探討啟聰學校學生持有之科學家意象

Images of Scientists Held by High School Students With Hearing Impairment

10.6172/BSE.202107_46(2).0002

林佳穎(Jia-Ying Lin)；邱美虹(Mei-Hung Chiu)；林佳弘(Jia-Hong Lin)

科學家意象 ； 畫科學家測驗 ； 聽覺障礙學生 ； Draw-a-Scientist Test ； scientist image ； students with hearing impairment

特殊教育研究學刊

46卷2期（2021 / 07 / 31）

31 - 60

繁體中文

學生持有之科學家意象可能會影響他們對科學的態度，以及選讀科學相關科系與職業的意願。已有許多研究討論不同族群、性別與年齡的學生持有之科學家意象，但較少研究討論聽障學生持有之科學家意象。本研究認為可能是因為聽障學生的聽力受損，且溝通能力與閱讀能力受限，故使用問卷或晤談皆不易瞭解他們持有之科學家意象。Chambers於1983年發展出「畫科學家測驗」，受試者僅需在圖畫紙上繪製出人像即可進行評估，故本研究使用畫科學家測驗以瞭解啟聰學校學生持有之科學家意象。本研究參考先前研究發展出「現代科學家檢核表」，並將68位啟聰學校高中生的繪圖資料進行檢核與分析。研究結果顯示啟聰學校高中生持有之科學家特徵最多為整潔乾淨、男科學家、中年以上與有好奇心，女科學家特徵與較多正面印象有正相關，男科學家特徵與較多刻板印象有正相關；啟聰學校高中生持有之科學家類型以刻板印象為最多，並發現學生畫出無關科學家的比例偏高；此外也發現女學生持有較正面的科學家意象，男學生持有較負面的科學家意象，不同年級學生持有之科學家意象無顯著差異。經由深度晤談發現啟聰學校高中生對科學較不感興趣，也認為自己較不適合學習科學。最後本研究建議教師在教導使用手語之啟聰學校高中生時，可以多提供關鍵字線索，以及教導學生自我監控之技巧；並能於教學中多融入女科學家故事、科學有益於社會之議題以及探究與實作活動，讓學生產生科學認同感，進而提升學生參與科學的可能性。

Purpose: Students' images of scientists may affect their attitudes toward science and their willingness to choose science-related fields for majors or careers. Although many studies have investigated the images of scientists held by students of different ethnic groups, genders, and ages, few studies have discussed the images of scientists held by students with hearing impairment. Due to hearing loss, students with hearing impairment have poorer communication and reading abilities. Understanding such students' images of science and scientists through questionnaires or oral interviews alone is not easy. The purpose of this research was to understand the images of scientists held be students with hearing impairment. Methods: Chambers developed the Draw-a- Scientist Test (DAST) in 1983, where students draw an image of a scientist on drawing paper for evaluation. We used the DAST to understand the images of scientists held by students with hearing impairment. Results/Findings: We developed the Modern DAST Checklist based on previous research and analyzed the data from drawings by 68 senior high school students from a local hearing-impaired school. The results revealed that the attributes perceived of scientists held by the students with hearing impairment included neatness or cleanliness, male sex, middle-age or older, and curiosity. Female scientist sex was positively correlated with more positive impressions, and male scientist sex was positively correlated with stereotypes of scientists. The students tended to have stereotypical images of scientists, and a high percentage of students drew pictures of unrelated scientists. In addition, we discovered that female students held more positive images of scientists, and male students held more negative images of scientists. We observed no significant differences in the images of scientists held by students in different grades. Through in-depth interviews, we learned that the students were uninterested in science and believed that they were not suitable for learning science. Conclusions/Implications: Our findings reveal the images of scientists held by students with hearing impairment and the gender-related differences in such images. Overall, we suggest that, when teaching students who use sign language for learning, teachers provide keyword clues and teach students self-monitoring. Teachers can also tell more stories about female scientists than they typically share, discuss scientific issues that are beneficial to society, and implement more practical activities in classrooms to increase students' sense of scientific identity and enhance the possibility of students participating in science. This study proposed follow-up research directions and practical applications as well as provided suggestions for future related activities.

1. 呂紹海, Shao-Hi,巫俊明, Chun-Ming(2008)。國小「自然與生活科技」教科書中科學史內容之分析。新竹教育大學教育學報，25(2)，1-31。
   連結：
2. 張蓓莉, Bey-Lih(2006)。啟動建構學習的教學方式對數學低成就聽覺障礙學生二步驟四則運算文字題的教學效果。特殊教育研究學刊，30，75-94。
   連結：
3. 劉秀丹, Hsiu-Tan(2009)。手語和口語工作記憶機制之異同分析。台灣聽力語言學會雜誌，23，31-47。
   連結：
4. Allen, J. M.,Muragishi, G. A.,Smith, J. L.,Thoman, D. B.,Brown, E. R.(2015).To grab and to hold: Cultivating communal goals to overcome cultural and structural barriers in first-generation college students’ science interest.Translational Issues in Psychological Science,1(4),331-341.
5. Bodzin, A.,Gehringer, M.(2001).Breaking science stereotypes.Science and Children,38(4),36-41.
6. Bohrmann, M. L.,Akerson, V. L.(2001).A teacher’s reflections on her actions to improve her female students’ self-efficacy toward science.Journal of Elementary Science Education,13(2),41-55.
7. Brown, E. R.,Thoman, D. B.,Smith, J. L.,Diekman, A. B.(2015).Closing the communal gap: The importance of communal affordances in science career motivation.Journal of Applied Social Psychology,45(12),662-673.
8. Cawthon, S. W.(2004).Schools for the deaf and the no child left behind act.American Annals of the Deaf,149(4),314-323.
9. Chambers, D. W.(1983).Stereotypic images of the scientist: The draw-a-scientist test.Science Education,67(2),255-265.
10. Christidou, V.,Bonoti, F.,Kontopoulou, A.(2016).American and Greek children’s visual images of scientists.Science & Education,25(5-6),497-522.
11. Easterbrooks, S. R.,Stephenson, B.(2006).An examination of twenty literacy, science, and mathematics practices used to educate students who are deaf or hard of hearing.American Annals of the Deaf,151(4),385-397.
12. Emvalotis, A.,Koutsianou, A.(2018).Greek primary school students’ images of scientists and their work: has anything changed?.Research in Science & Technological Education,36(1),69-85.
13. Farland Smith, D.(2012).Development and field test of the modified Draw A Scientist test and the Draw A Scientist rubric.School Science and Mathematics,112(2),109-116.
14. Ferguson, S. L.,Lezotte, S. M.(2020).Exploring the state of science stereotypes: Systematic review and meta analysis of the Draw A Scientist Checklist.School Science and Mathematics,120(1),55-65.
15. Finson, K. D.(2003).Applicability of the DAST-C to the images of scientists drawn by students of different racial groups.Journal of Elementary Science Education,15(1),15-26.
16. Finson, K. D.,Beaver, J. B.,Cramond, B. L.(1995).Development and field test of a checklist for the Draw A Scientist Test.School Science and Mathematics,95(4),195-205.
17. Flick, L.(1990).Scientist in Residence Program Improving Children's Image of Science.School Science and Mathematics,90(3),204-214.
18. Fung, Y. Y.(2002).A comparative study of primary and secondary school students' images of scientists.Research in Science & Technological Education,20(2),199-213.
19. Gibson, H. L.,Chase, C.(2002).Longitudinal impact of an inquiry based science program on middle school students' attitudes toward science.Science Education,86(5),693-705.
20. Gormally, C. L.,Marchut, A.(2017)."Science Is Not My Thing": Exploring Deaf NonScience Majors' Science Identities.Journal of Science Education for Students with Disabilities,20(1),1-15.
21. Gormally, C.,Inghram, R.(2021).Goggles and White Lab Coats: Students' Perspectives on Scientists and the Continued Need to Challenge Stereotypes.Journal of Microbiology & Biology Education,22(1),1-11.
22. Head, J.(1985).The Personal Response to Science.NY:Cambridge University Press.
23. Holt, J. A.(1994).Classroom attributes and achievement test scores for deaf and hard of hearing students.American Annals of the Deaf,139(4),430-437.
24. Huber, R. A.,Burton, G. M.(1995).What do students think scientists look like?.School Science and Mathematics,95(7),371-376.
25. Kelly, L.(1996).The interaction of syntactic competence and vocabulary during reading by deaf students.The Journal of Deaf Studies and Deaf Education,1(1),75-90.
26. Kelly, L. P.(1995).Processing of bottom-up and top-down information by skilled and average deaf readers and implications for whole language instruction.Exceptional Children,61(4),318-334.
27. Kelly, R. R.,Mousley, K.(2001).Solving word problems: More than reading issues for deaf students.American Annals of the Deaf,146(3),251-262.
28. Krajkovich, J. G.,Smith, J. K.(1982).The development of the image of science and scientists scale.Journal of Research in Science Teaching,19(1),39-44.
29. Liu, H. T.,Tseng, C. H.,Liu, C. J.(2008).A comparison of Taiwanese Sign Language and Manually Coded Chinese: Word length and Short-Term Memory capacity.International Speech Communication Association Tutorial and Research Workshop on Experimental Linguistics,Athen Greece:
30. Luetke-Stahlman, B.,Nielsen, D. C.(2003).The contribution of phonological awareness and receptive and expressive English to the reading ability of deaf students with varying degrees of exposure to accurate English.Journal of Deaf Studies and Deaf Education,8(4),464-484.
31. Mangrubang, F. R.(2004).Preparing elementary education majors to teach science using an inquiry-based approach: The Full Option Science System.American Annals of the Deaf,149(3),290-303.
32. Marschark, M.,Sapere, P.,Convertino, C. M.,Mayer, C.,Wauters, L.,Sarchet, T.(2009).Are deaf students’ reading challenges really about reading?.American Annals of the Deaf,154(4),357-370.
33. Marschark, M.,Wauters, L.(2008).Language comprehension and learning by deaf students.Perspectives on deafness. Deaf cognition: Foundations and outcomes,Oxford, England:
34. McCarthy, D.(2015).Teacher candidates’ perceptions of scientists: Images and attributes.Educational Review,67(4),389-413.
35. Mead, M.,Metraux, R.(1957).Image of the scientist among high-school students.Science,126(3270),384-390.
36. Meyer, C.,Guenther, L.,Joubert, M.(2019).The draw-a-scientist test in an African context: Comparing students’(stereotypical) images of scientists across university faculties.Research in Science & Technological Education,37(1),1-14.
37. Miller, D. I.,Nolla, K. M.,Eagly, A. H.,Uttal, D. H.(2018).The development of children's gender science stereotypes: a meta analysis of 5 decades of US draw a scientist studies.Child Development,89(6),1943-1955.
38. Moores, D. F.,Jatho, J.,Creech, B.(2001).Issues and trends in instruction and deafness: American Annals of the Deaf 1996 to 2000.American Annals of the Deaf,146(2),71-76.
39. Napier, J.,Barker, R.(2004).Accessing university education: Perceptions, preferences, and expectations for interpreting by deaf students.Journal of Deaf Studies and Deaf Education,9(2),228-238.
40. Nunes, T.,Moreno, C.(2002).An intervention program for promoting deaf pupils’ achievement in mathematics.Journal of Deaf Studies and Deaf Education,7(2),120-133.
41. Qi, S.,Mitchell, R. E.(2012).Large-scale academic achievement testing of deaf and hard-of-hearing students: Past, present, and future.Journal of Deaf Studies and Deaf Education,17(1),1-18.
42. Schibeci, R. A.,Sorensen, I.(1983).Elementary school children's perceptions of scientists.School Science and Mathematics,83(1),14-20.
43. She, H. C.(1998).Interaction between different gender students interaction and teacher in junior high school biology classes.Proceedings of the National Science Council: Part D, Mathematics, Science, and Technology Education,8(1),16-21.
44. Simpson, R. D.,Koballa, T. R.,Oliver, J. S.,Crawley, F. E.(1994).Research on the affective dimension of science learning.Handbook of research on science teaching and learning,New York:
45. Steinke, J.,Lapinski, M. K.,Crocker, N.,Zietsman-Thomas, A.,Williams, Y.,Evergreen, S. H.,Kuchibhotla, S.(2007).Assessing media influences on middle school–aged children's perceptions of women in science using the Draw-A-Scientist Test (DAST).Science Communication,29(1),35-64.
46. Subramaniam, K.,Esprívalo Harrell, P.,Wojnowski, D.(2013).Analyzing prospective teachers’ images of scientists using positive, negative and stereotypical images of scientists.Research in Science & Technological Education,31(1),66-89.
47. Swanwick, R.,Oddy, A.,Roper, T.(2005).Mathematics and deaf children: an exploration of barriers to success.Deafness & Education International,7(1),1-21.
48. Thomas, M. D.,Henley, T. B.,Snell, C. M.(2006).The draw a scientist test: A different population and a somewhat different story.College Student Journal,40(1),140-149.
49. Türkmen, H.(2008).Turkish Primary Students' Perceptions about Scientist and What Factors Affecting the Image of the scientists.Eurasia Journal of Mathematics, Science & Technology Education,4(1),55-61.
50. Vosganoff, D.,Paatsch, L. E.,Toe, D. M.(2011).The mathematical and science skills of students who are deaf or hard of hearing educated in inclusive settings.Deafness & Education International,13(2),70-88.
51. 王文科（編）, Wen-Ke(Ed.)(2015).特殊教育導論.臺北=Taipei, Taiwan:五南=Wu-Nan.
52. 台華, Tai-Hwa(1995)。殘障資優學生身心特質之研究。特殊教育研究學刊，13，203-219。
53. 林寶貴, Bao-Guey,黃玉枝, Yu-Chih(1997)。聽障學生國語文能力及錯誤類型之分析。特殊教育研究學刊，15，109-129。
54. 林寶貴, Bao-Guey,錡寶香, Pao-Hsaing(1991)。高職階段聽覺障礙學生國語文與數學能力之研究。特殊教育研究學刊，7，109-127。
55. 洪文東, Wen-Tung,黃俊偉, Chun-Wei(2008)。國小學童對科學家的意象調查研究：以屏東縣某國小學童為例。美和技術學院學報，27(2)，21-47。
56. 張蓓莉, Bey-Lih(1989)。聽覺障礙學生之語言能力研究。特殊教育研究學刊，5，165-204。
57. 教育部=Ministry of Education(2014)。教育部（2014）：十二年國民基本教育實施計畫。臺北：教育部。[Ministry of Education (2014). Implementation Scheme for 12-year Basic Education. Taipei, Taiwan: Ministry of Education.]。
58. 教育部（2018）：十二年國民基本教育-特殊教育課程實施規範。臺北：教育部。[Ministry of Education (2018). Special Education Curriculum Implementation Specification for 12-year Basic Education. Taipei, Taiwan: Ministry of Education.]
59. 教育部=Ministry of Education(2003).科學教育白皮書.臺北=Taipei, Taiwan:教育部=Ministry of Education.
60. 郭重吉, Chorng-Jee,蔣佳玲, Chia-Ling(1995)。評析學生對科學家的形象之相關研究。科學教育月刊，179，2-27。
61. 黃孝宗, Hsiao-tsung(2000)。臺東=Taitung，臺東師範學院教育研究所=National Taitung Teachers College。
62. 鄭豔齡, Yen-Ling(2013)。彰化=Changhua，國立彰化師範大學生物學系研究所=National Changhua University of Education。