「精神疾病強制鑑定審查會」運作之探討：以社工委員為例

Dilemma and Reflection on Social Workers in the Mandatory Hospitalization Review Committee for People with Serious Mental Illness

10.29734/SJSW.201206.0001

吳慧菁(Hui-Ching Wu)；林萬億(Wan-I Lin)；張莉馨(Li-Hsin Chang)；唐宜楨(I-Chen Tang)

嚴重精神病患 ； 社會工作專業倫理 ； 人權 ； 審查會 ； 精神醫療社工 ； Human rights ； Social Work Ethics ； Psychiatric Disability ； Mental Health Social Worker ； Review Board

東吳社會工作學報

23期（2012 / 06 / 01）

9 - 45

繁體中文

依據2007年所修訂的「精神衛生法」第四十一條規定，嚴重病人經評估後有全日住院治療的需要但不接受時，經由中央主管機關精神疾病強制鑑定審查會審查有全日住院治療之必要者，將強制住院治療。而2007年「精神衛生法」第十五條規定，精神疾病強制鑑定審查會成員（以下簡稱審查會）包括專科醫師、護理師、職能治療師、心理師、社會工作師、病人權益促進團體代表、法律專家及其他相關專業人士。由於此一審查會的設置，使得社工專業得以有一合法發言位置，表達社工專業考量。然而值得關注的是，在審查過程當中，權衡「嚴重病人」以及「自傷傷人之虞」的審查要件經常使得社工委員面臨違反案主自決等原則是可被接受的境況。因此，本文旨在了解社會工作委員在參與審查會過程中所面臨的倫理立場兩難、社工委員在跨專業團隊合作的審查會機制裡所扮演的專業角色以及精神疾患強制就醫實務面的省思，進一步對目前審查會的審查準則提供更完備的建議。

Involuntary admission and treatment for patients with severe mental illness is usually based on the dangerousness to oneself or others. According to Article 15 of Mental Health Act Amendment, 2007 in Taiwan, the decision regarding to involuntary placement of severe psychiatric patients is subjected to review by the Psychiatric Disease Mandatory Assessment and Community Care Review Committee (hereinafter the Review Committee). The committee members including seven specialists, namely psychiatrists, professional registered nurses, legal experts, occupational therapists, psychologists, psychiatric social workers, and caregiver representatives advocating for patients' rights are involved in this court-like body to check and ensure the criteria for involuntary placement is met.For verifying the responsibilities as a psychiatric social worker committee representative, the purpose of this research is to find out the roles of social worker in the Review Committee and their perspectives on involuntary admission and treatment of severe psychiatric patients. Despite the fact that decision-making process of involuntary psychiatric admission and treatment is a struggle since it is against the patient's will. This study would be important in finding social worker roles on contribution to a full-picture of psychosocial consideration for severe psychiatric patients in the Review Committee.

1. 王金永(2008)。英國與台灣精神衛生法的變革。社會政策與社會工作學刊，12(1)，189-218。
   連結：
2. 唐宜楨、陳心怡(2008)。從《身心障礙者權利公約》來探討身心障礙概念的新轉向。身心障礙研究，6(4)，238-251。
   連結：
3. 陳淵渝、林志強、諶立中、楊斯年(2007)。經急診室收住院之精神分裂症病人的臨床特徵。台灣精神醫學，21(3)，167-175。
   連結：
4. 葛謹(2010)。Gillick 行為能力-最高法院95 年度台非字第115 號刑事叛決評譯。醫事法學，17(1)，34-40。
   連結：
5. Adams, P.(2009).Code of duties or ideological club?.Journal of social work values and ethics,6(1)
6. Alem, A.,Jacobsson, L.,Lynoe, N.,Kohn, R.,Kullgren, G.(2002).Attitudes and practices among ethiopian health care professionals in psychiatry regarding compulsory treatment.International journal of law and psychiatry,25,599-610.
7. Barsky A. E.(2010).Ethics and values in social work: An integrated approach for a comprehensive curriculum.Oxford:OUP.
8. Bentley, K. J.(1993).The right of psychiatric patients to refuse medication-where should social workers stand?.Social work,38(1),101-106.
9. Biehal, N.,Sainsbury, E.(1991).From values of rights in social work.British journal of social work,21,24-257.
10. Borinstein, A. B.(1992).Public attitudes toward persons with mental illness.Health affair,11,186-196.
11. Bywaters, P.(1986).Social work and the medical profession-arguments against unconditional collaboration.British journal of social work,16,661-677.
12. Campbell, J.(2010).Deciding to detain: The use of compulsory mental health law by UK social workers.British journal of social work,40,328-334.
13. Chiu, T. L.,Wei, F. W.,Lee, S.(2006).Personal tragedy or system failure: A qualitative analysis of narratives of caregivers of people with severe mental illness in Hong Kong and Taiwan.International journal of social psychiatry,52(5),413-423.
14. Cummings, S. M.,Cassie, K. M.(2008).Perceptions of biopsychosocial services needs among older adults with severe mental illness: Met and unmet needs.Health & social work,33(2),133-143.
15. Dickens, G.,Sugarman, P.(2008).Interpretation and knowledge of human rights in mental health practice.British Journal of Nursing,17(10),664-667.
16. Dolgoff, R.,Loewenberg, F. M.,Harrington, D.(2009).Ethical decisions for social work practice.Belmont:Brooks/Cole.
17. Fakhoury, W. K. H.,Wright, D.(2004).A national survey of approved social workers in the UK: Information, communication and training needs.British journal of social work,34,663-675.
18. Furminger, E.,Webber, M.(2008).The effect of crisis resolution and home treatment on assessments under the 1983 mental health act: An increased workload for approved social workers?.British journal of social work,39(5),901-917.
19. Gambril, E.(ed.)(2009).Social work ethics.Farnham:Ashgate.
20. Golightley, M.(2004).Social work and mental health.Exeter:Learning Matters.
21. Gostin, L. O.(2004).International human rights law and mental disability.Hastings center report,34(2),11-12.
22. Grob, G. N.(2008).Mental health policy in the liberal state: The example of the united states.International journal of law and psychiatry,31,89-100.
23. Hale, B.(2007).Justice and equality in mental health law: The european experience.International journal of law and psychiatry,30,18-28.
24. Häyry, H.(1991).The limits of medical paternalism.London:Routledge.
25. Hewitt, J. L.(2008).Dangerousness and mental health policy.Journal of psychiatric and mental health nursing,15,186-194.
26. Husum, T. L.,Finset, A.,Ruud, T.(2008).The staff attitude to coercion scale: Reliability, validity and feasibility.International journal of law and psychiatry,31,417-422.
27. Hutchison, E. D.(1987).Use of authority in direct social work practice with mandated clients.Social service review,61(4),581-598.
28. Huxley, P.,Thornicroft, G.(2003).Social inclusion, social quality and mental illness.British journal of psychiatry,182,289-290.
29. Ife, J.(2008).Human Rights and Social Work.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
30. Janssen, W. A.,Noorthoorn, E. O.,De Vries, W. J.,Hutschemaekers, G. J. M.,Lendemeijer, H. H. G. M.,Widdershoven, G. A. M.(2008).The use of seclusion in the netherlands compared to countries in and outside Europe.International journal of law and psychiatry,31,463-470.
31. Kinderman, P.,Tai, S.(2008).Psychological models of mental disorder, human rights and compulsory mental health care in the community.International journal of law and psychiatry,31,479-486.
32. Lindley, R.(1986).Autonomy.London:Macmillan.
33. Loewenberg, F.,Dolgoff , R.(1982).Ethical decisions for social work practice.Itasca. IL:F. E. Peacock.
34. Lorant, V.,Depuydt, C.,Gillain, B.,Guillet, A.,Dubois, V.(2007).Involuntary commitment in psychiatric care: What drives the decision?.Social psychiatry epidemiology,42,360-365.
35. Mann, J. M.(ed.),Gruskin, S.(ed.),Grodin, M. A.(ed.),Annas, G. J.(ed.)(1999).Health and human rights: A reader.London:Routledge.
36. Mulder, C. L.,Uitenbroek, D.,Broer, J.,Lendemeijer, B.,van Veldhuizen, J. R.,van Tilburg, W.(2008).Changing patterns in emergency involuntary admissions in the netherlands in the period 2000-2004.International journal of law and psychiatry,31,331-336.
37. Newhill, C. E.(1992).Assessing danger to others in clinical social work practice.Social service review,66(1),64-84.
38. Payne, M.(2005).Modern social work theory.Chicago:Lyceum.
39. Pilgrim, D.(2005).Key concepts in mental health.London:SAGE.
40. Reamer, F. G.(1983).The concept of paternalism in social work.Social service review,57(2),254-271.
41. Sattar, S. P.,Pinals, D.A.,Din, A.U.,Appealbaum, P. S.(2006).To commit or not to commit: The psychiatry resident as a variable in involuntary commitment decisions.Academic psychiatry,30(3),191-195.
42. Shields, C.V.(1956).On liberty.Indianapolis:Bobbs-Merrill.
43. Spandler, H.,Calton, T.(2009).Psychosis and human rights: Conflicts in mental health policy and practice.Social policy & society,8(2),245-256.
44. Spicker, P.(1990).Social work and self-determination.British journal of social work,20,221-236.
45. Szmukler, G.,Holloway, F.(2000).Reform of the mental health act-health or safety.British journal of psychiatry,177,196-200.
46. Taylor, M. F.(2006).Social workers and involuntary treatment in mental health.Advances in social work,7(2),23-33.
47. Trotter, C.(2006).Working with involuntary clients: A guide to practice.London:SAGE.
48. Tung, W. C.,Beck, S. L.(2007).Family caregivers' satisfaction with home care for mental illness in Taiwan.International journal of mental health nursing,16,62-69.
49. Ungvari, G. S.,Hantz, P. M.(1991).Social breakdown in the elderly, I. Case Studies and Management.Comprehensive psychiatry,32(5),440-444.
50. Weiss-Gal, I.(2008).The person-in-environment approach: Professional ideology and practice of social work in Israel.social work,53(1),65-75.
51. Wilk, R. J.(1994).Are the rights of people with mental illness still important?.Social work,39(2),167-175.
52. Wu, H. C(2008).Predicting subjective quality of life in workers with psychiatric disabilities.Community mental health journal,44(2),135-146.
53. 王燦槐(2005)。性侵害防治中心在司法流程中的角色減少性侵害被害人重複陳述作業之評析。亞洲家庭暴力與性侵害期刊，1(1)，111-136。
54. 余漢儀(2003)。國科會研究計劃國科會研究計劃,國科會。
55. 吳建昌(2010)。精神疾病患者之意思能力。護理雜誌，57(6)，5-10。
56. 吳淑妤(1991)。精神衛生法對醫療照護之影響。中華心理衛生學刊，5(2)，27-31。
57. 宋維村(2009)。病人行為能力及其評估。澄清醫護管理雜誌，5(1)，4-7。
58. 宋維村、林令世、陳尚義、丘彥南(1994)。我國精神衛生法之檢討。中華心理衛生學刊，7(1)，37-50。
59. 宋麗玉(1999)。精神病患照顧者之探究：照顧負荷之程度與其相關因素。中華心理衛生學刊，12(1)，1-30。
60. 李俊穎、周煌智(2003)。從精神病患住院實例探討精神衛生法中強制就醫權疑義。醫事法學，10(3)/11(1)，42-49。
61. 沈楚文(1991)。精神科急診處理強制住院問題探討─因應精神衛生法之實施。臨床醫學，28，165-170。
62. 林萬億(2002)。當代社會工作：理論與方法。台北:五南。
63. 林萬億(2006)。台灣的社會福利：歷史經驗與制度分析。台北:五南。
64. 孫哲(1995)。新人權論。台北:五南。
65. 徐震編、李明政編(2001)。社會工作倫理。台北:五南。
66. 張玨、許蓉雰(1995)。疑似嚴重精神病患住院過程之探討。中華心理衛生學刊，14(5)，438-445。
67. 張玨、許蓉雰(1995)。精神衛生法中強制住院之知識：醫療與非醫療人員之比較。中華心理衛生學刊，14(5)，426-436。
68. 曾華源、胡慧嫈、李仰慈、郭世豐(2009)。社會工作專業價值與倫理概論。台北:洪葉。
69. 黃維憲、曾華源、王慧君(2006)。社會個案工作。台北:五南。
70. 楊聰財、魏兆玟(2008)。新版精神衛生法與強制就醫新制。源遠護理，2(2)，11-17。
71. 廖榮利(2004)。精神病理社會工作。台北:五南。
72. 劉蓉台(2007)。精障個案社區整合照顧模式。護理雜誌，54(5)，11-17。
73. 鄭泰安(1985)。台灣地區精神病患者之社會文化特徵及療養結果研究。中華心理衛生學刊，2，117-133。
74. 嚴久元(1996)。當代醫事倫理學。台北:橘井。

1. (2015)。以社會工作者角度探討： 精神疾病患者於醫療過程 之人權與倫理議題。社區發展季刊，151，307-315。
2. (2020)。精神病人的強制醫療與優惠待遇。法學叢刊，65(3)，57-91。