投資人情緒與愚笨錢效果之研究

A Study of Investor Sentiment and Dumb Money Effect

陳信憲(Bryan H. Chen)；蔡佳穎(Chia-Yin Tsai)

投資人情緒 ； 基金流量 ； 愚笨錢效果 ； Investor sentiment ； Fund flow ； Dumb money effect

企業管理學報

87期（2010 / 12 / 01）

1 - 26

繁體中文

本研究利用共同基金流量衡量投資人情緒，探討投資人情緒對於共同基金績效以及基金持股超額報酬之影響，並進一步探討其相互關係。本研究之投資標的為國內上市櫃股票之開放式股票型基金為研究對象，研究期間為2000年1月至2008年12月。研究結果顯示，共同基金在短期投資人之情緒水準下，存在愚笨錢效果。我們發現高情緒的基金比低情緒的基金其在未來的績效相對較差。不論前期基金績效的高低，基金績效存在持續性現象，且高情緒的基金其未來績效皆不如低情緒的基金。此外，在基金持股的超額報酬方面，發現高情緒的股票比低情緒的股票其在未來的超額報酬相對較差，若高情緒使得股價被推動而超過了基本價值，其在未來將會出現低報酬。因此，不論前期股票報酬的高低，高情緒的股票其在未來報酬皆不如低情緒的股票。

In this study, we use mutual fund flows as a proxy of individual investor sentiment to explore whether investor sentiment affects mutual fund performance and excess return. All domestic open-end equity mutual funds from January 2000 to December 2008 were included in this study. The results show that there is dumb money effect in short horizons of investor sentiment. We found that mutual funds with lower investor sentiment exhibit higher future return than those with higher investor sentiment, no matter the funds had high or low past return. Excess return of stocks also shows the same results. Due to the high sentiment, stock price was raised over its fundamental value. So, high sentiment investor always has lower future return than low sentiment investor in the future. Therefore, we can conclude that investors' sentiment would affect their wealth. Consequently, investors should avoid emotional investment behavior.

1. 池祥萱、林煜恩、周賓凰(2007)。基金績效持續與聰明錢效果：台灣實證。管理學報，24(3)，307-330。
   連結：
2. Gemmill, G. & Thomas, C. (2004). Does Governance Affect the Performance of Closed-End Funds? (Cass Business School ,Working Paper)
3. Baker, M.,Jeremy, C. S.(2002).NBER Working PaperNBER Working Paper,未出版
4. Blake, C. R.,Elton, E. J.,Gruber, M. J.(1996).The persistence of risk-adjusted mutual fund performance.Journal of Business,69(2),133-157.
5. Carhart, M. M.(1997).On persistence in mutual fund performance.Journal of Finance,52(1),57-82.
6. Edelen, R.,Warner, J.(2001).Aggregate price effects of institutional trading: A study of mutual fund flow and market returns.Journal of Financial Economics,59(2),195-220.
7. Frazzini, A.,Lamont, O. A.(2008).Dumb money: Mutual fund flows and the cross-section of stock returns.Journal of Financial Economics,88(2),299-322.
8. Goetzmann, W. N.,Ibbotson, R. G.(1994).Do winners repeat? Pattern in mutual fund performance.Journal of Portfolio Management,20,9-17.
9. Gruber, M. J.(1996).Another puzzle: The growth in actively managed mutual funds.Journal of Finance,51(3),783-810.
10. Jensen, M. C.(1968).The performance of mutual funds in the period 1945-1964.The Journal of Finance,23(2),389-416.
11. Karceski, J.(2002).Returns-chasing behavior, mutual funds, and beta's death.Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,37(4),559-594.
12. Lee, W. Y.,Christine, X. J.,Daniel, C. I.(2002).Stock market volatility, excess returns, and the role of investor sentiment.Journal of Banking & Finance,26(12),2277-2299.
13. Lettau, M.(1997).Explaining the facts with adaptive agent: The case of mutual fund flows.Journal of Economic Dynamics & Control,21(7),1117-1147.
14. Lynch, A. W.,Musto, D. K.(2003).How investors interpret past fund returns.Journal of Finance,58(5),2033-2058.
15. Potter, M.(2000).Determinants of aggregate mutual fund flows.Journal of Business & Economic studies,6(2),55-74.
16. Potter, M.(1996).MA,University of Massachusetts-Amherst.
17. Sapp, T.,Tiwari, A.(2004).Does stock return momentum explain the smart money effect?.Journal of Finance,59(6),2605-2622.
18. Shu, P. G.,Yeh, Y. H.,Yamada, T.(2002).The behavior of taiwan mutual fund investors-performance and fund flows.Pacific-Basin Finance Journal,10(5),583-600.
19. Sirri, E. R.,Tufano, P.(1998).Costly search and mutual fund flows.Journal of Finance,53(5),1589-1622.
20. Warther, V. A.(1995).Aggregate mutual fund flows and security returns.Journal of Financial Economics,39(2-3),209-235.
21. Williamson, P. J.(1972).Measurement and forecasting of mutual fund performance: Choosing an investment strategy.Financial Analysts Journal,28(6),78-84.
22. Zheng, L.(1999).Is money smart? A study of mutual fund investors' fund selection ability.Journal of Finance,54(3),901-933.
23. 周賓凰、張宇志、林美珍(2007)。投資人情緒與股價報酬互動關係。證券市場發展季刊，19(2)，153-190。
24. 林修葳、王佳真(2003)。台灣共同基金績效持續性之研究。管理學報，20(4)，655-688。