整合區間語意選擇性投票法與最大變異法處理公部門之政務官評選問題

Integrate Interval Linguistic Alternative Voting System and Maximum Deviation Method for Administrative Officer Selection in Public Sector

陳詠霖(Yung-Lin Chen)；譚術魁(Shu Kui Tan)

行政管理 ； 人力資源管理 ； 區間語意選擇性投票法 ； 最大變異法 ； Administration Management ； Human Resource Management ； Interval Linguistic Alternative Voting System ； Maximum Deviation Method

聯大學報

11卷2期（2014 / 12 / 01）

131 - 146

繁體中文

政務官的選擇攸關國家長期的發展，好的政務官會訂出使命、願景，並帶領政府部門替國家在特定領域取得良好的施政績效。由於，政務官的政策規劃、執行能力、施政風格、交際手腕與關係人脈都會影響政策施行結果，且不易進行評估，讓專家使用區間語意評估政務官的能力為最符合人性與實際現實狀況的表達方式。區間語意選擇性投票法的優點包括專家可便利的表達意見、選出的政務官具有統治正當性且所選政務官在特定領域出類拔萃而其他領域至少差強人意與具有完全排序的特質。本研究讓專家使用區間語意以彈性地表達意見，並使用最大變異法評估各評估準則的權重，並結合區間語意選擇性投票法進行政務官候選人的排序，然後以政務官評選問題當作範例進行實作，並作簡單的比較以進行分析，最後則進行結論與未來研究的說明。

Administrative Officer Selection is related to the long term development of Nation. A better administrative Officer will set up goal and vision. And he/she will lead the government team to acquire a better policy performance in the special field. Because the policy plan design ability, execution ability, leading style, diplomacy and human resource of administrative officer will influence the performance of policy execution and is not easy to evaluate. Let experts use interval linguistic variable to express their opinions is suitable for human style and practical environment. The advantage of interval linguistic alternative voting system includes convenience for experts to express their opinions, the characteristic of selected administrative officer with best performance in major field and not worst in minor field, the characteristic of completed ranking. In this research, expert uses interval linguistic variable to express their opinion and maximum deviation method is used to acquire the weight of criterion. Interval linguistic alternative voting system is applied to rank administrative officer. A example is implemented for reader understanding proposed method. A simple comparison between proposed method and tradition government selection process is discussed. Finally, conclusion and future research is discussed.

1. Chen, C. T.,Chen, P. Y.(2009).An evaluation model of innovation performance based on fuzzy interval linguistic variables.Journal of the Chinese Institute of Industrial Engineers,26(5),387-396.
   連結：
2. Chen, C.T.,Pai, P.F.,Hung, W.Z.(2011).Applying Linguistic VIKOR and Knowledge Map in Personnel Selection.Asia Pacific Management Review,16,491-502.
   連結：
3. Afshari, A. R.,Yusuff, R. M.,Derayatifar, A. R.(2013).Linguistic Extension of Fuzzy Integral for Group Personnel Selection Problem.Arabian Journal for Science and Engineering,38(10),2901-2910.
4. Baležentis, A.,Baležentis, T.,Brauers, W. K.(2012).Personnel selection based on computing with words and fuzzy MULTIMOORA.Expert Systems with Applications,39(9),7961-7967.
5. Celik, M.,Kandakoglu, A.,Er, I. D.(2009).Structuring fuzzy integrated multi-stages evaluation model on academic personnel recruitment in MET institutions.Expert Systems with Applications,36(3),6918-6927.
6. Chen, C. T.,Huang, C. C.,Pai, P. F.,Hung, W. Z.(2012).Group MCDM Method With Alternative Voting System Based on Multi-Information Environment.Uncertainty Modeling in Knowlege Engineering and Decision Making: Proceedings of the 10th International FLINS Conference
7. Chen, C. T.,Hung, W. Z.(2009).Applying ELECTRE and maximizing deviation method for stock portfolio selection under fuzzy environment.Opportunities and Challenges for Next-Generation Applied Intelligence
8. Chen, C. T.,Pai, P. F.,Hung, W. Z.(2013).A New Decision-Making Process for Selecting Project Leader Based on Social Network and Knowledge Map.International Journal of Fuzzy Systems,15(1)
9. Chien, C. F.,Chen, L. F.(2008).Data mining to improve personnel selection and enhance human capital: A case study in high-technology industry.Expert Systems with applications,34(1),280-290.
10. Chien, C. F.,Chen, L. F.(2007).Using rough set theory to recruit and retain high-potential talents for semiconductor manufacturing.IEEE Transactions on Semiconductor Manufacturing,20(4),528-541.
11. Dellis, A.(2013).The two-party system under alternative voting procedures.Social Choice and Welfare,40,263-284.
12. Ertugrul Karsak, E.(2000).A fuzzy multiple objective programming approach for personnel selection.IEEE International Conference on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics,3,2007-2012.
13. Fan, Z. P.,Feng, B.,Jiang, Z. Z.,Fu, N.(2009).A method for member selection of R&D teams using the individual and collaborative information.Expert systems with Applications,36(4),8313-8323.
14. Gilan, S.S.,Sebt, M.H.,Shahhosseini, V.(2012).Computing with words for hierarchical competency based selection of personnel in construction companies.Applied Soft Computing,12,860-871.
15. Güngör, Z.,Serhadlıoğlu, G.,Kesen, S. E.(2009).A fuzzy AHP approach to personnel selection problem.Applied Soft Computing,9(2),641-646.
16. Herrera, F.(2012).An overview on the 2-tuple linguistic model for computing with words in decision making: Extensions, applications and challenges.Information Sciences,207,1-18.
17. Herrera, F.,Herrera-Viedma, E.,Martínez, L.(2000).A fusion approach for managing multi-granularity linguistic term sets in decision making.Fuzzy Sets and Systems,114(1),43-58.
18. Herrera, F.,Martinez, L.(2001).A model based on linguistic 2-tuples for dealing with multigranular hierarchical linguistic contexts in multi-expert decision-making.IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics Part B: Cybernetics,31(2),227-234.
19. Herrera-Viedma, E.,Cordón, O.,Luque, M.,Lopez, A. G.,Muñoz, A.M.(2003).A model of fuzzy linguistic IRS based on multigranular linguistic information.International Journal of Approximate Reasoning,34,221-239.
20. Huang, Y. C.,Hung, W. Z.(2014).Applying Linguistic Alternative Voting System for Tourism Destination Selection for Enterprise Sightseeing Activity.2014 International conference on Information Management
21. Jun, D.,Tian-tian, F.,Yi-sheng, Y.,Yu, M.(2014).Macro-site selection of wind/solar hybrid power station based on ELECTRE-II.Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews,35,194-204.
22. Keršulienė, V.,Turskis, Z.(2014).A hybrid linguistic fuzzy multiple criteria group selection of a chief accounting officer.Journal of Business Economics and Management,15(2),232-252.
23. Korvin, A.D.,Shipley, M.F.,Kleyle, R.(2002).Utilizing fuzzy compatibility of skill sets for team selection in multi-phase projects.Journal of Engineer Technology Management,19,307-319.
24. Mafakheri, F.,Nasiri, F.,Mousavi, M.(2008).Project agility assessment: an integrated decision analysis approach.Production Planning and Control,19(6),567-576.
25. Nurmi, H.,Salonen, H.(2008).More Borda Count Variations for Project Assesment.Czech Economic Review,2,109-122.
26. Ozyigit, T.,Murat Egi, S.,Aydin, S.,Tunc, N.(2011).Personnel Selection for Manned Diving Operations.Digital Information and Communication Technology and Its Applications
27. Pai, P. F.,Chen, C. T.,Hung, W. Z.(2014).Applying Linguistic Information and Intersection Concept to Improve Effectiveness of Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis Technology.International Journal of Information Technology & Decision Making
28. Powell, G. B.,Dalton, R.,Strom, K.(2014).Comparative Politics Today: A World View.New York:Longman.
29. Ratliff, T. C.(2002).A comparison of Dodgson's method and the Borda count.Economic Theory,20(2),357-372.
30. Roskin, M.G.(2011)。政治學。雙葉書廊。
31. Wu, Z.,Chen, Y.(2007).The maximizing deviation method for group multiple attribute decision making under linguistic environment.Fuzzy Sets and Systems,158,1608-1617.
32. Xu, Z.(2009).An interactive approach to multiple attribute group decision making with multigranular uncertain linguistic information.Group Decision and Negotiation,18(2),119-145.
33. Zadeh, L. A.(1965).Fuzzy sets.Information Control,8,338-353.
34. Zhang, S. F.,Liu, S. Y.(2011).A GRA-based intuitionistic fuzzy multi-criteria group decision making method for personnel selection.Expert Systems with Applications,38(9),11401-11405.
35. 吳瓊恩、李允傑、陳銘薰(2006)。公共管理。智勝文化事業有限公司。
36. 許南雄(2014)。各國人事制度：比較人事制度。千華出版社。
37. 陳詠霖(2013)。管理學。三和文化事業有限公司。