遊戲式身體活動對靜態平衡能力與注意力之影響：一對具妥瑞症狀之泛自閉症雙胞胎國中生個案研究

Effect of Game-Based Physical Activities on Static Balance and Selective Attention - A Case Study of Junior High School Twins with Autism and Tourette Syndrome

10.6172/BSE.201907_44(2).0003

莊佩璇(Pei-Hsuan Chuang)；賴世烱(Shih-Chiung Lai)

自閉症 ； 妥瑞症 ； 注意力 ； 遊戲 ； 靜態平衡能力 ； autism ； attention ； game ； Tourette syndrome ； static balance

特殊教育研究學刊

44卷2期（2019 / 07 / 31）

57 - 81

繁體中文

本研究依據Gentile提出的運動技能分類法，由易到難，設計出適合自閉症學生的遊戲式身體活動，以探討遊戲式身體活動對國中自閉症學生之靜態平衡能力及注意力之影響。研究對象為一對七年級具妥瑞症狀之泛自閉症國中生雙胞胎。在遊戲式身體活動介入前進行平衡能力測量與田字注意力測驗。遊戲式身體活動進行連續八週，一週兩次，一次45分鐘，每次活動結束後，進行靜態平衡能力的測量；注意力評估部分，於每週第二次活動結束後，進行田字注意力測驗。八週活動介入後，分別在第九週及第十週進行保留期的靜態平衡能力測量與注意力測驗。最後，以座標軸散布圖方式呈現時間遞移過程中其靜態平衡能力及注意力之動力變化。本研究有以下發現：一、兩名個案靜態平衡能力的進步軌跡都有進步，但差異頗大，且弟弟的進步幅度優於哥哥。二、個案哥哥的選擇性注意力有提升的趨勢，弟弟則為退步的趨勢。上述研究結果顯示：一、遊戲式身體活動訓練後能提升國中具妥瑞症狀之泛自閉症學生在張眼及閉眼單足站立之靜態平衡能力，且具有良好的介入及維持效果。二、遊戲式身體活動訓練後在提升國中具妥瑞症狀之泛自閉症學生選擇性注意力上成效不一致，對妥瑞症狀發作頻率較低者（個案哥哥）的選擇性注意力有所提升，但對妥瑞症狀發作頻率較高者（個案弟弟）的選擇性注意力則無明顯改善，甚至有倒退趨勢。

Purpose: On the basis of the motor skill taxonomy proposed by Gentile, the researchers designed easy-to-difficult game-based physical activities, which are suitable for students with autism and Tourette syndrome. The study investigated the effects of the game-based physical activities (GPA) on static balance abilities and selective attention in junior high school twins with autism and Tourette syndrome. Methods: The participants were seventh-grade twins with autism and Tourette syndrome. Static balance tests and the Tien-Character Attention Test were empirically applied before the intervention that involved the game-based physical activities. The GPA lasted for eight weeks, twice per week, once for 45 minutes. The static balance was measured after each GPA course, whereas the Tien-Character Attention Test was applied once per week. The 8-weeks changes of the balance and attention were dynamically presented in the coordinate systems. Results/Findings: Through the 8-week intervention involving game-based physical activities, we obtained the following findings: 1) for both twins, the trajectories of improvement in static balance abilities showed very different trends, with the younger brother outperforming the older brother; and 2) the selective attention ability (inferred from the Tien-Character Attention Test scores) of the older brother improved, whereas that of the younger brother degenerated. Conclusions/Implications: The conclusions drawn in this study are outlined as follows: 1) After the intervention involving the game-based physical activities, the static balance abilities of the junior high school twins with autism and Tourette syndrome improved in the acquisition phase as well as the retention phase. 2) The selective attention of the twins with autism and Tourette syndrome was inconsistent. The older brother showed a higher frequency of tics in Tourette than the younger brother did. The younger brother showed more improvement in selective attention abilities from the game-based physical activities than the older brother did. A relatively high frequency of tics in Tourette seemed to engender no improvement in selective attention abilities, and a high frequency of tics may degenerate selective attention abilities.

1. 林秀怡, Shiu-Yi,賴世烱, Shih-Chiung(2017)。d2-test 原則之田字注意力測驗的發展與應用：以國小新式健身操為探討因子。臺灣運動心理學報，17(1)，59-75。
   連結：
2. 蔡佳良, Jia- Liang,黃啟煌, Qi-Huang(2004)。從肌力訓練的角度來看運動對老年人的重要性。大專體育，72，185-191。
   連結：
3. American Psychiatric Association (2013) What Is Autism Spectrum Disorder? Retrieved from https://www.psychiatry.org/patients-families/autism/what-is-autism-spectrum-disorder
4. Berkeley, S. L.,Zittel, L. L.,Pitney, L. V.,Nichols, S. E.(2001).Locomotor and Object Control Skills of Children Diagnosed with Autism.Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly,18(4),405-416.
5. Brickenkamp, R.,Zillmer, E.(1998).D2 test of attention: Manual.Seattle, WA:Hogrefe & Huber.
6. Canitano, R.,Vivanti, G.(2007).Tics and Tourette syndrome in autism spectrum disorders.Autism,11(1),19-28.
7. Carr, J. H.(Ed.),Shepherd, R. D.(Ed.)(2000).Movement science: Foundations for physical therapy.Rockville, MD:Aspen.
8. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2018). New data on Autism. Retrieved from https://www.cdc.gov/ncbddd/autism/data.html
9. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2013). New data on Autism. Retrieved from https://www.cdc.gov/ncbddd/autism/data.html
10. Chen, M. H.,Hsu, J. W.,Huang, K. L.,Su, T. P.,Li, C. T.,Lin, W. C.,Bai, Y. M.(2018).Risk and coaggregation of major psychiatric disorders among first-degree relatives of patients with bipolar disorder: A nationwide population-based study.Psychological Medicine,1-8.
11. Cliff, D. P.,Okely, A. D.,Smith, L. M.,McKeen, K.(2009).Relationships between Fundamental Movement Skills and Objectively Measured Physical Activity in Preschool Children.Pediatric Exercise Science,21(4),436-449.
12. Diamond, A.(2013).Executive functions.Annual Review of Psychology,64(1),135-168.
13. Drollette, E. S.,Shishido, T.,Pontifex, M. B.,Hillman, C. H.(2012).Maintenance of Cognitive Control during and after Walking in Preadolescent Children.Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise,44(10),2017-2024.
14. Flatters, I.,Mushtaq, F.,Hill, L. J.,Holt, R. J.,Wilkie, R. M.,Mon-Williams, M.(2014).The relationship between a child's postural stability and manual dexterity.Experimental Brain Research,232(9),2907-2917.
15. Folstein, S. E.,Rosen-Sheidley, B.(2001).Genetics of autism: complex aetiology for a heterogeneous disorder.Nature Reviews: Genetics,2(12),943-955.
16. Green, D.,Charman, T.,Pickles, A.,Chandler, S.,Loucas, T.,Simonoff, E.,Baird, G.(2009).Impairment in movement skills of children with autistic spectrum disorders.Developmental Medicine & Child Neurology,51(4),311-316.
17. Hillman, C. H.,Pontifex, M. B.,Raine, L. B.,Castelli, D. M.,Hall, E. E.,Kramer, A. F.(2009).The effect of acute treadmill walking on cognitive control and academic achievement in preadolescent children.Neuroscience,159(3),1044-1054.
18. Houwen, S.,Visscher, C.,Hartman, E.,Lemmink, K. A.(2007).Gross Motor Skills and Sports Participation of Children With visual Impairments.Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,78(2),16-23.
19. Jaakkola, T.,Kalaja, S.,Arijutila, J. L.,Virtanen, P.,Watt, A.(2009).Relations among Physical Activity Patterns, Lifestyle Activities, and Fundamental Movement Skills for Finnish Students in Grade 7.Perceptual and Motor Skills,108(1),97-111.
20. Jankovic, J.(2001).Tourette's syndrome.New England Journal of Medicine,345(16),1184-1192.
21. Jasmin, E.,Couture, M.,McKinley, P.,Reid, G.,Fombonne, E.,Gisel, E.(2009).Sensori-motor and Daily Living Skills of Preschool Children with Autism Spectrum Disorders.Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders,39(2),231-241.
22. Kanner, L. (1943). Autistic disturbances of affective contact. Nervous Child, 2, 217-250.
23. Kirk, S. A.,Gallagher, J. J.,Anastasiow, N. J.,Coleman, M. R.(2006).Educating exceptional children.Boston, MA:Houghton Mifflin.
24. Lai, D.-C.,Tseng, Y.-C.,Guo, H.-R.(2013).Trends in the prevalence of childhood disability: Analysis of data from the national disability registry of Taiwan, 2000-2011.Research in Developmental Disabilities,34(11),3766-3772.
25. Leckman, J. F.,Cohen, D. J.(2001).Tourette's syndrome- Tics, obsessions, compulsions: Developmental psychopathology and clinical care.New York, NY:John Wiley & Sons.
26. Leckman, J. F.,Walker, D. E.,Cohen, D. J.(1993).Premonitory urges in Tourette's syndrome.American Journal of Psychiatry,150(1),98-102.
27. Lim, Y. H.,Lee, H. C.,Falkmer, T.,Allison, G. T.,Tan, T.,Lee, W. L.,Morris, S. L.(2018).Effect of Visual Information on Postural Control in Adults with Autism Spectrum Disorder.Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders
28. Lopata, C.,Hamm, E. M.,Volker, M. A.,Sowinski, J. E.,Thomeer, M. L.(2007).Motor and Visuomotor Skills of Children with Asperger's Disorder: Preliminary Findings.Perceptual and Motor Skills,104(3),1183-1192.
29. Magill, R. A.,Anderson, D. I.(2016).Motor learning and control: Concepts and application.New York, NY:McGraw-Hill.
30. Memari, A. H.,Ghanouni, P.,Shayestehfar, M.,Ghaheri, B.(2014).Postural Control Impairments in Individuals With Autism：Teaching Tips and Strategies. Spectrum Disorder: A Critical Review of Current Literature.Asian Journal of Sports Medicine,5(3),e22963.
31. Menear, K.,Smith, S.(2008).Physical Education for Students with Autism: Teaching Tips and Strategies.Teaching Exceptional Children,40(5),32-37.
32. Pan, C.-Y.,Tsai, C.-L.,Chu, C.-H.,Sung, M.-C.,Ma, W.-Y.,Huang, C.-Y.(2016).Objectively Measured Physical Activity and Health-Related Physical Fitness in Secondary School-Aged Male Students With Autism Spectrum Disorders.Physical Therapy,96(4),511-520.
33. Rafie, F.,Ghasemi, A.,Zamani Jam, A.,Jalali, S.(2017).Effect of exercise intervention on the perceptual-motor skills in adolescents with autism.The Journal of Sports Medicine and Physical Fitness,57(1-2),53-59.
34. Raudsepp, L.,Päll, P.(2006).The Relationship between Fundamental Motor Skills and Outside-School Physical Activity of Elementary School Children.Pediatric Exercise Science,18(4),426-435.
35. Robertson, M. M.(2003).Diagnosing Tourette syndrome: Is it a common disorder?.Journal of Psychosomatic Research,55(1),3-6.
36. Shumway-Cook, A.,Woollacott, M. H.(1985).The Growth of Stability: Postural Control from a Developmental Perspective.Journal of Motor Behavior,17(2),131-147.
37. Simonoff, E.,Pickles, A.,Charman, T.,Chandler, S.,Loucas, T.,Baird, G.(2008).Psychiatric Disorders in Children With Autism Spectrum Disorders: Prevalence, Comorbidity, and Associated Factors in a Population-Derived Sample.Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry,47(8),921-929.
38. Staples, K. L.,Reid, G.(2010).Fundamental Movement Skills and Autism Spectrum Disorders.Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders,40(2),209-217.
39. Stins, J. F.,Emck, C.(2018).Balance Performance in Autism: A Brief Overview.Frontiers in Psychology,9,901.
40. Sun, X.,Allison, C.,Matthews, F. E.,Sharp, S. J.,Auyeung, B.,Baron-Cohen, S.,Brayne, C.(2013).Prevalence of autism in mainland China, Hong Kong and Taiwan: A systematic review and meta-analysis.Molecular Autism,4(1),7.
41. Townsend, J.,Courchesne, E.(1994).Parietal Damage and Narrow "Spotlight" Spatial Attention.Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience,6(3),220-232.
42. Wang, H.-S.,Kuo, M.-F.(2003).Tourette's syndrome in Taiwan: an epidemiological study of tic disorders in an elementary school at Taipei County.Brain and Development,25(Supplement 1),S29-S31.
43. Weimer, A. K.,Schatz, A. M.,Lincoln, A.,Ballantyne, A. O.,Trauner, D. A.(2001)."Motor" Impairment in Asperger Syndrome: Evidence for a Deficit in Proprioception.Journal of Developmental & Behavioral Pediatrics,22(2),92-101.
44. Wrotniak, B. H.,Epstein, L. H.,Dorn, J. M.,Jones, K. E.,Kondilis, V. A.(2006).The Relationship Between Motor Proficiency and Physical Activity in Children.Pediatrics,118(6),e1758-e1765.
45. Xavier, J.,Guedjou, H.,Anzalone, S. M.,Boucenna, S.,Guigon, E.,Chetouani, M.,Cohen, D.(2018).Toward a motor signature in autism: Studies from human-machine interaction.L'Enćephale,45(2),182-187.
46. 朱啟誠, Chi-Cheng(2017)。臺北=Taipei, Taiwan，國立臺灣師範大學特殊教育學系=National Taiwan Normal University。
47. 吳靜怡, Ching-Yi(2013)。臺北=Taipei, Taiwan，臺北巿立體育學院運動教育研究所=University of Taipei。
48. 杜戎玨, Jung-Chueh(2011)。兒童妥瑞症簡介。台北市醫師公會會刊，55(4)，13-17。
49. 侯堂盛, Tang-Sheng(2008)。跑走運動對智障者體適能與運動技能之影響研究。嘉大體育健康休閒期刊，7(3)，44-58。
50. 侯堂盛, Tang-Sheng,任秀林, Xiu-Lin,侯均穎, Jun-Ying(2009)。注意力缺陷／過動症兒童體適能之研究。嘉大體育健康休閒期刊，8(1)，165-176。
51. 洪建智, Jian-Zhi(2008)。淺析活化水上活動（游泳）趣味遊戲課程。淡江體育，11，86-92。
52. 教育部（2015）：104年度特殊教育統計年報。取自 https://www.set.edu.tw/Stastic_WEB/sta2/doc/stuA_city_All_spckind_BC/stuA_city_All_spckind_BC_20151021.asp [Ministry of Education (2015). 104 annual special education statistics annual report. Retrieved from https://www.set.edu.tw/Stastic_WEB/sta2/doc/stuA_city_All_spckind_BC/stuA_city_All_spckind_BC_20151021.asp]
53. 教育部（2018）：106年度特殊教育統計年報。取自 https://www.set.edu.tw/Stastic_WEB/sta2/doc/stuA_city_All_spckind_BC/stuA_city_All_spckind_BC_20180320.asp [Ministry of Education (2018). 106 annual special education statistics annual report. Retrieved from https://www.set.edu.tw/Stastic_WEB/sta2/doc/stuA_city_All_spckind_BC/stuA_city_All_spckind_BC_20180320.asp]
54. 曹雅茜, Ya-Qian(2009)。花蓮=Hualian, Taiwan，國立花蓮教育大學身心障礙與輔助科技研究所=National Dong Hwa University。
55. 湯億雯, Yi-Wen(2011)。臺北=Taipei, Taiwan，國立臺灣師範大學體育學系=National Taiwan Normal University。
56. 劉正超, Cheng-Chao(2014)。妥瑞症的現況。醫學與健康期刊，3(1)，89-96。
57. 衛生福利部（2017）：2017 年第二季報表衛生福利部身心障礙者人數統計表。取自 https://dep.mohw.gov.tw/DOS/cp-2976-13823-113.html [Ministry of Health and Welfare (2017). Statistics for the second quarter of 2017, the number of persons with disabilities in the Ministry of Health and Welfare. Retrieved from https://dep.mohw.gov.tw/DOS/cp-2976-13823-113.html]
58. 藍瑋琛, Wei-Chen(2010).自閉症學生敎學策略.臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan:台北市立教育大學特殊教育中心=Special Education Center in University of Taipei.
59. 蘇莉莉, Li-Li(2016)。嘉義=Chiayi, Taiwan，國立嘉義大學體育與健康休閒學系=National Chiayi University。

1. 張凌瑋,佘永吉(2021)。競技疊杯運動教學方案對國小注意力不足過動症學生注意力影響之研究。身心障礙研究季刊，19(1＆2)，25-44。
2. 鍾佳蓁,歐陽佳琪,陳玉枝,許安,張原豪(2020)。以文獻分析法回顧適應體育領域融合與非融合式教育教學策略研究。臺東大學體育學報，33，1-16。
3. (2022)。妥瑞氏症兒童認知行為、教學策略與運動介入之探討。特殊教育季刊，165，25-35。