity goals are salient.Journal of Consumer Psychology,16(3),260-271.
  54. Liu, H.,Jayawardhena, C.,Osburg, V. S.,Mohiuddin Babu, M.(2020).Do online reviews still matter post-purchase?.Internet Research,30(1),109-139.
  55. Liu, Y.(2006).Word of mouth for movies: Its dynamics and impact on box office revenue.Journal of Marketing,70(3),74-89.
  56. Ma, X.,Khansa, L.,Deng, Y.,Kim, S. S.(2013).Impact of prior reviews on the subsequent review process in reputation systems.Journal of Management Information Systems,30(3),279-310.
  57. Man Yee, C.,Chuan, L.,Choon Ling, S.,Huaping, C.(2009).Credibility of electronic word-of-mouth: Informational and normative determinants of on-line consumer recommendations.International Journal of Electronic Commerce,13(4),9-38.
  58. Markus, H. R.,Kitayama, S.(1991).Culture and the self: Implications for cognition, emotion, and motivation.Psychological Review,98(2),224-253.
  59. Moe, W. W.,Trusov, M.(2011).The value of social dynamics in online product ratings forums.Journal of Marketing Research,48(3),444-456.
  60. Nielsen (2013). Global trust in advertising and brand messages. Nielsen.
  61. Nisbett, R. E.,Peng, K.,Choi, I.,Norenzayan, A.(2001).Culture and systems of thought: Holistic versus analytic cognition.Psychological Review,108(2),291-310.
  62. Öğüt, H.,Onur Taş, B. K(2012).The influence of internet customer reviews on the online sales and prices in hotel industry.The Service Industries Journal,32(2),197-214.
  63. Park, C.,Lee, T. M.(2009).Information direction, website reputation and eWOM effect: A moderating role of product type.Journal of Business Research,62(1),61-67.
  64. Park, D. H.,Kim, S.(2008).The effects of consumer knowledge on message processing of electronic word-of-mouth via online consumer reviews.Electronic Commerce Research and Applications,7(4),399-410.
  65. Purohit, D.,Srivastava, J.(2001).Effect of manufacturer reputation, retailer reputation, and product warranty on consumer judgments of product quality: A cue diagnosticity framework.Journal of Consumer Psychology,10(3),123-134.
  66. Ryu, G.,Han, J. K.(2009).Word-of-mouth transmission in settings with multiple opinions: The impact of other opinions on WOM likelihood and valence.Journal of Consumer Psychology,19(3),403-415.
  67. Sen, S.,Lerman, D.(2007).Why are you telling me this? An examination into negative consumer reviews on the Web.Journal of Interactive Marketing,21(4),76-94.
  68. Simpson, B.,White, K.,Laran, J.(2018).When public recognition for charitable giving backfires: The role of independent self-construal.Journal of Consumer Research,44(6),1257-1273.
  69. Skowronski, J. J.,Carlston, D. E.(1987).Social judgment and social memory: The role of cue diagnosticity in negativity, positivity, and extremity biases.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,52(4),689-699.
  70. Slovic, P.,MacPhillamy, D.(1974).Dimensional commensurability and cue utilization in comparative judgment.Organizational Behavior and Human Performance,11(2),172-194.
  71. Wen, J.,Lin, Z.,Liu, X.,Xiao, S. H.,Li, Y.(2021).The interaction effects of online reviews, brand, and price on consumer hotel booking decision making.Journal of Travel Research,60(4),846-859.
  72. Yang, J.,Kim, W.,Amblee, N.,Jeong, J.(2012).The heterogeneous effect of WOM on product sales: Why the effect of WOM valence is mixed?.European Journal of Marketing,46(11/12),1523-1538.
  73. Yang, Z.,Sun, S.,Lalwani, A. K.,Janakiraman, N.(2019).How does consumers' local or global identity influence price–perceived quality associations? The role of perceived quality variance.Journal of Marketing,83(3),145-162.
  74. Zhang, J. Q.,Craciun, G.,Shin, D.(2010).When does electronic word-of-mouth matter? A study of consumer product reviews.Journal of Business Research,63(12),1336-1341.
  75. Zhu, F.,Zhang, X.(2010).Impact of Online Consumer Reviews on Sales: The Moderating Role of Product and Consumer Characteristics.Journal of Marketing,74(2),133-148.
被引用次数
  1. 楊閔涵,林孟彥,方正璽(2023)。誰愛看AI翻譯評論？調節焦點與解釋水平理論之觀點。觀光休閒學報，29(1)，95-124。
  2. (2023)。舌尖上的美好－米其林指南推薦餐廳三顆星的重量？。觀光休閒學報，29(3)，347-368。
print cancel