居家照顧服務員工作留任意願影響因素探討

Understanding Factors Affecting Homecare Workers' Job Retention Willingness

謝美娥(Mei-O Hsieh)

居家照顧服務員 ； 工作意義 ； 工作條件 ； 留任意願 ； homecare workers ； work meaning ； work conditions ； job retention

東吳社會工作學報

33期（2017 / 12 / 01）

27 - 62

繁體中文

本研究係探討居家照顧服務員(以下簡稱居服員)的留任因素，研究目的為瞭解居服員對工作意義和工作條件的看法；探討重要人口變項、工作意義、與工作條件和留任意願的關係；以及預測居服員留任意願的重要因素。以臺北市與新北市的居家服務單位為研究母體，經立意抽樣各別選取居服人數較多的前五間機構，問卷採自填方式，由督導員於在職訓練中協助發放與回收，共發放350份，有效問卷總計308份，回收率達88％。研究結果顯示工作意義與工作條件為主要影響留任之因素，當居服員能投入工作且受到肯定、認同工作專業度、勝任工作、且工作界限能畫分清楚、得到居服督導的協助與支持、且有穩定並足夠的薪資，其留任意願會愈高，逐步迴歸可以解釋達37.2%的變異量；另外，透過階層化迴歸分析預測留任意願發現三個模式共可解釋達36.8％的變異量，顯著的變項與逐步迴歸前四個變項一致，確認工作意義與工作條件仍是主要對留任的預測力，其中工作意義部分預測力更大。

This study tries to investigate homecare service workers who are willing to retain in the workforce. Purpose: The purpose of the study are as follows: to understand homecare workers' viewpoints of the work meaning and work conditions, to investigate the relationship of important personal characteristics, the work meaning, and work conditions as well as the job retention, and to predict the factors which may affect the job retention. Method: Homecare service agencies in Taipei City and New Taipei City are the population. We purposefully select the five larger agencies in each city. The homecare supervisors handed out the self-reported questionnaires and then collected in their training session. Finally, 308 valid data were collected. The response rate is 88%. Results: The findings show that if the workers commit into the work and receive high recognition and assertion, identify with the work professionalism, feel competent, have clear work-setting boundary, have supervisor's assistance and support, have stable and adequate wage, will have higher willingness of job retention. The total variance of the stepwise regression is 37.2%. It is a moderate level in social research. In addition to stepwise regression, hierarchical regression can demonstrate different effects of 3- set independent variables. The significant factors are similar to the former four factors in stepwise regression. The total variance of the hierarchical regression is 36.8%. Conclusion: Effective retention strategies may provide fruitful personnel and workers with efficacy. It is an important method to stabilize the workforce of homecare service.

1. 張江清、林秋菊、蔡和蓁、陳武宗(2011)。困境向前行─高雄縣市居家照顧服務員服務經驗探究。弘光學報，64，70-89。
   連結：
2. 楊筱慧(2014)。居家服務工作的任務、留任與離職因素。臺灣社會福利學刊，12(1)，165-214。
   連結：
3. Barbarotta, L. (2010). Direct Care Worker Retention: Strategies for Success. Retrieved June 17, 2012, from http://www.leadingage.org/uploadedFiles/Content/About/Center_for_Applied_Research/Publications_and_Products/Direct%20Care%20Workers%20Report%20%20FINAL%20(2).pdf
4. 衛生福利部（2015）。〈長期照顧服務量能提升計畫（104 年至107 年）〉。瀏覽日期:2016 年5 月1 日，網址:http://www.mohw.gov.tw/cht/LTC/DM1_P.aspx?f_list_no=917&fod_list_no=0&doc_no=53041
5. 內政部（2007）。〈96 年居家服務補助使用者調查摘要分析〉。瀏覽日期:2012 年7 月30日，網址:http://sowf.moi.gov.tw/stat/Survey/96 年居家服務補助使用者調查摘要分析.pdf
6. Airila, A.,Hakanen, J.,Punakallio, A.,Lusa, S.,Luukkonen, R.(2012).Is work engagement related to work ability beyond working conditions and lifestyle factors?.International Archives of Occupational and Environmental Health,85(8),915-925.
7. Arnoux-Nicolas, C.,Sovet, L.,Lhotellier, L.,Di Fabio, A.,Bernaud, J.-L.(2016).Perceived Work Conditions and Turnover Intentions: The Mediating Role of Meaning of Work.Front. Psychol.
8. Atchley, R. C.(1996).,未出版
9. Brannon, D.,Barry, T.,Kemper, P.,Schreiner, A.,Vasey, J.(2007).Job Perceptions and Intent to Leave among Direct Care Workers: Evidence from the Better Jobs Better Care Demonstrations.The Gerontologist,47(6),820-829.
10. Brannon, S. D.,Kemper, P.,Heier-Leitzell, B.,Stott, A.(2010).Reinventing management practices in long-term care: how cultural evolution can affect workforce recruitment and retention.Generations,34(4),68-74.
11. Chou, R. J.,Robert, S. A.(2008).Workplace Support, Role Overload, and Job Satisfaction of Direct Care Workers in Assisted Living.Journal of Health and Social Behavior,49,208-222.
12. Dawson, S. L.(2007).,未出版
13. Ellenbecker, C. H.,Porell, F.,Samia, L.W.,Byleckie, J. J.,Milburn, M.(2008).Predictors of Home Healthcare Nurse Retention.Health Policy and Systems,40(2),151-160.
14. Faul, A. C.,Schapmire, T. J.,D'Ambrosio, J.,Feaster, D.,Oak, C. S.,Farley, A.(2010).Promoting Sustainability in Frontline Home Care Aides: Understanding Factors Affecting Job Retention in the Home Care Workforce.Home Health Care Management & Practice,22(6),408-416.
15. Feldman, P. H.,Sapienza, A.,Kane, N.(1990).Who Cares for Them? Workers in the Home Care Industry.New York:Greenwood Press.
16. Fernando, F. C.,Jimenez, M. L.(2000).Motivation and Burnout in Volunteerism.Psychology in Spain,4(1),75-81.
17. Field, A.(2013).Discovering statistics using SPSS.London, England:Sage.
18. Fleming, G.,Taylor, B. J.(2006).Battle on the Home Care Front: Perceptions of Home Care Workers of Factors Influencing Staff Retention in Northern Ireland.Health and Social Care in the Community,15(1),67-76.
19. Freund, A.(2005).Commitment and Job Satisfaction as Predictors of Turnover Intentions among Welfare Workers.Administration in Social Work,29(2),5-21.
20. Halbesleben, J. R. B.,Wheeler, A. R.(2008).The Relative Roles of Engagement and Embeddedness in Predicting Job Performance and Intention to Leave.Work and Stress,22(3),242-256.
21. Hanson, G. C.,Perrin, N. A.,Moss, H.,Laharnar, N.,Glass, N.(2015).Workplace Violence against Homecare Workers and Its Relationship with Workers Health Outcomes: A Cross-Sectional Study.BMC Public Health,15(1),1-13.
22. Howes, C.(2008).Love, Money, or Flexibility: What Motivates People to Work in Consumer-Directed Home Care?.The gerontologist,48,46-59.
23. Howes, C.(2005).Living Wages and Retention of Homecare Workers in San Francisco.Industrial Relations,44(1),139-163.
24. Howes, C.(2015).Home: Care The Fastest Growing Low-Wage Industry.New Labor Forum,24(2),98-105.
25. Kemper, P.,Heier, B.,Barry, T.,Brannon, D.,Angelelli, J.,Vasey, J.,Knott, M. A.(2008).What Do Direct Care Workers Say Would Improve Their Jobs: Differences Across Settings.The gerontologist,48,17-25.
26. McCaughey, D.,Kim, J.,McGhan, G.,Jablonski, R.,Brannon, D.(2010).Who Needs Caring? We Do! Workplace Injury and Its Effect on Home Health Aides.Academy of Management Annual Meeting Proceedings,8(1),1-6.
27. McFarlane, L.,McLean, J.(2003).Education and Training for Direct Care Workers.Social Work Education,22(4),385-399.
28. Mickus, M.,Luz, C. C.,Hogan, A.(2004).Voices from the Front Recruitment and Retention of Direct Care Workers in Long Term Care across Michigan.Michigan:Michigan State University.
29. Mittal, V.,Rosen, J.,Leana, C.(2009).A Dual-Process Model of Retention and Turnover in the Direct Care Workforce: Insights from Qualitative Research.The Gerontologist,49(5),623-634.
30. Olsson, E.,Ingvad, B.(2001).The Emotional Climate of Care-Giving in Home-Care Services.Health & Social Care in the Community,9(6),454-463.
31. Price, J. L.(2001).Reflections on the Determinants of Voluntary Turnover.International Journal of Manpower,22(7),600-624.
32. Rosso, B. D.,Dekas, K. H.,Wrzesniewski, A.(2010).On the meaning of work: a theoretical integration and review.Research in Organization Behavior,30,91-127.
33. Sagie, A.,Krausz, M.(2003).What Aspects of the Job Have Most Effect on Nurses?.Israel Human Resource Management Journal,13(1),46-62.
34. Seavey, D.(2010).Caregivers on the Front Line: Building a Better Direct-Care Workforce.Journal of the American Society on Aging,34(4),27-35.
35. Sims-Gould, J.,Byrne, K.,Craven, C.,Martin-Matthews, A.,Keefe, J.(2010).Why I Became a Home Support Worker: Recruitment in the Home Health Sector.Home Health Care Services Quarterly,29(4),171-194.
36. Steger, M.F.,Dik, B.J.,Duffy, R.D.(2012).Measuring meaningful work: the work and meaning inventory.Journal of Career Assessment,20(3),322-337.
37. Stone, R. I.(2004).The Direct Care Worker: The Third Rail of Home Care Policy.Annual Review of Public Health,25,521-537.
38. Stone, R.,Wiener, J.(2001).Who will care for us? Addressing the long-term care workforce crisis.Washington:The Urban Institute and the American Association of Homes and Services for the Aging.
39. Tourangeau, A.,Patterson, E.,Rowe, A.,Saari, M.,Thomson, H.,MacDonald, G.,Cranley, L.,Squires, M.(2014).Factors influencing home care nurse intention to remain employed.Journal of nursing management,22(8),1015-1026.
40. Yin, J. C.,Yang, K. P.(2002).Nursing Turnover in Taiwan: A Meta-Analysis of Related Factors.International Journal of Nursing Studies,39(6),573-581.
41. 王郁智、朱正一、洪光良、章淑娟(2004)。護理人員留任意願文獻探討。慈濟護理雜誌，3(4)，8-12。
42. 江孟冠(2002)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。臺北，國立臺灣醫學院護理學研究所。
43. 吳玉琴(2008)。台灣居家照顧服務員勞動困境與對策。社區發展季刊，122，200-214。
44. 吳玉琴(2004)。台灣居家服務的現況與檢討。社區發展季刊，104，132-141。
45. 吳明隆、涂金堂(2005)。SPSS 與統計應用分析。臺北:五南圖書公司。
46. 吳淑瓊、陳亮汝、張文瓊(2013)。臺灣居家服務人力：現況與未來發展。社區發展季刊，141，101-112。
47. 呂寶靜(2012)。老人福利服務。臺北:五南圖書公司。
48. 沈慶盈(2011)。臺北市政府社會局100 年度補助之研究成果報告臺北市政府社會局100 年度補助之研究成果報告,臺北市政府社會局。
49. 林貞慧(2003)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。臺中，東海大學社會工作研究所。
50. 林家淯(2012)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。臺北，國立臺北大學社會工作研究所。
51. 林燕姿(2010)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。臺南，長榮大學社會工作研究所。
52. 邱皓政(2011)。量化研究與統計分析五版。臺北:五南圖書公司。
53. 胡正申、陳立孟、郭盛哲(2014)。居家照顧服務員倫理議題：居服員、督導員與機構主管的三個層面。復興崗學報，104，199-225。
54. 郭俊巖、李綉梅、胡慧嫈、蔡盈修、賴秦瑩(2015)。臺灣老人長期照顧體系下居家照顧服務員職場風險之研究。台灣社區工作與社區研究學刊，5(1)，129-169。
55. 陳曼華(2003)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。臺北，臺北護理學院長期照護研究所。
56. 陳順宇(2009)。迴歸分析四版。臺北:三民書局。
57. 陳寬裕、王正華(2011)。論文統計分析實務：SPSS 與AMOS 的運用。臺北:五南圖書公司。
58. 黃柏菁(2014)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。臺南，長榮大學社會工作研究所。
59. 楊筱慧(2011)。誰來照顧？居家服務方案對服務使用之影響。台灣高齡服務管理學刊，1(2)，97-119。
60. 葉建鑫(2009)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。桃園，長庚大學醫務管理研究所。
61. 詹秀玲(2005)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。桃園，元智大學資訊社會學研究所。
62. 蔡麗珍(2007)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。臺中，亞洲大學長期照護研究所。
63. 鄭洺洋(2012)。嘉義，南華大學非營利事業管理學系。
64. 謝美娥編、沈慶盈編(2015)。老人居家照顧的服務與治理。臺北:五南圖書公司。
65. 簡士評(2001)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。桃園，中央大學人力資源管理研究所。

1. 蔡蕙鞠,蔡育真,黃靖媛,許芝穎,張李淑女,翁瑞宏,吳宗晉(2023)。長照A單位個案管理人員工作滿意度、角色衝突與留任意願之探討。台灣公共衛生雜誌，42(3)，321-335。
2. 陳蕙芬(2019)。以使命感塑形：工作形塑的能力陶冶。中山管理評論，27(1)，179-226。
3. 黃靖媛,陳妤謙,許芝穎,常家馨,翁瑞宏(2022)。照顧服務員持續投入機構住宿式長照服務工作之意願與相關影響因素。國立金門大學學報，10(2)，1-21。
4. 蘇信鳳,涂世俊,林孟薇,李浩銘,李文禮,宋惠娟,王秀美(2022)。失智照護行動學習及支持計畫運用於居家照顧服務員可行性之探討。長期照護雜誌，24(3)，249-265。
5. (2023)。分級會升級？臺灣長期照顧服務員證照分級制度之研究─職能理論觀點。臺灣社會福利學刊，19(2)，1-51。
6. (2023)。探討COVID-19後疫情時代護理、長照與公衛相關科系學生投入長照產業意圖之影響因素。健康促進與衛生教育學報，57，93-128。
7. (2024)。新住民照輔員在醫院工作之身心負荷與留任探討。彰化護理，31(2)，50-53。